News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How does Google know where I am? by pawadu on Friday September 23, 2016 @11:02AM (#12565120)
This is not tower triangulation.

Android searches for access points even when wifi is turned off. If anyone (with GPS enabled) uses that wifi with any google services the bssid will end up in their database. Also if the google car has been nearby it has recorded the presence of the wifi access point at that location [1].

Before you freak out: Apple and Microsoft also use access point information for positioning, although not as successfully.

[1] https://googleblog.blogspot.se/2010/05/wifi-data-collection-...

Re:How does Google know where I am? by comboy on Friday September 23, 2016 @11:44AM (#12565455)
Are you sure they do that when wifi is off? I was under the impression that it only happens when wifi is on (and it seems to me that my location on the map is more stable with wifi on).

That would be very not ok if it would happen with wifi off. I turn my wifi off to save the battery, and it wouldn't do much if it was still looking for broadcasts.

Re:How does Google know where I am? by takeda on Friday September 23, 2016 @10:47PM (#12569201)
This was true in the past. Now wifi off is not really off. There is an obscure setting in location where you can disable it.

Of course Google does its usual, making it inconvenient. When you enable that setting wifi location is completely disabled and many apps which use finer location will trigger a popup to enable it back in order to get a better location.

They do this with any setting that benefits them. For example if you don't allow Google to store your historical location Maps won't remember any locations searched. As if it was impossible to maps store that details locally sigh.

Re:How does Google know where I am? by lkbm on Saturday September 24, 2016 @11:24AM (#12571264)
> There is an obscure setting in location where you can disable it.

For those wondering, I believe the setting is Settings => Location => => Scanning (in the the vertical dots menu in the upper right) => Wi-Fi scanning (on my Nexus 5 running Android 6.0.1, anyway.)

Re:How does Google know where I am? by sly010 on Friday September 23, 2016 @12:30PM (#12565839)
Its a question of terminology. When you are passively listening to (periodic) SSID beacons, you are not transmitting anything, nor consuming any energy on your radio. One could do that even in airplane mode.

It's very different from when you hit "scan" and are actively sending broadcast packets on every frequency and waiting for the wifi routers to (actively) answer. Which really only happens when you pull down the list of nearby hotspots.

Re:How does Google know where I am? by mirashii on Friday September 23, 2016 @04:41PM (#12567791)
> nor consuming any energy on your radio

This simply isn't true. You'll be using power to demodulate at a minimum. You'll also be using energy to ammplify the incoming signals and a variety of other things.

Re:How does Google know where I am? by klodolph on Friday September 23, 2016 @09:33PM (#12569033)
Yes, this is also the reason why GPS is so power hungry--it takes a lot of power to keep a GPS radio receiver operating.
Re:How does Google know where I am? by jsjohnst on Saturday September 24, 2016 @02:19AM (#12569693)
Close enough for a quick reply, but it's not the "radio" using lots of power, it's the chip that's doing the signal processing. GPS signals are very weak (approximately -120dbm) and thus below the noise floor. It takes complex FFT operations that actually cause the power hungry nature to find the proverbial needle in the haystack.
Re:How does Google know where I am? by klodolph on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @12:53PM (#12591022)
Normally, "radio" includes the amplifiers and demodulators, even if they're digital.
Re:How does Google know where I am? by jhayward on Friday September 23, 2016 @06:03PM (#12568297)
> or consuming any energy on your radio

Listening is actually one of the more power-intensive things a radio does, because it tends to be active more of the time than transmitting does. For many radios power consumption is the same whether transmitting or receiving.

Re:How does Google know where I am? by omilu on Friday September 23, 2016 @09:25PM (#12569016)
>For many radios power consumption is the same whether transmitting or receiving

This, is not right.

Re:How does Google know where I am? by mynewtb on Saturday September 24, 2016 @02:13AM (#12569685)
Please elaborate at least a bit.
Re:How does Google know where I am? by anexprogrammer on Friday September 23, 2016 @11:59AM (#12565560)
There's another wifi setting, in advanced I think, for "scanning always available"
Re:How does Google know where I am? by tuxracer on Friday September 23, 2016 @01:03PM (#12566127)
WiFi is never completely off until you disable "Scanning always available" https://i.stack.imgur.com/wcQkc.png
Re:How does Google know where I am? by jasonkostempski on Friday September 23, 2016 @01:13PM (#12566218)
I don't have that option under "Advanced Wi-Fi" but under Settings -> Location -> Scanning I have "Wi-Fi Scanning Improve location by allowing system apps and services to detect Wi-Fi networks at any time". Is that the same thing?

