News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by dflock on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @02:13PM (#12591665)
In a world with "designer babies", the rich don't just get richer, they get smarter, stronger, more attractive and start to live longer.

The poor can't afford this, so fall further and further behind, perhaps eventually humanity splits into subspecies.

This is very well trod ground. See The time machine by H G Wells with the Morlocs and Eloi, A Brave New World by Aldous Huxley with the Alphas and Betas, etc, etc...

Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by runeks on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @02:40PM (#12591888)
So the more powerful a technology is in changing our capabilities as human beings, the more unethical it inherently is, because poor people will have less access to it (assuming it costs money)?

I'm not arguing on the validity of this world view, but it does seems very negative to me, since it can be applied to any powerful technology (that isn't free of charge).

I mean, computers and internet access also costs money, so does this mean that the introduction of these technologies presents an ethical problem, because the poorer part of the population may not be able to afford it, thus increasing inequality?

Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by jlgaddis on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @03:09PM (#12592178)
Just today there was an article in the newspaper of a nearby town stating that the school system there would be moving to "paperless" report cards; that is, report cards would be entirely online. (It did mention that parents could request a printed copy of their child's report card at any time.)

My first thought was "not everyone has Internet access" -- especially in this relatively small city -- and the possible ramifications of that.

Will those parents have to request a paper copy every time a report card is issued (four times per school year)? Will they eventually stop doing so? Will they stop paying attention to their child's academic progress and will the child's academic performance then suffer? Will the child slowly begin to perform worse and worse (academically) over time?

Will this "digital divide" simply continue to worsen?

Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by milcron on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @04:42PM (#12593000)
Internet access should be a public utility.
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by Esau on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @06:59PM (#12593979)
Some people can't afford public utilities either.
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by int_19h on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @11:38PM (#12595273)
Then perhaps that is a problem that we should tackle, instead of going all Luddite about fairly basic tech because someone cannot afford it?

I even wouldn't be surprised if it resulted in a net economic benefit, because the reduced overhead of new tech is less than amount of money you need to spend to make sure that everyone has access to it.

Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by bitJericho on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @01:29AM (#12595615)
Libraries already tackle this. As well as other organizations. For example, when I was a kid my main internet pc was at the state extension office.
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by tjbiddle on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @09:33PM (#12594783)
I'm sure it wouldn't be four times a year - but rather, when beginning the school year (Or possibly entering the school system even the first time) it's an option to choose. And then on the bottom of the paper report cards, have a statement saying "Like to go paperless?" for if/when they do have the option to switch.
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by joesb on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @10:00PM (#12594870)
If you need a piece of paper to remind you to be a parent, you are not a good parent to begin with. And a piece of paper is not going to save child from such parent.
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by RhodaLs on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @02:54AM (#12595897)
That's much too harsh. If someone is poor enough they can't afford internet access, then they're probably under some stress from all sorts of factors. Working two jobs, trying to keep their head above water, possibly a single parent, etc.

Having the kid bring the paper home can be a good reminder. Even my own quite devoted mother would occasionally forget it was grade time until I'd show her the report card.

Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by tomrod on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @08:18PM (#12594454)
> I mean, computers and internet access also costs money, so does this mean that the introduction of these technologies presents an ethical problem, because the poorer part of the population may not be able to afford it, thus increasing inequality?

Actually, yes, there are inherent ethical problems here. In this case (computers/internet), the divide it causes is not so large that it cannot be overcome by training, savings, charitable donations, etc. However, "designer baby" technology, if not available to whomever wants it, results in an increase in feudalism to society.

With a computer, anyone can become a programmer as the technology gets cheaper and more widely adopted. Designer babies and similar technologies may not have the same increasing efficiencies with adoption; such considerations should be made.

Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by int_19h on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @11:39PM (#12595279)
It may result in more stratification, but I don't see how that translates to feudalism.
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by tomrod on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @08:35AM (#12597152)
I view feudalism as the result of prolonged, accepted stratification. David Brin talks a bit to this in his essay The Dogma of Otherness[0]

[0] http://www.davidbrin.com/dogmaofotherness.html

Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by oxide on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @02:57PM (#12592069)
>computers and internet access also costs money, so does this mean that the introduction of these technologies presents an ethical problem, because the poorer part of the population may not be able to afford it, thus increasing inequality?

some folks argue yes, that internet access should be a basic human right.

Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by paulddraper on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @08:08PM (#12594405)
Poor wretched souls of the previous millennia...they all were denied their basic human rights.
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by joesb on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @10:02PM (#12594883)
Poor slaves of the previous century .... they all were denied their basic human rights.
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by paulddraper on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @10:13PM (#12594932)
Yes, they were.

And this is insensitive to say, but at least it was just the enslaved minority denied basic rights, rather than every single human on the face of the earth.

Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by digi_owl on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @04:11PM (#12592699)
These days a homeless most cherished thing is a outdated mobile phone. This because job listing etc has moved online.

Damn it, in most parts of the world these days healthcare handled as a public utility.

Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by sokoloff on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @04:22PM (#12592797)
I can certainly imagine why you'd want a mobile phone, but at least in our area, internet access is readily available at all public library branches as well.
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by peteretep on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @02:51AM (#12595888)

    > the poorer part of the
    > population may not be able
    > to afford it, thus 
    > increasing inequality?
I am currently in Bangkok, Thailand. I walked past several people sweeping streets today who all had smartphones. I can't imagine they're getting paid above the $9/day minimum wage. Notably one was packing an iPhone 4. If 3rd-world street sweepers can get online, I believe someone in America can too, without breaking the bank.
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by hueving on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @03:00AM (#12595913)
But we wouldn't be in a smartphone world if people applied this 'ethical' argument to the relatively higher cost of getting online 10-20 years ago.
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by paulddraper on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @10:18PM (#12594952)
Access to computers and the internet is not quite as permanent as genetics.

Were they bestowed at birth by your parents and could be acquired no other way, then you may have a case.

Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by tkxxx7 on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @12:34PM (#12599051)
It's better if you think of "designer babies" as a separate, er, product, than the biotech being discussed.
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by thaumasiotes on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @06:42PM (#12593848)
It's probably worth pointing out that the rich are already smarter, more attractive, and longer-lived than the poor. I'm not aware of a study testing rich vs poor bodily strength, but given the other results I wouldn't exactly find it surprising if the rich were stronger too.
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by dexterdog on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @04:10PM (#12592689)
But what the rich don't have is the raw numbers that the poor can output. The rich are already a selective group, but the poor can just throw armies of meat at the evolutionary battlefield.
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by BurningFrog on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @08:10PM (#12594416)
Since it doesn't make anyone else dumber, weaker or uglier, this mostly sounds like an argument based in envy.
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by grive on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @08:07AM (#12597021)
It makes people dumber, weaker and uglier, relatively to those that can afford it.

There is no "dumb", "weak" or "ugly" in Nature. These are not objective measurements. They are all judgements passed comparatively to the rest of humanity.

Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by BurningFrog on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @11:20AM (#12598338)
"Weak" and "dumb" are absolutely objectively and absolutely measurable.

- Someone who can lift 100 kg is stronger than someone who can only lift 80 kg.

- Someone who understand that is smarter than someone who doesn't.

You could possibly have an argument about "ugly".

Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by tkxxx7 on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @12:37PM (#12599087)
Both of those are comparative, relative measurements which I think was GP's point.

If I can lift 10 kg this week, and 20 kg next week, am I strong, or ("just") stronger than before?

Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by grive on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @04:12PM (#12600913)
That's pretty much exactly my point. These can only exist as comparisons. They are meaningless on their own, e.g. they are not objective attributes.
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by BurningFrog on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @06:27PM (#12601862)
No. I'm sorry, but that is just wrong.

That someone can lift 100 kg is an objective attribute of that person.

Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by grive on Thursday September 29, 2016 @09:07AM (#12604900)
"Lifting 100kg" is objective. Saying that "being able to lift 100kg is being strong" is not. What is not objective is saying what it takes to be considered strong. Not the measurement itself.
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by BurningFrog on Thursday September 29, 2016 @10:42AM (#12605616)
Looking back at the thread, I started by saying "it doesn't make anyone else dumber, weaker or uglier".

You talked about "dumb", "weak" or "ugly" instead, and have stuck to it.

So I suppose you're right within your changed phrasing, because you chose to talk about something different than my point.

Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by grive on Thursday September 29, 2016 @07:16PM (#12609549)
You imply that it was dishonest. It was absolutely not dishonest. It was precisely to emphasize my point.

My point being that the words you used were all comparisons, made in relation to a norm. That's the whole point of the thread. That it was actually impossible to use the nouns themselves ("dumb", "weak", "ugly"), exactly because there cannot be any objective measure of it in nature.

