News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by jwr on Monday September 12, 2016 @07:24AM (#12478755)
> "to breathe much needed new energy and ideas into the industry"

Much needed indeed. The printer industry is a catastrophe. There is zero innovation, everybody keeps making the same crap over and over again, with new branding, and new numbers/designations. Is your Samsung X1214LX2 better than your HP LP19311A?

Also, where are the specialized niche printers? Why can't I print ink on a copper PCB, so that I can etch it later? Why can't I print soldermasks or silkscreens? Where is my printer that prints on fabric? All of these could be sold for much more than the ultra-low-margin generic home office printers, and yet manufacturers can't be bothered to innovate.

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by makomk on Monday September 12, 2016 @07:30AM (#12478784)
I'm pretty sure one big printer company buying another big printer company is the exact opposite of "disruption" and reduces the amount of "new ideas and energy" in the industry. Indeed, the press release says something slighthy different: "Today, HP is investing to disrupt this category by replacing copiers with superior multifunction printer (MFP) technology." Basically, they want to replace the copier industry with printers, bringing the exact same crap you complain about to a whole new market segment. (Most photocopiers are already just digital scanners coupled to printers internally. They just want to replace them with cheaper, worse ones.)
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by mseebach on Monday September 12, 2016 @08:20AM (#12479041)
Hasn't pretty much every copier sold in the past 20 years essentially been an MFP anyway? And isn't it fairly obvious that once you're bringing in a scanner and a printer anyway, you might as well expose them on the network as separate devices? (I use the scan-to-email function of the office "copier" fairly frequently myself, I print a bit too, but I practically never copy anything directly)
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by dv_dt on Monday September 12, 2016 @12:05PM (#12480861)
What drives me crazy is why are there always new drivers for printers? At this point isn't there more than enough compute power in the devices to supply a consistent abstract interface?
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by i80and on Monday September 12, 2016 @12:09PM (#12480903)
That "consistent abstract interface" is called PostScript.

The last printer I bought was a Xerox PostScript printer, and with a few minor caveats, it's been lovely not having to putz with drivers.

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by makomk on Monday September 12, 2016 @12:44PM (#12481256)
PostScript has never been that consistent, and the abstraction is decidedly leaky. Having to upgrade the RAM in your printer in order to print more complex documents is not a fun experience. As it happens, I think a lot of modern printers do expose an abstract interface - it's just generally a proprietary raster-based one that doesn't involve running arbitrary user-supplied code.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by kevin_thibedeau on Monday September 12, 2016 @07:26PM (#12484491)
HP goes out of its way to avoid putting PS support into its consumer level printers. I can only imagine it's to trim money spent on internal RAM since any common embedded processor these days has the power to run an on board RIP.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by dv_dt on Monday September 12, 2016 @07:38PM (#12484594)
I'd seriously wonder if the infrastructure to support putting that into drivers, deployments, testing of different versions, etc exceeds all the RAM savings cost at this point.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by dv_dt on Monday September 12, 2016 @12:43PM (#12481239)
I've shopped for too many printers where all PostScript support means is you can shove PS into their front end driver.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by _JamesA_ on Monday September 12, 2016 @04:46PM (#12483500)
The same is true with "PCL3 GUI". It's like the "Win-modem" fiasco all over again.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by rahimnathwani on Tuesday September 13, 2016 @01:41AM (#12485854)
You mean like winprinters (aka GDI printers): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graphics_Device_Interface#GDI_...
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by wmf on Monday September 12, 2016 @03:03PM (#12482645)
Were those Ethernet or USB? AFAIK PostScript + Ethernet has always meant an internal RIP with no driver needed.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by dv_dt on Monday September 12, 2016 @04:35PM (#12483406)
At this point, I don't recall - I've gone over to only buying network capable printers as they do tend to be better about their drivers (still need somthing usually) - but the ones I've been looking at lately seem to speak some dialect of PCL.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by jimjimjim on Monday September 12, 2016 @07:35PM (#12484562)
windows!

same thing with XPS support in printers.

most windows xps printer drivers just convert the xps into the printers native language. And maxing out one core for the exe that initiated the printing.

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by SixSigma on Monday September 12, 2016 @10:06AM (#12479750)
your email system might thank you if you used scan-to-SMB instead :)
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by discreditable on Monday September 12, 2016 @11:37AM (#12480611)
Scan to SMB is a pain. We had to have our copier company come out to upgrade the firmware on all of the devices when we moved to Server 2012. Even then, we have to enable SMB 1.0 for the feature to work.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by cptskippy on Monday September 12, 2016 @10:24AM (#12479889)
I've never seen that work, the I've manages was to save to USB and I was surprised it allowed that at all. Email works flawlessly every time.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by brazzledazzle on Monday September 12, 2016 @10:37AM (#12480014)
What? It's really simple. First figure out what version of SMB/CIFS you're using and if that's compatible. Then figure out if you have packet encryption enabled and if that's compatible. Then figure out if the compatibility issue you're still experiencing is due to the volume being served by a non-Windows appliance or server. If it's Windows dig through group policy settings applied and start toggling them on and off desperately until you're ready to explode. Then after days or weeks of packet captures and support calls find out it was a known issue and get a firmware patch from the MFP manufacturer.

Easy.

