Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ...
by dredmorbius on Saturday October 08, 2016 @11:04AM
(#12667156)
There's a huge difference between work which you can do tools-down without a lot of fuss, versus work which involves keeping a ton of state in your head. I've done both myself, and there's a distinct difference between working with your hands and working with your mind entirely.
Not that tools-based work can't involve thinking. The design or planning elemments of carpentry or construction or machining or cabinetry can be quite cerebral. But there's that hand-eye tangibility that's missing.
The plant I used to work in also did daily standups. They worked a hell of a lot better than any I have ever seen in software, since they started the minute after everybody was supposed to punch in, rather than some amorphous time mid-morning when somebody decided there might be a better-than-average chance of everybody finally dragging into the office or there not being some other regularly scheduled meeting.