That seems like a totally disproportionate approach versus responding with a polite 'this is a legitimate use of the word, thanks' message.
Just firing off a warning based on a simple text match seems high-handed and/or incompetent enough to consider leaving.
"Hey boss,I tried cloning the Github repo of project X, but it says it can't be found, and I noticed our org page on Github is gone."
"Oh yeah, they sent us a message about the use of the word 'retard' in when referring to phase shifting."
"Oh, so they deleted our organization?"
"No."
"Oh? Well why can't I view it, weren't the projects public? What did you say to them?"
"I didn't say anything, I moved us to a different host."
My point is simply: if Github is flagging content based on perceived personal morals (not ever being allowed to use the word "retard," even in legitimate contexts), some choose not to associate their work with them.
Also why as a code hosting service would they be getting involved with the politics of the content of projects they host?
It raises questions about the internal company culture, their commitment to pragmatism (doubly important for a source code hosting site), and their priorities. Any developer could have told this person that a string match does not equal a linguistic match.
Small signals matter; they're usually all you get out of large orgs.
I'm definitely not interested in company I'm paying for investing resources retarded things.
- a happy gitlab user.
It just seems that this problems is remarkably easily solved with a simple "We are using a technical term correctly, maybe you should consider adjusting your automated emails."
I do get the impression that people generally seem to be all to eager to take offence, and it strikes me as a bit ironic to flounce off in a huff as a result of a badly-judged automated process!
How is this any better?
Idk, i dont understand why they would even care. Unless it reached a very intolerable bar, i dont think this is necessary
[1] https://github.com/opal/opal/issues/954 [2] https://github.com/CoralineAda?tab=activity
I'm not terribly surprised. GitHub is, after all, a company which changed its logo to celebrate a highly political U.S. Supreme Court decision and which has had issues with left-wing racism (http://www.businessinsider.com/github-the-full-inside-story-...).
For me it's still about the organization, and singling out individuals is about as productive as yelling at customer support on the phone.
Related: The company is slipping my mind right now, but one startup changed their email name in automated messages from male to female and saw improved metrics as a result.
And what level of access do these on-staff political activists have to private user information? What measures, if any, does GitHub have in place to prevent one of their political activist employees from using privileged information to go after perceived political enemies or even just retaliate against users who protest being harassed?
What is "bigoted" about trying to avoid the user of the word "retard"? I'm not saying that what Github is doing is wise or sensible, but I'm struggling to see how it is bigoted.
> What measures, if any, does GitHub have in place to prevent one of their political activist employees from using privileged information to go after perceived political enemies or even just retaliate against users who protest being harassed?
I would imagine the same as any other company. There's nothing that would indicate otherwise, aside from your own biases against Github.
It cannot be healthy to have all our eggs in one basket (Github), regardless of how featureful and nice Github is, especially so given the availability of viable options. To that end, we should not complain when a project, say, evil-mode is on bitbucket, and similarly not ask a project to open shop on github.
I mean, if we don't work towards a fully distributed project model ala fossil-scm (via things like git-appraise), we should at least use alternatives when we can, and not strengthen Github's monopoly.
If you find it on Github, you can find out how to get started but everything else is on Gitlab.
Going away is the correct response, fighting the decision is never useful. One might wait a bit to see if it's a fluke, but that will certainly depend on the GP's evaluation of the company.
She indicated that it doesn't matter how the word is used, some will see it as aggressive.
I was there to code. Not worry about if I hurt some oversensitive person's feelings for referring to master/slave copies.
We're all on Github to write code, but I'd argue you are dangerously close to throwing the baby out with the bathwater there. It seems perfectly reasonable for someone to say "hey, this term you use might be offensive/makes me uncomfortable, please consider changing it." It's also perfectly legitimate for you to say "I don't want to do that".
I just kind of wish that everyone would be a little less sensitive about the prospect of other people being offended by things that they are not. Political correctness, in the sense of "try not to say things that are offensive" sense, is probably not the worst idea in the world!
This doesn't mean people stop having them.
This just means that they are labelled/judged if they have them.
Guess what happens then? People keep it to themselves. And then they vote for Trump. Why? Because, he is a ridiculous loudmouth who is very out of touch with most of reality. But, he doesn't feel the need to be censored. And to people who haven't spoken out due to fear of reprisal, this is an admiral characteristic. He gives them validation.
So yeah, political correctness is retarded.
At which point you get harassed by a mob, spammed with issues that clutter up your project, and get emailed death threats.
Github is allowed, of course, to choose which projects they decide to host. Demanding the removal of the word "retards" [0] or a project would be shut down drove at least one developer away.
So no - that isn't "perfectly legitimate" for that community. "I don't want to do that" is not good enough.