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by discreditable on Monday September 12, 2016 @11:40AM (#12480638)
I just went through all of that when upgrading our file server to 2012 R2. Would not recommend. SMTP is easier but has its own problems (such as file size limits).
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by vetinari on Monday September 12, 2016 @12:15PM (#12480953)
Works like charm - put in server ip address, share, username, password and it nicely puts every scan there.

(We used Konica-Minolta machine and Synology NAS - i.e. Samba 4).

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by brazzledazzle on Tuesday September 13, 2016 @12:13AM (#12485588)
I've had it go both ways. I've found it easier in the past if someone already compromised security by disabling signing. But that was a long time ago in another life. Things have probably changed a lot since.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by sly010 on Monday September 12, 2016 @09:25AM (#12479434)
My mom worked in the printing industry with a company doing refills. She told me newer printers are hardwired to unrecoverably die after a fixed number of pages. Depending on the model you can even query how many pages you have left in the machine (not talking about ink here).

Also my vet once told me he replaces his home printer every time it runs out of ink, because replacing the cartridge costs the same order of magnitude as a new printer and this he can always have the latest and greatest.

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by wlesieutre on Monday September 12, 2016 @09:59AM (#12479697)
You should let you vet know that the printers ship with "starter cartridges" that are lower capacity than the replacements. Buying new ink cartridges might cost $10 more than the new printer, but it'll give him twice as many pages.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by semi-extrinsic on Monday September 12, 2016 @10:51AM (#12480127)
I've figured it makes most sense to have a cheap'n'stupid B/W laserprinter at home, and just order whatever photo prints I need from a print shop. Occasional color photo printing at home is more expensive per photo than getting it from a shop i I'm not printing photos every week.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by kalleboo on Monday September 12, 2016 @12:07PM (#12480879)
The only thing I seem to print these days is a yearly tax form or two. I don't even waste the space with a printer - I just go to 7/11 for my printing needs and pay a couple cents per page.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by pmorici on Monday September 12, 2016 @09:30PM (#12485051)
If all you print is sensitive tax documents is 7/11 really the place you want to do that?
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by kalleboo on Monday September 12, 2016 @10:55PM (#12485335)
I'm not sure how sensitive tax documents are to me https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12423891

A valid concern though, it's been shown those MFDs keep junk around in their buffers forever

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by pmorici on Tuesday September 13, 2016 @05:49PM (#12492546)
In the US very sensitive. Mostly because they contain all the personal information you would need to commit identity fraud. They also us information from prior year returns to positively identify you on subsequent years. ie: your AGI from last years form is used to verify your identity for the next year.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by jschwartzi on Monday September 12, 2016 @11:23AM (#12480481)
Ditto. I have a ten year old Dell 1110 that continues to work despite moves, drops, and abuse. This includes a period when it was stored in a hay barn.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by phil21 on Monday September 12, 2016 @11:42AM (#12480661)
Same, I have an older HP Laserjet I forget the model of that's been rock solid for 15 years.

You can also still buy parts for these printers as well reasonably cheap. I was able to find a plastic gear that got stripped due to an object falling into the paper tray - cost me about $8 and 20 minutes of repair time and it's good as new.

The average person doesn't print much, but when they do they really need it right now (e.g. boarding passes, legal document to sign, concert tickets, whatever) and having a rock-solid printer that you know just works every time even if you haven't printed in 6 months is great.

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by Thlom on Monday September 12, 2016 @04:11PM (#12483231)
I have a Canon Pixma something or other printer. After an upgrade of OS X, Canon stopped suppling drivers for newer versions. It wasn't even straight forward to use the driver for the previous version. I think I had to extract the driver from their lousy installer to get it to work. Very fun when I just wanted to print flight tickets ASAP. It's a PRINTER. All it does 95% of the time is printing B/W documents. How hard can it be to get this right?
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by TheOtherHobbes on Tuesday September 13, 2016 @09:31AM (#12488001)
Printers are really just a hardware distribution mechanism for printer drivers, which are an unusually bulky form of malware.

Any printing functionality is entirely incidental, especially on inkjets.

If you need something printed urgently, you can guarantee that one of the following will happen: drivers need updating (=> 400MB download, if you can even find the file on the site), drivers don't work, out of ink, clogged nozzles that need cleaning (followed by out of ink), paper jam, file prints landscape instead of portrait, or vice versa, and there's no obvious way to fix this.

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday September 13, 2016 @09:38AM (#12488068)
Been this way for years. Old dot-matrix printers often had a dip-switch to select 'options'. If there were 4 of them, you had a 1-in-16 chance of it working. If there were 8, forget it.

Its like mean-time-between-failure, excepts more like chance-of-succeeding: multiply all the probabilities of success at a stage together, you get the total chance of success. It becomes diminishingly small the more screw-ups are possible. Inkjet has two or three more places to fail, so.

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by tracker1 on Monday September 12, 2016 @08:27PM (#12484837)
I had a used HP4000 series that was bough used at a school auction, probably 5+ years old at that time... thing ran for another 3 years on the toner that was in there when I got it and another 3-4 after that before it died and wouldn't come on... replaced it with an hp color laserjet 3-4 years ago, and that one still runs like a tank...

When you rarely print, having a laser is better as they can sit a long time and not dry out or gum up like the ink printers.

