News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by 0x0 on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @04:56PM (#12593122)
What's the point of a private blockchain? Who are you competing against with your hash rate? And if you are keeping it private to stay in control, why choose a technology designed to not let you stay in control?

I've heard buzz about "enterprise blockchains" several times, but I still don't understand what this brings that an authenticated REST service on top of an SQL database doesn't.

Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by ledgerdev on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @11:48PM (#12595311)
The value prop for private or consortium chains is significantly different than public blockchains.

The first point is that it's a shared database that allows organizations to co-operate, with a common view of the world meaning fewer integration points which are exponential as the number of participants grows.

The second point is that none of the individual parties has monopoly control of the "central" database meaning they can't extract excessive rent from the participants and exert political/corrupt influence on the network.

This is my favorite video explaining this and blockchains in general, and this aspect specifically which begins at 23:45 in. The sound is terrible, but definitely worth listening to. https://vimeo.com/153600491

Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by runeks on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @08:10AM (#12597037)
The thing is, none of the things you mention require proof-of-work, which is really the only thing that makes a Blockchain a Blockchain, rather than just a weird append-only database which allocates tokens to accounts (scripts). Only by proof-of-work do these tokens become meaningful, because it allows the tokens to be moved around by the account-holders without a central party.

There is simply no need for a private consortium to waste energy on proof-of-work. The features you mention can be implemented without any need for proof-of-work. The purpose of the organized waste that is proof-of-work is to achieve trustlessness, simply by requiring a huge expansion of energy if you wish to rewrite history.

In Bitcoin, the maintainers of the database (the miners) are separate from the users, and proof-of-work prevents the Blockchain/database maintainers (miners) from rewriting history. But if the owners and users of the database exist within the same organization, it would be trivial to verify that nothing has been rewritten simply by every party keeping a copy.

Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by pjc50 on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @05:49PM (#12593530)
Presumably you'd ditch the proof-of-waste system entirely and just have a short whitelist of keys allowed to post to it.

It sounds like a means of getting a distributed database that actually works, with no central admin. That's no small thing.

Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by brighton36 on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @07:45PM (#12594274)
There's also no way to order transactions, and no need for blocks in your proposed model. You can just syndicate signed messages in exactly the way we do now, over http, and have the same security.
Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by RyJones on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @09:48PM (#12594830)
Look into Sawtooth Lake by Intel. It uses PoET (proof of elapsed time). https://www.google.com/amp/www.nasdaq.com/article/intel-deve...
Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by 0x0 on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @07:10PM (#12594073)
What, like git?
Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by oconnore on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @07:31PM (#12594199)
Probably like git but with every commit signed by n+1 / 2n participants.
Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by therein on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @01:33AM (#12595633)
So git with a few pre-commit hooks?
Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by verroq on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @03:06AM (#12595931)
And Dropbox is literally rsync am I right?
Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by pjc50 on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @01:34AM (#12595636)
Git doesn't currently handle "accounts", it handles lines of text in diff form. You can't currently use git to pay for things, though no doubt someone will add this feature.
Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by brighton36 on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @07:44PM (#12594265)
Proof of Work is the process by which registered value (an electric bill) is converted to fungible value. It is nearly 100% efficient (depending on how you quantify waste).

If you don't like the externality costs of mining - I'm with you. But that's the government's job to manage, and seemingly, they're ok with that. They even subsidize the network by requiring that some goods only be purchased via blockchain.

Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by danbruc on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @08:52PM (#12594611)
Proof of Work is the process by which registered value (an electric bill) is converted to fungible value. It is nearly 100% efficient (depending on how you quantify waste).

That is not true. The proof of work is the mechanism required to prevent users from casting arbitrarily many (fraudulent) votes on blocks because Bitcoin is anonymous. If Bitcoin were not anonymous, you could just give one vote per block to every user and everything would be fine. But Bitcoin is anonymous and the proof of work essentially only replaces knowing all users by making it hard to cast a vote and in consequence even harder to cast many. So the proof of work is logically the component in Bitcoin establishing some kind of identity for users and has nothing to do with the creation of value.

Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by digi_owl on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @02:31AM (#12595812)
Proof of work also gives goldbugs that warm and fussy...
Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by bduerst on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @07:52PM (#12594323)
>[Proof of work] is nearly 100% efficient

I'm curious how you're defining efficiency here. If it's "nearly 100% efficient", does that mean it's 99% efficient? 99.999% efficient?