Nexus 5X, Android 7.0

Re:How does Google know where I am? by khedoros on Friday September 23, 2016 @06:36PM (#12568443)
Ditto, Nexus 5, Android 6.0.1. That's how I interpreted it: as a relocation and rewording of a setting.
Re:How does Google know where I am? by kllrnohj on Friday September 23, 2016 @01:11PM (#12566200)
> I turn my wifi off to save the battery

Sending/receiving data over wifi takes roughly ~8x less power than sending/receiving data over cell.

If you want to save battery you need to turn off data entirely not turn off wifi. Turning off wifi ultimately costs you battery.

Re:How does Google know where I am? by bogomipz on Friday September 23, 2016 @02:58PM (#12567091)
>"Sending/receiving data over wifi takes roughly ~8x less power than sending/receiving data over cell"

How did you arrive at this 8x figure? I don't think this is correct at all. See:

http://people.cs.umass.edu/~arun/papers/TailEnder.pdf

Additionally power efficiency is related to distance from the cell tower which is generally much further away than a wifi access point.

Re:How does Google know where I am? by kllrnohj on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @04:21PM (#12639108)
Were you misled by the changing axis scale? From that paper:

> Our measurements (Section 3) confirm that the transmission energy consumed by WiFi is significantly smaller than both 3G and GSM, especially for large transfer sizes.

Also that's 3G, not LTE which is what most everyone is using nowadays.

Re:How does Google know where I am? by comboy on Friday September 23, 2016 @01:41PM (#12566479)
Not if I'm out of range of my home wifi which is practically the only wifi I connect to. I think my phone last longer like that, but I never actually measured it, so maybe it's not worth it after all. I guess I also don't like the idea of broadcasting these few known networks I have saved.
Re:How does Google know where I am? by killnine on Friday September 23, 2016 @04:27PM (#12567699)
Re:How does Google know where I am? by pawadu on Friday September 23, 2016 @11:25AM (#12565289)
This raises another imprtant question: Is it okay for a private company to have detailed positioning data from inside of your office or home?

Who would really need that sort of information? I understand how this can be useful at the mall but I think I can find my way around my own house thank you.

Re:How does Google know where I am? by mikestew on Friday September 23, 2016 @11:58AM (#12565553)
Is it okay for a private company to have detailed positioning data from inside of your office or home?

I don't know the answer to that question, but I have a guess at the answer to another question: "is it okay for a private company to create a geodatabase of SSID strings that were freely and willingly broadcast via radio?"

I think the answer is "yes". Ten, fifteen years ago, if there were an HN story about how I, owner of a small business you've never heard of, created a database of SSIDs that are broadcast and tagged them with lat/longs, I'd bet money it would make the top of the front page. Bonus points if I included an API and threw the thing up on github.

Fine, it's evil, append "_nomap" to your SSID string. That's fine for stopping Google, but it won't stop "owner of small business you've never heard of". Don't broad SSIDs, but then (IIRC) one can still obtain the MAC address.

But in the end, if a radio broadcasts something then one has little recourse when receivers use that broadcast in ways you didn't intend. The analogy crumbles under a little scrutiny, but it's similar to FM broadcasters complain about geodatabases of FM towers because the intent of the broadcaster was to allow you to listen to drive-time hyenas, not use it for location services.