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by coredog64 on Monday September 12, 2016 @12:52PM (#12481337)
I had to give up on my LaserJet IIIP a while ago. I spent nearly as much on trying to recondition all the dried out rubber parts as I did on a cheap laser printer.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by semi-extrinsic on Monday September 12, 2016 @04:33PM (#12483390)
Early 90's printers tend to do that. We have a LaserJet IV gathering dust in a corner at work. Turned it on the other day, to a three minute warmup and much smell of dust burning, but it still printed well.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by JoeAltmaier on Monday September 12, 2016 @10:02AM (#12479716)
Sometimes the cartridge is the first thing to fail, especially if you go days between printing anything. The delicate print heads get tarry ink deposits.

Pages per dollar means something if you're printing in bulk. Otherwise, its trouble-free-printing-per-dollar. Which may be improved by buying a new printer periodically as a sort of prophylactic maintenance.

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by darryl42 on Monday September 12, 2016 @01:03PM (#12481461)
Which is why I bought a black and white laser printer 10+ years ago. Never need to worry about the ink drying out. I am still on the starter toner. Not sure if I will be able to buy toner when it runs out, but it still works even with Windows 10 over USB. Network mode only works for printing, no network scanner drivers anymore.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by blowski on Monday September 12, 2016 @09:32AM (#12479491)
Why would they kill the printers when they make their money off the consumables? If my HP printer dies I might replace it with an Epson, so they would lose that revenue stream. Also, I find it difficult to believe that they would be so explicit as it could cause legal trouble.

Now cartridges needing to be replaced prematurely 'because we haven't figured out a technology to prevent them drying up' does sound suspicious.

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by icantdrive55 on Monday September 12, 2016 @11:00AM (#12480238)
I wouldn't be suprised if what his mother said was true. The printer industry must know about printer chip reset chips, universal refill systems, drilling out their liquid gold containers, and refilling with better/cheaper ink, etc.

My printers sit idle. First it was the price of ink. Then I just found I didn't like fiddling with them. Then I just got used to not using them.

I think the printing industry is in a huge hole, and it will take a lot of ass kissing, and honest innovation, that benefits the consumer, to bring home printing back.

Good luck-

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by ChuckMcM on Monday September 12, 2016 @01:41PM (#12481842)
Well in the Canon Pixma case they have the "discharge sponge" which collects ink and is used when cleaning the heads. That "fills up" apparently and then the printer is dead. My wife spent a couple of interesting weeks going around and around with customer service trying to understand how a product can be designed to fail like that, they eventually gave up and sent her another one, but I was thinking it would be interesting to take it to court to see how California's warranty protection laws would be interpreted. (I think its a defect to have a designed in product killing part that isn't replaceable).
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by 72deluxe on Monday September 12, 2016 @10:22AM (#12479878)
Laser printers: The imaging drums have a chip on them which counts how many pages they have processed, and will refuse to work after a certain number of pages even if the drum itself is fine. They do this to stop potential damage to the drum.

You can buy cheap chips to put into the printer if you want to risk it - search for "drum reset refill chip".

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by bonzini on Monday September 12, 2016 @04:02PM (#12483165)
That's not to stop potential damage to the drum. It's because on average the drum starts showing damage around 30.000 pages (a damaged drum it leaves lighter or darker bands on the paper, same as on old badly-maintained photocopiers). But because _sometimes_ it starts shows damage earlier, and they don't want you to confuse a damaged drum and an empty toner cartridge, they just force you to change it around 20.000 pages.

The drum reset refill chip is not even a chip, it's a 56 ohm resistor that acts like a fuse. The drum has two resistors in parallel, one with very low resistance and one that's like 200 000 ohm. If the printer sees a high current when you turn on the printer, the firmware thinks it's a new drum and resets the page counter. After a short while the 100 ohm resistor burns (quite literally), and from that point on the firmware will only see a low current when you turn on the printer, and it will not reset the page counter.

So the drum reset refill chip lets you connect the two pads where the printer applies the current with a resistor like the one on a new drum. You can buy a 56 ohm resistor yourself to achieve the same effect.

It's literally a resistor and some plastic, only usable once, and they sell it to you for $10, which makes it much more of a scam than anything printer manufacturers do.

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by 72deluxe on Tuesday September 13, 2016 @04:33AM (#12486453)
Thanks for the info!
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by Yxven on Monday September 12, 2016 @03:44PM (#12483005)
Is damaging the drum dangerous, or is it a profit scheme?
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by rayiner on Monday September 12, 2016 @09:37AM (#12479532)
He should stop buying inkjet printers. You can pick up an HP m402dn laser printer on Amazon for $150. It's fast, plugs directly into an ethernet network, and handles full duplex without a hiccup.

It's a printer, what more innovation do you need?

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by ssharp on Monday September 12, 2016 @10:01AM (#12479706)
Once I realized home laser printers were cheap, I switched and it was the best decision on a printer I'll probably ever make. I can get generic toner cartridges for $15-20 that last a long time, don't yell at me if I don't replace according to their schedule, and print black and white super fast.

The printer I bought was a Samsung and cost right around $100. Compare that to my old HP inkjet that cost more than that and required upwards of 5 ink cartridges.

I don't get color printing out of this but I can't recall the last time I needed to print in color. If I want to print photos, it's cheaper and easier to just order them.

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by GFischer on Monday September 12, 2016 @10:23AM (#12479886)
Ironically, I bought a cheap Samsung printer (Ml2165W), and I had to flash its firmware to let it accept generic cartridges.

I ended up buying an used, better model, which had more generic toners available.

I hope HP doesn't start doing that crap.