If 100 people compete on a block and 1 person is awarded the block, then isn't it 1% efficient and 99% wasteful?

Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by wyager on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @08:27PM (#12594491)
> If 100 people compete on a block and 1 person is awarded the block, then isn't it 1% efficient and 99% wasteful?

From the network's perspective, everyone collaborated to make that block more secure. The more hashing power you have, the harder it is to subvert the network.

"Wastefulness" in this case can only be expressed by comparing energy spent per hash to the most efficient extant computer which could hypothetically be used by an attacker. In this case, Bitcoin is already mined using specialized ultra-efficient ASICs, so by this standard it is not wasteful.

Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by bduerst on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @12:23PM (#12598963)
> everyone collaborated to make that block more secure.

The rational actors aren't collaborating to make the network more secure, they're competing to get the reward.

In fact, the asics you mention is why the network isn't that secure. They create an economies of scale that allows the network to be controlled by a handful of Chinese miners, who in turn won't fork useful updates.

That means the redundant work being done by the miners is wasted.

Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by discodave on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @09:07PM (#12594683)
It's 100% efficient at turning electricity into heat... that's about all it's efficient at though.

If you need distributed state, use Paxos, raft or be OK with having a single point of failure.

Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by ChrisClark on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @10:52PM (#12595095)
It's 100% efficient at turning greed into security for the blockchain.
Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by JBReefer on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @09:55PM (#12594854)
It's 100% efficient at worsening climate change due to subsidized Chinese coal electricity in order to further a Ponzi scheme.
Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by AtheistOfFail on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @12:48AM (#12595469)
Lol, the entire Bitcoin mining ecosystem uses less electricy than the Bank of America headquarters.

Also, ponzi schemes require that money from users be stolen to pay off new users. Instead we pay miners to secure all the Bitcoins in the network by burning power (IE, just like a job, you use 8 hours of energy and you get a paycheck)

Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by sanswork on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @01:07AM (#12595534)
Where did you see that figure because that sounds hugely wrong.
Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by redcalx on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @07:24AM (#12596837)
You can sort of ballpark the bitcoin energy usage by assuming all mined coins are sold at the current exchange rate, and used to buy electricity at a reasonable average for the world...

12.5 BTC every 10 mins => 12.5 / 600 per second => 0.02083.

0.02083. * $600 = $12.5 / sec

Assuming electricity cost of $0.10 per kWH...

%12.50 / 0.10 = 125 kWh / sec.

125kWH * 3.6e6 joules, per second => 450 MW

For comparison, the UK power grid runs at about 30-40GW.

Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by rabboRubble on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @05:15PM (#12593298)
In finance, successful two party private systems / standards are often turned into industry standards. Think Swift, FIX, etc.

In the case of FIX, the reason it was widely adopted was that a buy-side client (Fidelity) demanded their brokers (developed with Goldman, then taken up by others) adopt the standard.

I understand why Microsoft would want to support this. I can understand why BoAML would want this. Where I'm failing to see how this initiative will succeed is there seem to be missing a buy side participant to demand implementation. Perhaps BoAML has some sort of leverage with other market participants to get them on board? Recording transactions from one arm of BoAML with another arm of BoAML doesn't make sense to me. There are already internal systems to handle transaction recording.

Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by milcron on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @05:49PM (#12593525)
It's possible to design a blockchains that don't require brute-force computation. Bitcoin uses a "proof of work" algorithm, but Peercoin (for instance) uses "proof of stake" which is a lot less CPU-intensive.
Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by brighton36 on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @07:45PM (#12594281)
And peercoin stake grinded to oblivion. Andrew Poelstra writes extensively about the problems with non-work systems. (which are ancient technology)
Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by milcron on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @08:48PM (#12594583)
Are there any active attempts at finding alternatives to proof-of-work?
Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by jude- on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @09:07PM (#12594678)
The fundamental problem seems to be that, when positioned against the same threat model as Bitcoin, all the PoW alternatives reduce to an obscured form of PoW. Put another way, a PoW alternative proposal must be designed such that participants can't increase profits expending more energy (for example, the fact that stake-grinding is profitable shows that Peercoin's PoS is really PoW-by-obscurity). As far as I know, this is still an open problem.

There's an interesting primer on the subject here: http://www.truthcoin.info/blog/pow-cheapest/

Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by aeijdenberg on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @11:07PM (#12595167)
If you can accept centralization (which for many non-crypto-currency use-cases actually makes sense, since it mirrors the way the real world works) - you don't actually need proof of work.