[0] https://github.com/nixxquality/WebMConverter/commit/9fde8f33...
To olay devil's advocate, what's wrong with offending people who read your source code? You can't harass people through source code in a meaningful way because you can't force them to look at the code through natural interaction with GitHub itself, if they see a project that is insulting, they can just ignore it.
It's not like a social media site where you can ensure your victims' feeds will be polluted with your insults.
Also that interaction with Github, can be interpreted as a pointer to larger systemic issue (for better or for worse) which the customer doesn't believe will be solved with a simple email.
A customer can choose to take their business elsewhere for whatever reason, at any time. I mean you can speculate as to whether it was disproportionate or not, but the only determinant here whose opinion matters is the paying customer.
I'm also curious on how many downvotes I will get for this, because the polite way is to use f*ck or something, right?
Fortunately, people like me see such declarations — "Hmm, I'd better now reactivate my paid GitHub subscription, and stop pushing people to competitors. Their attitude is improving!"
But ..
Me too!
I now use gitlab for my company and haven't noticed a difference.
I want my git host to worry about hosting git.
As she appeared to be a non-technical person mysteriously employed by GitHub as some consolation to some organization (IIRC it was called the "Ada Initiative") I realized that github is no longer a technology company. It's a Social Justice company. Good luck to them--I don't even disagree with the basic premise--but I like my git repo companies to be worried about git.
EG The french for "I'm late" is "Je suis en retard".
Github is never getting another penny from me.
It's not usual to avoid any mention of gender in English; some people avoid it for political reasons. But when you're translating a gender-marked word into an English equivalent which is not marked for gender, it's not idiomatic to add another word to indicate gender unless it's relevant to the topic at hand.
English lost most of its grammatical gender centuries ago. Since the 1960s and 1970s the parts that remain have become politically fraught in some circles, but usage varies by community. Unless you're deliberately wading into that fight, I'd stick to the way you were taught.
On a side not, I do miss that added context in English, especially in novels, when it's hard to guess just based on the names of the characters. It makes it easier for me to imagine them and evaluate interactions between them.
We can't just erase gender. People think in gender, and they consequently speak it. I don't think twice about mentioning "some guy" commented on my post, for example. Just the other day I decided to be even and refer to a hypothetical person by using "s/he", and even got called out on it.
If someone rolls a die 10.000 times, and 75% of the time it lands on a six, then instead of "not caring", many people will care. Particularly those that are not betting on the six. Though the people betting on the six have a vested stake in "not caring".
In other words, it's a matter of bias.
If talent is not correlated to race/sex, then we can expect that the number of people of various races/sexes that are represented in the industry should roughly match the general makeup of the population (ie it's a mostly random distribution). Instead we see that this is not case. So either, talent is correlated to race/sex or there is a bias somewhere in the process.
Employer hiring should match the candidate population, not the general population. This is a subtle but very important difference when we also see, for instance, gender bias in graduation rates of STEM fields. (I'm not claiming that this accounts for all bias.) Really, when you say "there is a bias somewhere in the process", it must be remembered that the "process" being spoken of is the entire process that leads to a person being a valid candidate, from schooling to prior experience. (It's hard to get hired as a senior if you can't get hired as a junior first.)
Secondly: there are obviously some differences in the behavior, knowledge, and culture of different groups and it is beneficial for a company to include those and profit from it.
But... you can't have gone through more than 14 years of life without having heard all thread a few times, can you?
See – it feels kinda strange when people willfully misunderstand you and put words in your mouth you never said...
- Race, gender, sexual orientation, disability etc. do not generally affect an individual's skill as an employee
- People from certain groups are under-represented in the industry
- Under-representation generally reflects an underlying problem somewhere, because one would expect various groups to be represented broadly in line with wider society
- One of the problems that can cause under-representation is an existing bias in an industry, which can discourage other members of a group
- One of the approaches to solving this is to help ensure that those groups feel comfortable in the industry
- One of the approaches to helping them feel comfortable is to ensure that communities are inviting, open-minded, and aware that things they say or do may upset or discourage other people, even though they are do not find those things offensive themselves.
It's about observing a trend which seems wrong for various reasons, and attempting to help solve it. I don't doubt for a second that many people go completely overboard on this issue, but outright rejecting any attempt at using, say, gender-neutral language in open-source projects just seems to go completely in the other direction.
We don't like to use Github anymore because of the politics there. Example: We had a project involving software filters that included this sentence in the description:
> Phase is related to time, but a pure time delay does not involve any phase shift. A pure time delay or "group delay" is constant with frequency. Phase shift varies with frequency and can advance or retard as the frequency changes.
We got a note from a woman who works at github who was apparently scanning open source projects for "offensive" words. Our project was flagged for the use of the word "retard".
We removed our project and never used github again.