Re:How does Google know where I am? by grkvlt on Friday September 23, 2016 @03:18PM (#12567223)
Interesting point about `_nomap` which I wasn't aware of until now. See this page, under 'How do I opt out?' for details: https://support.google.com/nexus/answer/1725632?hl=en&visit_...
Re:How does Google know where I am? by newman314 on Friday September 23, 2016 @06:51PM (#12568500)
FWIW, Microsoft has a different string and yes, order matters IIRC.
Re:How does Google know where I am? by clort on Sunday September 25, 2016 @11:07AM (#12575631)
Re:How does Google know where I am? by tlow on Friday September 23, 2016 @01:09PM (#12566186)
When you use their service your forfeit your privacy.
Re:How does Google know where I am? by brightsize on Friday September 23, 2016 @01:52PM (#12566581)
You don't even need to use their services, interested crowdsourcers will map your router and help build a SSID:location database just for fun. https://www.wigle.net/
Re:How does Google know where I am? by nitrogen on Friday September 23, 2016 @12:12PM (#12565669)
I seriously doubt most people even know whst "broadcast" means, or that "their" wifi is not limited to their own four walls and personal use.
Re:How does Google know where I am? by bhhaskin on Friday September 23, 2016 @12:23PM (#12565774)
Not knowing how it works doesn't change the fact that broadcasting the SSID is a key part of how wifi works. The only real solution is not to use wifi if you don't want it to be mapped.
Re:How does Google know where I am? by mikestew on Friday September 23, 2016 @12:32PM (#12565858)
"Ignorance is no excuse"? I mean, I don't know what the solution is if that's an allowable excuse. Google has to run PSA's on how WiFi works before they're allowed to scoop up SSIDs?

Additionally, I don't buy that to begin with, at least not as it concerns the majority. Where do folks think those other SSIDs (even if they don't call them that) in their list of networks come from?

Re:How does Google know where I am? by TeMPOraL on Friday September 23, 2016 @12:38PM (#12565914)
Come on. There have to be some minimum standards of knowledge required for the citizens of a technological society, and I'd argue that "how radio works" is one of those things one should be expected to know.
Re:How does Google know where I am? by paavokoya on Friday September 23, 2016 @12:49PM (#12566001)

   minimum standards of knowledge required for the citizens
Do you know how the electricity in your wall works? What about the plumbing under your house? Would you be able to fix those things on your own?
Re:How does Google know where I am? by TeMPOraL on Friday September 23, 2016 @01:23PM (#12566322)
Yes. Yes. No.

The level of IMO required knowledge I'm talking about here is to know e.g. that water in your faucet is distributed through the building via water pipes, and electricity comes through cables that are inside walls. Even this basic knowledge allows one to infer quite a lot.

Re:How does Google know where I am? by jpindar on Friday September 23, 2016 @01:22PM (#12566314)
You don't?
Re:How does Google know where I am? by DominikR on Friday September 23, 2016 @01:13PM (#12566226)
His argument was that you can reasonably expect people to know how to handle such technologies safely, not that he expects people to know how to build a WiFi Router from electronic parts themselves.

Using your analogy it would be sufficient for a person to know how to handle electricity coming from your wall or the plumbing under your house safely. And generally people do know how to do that.

Everyone who is regularly using WiFi networks knows that he/she can see the names of other WiFi networks in their vicinity. Therefore people using WiFi generally do know that this information is publicly broadcasted and available to be collected by anyone interested in doing so.

No one believes that he is the only person being able to somehow magically see the name of his neighbours WiFi.

Re:How does Google know where I am? by paavokoya on Friday September 23, 2016 @02:00PM (#12566649)
I think the advanced users of HN vastly over-estimate the common sense level of the general public.

http://qz.com/333313/milliions-of-facebook-users-have-no-ide...

Re:How does Google know where I am? by grkvlt on Friday September 23, 2016 @03:27PM (#12567287)
I think the 'advanced' users of HN vastly over-estimate the amount of information that the general public requires in order to apply common sense. As a member of the public, I have no real need to know about the protocols the Internet uses, or how Facebook and the Web are related, but it is useful to make a distinction between using Facebook (social interaction, sharing information actively, communicating with friends) and using the Internet (browsing Wikipedia, looking up recipes on Google, accessing Web sites on my laptop or tablet by myself) when communicating with others.
Re:How does Google know where I am? by DominikR on Friday September 23, 2016 @02:18PM (#12566785)
In third world countries people historically got to use Internet services much later, with more limited hardware and in also in a very different way. (not on a PC, instead on a feature phone with a very small screen) So it's not surprising that they have a different perception than we do.

Frankly I don't care for the matter at hand about the perception and understanding of the Internet that people from a different culture might have just as I do not care about the Saudi perspective on women's and LGBT rights. We are discussing here what should be the standard in our societies.

Re:How does Google know where I am? by mentat on Friday September 23, 2016 @09:07PM (#12568972)
This existed 15 years ago, called WiGLE.
Re:How does Google know where I am? by tdkl on Friday September 23, 2016 @12:56PM (#12566065)
> Fine, it's evil, append "_nomap" to your SSID string. That's fine for stopping Google,

This should be opt-in by default in sane universe, not opt-out.