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by mpnordland on Monday September 12, 2016 @05:53PM (#12484006)
HP already does, in fact, they don't let you refill either, although there are workarounds.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by enraged_camel on Monday September 12, 2016 @06:25PM (#12484179)
>>It's a printer, what more innovation do you need?

Yeah, a lot of people also said that about cellphones and then the iPhone came out. :)

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by justinlardinois on Monday September 12, 2016 @07:55PM (#12484697)
Calling bullshit on this. In the pre-iPhone era:

- Mobile internet access was prohibitively expensive (sometimes as high as a penny per kilobyte), browsers were terrible, and some even pushed for an alternative language to HTML for the mobile web. [0]

- Every phone was running a mobile JVM, but apps still had compatibility issues across models and carriers.

- Camera quality was horrid.

- Many phones had poor or inconsistent support for MMS, group texts, and visual voicemail. Even the iPhone itself didn't support MMS at first.

And these were problems even with the devices that were marketed as "smartphones" back then. Mobile phones were awful.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wireless_Markup_Language

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by FabHK on Monday September 12, 2016 @01:56PM (#12482008)
I got my mom a nice Lexmark MFP, so she could print and scan and copy and fax (she still faxes, yes).

After a while, the printer started complaining on the beautiful big touch screen display, and said "Service cartridges" or print head or something along those lines (my mom might have put in non-"genuine" replacement cartridges, I seem to recall, but not sure). Fair enough - we had gotten her a cheap laser for printing anyway by that time, as it's really cheaper and far less trouble.

However, this stupid Lexmark thingy would not allow you to acknowledge that warning and then start up, so mom could at least still scan and fax - no, it would just sit there and complain about the print head or ink or what have you and refuse to do anything!

Needless to say, we tossed it. Still need to get a scanner and fax now :-/

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by thesimpsons1022 on Monday September 12, 2016 @12:33PM (#12481121)
I worked IT when I was a freshman in college and the printers were known to fail automatically after a certain amount of pages. To fix it, we would just remove a certain part and out it back in. We'd get much more life out of it because it just reset the counter.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by scarface74 on Monday September 12, 2016 @08:40AM (#12479164)
I actually had to look up how traditional copiers worked based on your statement "Most photocopiers are already just digital scanners coupled with printers". I was so use to think of a copier being scanner + printer in the modern era, I had to take a step back and realize that wouldn't have been feasible 30 years ago.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by otaviokz on Monday September 12, 2016 @03:07PM (#12482679)
Indeed. I for one fail to see how "disruption" through competition acquisition can live up to anything more than just marketing buzz wording.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by avian on Monday September 12, 2016 @08:09AM (#12478983)
> The printer industry is a catastrophe. There is zero innovation

I agree with you that printers are still terrible and a pain to work with from the user's perspective. However, I don't think it's true that there has been no innovation. It's just that it has been mostly on the side of reducing per-unit manufacturing costs. I recently took apart a modern HP inkjet and was surprised to find for instance that stepper motors have been replaced with DC motors and optical encoders.

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by dnzm on Monday September 12, 2016 @10:13AM (#12479807)
> It's just that it has been mostly on the side of reducing per-unit manufacturing costs.

And on the "let's see how much further we can bloat a printer driver, since 1GB to get letters from your computer to paper is obviously not enough".

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by Grishnakh on Monday September 12, 2016 @12:41PM (#12481222)
That's what you get for using Windows. In Linux, the PPD drivers are tiny, and they never become "obsolete" like in Windows where you can't get an older printer to work in Win10 because there's no drivers.

I hear MacOSX is about the same as Linux, and since Apple owns CUPS (the printing subsystem in Linux) that would make sense.

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by stagger87 on Monday September 12, 2016 @02:24PM (#12482284)
This has nothing to do with Windows. The Windows drivers themselves are relatively small, it's the software suite they push that is bloated. The two download options for my latest Brother printer was a 2MB driver only download, or a 300MB software suite. I've also seen this for Dell and HP printers. I use mostly B/W laser printers, so YMMV.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by Grishnakh on Monday September 12, 2016 @04:13PM (#12483248)
It has everything to do with Windows, as you admit yourself here. On Linux, there is no included software suite, there's only PPD drivers. Those bloated software suites only exist on Windows because they commonly tie them to the printer drivers. As for offering a driver-only download, I don't think that's normal for consumer-grade inkjets.

Edit: I'd also like to add that the whole "bloated software suite", not just for printers but for everything else, is mainly a Windows problem because Windows has a culture of downloading bloated software suites from the manufacturer, instead of having a "distro" with all the device drivers included by default along with lots of open-source software to use those devices. The idea of downloading some big pie of software (or getting it from an included optical disc) from a hardware maker, just to use your piece of hardware, simply does not exist on Linux. And that's the way it should be: the Windows way is what's given us gigabyte+ software suites for simple tasks like using a printer.

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by DougN7 on Monday September 12, 2016 @05:20PM (#12483789)
> Those bloated software suites only exist on Windows because they commonly tie them to the printer drivers

Not following at all why that has anything to do with Windows.

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by dv_dt on Monday September 12, 2016 @05:49PM (#12483988)
Why do you even need the PPD? Why doesn't the print infrastructure allow the printer itself to supply the content of the PPD or the literal PPD file?
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by tracker1 on Monday September 12, 2016 @08:35PM (#12484877)
Last three printers I had detected via the network install, and downloaded the drivers from windows update directly, just the driver, not the bloatware... seems to work fine in windows.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by tonyedgecombe on Monday September 12, 2016 @08:28AM (#12479095)
Absolutely, I remember selling the first colour PostScript printer in the UK to an advertising agency, they paid £25,000 for something much worse than I can get for £50 in my local Staples.

