- lower class: your name is on your shirt
- middle class: your name is on your office door
- upper class: your name is on the building
:-)
Your class is more related to your self-esteem than your income.
In one of the companies I worked for as a contractor, I had my own office and it felt great.
When I was younger, I briefly worked in a telemarketing call center for the equivalent of $20K per year. Then many years later (after I finished uni), I was earning $200K per year in a different company (as a software engineer in an open workspace).
The $200K workplace didn't boost my self-esteem much more than than the $20k workplace.
This is the epitome of pampered engineer BS. You aren't lower class because you don't have a private office.
$200k/year and lower class? You can afford to buy your own private office for much less than that.
It's funny because software developers are more kin to the 'real professions' like law when it comes to earnings potential: like lawyers, a software dev can simply make money by setting up his or her own shop with very* little capital investment beyond education.
Edit:
Now that I think about it, the loss of respect might come from the fact that software devs have a 'management' looking over their shoulders at all. In other 'true' professions, the ones who are liable to cut-costs, haze, or otherwise pour abuse on a professional would also be in the same profession. E.g. if you're a lawyer, you may work 100 hour weeks for the first 8 years, but you're doing so not because some pointy-haired MBA is telling you, but because X lawyer with prestige who owns the company is telling you to. So even though the outcome is the same, it may feel more okay because its coming from someone of your same class/category.
coming from someone of your same class/category
I think you make a very good point here: it is coming from a colleague, someone who is on (more or less) the same track as you are, only a little ahead of you in terms of the career path.Nah, that's just how wage-labor works.
Historically, there's been a push-pull between engineering and the professions. Engineering (artillery, civil, metal-working and the like) being seen as low class labour where as the professions (law/medicine/natural philosophy then science) was seen as high class work.
I once believed this was because engineering always had a physical outcome, where as professional work could be done as a pure though experiment (e.g. law) or had literal connotations of power of live (e.g. medicine).
But looking at computer science/engineering, I wonder if that's a good hypothesis. CS is still suffering from the same low-prestige status despite having billionaires rise from its ranks, and despite that it has no physical equivalent.
Perhaps their point is that autonomy is a better indicator of class than salary. Just like 'stupid is as stupid does,' 'class is as class does.'
Being able to afford your own office means nothing if you can't actually use it because you spend 8-10 hours a day trapped in an environment that you find degrading.
The barrier to class mobility in this case is mental. The engineer has traded autonomy for cash.
My own opinion is that one becomes upper class when they can choose not to work. If your living expenses are $20k/year and you make that from returns on passive investments, congratulations, you're a part of the leisure class.
If your expenses are $190k/year and you earn a salary of $200k/year you're a part of the lower/precariat class.
However having your family name on your building seems less common in the US and Europe nowadays. In American business culture having a generic name such as Google, Microsoft seems to be viewed as being more elite. Would Americans say that is accurate?
This causes me to suspect that Trump and Andreessen Horowitz are exceptions that view themselves as outsiders to the corporate club in some way, which is interesting.
It might have something to do with the difference between new and old money or different subclasses butting up against each other.
I myself would be proud to put the family crest blazoned on the helm of our battlebots at the factory, Game of Thrones has evidently influenced my education. Much better than something like 'Active Defense Ltd' or 'Pro-Tech.org'.
Just because a 22yr old might work as an intern does not make them lower class.
In the UK we generally consider class to be something to include family, upbringing, attitude and as well as finances.
- Lower class: convert social good into survival, dependent on others for basic survival
- Middle class: convert work into survival, provide for yourself and maybe your family
- Upper class: convert capital into survival, provide for yourself, your family and potentially society.
I stopped saying lower/middle/upper colloquially and started saying simply dependent, middle class or capital class.
This is not the way most people have traditionally thought of the middle class.
The middle class were the highly-skilled white-collar professionals: doctors, lawyers, engineers. In contrast, the lower class were the poor or blue-collar workers: farmers, factory workers, and the unemployed. Whereas the upper class referred to business owners and financiers.
With the decline of farming and manufacturing, blue-collar workers shifted to service industries.
What is striking is most people think they have the living standard of skilled white-collar professionals, even though they are just service industry workers.
This situation is only possible because of universal access to cheap credit.