Re:How does Google know where I am? by dragonwriter on Friday September 23, 2016 @01:04PM (#12566137)
I'd agree, if you mean broadcasting an SSID should be opt-in by default, but not if you mean having a publicly broadcast SSID be mapped should be opt-in by default separately from broadcasting the SSID.

OTOH, to the extent this is not true, its ISPs and router manufacturers who are at fault.

Re:How does Google know where I am? by packetslave on Friday September 23, 2016 @01:09PM (#12566188)
if broadcasting SSID was not on by default, mom and dad would be screaming at tech support that wifi isn't "working" on their phone because the network isn't in the list of discovered networks.
Re:How does Google know where I am? by tdkl on Friday September 23, 2016 @01:19PM (#12566287)
I've meant sharing the location of the SSID with $company should be opt-in. Who the fuck do they think they are?
Re:How does Google know where I am? by dragonwriter on Friday September 23, 2016 @01:22PM (#12566315)
> I've meant sharing the location of the SSID with $company should be opt-in.

Broadcasting is, inherently, sharing location with everyone with a receiver.

> Who the fuck do they think they are?

People with receivers (see above.)

Re:How does Google know where I am? by tdkl on Friday September 23, 2016 @01:25PM (#12566333)
Ok, but one thing is broadcasting something that has a limited reach then documenting and storing in various databases around the planet.
Re:How does Google know where I am? by mikestew on Friday September 23, 2016 @01:48PM (#12566538)
Cell towers, FM/AM radio towers, amateur radio repeaters are just a few things off the top of my head that have limited reach but are stored somewhere as key/value pairs with a lay/long with public access.

I don't know what to tell you other than "I don't like the way I feel about this" is not the basis of good policy.

Re:How does Google know where I am? by kuschku on Friday September 23, 2016 @01:09PM (#12566187)
So, then it’d also be legal if I stand near all schools, and photograph every child with a telezoom lens, follow each of them home, and then publish a website with photos of every child and where they live?

If they don’t want to be seen, they can just stop broadcasting their face and wear a burqa, right?

There is a huge difference between "publicly available in every case seperately" and "publicly indexable".

EDIT: Instead of downvoting, please leave a comment instead – do you disagree because you believe there’s a fundamental difference between gigahertz and terahertz light waves? Or is there another reason you disagree?

Re:How does Google know where I am? by xapata on Friday September 23, 2016 @01:49PM (#12566546)
Yes, that probably is a legal activity. However, someone could sue for a restraining order. After that, and possibly further lawsuits, that activity would become illegal for you.

The possibilities of human behavior are infinite. We don't need to and can't enumerate all possible bad behaviors as illegal. Thus the civil court system.

On the second thought, I think there's some law against publishing images of people without their consent in some circumstances. I'm not clear on exactly what is allowed, but I know that TV broadcasters post notices in places that they are filming.

Re:How does Google know where I am? by dragonwriter on Friday September 23, 2016 @01:53PM (#12566590)
> Yes, that probably is a legal activity. However, someone could sue for a restraining order.

A restraining order is issued for either actually illegal activity, or for activity whose legal status is in dispute, and which would irreparably negatively impact a party in the case in which it that status was in dispute, or for activity which might straddle the line of legality but which is related to a broader pattern of activity which was found to be illegal.

Its not done for specifically legal activity.

> The possibilities of human behavior are infinite. We don't need and can't enumerate all possible bad behaviors as illegal. Thus the civil court system.

The civil court system is for addressing things which are illegal -- violations of the law -- but which are not violation of criminal law. The civil court system applies those things prohibited in civil law, it does not substitute for having laws to determine what is prohibited.

Re:How does Google know where I am? by grkvlt on Friday September 23, 2016 @03:33PM (#12567338)
No, a restraining order is issued when someone is performing actions that, taken individually, are legal - recording a link between an SSID and a street address, knocking on an ex-girlfriends door to ask them to talk to you, photographing a child - but when carried out systematically, constitute a pattern of behaviour that is undesirable, and by virtue of the order becomes illegal. Sometimes the pattern itself is also illegal, if it falls under harassment or stalking laws. Generally restraining orders prevent you from doing things that are otherwise legal, such as being within 50m of some person, or within 300m of a particular place or type of place, or sending a message, e-mail or similar to someone.
Re:How does Google know where I am? by dragonwriter on Friday September 23, 2016 @06:13PM (#12568328)
> No, a restraining order is issued when someone is performing actions that, taken individually, are legal - recording a link between an SSID and a street address, knocking on an ex-girlfriends door to ask them to talk to you, photographing a child - but when carried out systematically, constitute a pattern of behaviour that is undesirable, and by virtue of the order becomes illegal.