You can still get the benefits of verifiability, append-only, detect misbehavior etc without it. See for example Certificate Transparency (RFC6962) for a standard that implements those properties using similar Merkle Tree constructions.

Disclaimer, I have a startup that generalizes the same Verifiable Logs (and also allows for Verifiable Maps): https://www.continusec.com/

Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by mistermumble on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @03:16AM (#12595966)
But if you can accept centralization, then why not just use a conventional DBMS? (This is a real question, not a rhetorical argument.)
Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by aeijdenberg on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @08:18PM (#12602400)
So that you (or other interested parties) can verify the correct operation of the centralized authority, and so that the central authority can prove that they aren't hiding anything.

For example, in the case of certificate transparency, that the CAs aren't mis-issuing certificates, and further that the logs aren't conspiring to hide entries (such as via split views).

Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by gst on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @02:17AM (#12595770)
Yes! IMO the most promising approach is Ethereum's Casper protocol. See http://vitalik.ca/files/mauve_paper3.html for more details.
Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by polyomino on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @04:29AM (#12596201)
Burstcoin seems to be on the up and up. Proof of storage.
Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by conistonwater on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @05:01PM (#12593170)
Fees, dude, fees!

(More directly, it's not easy to sell nor charge a lot of money for just a database, so this is a genuine advance in sales technique.)

Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by wmf on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @05:57PM (#12593578)
I thought it's the opposite: banks want to stop paying fees to trusted third parties who run central settlement databases.
Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by conistonwater on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @06:05PM (#12593624)
I might be confused: I thought the only reason those third parties were trusted in the first place was that they were co-owned by all the banks? My point was, you replace one cooperative system with another functionally equivalent one, and nothing much changes except that there are fees to be collected in the process. A centralized settlement system is like a commodity, it's standardized and cheap to run, but a blockchain can be sold. There's also an unjustified assumption that the new system wouldn't have banks paying fees, because blockchain. There's a long series of posts on Alphaville about just that. All those trust and legal issue don't just disappear.
Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by AtheistOfFail on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @12:51AM (#12595477)
Think about this, burning power in every office while gaining a 100x redundancy factor may be worth it.

The cost of going from 99% to 99.999% can be a 100000x increase in the software space.

For reference Bitcoin has a 99.99% uptime per http://www.bitcoinuptime.com/

Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by dragonwriter on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @12:54AM (#12595491)
So, instead they are going to pay fees to third parties who provide cloud-based "blockchain-as-a-service" which functions as a centralized (on Azure) settlement database?
Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by cloudjacker on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @06:27PM (#12593752)
well this is built on the Ethereum network, according to a tweet I saw in this thread, and would therefore be a private contract. So the private data is settled on a blockchain that is secured by proof of work now, and proof of stake later.
Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by ThomPete on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @06:56PM (#12593956)
One of them I think is to establish the standard for true international wireless transfers protocol since they don't really exist today[1]. This makes a huge difference when it comes to something like remittance and would allow for a whole new kind of international companies and collaboration to be built.

[1] http://paymentsviews.com/2014/05/15/there-is-no-such-thing-a...

Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by brighton36 on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @07:48PM (#12594295)
it's just a buzzword. These are simply bad message passing systems that will never come to fruition as a blockchain. R3 spearheaded this effort and already dropped the unneccessary 'blocks' from their project. I'm unclear what their pitch is now, other than sharing your data with your competitors. A stupid goal that could be better performed with http..
Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by eternalban on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @09:42AM (#12597521)
Was interviewing with a blockchain company yesterday and this was my question to them. There is a strong buzz -- imo not very informed buzz -- about this approach in the enterprise and after this cycle of failed pilot projects the buzz should/will die.

Blockchains waste a substantial amount of computing resources. All that heat is wasted energy if the technology is used where the unique featureset of a blockchain are not important. And in the enterprise, that unique featureset is typically not really that important. B2B is a much better enterprise space for blockchains since the name of the blockchain game is 'distributed computing at the edge'.

Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by mistermumble on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @03:19AM (#12595972)
R3 is now emphasizing the smart contract aspect, and is building their system on Java Virtual Machine (JVM).

If blockchain technology is all about adding trust in a trustless environment, what are the trust implications of using Oracle JVM?

Re:Microsoft and Bank of America collaborate with Azure Bloc... by kpil on Thursday September 29, 2016 @02:23AM (#12603603)
That it's fine?

The problem have always been running others untrusted code in your own jvm.