News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by BurningFrog on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @08:10PM (#12594416)
Since it doesn't make anyone else dumber, weaker or uglier, this mostly sounds like an argument based in envy.
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by grive on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @08:07AM (#12597021)
It makes people dumber, weaker and uglier, relatively to those that can afford it.

There is no "dumb", "weak" or "ugly" in Nature. These are not objective measurements. They are all judgements passed comparatively to the rest of humanity.

Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by BurningFrog on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @11:20AM (#12598338)
"Weak" and "dumb" are absolutely objectively and absolutely measurable.

- Someone who can lift 100 kg is stronger than someone who can only lift 80 kg.

- Someone who understand that is smarter than someone who doesn't.

You could possibly have an argument about "ugly".

Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by tkxxx7 on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @12:37PM (#12599087)
Both of those are comparative, relative measurements which I think was GP's point.

If I can lift 10 kg this week, and 20 kg next week, am I strong, or ("just") stronger than before?

Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by grive on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @04:12PM (#12600913)
That's pretty much exactly my point. These can only exist as comparisons. They are meaningless on their own, e.g. they are not objective attributes.
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by BurningFrog on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @06:27PM (#12601862)
No. I'm sorry, but that is just wrong.

That someone can lift 100 kg is an objective attribute of that person.

Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by grive on Thursday September 29, 2016 @09:07AM (#12604900)
"Lifting 100kg" is objective. Saying that "being able to lift 100kg is being strong" is not. What is not objective is saying what it takes to be considered strong. Not the measurement itself.
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by BurningFrog on Thursday September 29, 2016 @10:42AM (#12605616)
Looking back at the thread, I started by saying "it doesn't make anyone else dumber, weaker or uglier".

You talked about "dumb", "weak" or "ugly" instead, and have stuck to it.

So I suppose you're right within your changed phrasing, because you chose to talk about something different than my point.

Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by grive on Thursday September 29, 2016 @07:16PM (#12609549)
You imply that it was dishonest. It was absolutely not dishonest. It was precisely to emphasize my point.

My point being that the words you used were all comparisons, made in relation to a norm. That's the whole point of the thread. That it was actually impossible to use the nouns themselves ("dumb", "weak", "ugly"), exactly because there cannot be any objective measure of it in nature.

Yes, you lift Nkg. You weight Mkg. You measure Xcm. That does not tell whether you are strong, heavy or tall. These are all meaningless in a vacuum. More importantly, it does not tell whether you are stronger, heavier, taller. Stronger, heavier, taller than what, than whom?

You were excluding this context in you analysis, telling that the poors would not lose anything as they would not be worse off from their former self. The context here is that they are not measured against humanity decades, centuries earlier, but to their contemporaries, the elites that would design their babies.

It is impossible to abstract this context from the comparison, precisely because it is a comparison, and because the only meaningful comparison is that which concerns contemporaries.

Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by BurningFrog on Thursday September 29, 2016 @09:21PM (#12609996)
I didn't mean to say you were dishonest, only that you're talking about a different thing than I am.

It seems like you honestly can't tell the difference. Thanks for the chat!

Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by grive on Friday September 30, 2016 @05:26AM (#12611383)
I can perfectly tell the difference, you simply missed the point.
Re:First 'three person baby' born using new method by johncolanduoni on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @08:06AM (#12597018)
Not really. Do you imagine social and economic classes and their relationship/attitudes toward another wouldn't be affected by this? Even if all it does is increase envy of the people who can't afford the treatments for their children, making that existing envy so much more concrete could have some pretty wide-reaching social consequences. No matter how strict your principle of harm.