The subset of restraining orders (sometimes called "protective" orders) you are thinking of are available when something illegal has been done, and relate to patterns of activity related to that illegal thing. For California, there are several kinds [0] of such orders:

(1) Domestic Violence Restraining Order: available if someone close to you in specific ways defined in law has abused you in specific ways defined in law as acts of domestic violence.

(2) Elder or Dependent Adult Abuse Restraining Order: available if you are elderly or disabled and have been a victim of certain kinds of abuse.

(3) Civil Harassment Restraining Order: available if you are being harassed or stalked, etc., by someone not close enough to be covered by a domestic violence restraining order.

(4) Workplace Violence Restraining Order: available to an employer to protect an employee that has been a victim of stalking, harassment, violence, or serious threats.

Now, yes, they sometimes cover acts which would not otherwise be illegal, but they actual require something illegal to have happened as their basis (a temporary restraining order can be issued on the claim that such a thing has occurred, and a permanent restraining order only after a hearing to determine that.)

[0] http://www.courts.ca.gov/1260.htm

Re:How does Google know where I am? by nerdponx on Saturday September 24, 2016 @09:23AM (#12570824)
Would obsessive public surveillance not qualify as "stalking"?
Re:How does Google know where I am? by clort on Sunday September 25, 2016 @11:19AM (#12575691)
In the scenario that kuschku suggested, taking a photo of each child and following them home to record the location (once) would probably not count as stalking IMO but its difficult to say. In the UK it has to happen twice, according to Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stalking

Re:How does Google know where I am? by mikestew on Friday September 23, 2016 @02:17PM (#12566776)
Others have explained it, but I downvoted without comment because, to paraphrase Jules in Pulp Fiction: "that's not only not in the same ballpark, it's not even the same fuckin' sport." I wouldn't know how to comment beyond that. (That, and your "think of the children" didn't help.)
Re:How does Google know where I am? by kuschku on Saturday September 24, 2016 @04:16AM (#12570024)
Then assume I'm talking about photographing every building and putting a list of that online. Also illegal.

Or putting video surveillance up in public spaces. Also illegal, even for the government.

Or whatever.

Collect the router mac and BSSID? Possibly justifiable. That's like making a map where phone numbers are, physically.

But collecting the SSID?

Looking at the wifi list, I see "Meier family WiFi" and "Meier WiFi upper floor: Finn & Jan" (that's their children, having both the room on the upper floor, and family protection filters enabled for that WiFi).

I see WiFi names that are identifiable, somes that have a little poetry in them, others named as the favourite football club of their owners.

That's creative work and PII.

Re:How does Google know where I am? by xapata on Sunday September 25, 2016 @08:25AM (#12575023)
> Then assume I'm talking about photographing every building and putting a list of that online. Also illegal.

How is that illegal? That's called a map.

Re:How does Google know where I am? by KirinDave on Friday September 23, 2016 @08:40PM (#12568899)
I down voted and left a comment.

Appealing to child stalking as a way to emotionally charge your argument about radio reception is a disingenuous tactic for this conversation. What's more, people who actually work to promote and secure a safer environment for kids don't need people like you constantly exacerbating parental paranoia with a constant back chatter stranger danger.

Please refrain from emotionally manipulative rhetoric.

Re:How does Google know where I am? by kuschku on Saturday September 24, 2016 @04:10AM (#12570006)
Then assume I'm talking about taking a picture of every living room through the window whenever no one is there.

Or anything else that's that personal.

The point isn't about what is collected, but that this type of broad data collection exists in the first place.

Let's recap: not eventhe government can do video surveillance of public places, streetview became opt in, the phone book is opt in.

But Google collects SSIDs?

Collecting only the router mac or BSSID might possibly be justifiable, because it's just a map of technical data, but collecting a string where people but creative works in, or names, or jokes?

I've seen families where the WiFi for the first floor had another name than that for the ground floor — specifically, the names of their two children, whose room was on first floor.