The idea that being a business owner makes you "upper class" is absurd. Most business owners have always been middle class. Most businesses aren't that lucrative and require large amounts of time relative to the amount of profit generated.
As far as I know, there are no formal and universal definitions of the class system. Certainly in Britain, class has almost nothing to do with your income or bank balance. A lot of the upper class are completely broke, while there are many "working class millionaires".
Many Europeans are descended from people that potentially give them the right to nobility. Few invoke that in everyday life though.
So you could become an aristocrat if you really wanted to be, by blue blood or by financial assistance. In the old days somebody successful in business would often transition to aristocracy by taking on a name and the associated trappings. It is something of a controversial area! In Japan it is still common for an unrelated successful young man to be adopted into the family tree of a business dynasty.
I suspect the upper class alternates between being meritocratic and being hereditary, while claiming 'it ever twas'.
Not entirely. Perhaps more than in the UK, yet behavior and social circle are still a factor in the US.
That's fine and indicates you're using a more historical definition, but doesn't make the parent comment accurate. A decidedly lower-middle class individual can start a business and this will in no way suddenly push them into the upper class. If they make millions, they still won't be upper class by your definition unless maybe they do so well they somehow get a lordship or at least a knighthood out of it.
Nope, that is very much the historical definition. With the caveat that for "business owners" you should read big business owners (from Larry Elisson to the guy that owns a restaurant chain), not some person with his own hair saloon in Iowa, or some programmer who freelances as an LLC.
From the dictionary:
"the class traditionally intermediate between the aristocratic class and the laboring class."
From Wikipedia:
"In Weberian socio-economic terms, the middle class is the broad group of people in contemporary society who fall socio-economically between the working class and upper class."
"The modern usage of the term "middle class", however, dates to the 1913 UK Registrar-General's report, in which the statistician T.H.C. Stevenson identified the middle class as that falling between the upper class and the working class. Included as belonging to the middle class are professionals, managers, and senior civil servants. The chief defining characteristic of membership in the middle class is possession of significant human capital."
And generally:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Middle_class#History_and_evolu...
Also, they went to the Mall of America to get opinions. Malls almost by definition avoid having the extremely poor (who can't afford anything) and the extremely wealthy (who certainly don't need to go to a mall to buy things).
There are always window shoppers and people that go there just to "hang out" without buying anything.
The wealthy people also have to buy their clothes somewhere and they probably stick to overpriced items in brand stores (not sure if I'm using the right name, but I'm thinking of the stores where they only sell one brand) which could be locates in a mall.
I mean, $500k a year is a LOT of money, even in places like SF.
http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2012/01/13/the-shockingly-sim...
The $500k lawyer isn't going to just drive a Honda. He has to have the BMW 7 Series ($130k) -- and he wants a brand new one every 2 or 3 years. Instead of getting a mortgage that consumes a tiny fraction of his income or buying a cheap house free & clear, he'll take on a mortgage up to the max credit limit allowed by the bank. Hence he has a $2+ million dollar estate in a gated neighborhood. Does he have kids? Well then, it must be private school. The most desirable private schools in NYC cost $40k tuition per student per year. 3 kids means $120k/year. Basically, you do the arithmetic and $500k/year is abject poverty -- uh I mean -- middle class.
Few lawyers (or consultants or bankers) can make $500k in Iowa City (or even Seattle for that matter). Someone with a household income of $120k can easily afford a 2400 square foot house (that's the national average for a new house) within 30 minutes of work in a good school district near Des Moines. I'd estimate same combination takes an HHI of around $300k in the DC metro area. Jump to $500k (at that bracket you're losing almost half in taxes), and you're wearing nicer suits and saving better for retirement and your kids' college, but saving $100k per year isn't going to let you quit your job and live off interest any time soon.
If anything the Medean income seems like a good ballpark for enough. But, it's really hard to stop.
Even if MicroSoft didn't take off, he'd still be wealthy. He's the kind of guy that waits to get the absolute maximum value out of each dollar he spends.
That's not a bad thing, by the way, just unusual.
Being the richest man in the world makes pretty much everything appear a trivial expense, but there has to be a limit somewhere.