Yes, you lift Nkg. You weight Mkg. You measure Xcm. That does not tell whether you are strong, heavy or tall. These are all meaningless in a vacuum. More importantly, it does not tell whether you are stronger, heavier, taller. Stronger, heavier, taller than what, than whom?

You were excluding this context in you analysis, telling that the poors would not lose anything as they would not be worse off from their former self. The context here is that they are not measured against humanity decades, centuries earlier, but to their contemporaries, the elites that would design their babies.

It is impossible to abstract this context from the comparison, precisely because it is a comparison, and because the only meaningful comparison is that which concerns contemporaries.

Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by BurningFrog on Thursday September 29, 2016 @09:21PM (#12609996)
I didn't mean to say you were dishonest, only that you're talking about a different thing than I am.

It seems like you honestly can't tell the difference. Thanks for the chat!

Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by grive on Friday September 30, 2016 @05:26AM (#12611383)
I can perfectly tell the difference, you simply missed the point.
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by johncolanduoni on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @08:06AM (#12597018)
Not really. Do you imagine social and economic classes and their relationship/attitudes toward another wouldn't be affected by this? Even if all it does is increase envy of the people who can't afford the treatments for their children, making that existing envy so much more concrete could have some pretty wide-reaching social consequences. No matter how strict your principle of harm.
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by Kalium on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @04:11PM (#12592698)
In short, "designer babies" is approximately the same thing to us today as nutrition was to an earlier age.
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by pyre on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @05:16PM (#12593301)
A better analogy for "designer babies" would be performance enhancing drugs in sports. If we accept their use, then it basically becomes a requirement on anyone that wants to participate (or at least compete).
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by roywiggins on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @07:59PM (#12594352)
The real ethical issue is that you're giving "performance enhancers" to babies. We can't test this stuff in vitro or in adults, not really. So any baby born this way is, in some sense, an experiment.

And crucially, so are all of those babies' children and their children, because they will inherit some or all of the genetic changes.

Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by int_19h on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @11:41PM (#12595288)
Participate in what, though?

This outlook basically presupposes that society is a competition of everyone against everyone. Does it have to be? If it does, what does "losing" mean, and can we reduce its impact to the point where it stops mattering?

Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by malka on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @07:28AM (#12596854)
> society is a competition of everyone against everyone. Does it have to be?

Not society. The universe. Ressource ownership is exclusive. If I own something, no one else can own the very same thing at the same time.

Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by int_19h on Thursday September 29, 2016 @05:37PM (#12608967)
One other thing. Just because I own fewer resources than someone else, doesn't mean that I "lose". I mean, you can arbitrarily define it that way, but in practice, I only need enough resources to sustain a certain quality of life. So, while universe may be finite wrt resources in theory, the actual number is so big that it may well be treated as infinite for all practical purposes, provided that we don't have unbounded population growth.
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by int_19h on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @02:27PM (#12600041)
Sure, but society can prevent you from hogging too much for yourself (via taxes etc), so long as it's not 100% laissez-faire, and not just the rich have political rights.
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by pyre on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @09:32PM (#12602715)
Do you have faith that these aspects of human society will be solved in parallel with increased "designer baby" technology?
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by int_19h on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @09:44PM (#12602768)
No, but I don't see the "designer baby" tech as something that radically changes the nature of the problem (which already exists, and has existed for a long time), either. Basically, insofar as status quo is tolerable, this doesn't move the needle enough to care.

The other thing is, coming from a "well, something must be done about it" perspective, fixing these aspects of human society strikes me as the least intrusive and harmful side-effect-free approach, compared to all the other alternatives (which are mostly about tightly regulating the tech and its use). Heavy handed regulation, in particular, will just produce a black market with no regulation at all, which is likely to result in more problems in the end.

Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by BurningFrog on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @08:08PM (#12594404)
Only if you see life as a competition against your fellow humans.
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by pyre on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @11:10PM (#12595180)
It's not always about whether or not you see everything as a competition. Consider the "requirement" nowadays of a college degree. I could say that you "need a college degree to compete in the work-force," but that doesn't mean you just need a college degree only if you want to be the "best of the best." Also see sci-fi exploration of this topic (e.g. Gattaca).
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by hueving on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @03:04AM (#12595926)
>Also see sci-fi exploration of this topic (e.g. Gattaca).

Don't use this as part of an argument. Some stories made up based on assumptions of writers not backed by any evidence have little to do with the ethical implications of actual technology.

Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by pyre on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @09:28PM (#12602701)
Are you saying that we should disregard all science-fiction that has explored this topic when considering possible implications? I was referencing sci-fi as more of a "further reading" than as part of an argument.
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by BurningFrog on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @12:44AM (#12595454)
I think the need for a college degree to even get a job is (1) specific to American society and regulations, and (2) not really true even there.

Since we're talking about general human morality, I wouldn't put much weight on the particulars of this region in 2016.

On a healthy job market, you get paid about as much as you produce. Regardless of what others produce. You also get to benefit from whatever inventions any new super talented people come up with.

Finally, the more intelligent a population is in general, the more peaceful it is.

Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by pyre on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @09:31PM (#12602712)
It's not a hard and fast requirement, but there is definitely a wage-gap between the have's and have-not's when it comes to college degrees.
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by dawidloubser on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @06:00AM (#12596508)
Life, arguably, is a competition. Evolution inherently rewards winners.
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by lyle_nel on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @03:44AM (#12596054)
Most world class athletes are already genetically superior by the measure of athleticism. Even though these favourable mutations or inherited traits have not been engineered, they still exist and it does enhance the athlete's performance.
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by joesb on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @10:04PM (#12594890)
What about drugs in general, not just performance enhancing drugs? I meant, everyone want to participate in modern medical treatment, right?
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by pyre on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @11:03PM (#12595149)
> What about drugs in general, not just performance enhancing drugs? I meant, everyone want to participate in modern medical treatment, right?

What? I'm talking about performance-enhancing drugs here because they enhance performance. So everyone else operating in the same space as you will need to also use performance-enhancing drugs if they want to compete. I'm not sure why this is a hard concept to grasp.

If there were a pill you could take to turn you into the mythical "10x programmer," the implication of industry-wide usage would be that you would have to start taking that pill to participate in the industry or else you wouldn't be able to keep up.

Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by int_19h on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @11:44PM (#12595294)
We already have such pills, in effect. For example, someone who has depression (a very common ailment), but also has access to drugs that mitigate it, can easily be 10x better programmer relative to someone who has depression but no drugs.

Come to think of it, this goes for a lot of other things. Having a car is better than not having one, if only because you shorten commute times, and so have more free time - which translates to better rest and therefore higher productivity, or you could spend it learning new things, again, for higher productivity.

So basically anything that improves your quality of life in exchange for money is "performance enhancing" directly or indirectly.

Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by hueving on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @03:04AM (#12595929)
Immunizations are performance enhancing drugs. Shall we ban them?
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by Goronmon on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @02:19PM (#12599959)
You are using an incorrect definition of "performance enhancing". Your question is easy to answer if you don't start off from an incorrect context.
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by rubber_duck on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @02:44PM (#12591922)
That happens anyway - traits that help you succeed (IQ, health, appearance, impulse control, etc.) are heritable.
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by undersuit on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @03:23PM (#12592294)
Yes and when you are successful and you keep the heritable traits close to the family... you end up with royal inbreds.
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by return0 on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @07:03PM (#12594017)
The rich always had access to new technologies first, and there is nothing new here; eventually all technology becomes affordable for the masses.

What you 're more likely to have a is clash of generations where the brave new generation will consider their fathers (rich or not) as parasites.

Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by crpatino on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @07:10PM (#12594070)
Dunno, I am still waiting for my damned flying Delorean.

Instead, the rich all got dumb old-fashioned helicopters.

Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by azazqadir on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @01:07AM (#12595535)
Gattaca was pretty much based on this as well.
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by vasco on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @02:24PM (#12591752)
Or you use state sponsored designs and everyone has access to it.
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by scarmig on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @02:33PM (#12591819)
Just like state sponsored designs have guaranteed access to health care and education.
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by notgood on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @02:44PM (#12591926)
They have in some country, if it doesn't in yours I don't think you can blame the technology involved.

There was a time in which only rich people had toilets and in-house showers, now many extremely poor people have access to those; the same thing will happen with "design babies", there will be a time where only rich people can do it, but as time goes it will become a commodity and making sure you are as healthy as possible even before born will be a human rights issue.

Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by YorickPeterse on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @03:31PM (#12592353)
They have in many modern first-world countries.
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by talideon on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @08:30AM (#12597122)
Not to mention the fact that the same processes could be used to create a permanent underclass though genetic manipulation of the masses.