Collecting such PII can be problematic.

Re:How does Google know where I am? by KirinDave on Saturday September 24, 2016 @11:57AM (#12571401)
> Then assume I'm talking about taking a picture of every living room through the window whenever no one is there.

No. That's not my job to arbitrarily re-interpret what you said to give you a free pass for your disingenuous rhetoric.

> Let's recap: not eventhe government can do video surveillance of public places, streetview became opt in, the phone book is opt in.

The government CAN do video surveillance though. Both our governments do it. What varies is how its deployed and who has access.

> Collecting only the router mac or BSSID might possibly be justifiable, because it's just a map of technical data, but collecting a string where people but creative works in, or names, or jokes?

Look, responsibility has to be exercised in all forms of data collection. But it's also the case that the light that shines out of your house is subject to public interpretation. Standing nude in your window facing a crowded street CAN be illegal in both our countries, as could placing a sign that says threatening things to passerbys. The trigger conditions for this vary between our countries, but they exist in both cases.

> Collecting such PII can be problematic.

COLLECTING PII is seldom the problem. Storing it or promptly and thoroughly deleting it is the challenge. You might argue that you shouldn't have collected it in the first place, and maybe that's true. But given the modern world where we have a rapidly expanding frontier of data analytics, it's actually difficult for real (re: not rhetorical trashbag arguments on HackerNews) people. Often times it's not obvious what PII is until later.

For example, there are people who claim that transactional data can be "anonymized". Do not believe these people; it is nearly impossible to anonymize transactional data. Even mixing users and attempting to delocalize vendor strings will not fix the problems.

Re:How does Google know where I am? by kuschku on Sunday September 25, 2016 @06:13AM (#12574664)
> The government CAN do video surveillance though. Both our governments do it. What varies is how its deployed and who has access.

But they literally can not at any point ever do it. Video surveillance of public space is a crime, even for the police, government, or security agencies, and it does not happen.

> COLLECTING PII is seldom the problem. Storing it or promptly and thoroughly deleting it is the challenge. You might argue that you shouldn't have collected it in the first place, and maybe that's true. But given the modern world where we have a rapidly expanding frontier of data analytics, it's actually difficult for real (re: not rhetorical trashbag arguments on HackerNews) people. Often times it's not obvious what PII is until later.

The law literally makes that a crime. You have to stop collection of PII, not just delete it at any later point.

Re:How does Google know where I am? by KirinDave on Sunday September 25, 2016 @06:49PM (#12577876)
> But they literally can not at any point ever do it. Video surveillance of public space is a crime, even for the police, government, or security agencies, and it does not happen.

Surveillance of public environments via the private security systems is how your government (and ours really) accomplishes this "legally."

> The law literally makes that a crime. You have to stop collection of PII, not just delete it at any later point.

The law's definition of PII in your country is woefully out of date. Same in mine.

Re:How does Google know where I am? by xapata on Sunday September 25, 2016 @08:29AM (#12575043)
What do you think of high-resolution satellite imagery? Do you imagine that a satellite operator needs to get opt-in consent from anyone who happened to be looking up at the sky at the moment of the photograph?
Re:How does Google know where I am? by DominikR on Friday September 23, 2016 @01:27PM (#12566353)
It is different because this behaviour fits a well know pattern of a certain type of criminal. The child molester.

There is no such established pattern where we can reasonably assume that a company collecting SSIDs will usually do this to act in a criminal way.

By the way I didn't down vote you, but I think this is the "common sense" reason why people reject your position.

Re:How does Google know where I am? by kuschku on Friday September 23, 2016 @02:32PM (#12566892)
Well, but it applies to every other such case, too.

You can't publicly index newspaper articles that are already decades old and irrelevant, you can't publicly index photos of buildings, you can't publicly index the names of people even.

Every of these things requires written approval of everyone listed, be it StreetView, the application of the Right to be Forgotten, or collecting WiFi SSIDs.

So the question is: why does everything require approval, except for SSIDs?