However they have been absolutely terrible at the software side of things. This is a shame as it's as visible as the rest of the package to the consumer.

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by scarface74 on Monday September 12, 2016 @08:47AM (#12479202)
The software side of printers have gotten worse. Back in the day, when all high end printers support PostScript, you didn't have to worry about drivers. Now, especially with Windows, your printer can become obsolete with the next OS upgrade.

At least on the Mac/iOS side, most consumer printers support AirPrint and you don't need drivers to support basic operations. I have a perfectly functional (cheap) color laser printer that doesn't work pass Windows 7. But works fine with my iOS devices thanks to AirPrint. It also supports Google's Cloud Print so I guess that's one way I could make it work with Windows 10 if I were so inclined.

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by sjwright on Monday September 12, 2016 @09:39AM (#12479561)
AirPrint is, when compared to what came before it, mind-numbingly simple. Printer announces itself with Bonjour, provides basic configuration (like choice of paper tray) with IPP, then accepts documents in PDF format. The end.

Put simply, it upends the retarded mess of printer drivers and replaces it with something that does the job perfectly well 99 percent of the time. All it requires is for the printer to have sufficient MIPS to raster PDF files.

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by tonyedgecombe on Monday September 12, 2016 @10:31AM (#12479952)
Isn't it a subset of PDF? I thought the rasterisation happens on the host.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by scarface74 on Monday September 12, 2016 @10:46AM (#12480086)
It does happen on the host (I think). That reminds me of another advantage of hosting a network printer on the Mac. Even if the printer does require a dedicated print driver, to the rest of the network - including Windows computers -it's seen as a generic PostScript printer and the Mac takes care of the translation.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by vetinari on Monday September 12, 2016 @12:23PM (#12481028)
Raspberry Pi with debian and cups does the same job. Macs use cups too, they just use different stack for the pdf rasterization step.

I'm using it to network-share an older Samsung printer that has only USB port.

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by rayiner on Monday September 12, 2016 @09:42AM (#12479579)
> However they have been absolutely terrible at the software side of things. This is a shame as it's as visible as the rest of the package to the consumer.

With PCL/Postscript/PDF support in hardware these days, what software side is there? Last time we bought a printer (an HP LaserJet), we just plugged it into our router and with zero additional configuration were able to print from our Macbooks and iPhones/iPads. It literally couldn't have been easier.

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by maxerickson on Monday September 12, 2016 @12:12PM (#12480930)
My mom has bought a couple of HP ink jet printers. The software has been terrible. That seems to be the case, that consumer inkjets have terrible software and lasers are fine.

At one point while trying to figure out something else, I figured out that they had implemented the polling for the presence of the (usb) printer by having a Windows service rapidly and repeatedly start and stop a second service. So anytime the printer was unplugged, the logs would be nicely purged by this activity.

I don't remember if it was related to those services, but they also screwed up the permissions for a service, making it impossible to use the normal tools to make changes to the service.

The thinner drivers included in Windows 10 with her new computer seem to be better.

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by tonyedgecombe on Monday September 12, 2016 @10:32AM (#12479972)
It seems to have gone in both directions, the class drivers on Windows are pretty much all configuration and little or no real software. However most printer manufacturers can't seem to resist bundling extra software to manage the printer, sell you consumables, etc.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by jcrawfordor on Monday September 12, 2016 @08:43PM (#12484905)
Most printers today do not have hardware PCL or PostScript. Inkjet printers, and cheaper laser printers, usually act a lot like the older "winmodems" in that they offset almost everything that used to be done internally to the host computer, including at least rasterization and even aspects of what seem like basic motor control. This is a cost-saving measure in the printers themselves, but comes at the expense of significantly more complicated and device-specific host-side software.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by shazzy on Monday September 12, 2016 @08:51AM (#12479220)
I think Aiwip https://aiwip.com are doing a pretty good job of improving the user experience related to printing. The flow is: upload documents, stand next to printer, press print. It also allows you to print from any other aiwip printer and printing for free.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by snewk on Monday September 12, 2016 @10:17AM (#12479842)
and every dime saved in the actual purchase is lost when you factor in the price of replacement cartridges. Ultimately, the per-unit manufacturing cost reduction simply results in sub-par units that often break and need to be fully replaced.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by drzaiusapelord on Monday September 12, 2016 @10:17AM (#12479843)
Sysadmin here. I think HP's quality has gone way up in the past decade or so on the enterprise level. I remember the early 2000s as having a lot of lemons on their officejet line and now we have printers that run with hundreds of thousands of pages and only needing a new fuser now and again. Their enterprise drivers are usually okay but its a crapshoot between using the dedicated driver or the universal driver. Common wisdom is to never use the universal driver in production, which is a shame, because it was supposed to solve all the driver woes HP had with its dozens of different models.

That said, the consumer line is a complete nightmare, especially the all-in-ones. HP and the rest need to stop what they're doing and just re-do all the drivers and helper software from scratch. Its also inexcusable that anyone is still selling ink-based printers. The industry really needs to move to a laser-only strategy. Everything about ink printers is terrible.