1. http://blog.dupontregistry.com/celebrity-cars/bill-gates-ame...
edit
I get what you're saying. I just don't see the millions thrown away into nothing. Drugs, parties, wrecked cars, pissing away cash. Mike Tyson was worth $400,000,000. now he has nothing. It's easy to find people that got rich and lost it all. Lottery winners and pro athletes are prime examples.
Granted, spend one dollar less than you earn, and you're winning. He just seems like the kind of guy that has a hard time parting with cash for any reason.
The real difference is often positive vs negative investment returns. Most sports stars lose more money from poor investments than they do spending.
As to being rich, sure he inherited millions. But, connections, background, timing, and luck only go so far. You really can blow any amount of money.
I've never met the guy. By all accounts he's smart, dedicated and hard working. I think he'd be doing just fine regardless of the field he went into. He got very lucky, so he's a billionaire 80 times over.
And, yes. The prince of Brunei is a great example of not thrifty. 14 billion in just 10 years. [1]
[1] http://www.vanityfair.com/news/2011/07/prince-jefri-201107
It's natural to think of spending in morale term so donations or gifts don't count or relative to income. Which makes finding a reasonable limit on the absolute scale meaningless. Supose he had 10 trillion and spent 1% on a house would a 100 billion be extravagant in that context?
I guess you're saying he's just doing whatever he thinks is fun from moment to moment, like prince Jefri. It seems like there's a subtle difference there, but I don't know how to articulate it.
I make good money as a developer and live well below my means, but I am not thrifty. I simply don't have much interest in buying most things, but I can point to 10's of thousands of dollars in wasteful spending.
" Octopus sports two helicopter[2] pads on the top deck, a twin pad and hangars at the stern and a single pad on the bow; and a 63-foot (19 m) tender docked in the transom. There are a total of seven tenders aboard. The yacht also has a pool, located aft on one of its upper decks[citation needed], and two submarines (one of them operated by remote control for studying the bottom of the ocean).[citation needed] Side hatches at the water line form a dock for jet skis. "
The classes are most commonly defined by economists as income brackets, not as welfare vs jobs vs passive income. [1] Yet when people are asked what class they're in, they use welfare and investments as the indicator.
Look at the stats and you start to see that by almost all definitions, the vast majority of the "rich" still have to work for a living, they simply have very high salaries. Passive income lifestyles are only being had by a very very few people well above the median of any "upper class" definition you can find.
It's not surprising that relatively well-to-do people think they're middle class, but it also doesn't hurt to have some perspective and realize that at at household income of $200k, you're in the top 3% in the US. [2] The goal of a passive lifestyle is not and might never be a realistic definition of rich, nor a practical goal for the vast majority.
--
Of course, as others have pointed out, it definitely depends on where you live. For more perspective, here are some stats on the cities used in the infographic:
[In 2000] The median income for a household in [Lakefield, MN] was $31,250, and the median income for a family was $37,898. [3]
The median household income in Edina in 1999 was $66,019. [4]
According to a 2007 estimate, the median income for a household in [Scottsdale, AZ] was $70,533, and the median income for a family was $92,289. [5]
According to the U.S. Census Bureau's American Community Survey data estimates for 2008-2012, the median income for a household in [Chicago] was $47,408, and the median income for a family was $54,188. [6]
Real Median Household Income 2014: US=$53,657 Minnesota=$61,481 Minneapolis=$69,111 [7]
That's over 2x variation, but most people would judge incomes of 50k and 100k very differently. *Edit: btw, kinda wierd 3 of 5 examples were from Minnesota...?
--
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Affluence_in_the_United_States#Status_and_stratification
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Affluence_in_the_United_States#Top_percentiles
[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lakefield,_Minnesota#Demographics
[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edina,_Minnesota#Demographics
[5] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scottsdale,_Arizona#Demographics
[6] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chicago#Demographics
[7] https://www.google.com/search?q=median+income+minneapolis+mn
- lower class: on welfare & food stamps
- middle class: have a job, must work for a living
- upper class: not having to work and living off interest payments of wealth investments
Therefore, the middle class covers the wide spectrum of $9/hr Starbucks baristas and $500k white shoe lawyers. For "lower class", most people use the label "poor". For "upper class", most people use the label "rich".
(I'm guessing Bloomberg was attempting to give an insight similar to the mathematical contradiction of "everybody thinks they're an above-average driver". However, they misunderstood how people self-identify themselves as "middle class".)