Re:How does Google know where I am? by grkvlt on Friday September 23, 2016 @03:39PM (#12567374)
Does it? I didn't give written approval for the Google StreetView car to photography the front of my house. If I was to create a database of photographs of buildings, taken from a public location and indexed by street address, I don't believe I have to get permission, and the product could be released publicly, or even sold to estate agents or similar. I used to have to give the phone company written (or st least explicit) notice to opt out of their public index of numbers and names. So, it seems most things operate the same way as SSIDs, public information requires an opt-out to be available, not an opt-in.
[dead]
Re:How does Google know where I am? by mikestew on Saturday September 24, 2016 @12:55AM (#12569516)
the phone books have been opt-in for decades

Where I live, it used to cost extra to have an unlisted number (it might still, don't know).

"Enslave and rape"? You are quite the master of hyperbole, aren't you? Your point might be better made if you dialed back the emotional rhetoric a bit.

Re:How does Google know where I am? by kuschku on Saturday September 24, 2016 @04:05AM (#12569993)
I used the hyperbole tomake specifically clear I don't want to appeal to any "protect X group" or similar rhetoric — I literally wouldn't care if the US was wiped out if it was democratically legitimated — but I do care about Google following those democratically legitimated laws wherever they operate, and that means not collecting SSIDs where I live.

BSSIDs might possibly be legal to collect, but SSIDs definitely not. Likely one could even argue for copyright protection on a specifically poetic SSID.

Re:How does Google know where I am? by maxerickson on Saturday September 24, 2016 @07:11PM (#12573046)
What is the standard for "democratically legitimated"?

Like what if there is some group that is a substantial portion of a population and they decide to force their will on a smaller portion of the population. Say it gets severe. Does their larger number legitimize their actions?

Or does it mean something else?

Re:How does Google know where I am? by kuschku on Sunday September 25, 2016 @06:10AM (#12574658)
Democratically legitimated means there is a consensus within of the majority of society, yes.

Society can not cater to every minority, but has to hear them at least out, if they can present a logical argument for their position, and consider that. (See also: Petition laws, Election laws)

Re:How does Google know where I am? by KirinDave on Friday September 23, 2016 @08:42PM (#12568903)
It was never illegal. It has always been legal. Debates were around asking if people could change the law to make it retroactively illegal.

Also: down voted again for emotionally manipulative and outright vile rhetoric. If Hacker News is a place for free speech and open debate, you casually turning every conversation you can to molestation, rape and violence is a violation of the social contract we all have to keep the tone civil, and hurts the goal of honest debate.

Re:How does Google know where I am? by kuschku on Saturday September 24, 2016 @04:01AM (#12569983)
But that's literally what I don't care about? Google cando whatever they want, no matter how crazy it would be, in the US, as long as they follow the laws Ivoted for where I live.

I use that hyperbole to make it specifically clear that I would literally not care. I literally wouldn't care if they used Blackwater's army to level entire cities if the people chose to allow this by voting. It's literally the worst case scenario, and hundred times more, and I wouldn't care.

But I do care about them following the laws I voted for where I live.

And yes, it was already illegal.

German law has a principle where an action being done once or twice is very different from the same being automatically done thousands of times.

That includes collecting SSIDs, likely.

Re:How does Google know where I am? by KirinDave on Saturday September 24, 2016 @11:47AM (#12571365)
> And yes, it was already illegal.

Oh really. Fascinating. That seems to line up with the history.

> I use that hyperbole to make it specifically clear that I would literally not care.

I would like to make it clear I specifically don't care what your justification is for invoking that specter. It's at best utterly irrelevant and unneeded. At worst, it's threatening.

Find a better way to express this and you won't get downvotes. It's on you to communicate yourself in a socially acceptable way. If you don't care about that, then accept the downvotes as salty fluid that waters the tree of your liberty.

Re:How does Google know where I am? by nerdponx on Saturday September 24, 2016 @09:25AM (#12570834)
Did you just see the word "rape" and downvote blindly?
Re:How does Google know where I am? by KirinDave on Saturday September 24, 2016 @11:44AM (#12571350)
I read the whole thing, understood it, dismissed it. Vague or explicit allusions to sexual violence are about as funny/helpful/fair/meaningful/good/logical/whatever as vague allusions to racial violence.

So yeah, free downvote for mentioning it outside of a discussion that actually includes it meaningfully.

Re:How does Google know where I am? by nerdponx on Saturday September 24, 2016 @06:31PM (#12572937)
That's a shame. Extreme/hyperbolic examples have an important place in discourse. They force you to consider your ideas to their logical ends. In this case it illustrated that a line needs to be drawn somewhere by giving an example of something we all agree is reprehensible.