Currently, I have a $199 5+ year old brother b&w laser printer at home. Its a little tank. When I need to print photos I just send them to Walgreens. Win-win in my book.

> Why can't I print ink on a copper PCB, so that I can etch it later? Why can't I print soldermasks or silkscreens?

Well, to be fair, HP isn't in that industry. You're asking for 3D printing solutions from a paper printing company. When those things happen, they'll be from other companies. There's not a lot in common with circuit or 3D printing and traditional laser printing. Also considering HP is trying to re-do itself as a software company and always trying to find a buyer for its hardware lines, I suspect they have zero incentive to enter risky new markets. I'm guessing this acquisition is to make them more attractive to a hypothetical future buyer. This acquisition gives HP access to a robust copier line and mobile printing technology that works pretty well (samsungs copiers are android based so there are some mobile benefits and 'not reinventing the wheel' aspects here).

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by Decade on Monday September 12, 2016 @11:02AM (#12480260)
Ink is very expensive per page, but the ink printing process takes much less electricity, generates much less ozone, than xerographic printers. And the printers are substantially lighter. Depending on your situation, an inkjet printer could fit your purposes better.

Just not my situation nor my purposes.

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by 7952 on Monday September 12, 2016 @08:38AM (#12479151)
I think the main problem for buisness printers is the inclusion of proprietary software on the device. This means that it is very difficult for third parties to innovate. I would prefer printers to be a dumb IO device that connects to a full computer than can provide a good UI. Instead they have evolved to have an onboard computer of appalling quality.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by petra on Monday September 12, 2016 @08:54AM (#12479232)
This is a general problem of the embedded industry, where products could greatly benefit from openness.

But how do you align the incentives for the hardware manufacturer ,to commodify itself(to a large extent, unless there's some sort of app ecosystem or some other network effect setup) ?

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by zanny on Monday September 12, 2016 @10:00AM (#12479701)
In theory, consumer outreach to only support good actors, but there are two issues there:

* It is chicken and egg. You don't get the better UX until you have quality open products to market, and manufacturing the devices may not be that expensive for a new line (at least compared to silicon) but you still need the resources of a billion dollar company. * Consumers buying devices like this will not research quality much before buying. To my knowledge, the vast majority of muggle printer buyers are just picking up something based off a feature list at Best Buy.

So you need to persuade a company to invest in innovation in a market without any, and then you need to persuade consumers to actually care about quality.

It is the exact same issue with less horribly insecure mobile devices without rootkit backdoor class modems, or more open motherboards, or open hard drive firmware, etc. We would see much higher quality with open development drivers for almost everything, but to see attitudes change you need to present financial incentives, and its really hard to promote something when no product at market exists yet.

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by monatron on Monday September 12, 2016 @07:31AM (#12478790)
I think the printing industry is just inherently difficult to serve. Manufacturers can barely deliver quality products and support on the printers they make now. I can't imagine them also having to support all of these "custom" setups. I imagine a future where these custom printers you describe might exist, but in a centralized "kinkos" type store, or better yet a makerspace. There's a big difference marketing and selling to a consumer vs. specialized industry.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by tonyedgecombe on Monday September 12, 2016 @10:39AM (#12480032)
There are a ton of specialist printer manufacturers out there including point of sale, barcoding, wide format printing, etc. My guess is if the printer manufacturers thought there was a market for it they would do it.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by guest2143 on Monday September 12, 2016 @10:49AM (#12480111)
Why can't I print an image on my fingernail? :/

We had that working on the assembly line in 1998 at HP. Never really got off the ground.

Tatoos? Even temporary ones?

Not to mention the medical devices HP could have had.

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by JoelBennett on Monday September 12, 2016 @01:00PM (#12481418)
That makes me wonder if there's potential there for the medical industry: print a temporary barcode on a person, rather than tracking them with charts. I suppose an RFID bracelet could serve the same purpose, though.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by kalleboo on Monday September 12, 2016 @12:14PM (#12480945)
You can get inkjet transfer paper for temporary tattoos
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by hkmurakami on Monday September 12, 2016 @10:27AM (#12479919)
Imo the Fujitsu Scansnap has been an excellent innovation.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by Grishnakh on Monday September 12, 2016 @01:34PM (#12481769)
My workplace has a ScanSnap ix500 multi-document scanner.

It's an utterly amazing, high-quality piece of hardware.

However, the software needed to use it is some of the absolutely worst software I've ever seen.

My advice: purchase a copy of VueScan to go with it. As a bonus, VueScan even has a Linux version that works quite well. (Not a shill, and I haven't purchased a copy, I just used the trialware but I was impressed.)

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by fifteenforty on Monday September 12, 2016 @05:10PM (#12483716)
I concur! I have one at home. It's the single best tech purchase I've made in years. What advantage do you get with VueScan?
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by Grishnakh on Monday September 12, 2016 @05:26PM (#12483834)
I'm not a customer, and haven't used it in a while (I haven't had to do a scan in a while and don't work in that office much), but here's the main things:

1) It works in Linux. Other, simpler scanners (non-ADF) can frequently work OK in Linux, but the Linux scanning software is a bit of a mess. I use gscan2pdf at home which works well enough, but looks pretty rough and hasn't seen any updates in years. But ADF scanners are different because of their nature; I'm not sure it'd be easy to get existing software to work with them, and I don't think the SANE interface works with them. With VueScan, you just install it, plug in the scanner, and it works, at least that was my experience. It has its own built-in drivers for ADF scanners like the ix500.