As far as I can tell, though, you're opposed to mentioning racial and sexual violence at all in conversation. What is the point of that kind of self-censorship? Rape will continue to be rape even if you never read or say that word again.

Re:How does Google know where I am? by KirinDave on Saturday September 24, 2016 @07:05PM (#12573034)
You seem to think that maintaining a polite level in discourse amounts to be censorship.

Curiously, we never feel the need to make these hyperbolic examples in the highest levels of discourse (be they academic or political), and yet somehow feel incredibly strongly about allowing them on internet sites.

Attempting to evoke violence, sexual assault and child abuse in discourse about something as abstract as the proper rules for radio light interpretation is not a positive addition.

We have plenty of opportunities to actually discuss said topics and no dearth of extreme metaphors to reach for to extend arguments to the absurd. We need not pretend this speech is vital for this community. Eroding the bulwark that protects this low and lazy standard as discourse is a net good for the community.

Perhaps maybe the author should have compared the practice to how Germans correlate re-naturalozed jewish citizens with health care use and reporting them for it, a quiet but severe controversy for that country.

Re:How does Google know where I am? by nerdponx on Sunday September 25, 2016 @10:44AM (#12575536)
> Perhaps maybe the author should have compared the practice to how Germans correlate re-naturalozed jewish citizens with health care use and reporting them for it, a quiet but severe controversy for that country.

This is where we differ. If we were talking about healthcare and someone brought up that point, I'd stop and think about it for a minute. Just because it refers to something evil and terrifying doesn't make it any less of a good point.

I actually learned something in this back-and-forth about how people perceive offensiveness in public dialogue, and react to perceived that offensiveness. I hope you make an effort to learn something too, and don't just come away with a haughty sense of victory.

Re:How does Google know where I am? by KirinDave on Sunday September 25, 2016 @06:46PM (#12577861)
> If we were talking about healthcare and someone brought up that point, I'd stop and think about it for a minute.

Riiiiight, but it'd be germane to a discussion about health care (assuming it actually was and was not a cheap shot). "Stranger danger creeps outside schools with cameras because radio = light and therefore basically the same as having your phone notice SSIDs" is a complete non-sequitur.

> and don't just come away with a haughty sense of victory.

Do you think this website has ever given me any sense of value or return? I'm here because I feel obligated to be. Not because I enjoy it or relish these debates. Our conversation and your predictable downvoting were practically foretold 500 years ago during a seizure by someone who saw a comet... that's how lamentably predictable the whole thing has been.

Re:How does Google know where I am? by nerdponx on Saturday September 24, 2016 @09:20AM (#12570819)
I don't understand the down votes here, this is a sound analogy to me.

I wouldn't be surprised if there were in fact laws against this kind of public surveillance behavior in some jurisdictions in the United States.

Re:How does Google know where I am? by deelowe on Friday September 23, 2016 @11:43AM (#12565450)
I thought you can disable it.
Re:How does Google know where I am? by xiaoma on Friday September 23, 2016 @01:57PM (#12566629)
~
Re:How does Google know where I am? by qntty on Friday September 23, 2016 @02:04PM (#12566680)
GP meant private-sector company
Re:How does Google know where I am? by PavlovsCat on Saturday September 24, 2016 @07:53AM (#12570571)
> Before you freak out: Apple and Microsoft also use access point information for positioning

Is that supposed to comfort one, or make one freak out even more? The usage to mean the former is very.. peculiar, and the usage of the phrase "freak out" rather than, say, "before you are concerned about this and move to change it", does make it seem like that was the intended usage.

Re:How does Google know where I am? by cstejerean on Friday September 23, 2016 @01:17PM (#12566260)
Apple uses wifi for positioning but only while wifi is turned on. It does not use it while wifi is turned off. It sounds like in android there is a separate setting that allows wifi scanning to happen in the background for positioning even while wifi is turned off. Not sure if that's better or worse.
Re:How does Google know where I am? by yigitdemirag on Friday September 23, 2016 @01:46PM (#12566514)
This is also not triangulation but trilateration.
Re:How does Google know where I am? by formula_ninguna on Friday September 23, 2016 @08:53PM (#12568932)
Is there open source database of geo data for wifi hotspots? Or even closed source?
Re:How does Google know where I am? by LeoPanthera on Friday September 23, 2016 @08:58PM (#12568945)