2) On Windows, it's just better. The Fujitsu software was a complete nightmare; it's horribly bloated (I seem to remember it being a 500MB download!) and very difficult to get working. I'm not sure it even works in Windows 10. VueScan is not a big download, and like on Linux is simple and easy. I haven't done much with it there because it puts big ugly watermarks all over your scans with the trialware version. But if I had an ix500 of my own, I'd be buying a copy of VueScan; I think it's only $20.

Luckily I don't have to do much scanning, so I get by OK with gscan2pdf on Linux and my now-older CanoScan LiDE 50 (I think that's the model number, or is it 25? I forget now). It's slow, and a bit of a pain as I have to haul it out and plug it in, but it works reliably and decently. But if I were doing any volume scanning on a regular basis, I'd break down and buy an ix500. They're very expensive ($500 new I think, and used ones on Ebay usually fetch over $300), but I've never seen anything like them: they don't take up much desk space (they unfold out when you need to use them), they have excellent scan quality, and they're ridiculously fast, while also doing duplex scanning just as fast (using sensors on both sides). They also don't seem to have any trouble with misfeeding pages.

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by js2 on Monday September 12, 2016 @09:50AM (#12479642)
> Where is my printer that prints on fabric?

My father does this with large-format inkjets[1]. He uses a water-based ink and fabric that comes on a roll with a peel-off backing, but the printer itself is not special other than being large format.

[1] http://www.kuchikuu.com/

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by jcrawfordor on Monday September 12, 2016 @08:46PM (#12484912)
Printing on fabric would generally be referred to as "Direct-on-Garment" or DOG printing and is a common method for making small-run clothing items like custom T-shirts a la CafePress. The quality is generally (but not very noticeably these days) worse than screen printing but there are no setup costs involved.

The main issue with DOG printing is that poor adjustment of the heads can result in some overspray (as they must sit some small distance from the fabric to avoid smearing). This can be avoided by competent operators, the big internet companies just don't always bother.

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by jwr on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @03:07AM (#12494729)
Oh, sure, you can do it, if you try things out, fiddle with settings, experiment and find a combination that works. But that's not what I meant.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by ittekimasu on Monday September 12, 2016 @08:02AM (#12478940)
I can only wonder how they much they'll charge for precious soldermask and silkscreen inks.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by ethagknight on Monday September 12, 2016 @08:36AM (#12479143)
Anything less than the cost of the current process would be a win for the industry, right? Even if it's more expensive, isn't there benefit to having it available on demand?
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by jwr on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @03:08AM (#12494732)
Let them. I'd happily pay if it meant I could manufacture PCBs locally in a matter of hours, rather than wait weeks (right now if you want a cheap PCB, you wait 2-3 weeks).
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by technion on Monday September 12, 2016 @08:26AM (#12479077)
The irony is that it would just about be a massive disruption if someone could take that same old printer and create a highly reliable set of drivers, that could be completely trusted to with multiple OSes and services like RDS.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by hrktb on Monday September 12, 2016 @05:25PM (#12483827)
Wouldn't work with a separate print server ? I know there's some at Office depot for instance, but for a more flexible solution a raspberry pi works wonder as well.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by CPAhem on Monday September 12, 2016 @07:13PM (#12484420)
The market is a mature one, which is why there is so little innovation.

Also there is a huge barrier to entry in the form of patent roadblocks for anyone trying to enter. This deal included 6500 patents!

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by unclebucknasty on Monday September 12, 2016 @07:59AM (#12478933)
Funny. The idea of need for innovation in printing strikes me as anachronistic.

Printing itself should be on the decline and increasingly outmoded. If anything, we need to focus on killing faxing and paper as a medium once and for all.

Sure, there may always (or at least long) be a need for hard-copy for some applications, but it hardly strikes me as sufficient to drive need for innovation in printers.

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by sj4nz on Monday September 12, 2016 @10:00AM (#12479705)
Paper is fantastic for auditing and archival. You can't sanitize your dirty deeds if you can't prevent your sins from appearing on the souls of dead trees locked in their fire-proof chambers. Until we start using content-hashing for everything you cannot trust the "permanence" of bits because you cannot detect their tampering. Faxing is 90% dead as far as I can tell. I've got a fax machine, I think the last time I plugged it in was 2008.

Most of the lack of innovation in printers (and scanners) comes from the problem that, once you've bought their hardware, there is no incentive to make the software that ships-by-default with it great. The innovation isn't the hardware, the innovation is waiting, stuck between the hardware and the operating system (e.g. why does my Brother mysteriously screw up my right margins on Windows?) and stuck between the application and the user. The operating-system printing dialogs are way too complicated for mere users and the printer-manufacturer's printing-dialogs are mostly rebranded operating-system printing dialogs. Users just want their bits to burn onto their paper, appropriately and reliably.

You know, it might not be such a bad idea to make a printer-bot ala a RepRap that allowed you to put any writing instrument you wanted into the cross-hairs and slowly draw out your documents like a plotter. The ink might be "cheaper" that way and it would be kind of fun to watch 8 of them on your wall draw your documents concurrently.

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by SixSigma on Monday September 12, 2016 @10:10AM (#12479785)
> make a printer-bot ... that allowed you to put any writing instrument you wanted into the cross-hairs and slowly draw out your documents like a plotter.

http://shop.evilmadscientist.com/productsmenu/846

Mine is on order

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by sevensor on Monday September 12, 2016 @10:53AM (#12480162)
That's amazing!
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by sevensor on Monday September 12, 2016 @10:51AM (#12480130)
> You know, it might not be such a bad idea to make a printer-bot ala a RepRap that allowed you to put any writing instrument you wanted into the cross-hairs and slowly draw out your documents like a plotter. The ink might be "cheaper" that way and it would be kind of fun to watch 8 of them on your wall draw your documents concurrently.

This is a neat idea -- for bonus points you could have it understand MetaFont, which is designed around an idealized pen.

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by BeniBoy on Monday September 12, 2016 @11:46AM (#12480692)
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by fluxquanta on Monday September 12, 2016 @10:26AM (#12479907)
>Faxing is 90% dead as far as I can tell. I've got a fax machine, I think the last time I plugged it in was 2008.

Depends on the industry. I would say probably 80% of the clients I work with still rely on faxing as a regular part of doing business. Is it the ideal way of sending documents? Probably not, but I've also never heard of anyone who had to call in technical support to clear off malware or reformat their fax machine. It just works.

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by jcrawfordor on Monday September 12, 2016 @08:51PM (#12484929)
Are your clients on physical fax machines or an internet-based fax service? I use fax for business but I use Phaxio, and I think more than half the people I exchange faxes with are also using a fax service. This has the comical result of my producing a PDF file then paying someone to modulate it into noises that someone else will demodulate back into a PDF to deliver to the recipient. It's like e-mail if the intermediary servers lossily recompressed the attachments.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by fluxquanta on Tuesday September 13, 2016 @10:56AM (#12488805)
The clients I work with tend to still use physical fax machines to send/receive financing details to small banks and credit unions. The banks themselves probably use some sort of internet service, or at least I hope they do.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by Grishnakh on Monday September 12, 2016 @01:01PM (#12481430)
>Is it the ideal way of sending documents? Probably not, but I've also never heard of anyone who had to call in technical support to clear off malware or reformat their fax machine. It just works.

It's amazing just how much society is being held back by the Windows operating system.

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by unclebucknasty on Monday September 12, 2016 @11:03AM (#12480271)
>Until we start using content-hashing for everything you cannot trust the...

You are pointing to technological problems that are best addressed by direct innovation on those problems vs via workarounds that rely on outmoded technology.

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by ebiester on Monday September 12, 2016 @08:25AM (#12479067)
Our screens are still not good enough to avoid eye strain and still do not provide the tactile arrangement paper does. I have been typing as long as I have been reading, and I will still go to hard copy if I have to edit a manuscript of any length.

We still need printers.

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by unclebucknasty on Monday September 12, 2016 @08:43AM (#12479182)
I agree, and that makes my point. The need for innovation is in technologies that can adequately replace paper; not in better printers.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by copperx on Monday September 12, 2016 @11:34AM (#12480586)
Apple's retina screens take care of the resolution aspect. However, the software side needs a new paradigm to deal with digital paper. PDF files are not the solution.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by ebiester on Monday September 12, 2016 @05:52PM (#12484004)
I need to look at four pieces of paper and write on them and draw arrows on them at once without breaking my flow. That's four ipads at this point, and there's still no great way of flipping between pages. There is something about the 3Dness of a stack of papers that makes moving to digital difficult.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by tonyedgecombe on Monday September 12, 2016 @10:44AM (#12480074)
This has finally been happening, world wide paper volumes are decreasing, from http://www.mypurchasingcenter.com/commodities/commodities-ar...

"overall printing and writing paper demand in the U.S. has declined by about 4% in 2014 and there will be a similar contraction in 2015"

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by unclebucknasty on Monday September 12, 2016 @09:12AM (#12479341)
Down votes. Makes sense. Sure, one might be tempted to think that advocating a paperless world would be non-controversial here.

But, yes, let's rush headlong into the world of driverless cars, while holding on to a relatively minor update to 15th century technology at all costs.

I wonder if HN know how much it parodies itself at times.

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by reitanqild on Monday September 12, 2016 @10:15AM (#12479827)
From my observations: your first comment might have fared better if it was posted as a question.

The downvotes on the last one were most likely because you complained about the first ones, against site guidelines.

Anyways, here, have a couple of upvotes, -I haven't found any way to exchange mine for cash :-]

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by unclebucknasty on Monday September 12, 2016 @11:11AM (#12480344)
Thanks, I have actually figured out a way to make millions on them.

In seriousness, I agree that they are completely worthless as far as it goes. In fact, I've ranted in the past that the concept of downvotes is outright juvenile. Along those lines, I'm more complaining that they too frequently take the place of discussion, submarine dissenting opinions, and encourage group-think.

Which is also why I don't pose my opinions in the form of a question. I'm one of those people who believes it's OK to plainly and respectfully express a dissenting belief, without apologizing for it.

In fact, do you know of any other path to a better world? (See what I did there?)

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by hx87 on Monday September 12, 2016 @02:47PM (#12482517)
> I'm one of those people who believes it's OK to plainly and respectfully express a dissenting belief, without apologizing for it.

And I believe that downvotes are one avenue of doing so.

Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by unclebucknasty on Monday September 12, 2016 @06:09PM (#12484097)
Except that they add as little to thoughtful discussion as your comment advocating for them.
Re:HP is buying Samsung’s printer business for $1.05B by reitanqild on Monday September 12, 2016 @12:08PM (#12480890)
: )