But CA is a bit strange: A mortgage is non-recourse only in defined circumstances, eg when the mortgage is purchase money guaranteed by the property. It used to be that refis turn non-recourse debt into recourse debt.
I'd be very surprised if a loan backed by stock met the non-recourse requirements. So if you fail to pay, it's probable that they can go after your other assets.
fyi I haven't kept up with how things evolved out of the mortgage meltdown, so perhaps things have changed. But anyone taking such a loan should figure out their potential liabilities carefully.
edit: actually its complicated
This is not true. All manner of restricted stock units (granted to insiders) and unregistered stock (not publicly traded) can be used as collateral for loans (though some issuers make you sign documents promising not to do so). I have been asked to appraise private stock for lenders and render an opinion around its volatility and liquidity.
That must be a ton of fun. How do they incentivize you and your operation to be conservative? Because they presumably only make money if you hit the number, which was the big problem with home appraisers in the housing bubble.
They only way I can think of to cause correct behavior would be to ensure that your operation maintains an interest in the loan after the deal is done.
The contents are less "this is where you should mark this asset" and more "this is where others have marked it, the circumstances under which they did so and how those circumstances may differ from this situation". The value isn't in providing a "right" number as much as turning a zero-information situation into an information-positive one.
This should be the slogan for all market research companies. Good way to look at it.
Or maybe we're just back to 2006 standards for mortgages and I'm slow to realize it.
I wasn't being clear: It doesn't matter that you can pay, it matters that you will pay. (Four months is nothing to the mortgage principal.)
Look, the Fed is going to raise rates RSN. Which way does the high end of real estate go when interest rates come off zero %? So suddenly the homeowner is down 10% on the value of their $2M home. Is it worth it for them to mail in the keys to the bank for $200K and tell the collectors to pound sand? For a lot of people, yes. So the bank (or more accurately, the loan service) has to figure out how to send over two guys named Rocko with the power to get their money back.
In the bubble, the solution was to lay off all the Rockos because, you know, housing never goes down. Maybe we're back to that state, which would be amazing, but I'd guess the banks are somehow covering for their liability on zero-down loans this time around.
Edit for tcoppi's comment: s/FedIncrease/BlackSwan/ because home prices do decline for a variety of reasons.
BTW: Implied probability of a Fed rate increase in Sept is back to where it was before Brexit. http://www.ft.com/fastft/2016/07/25/odds-of-16-fed-rate-rise...
Edit for dragonwriter's comment (hn doesn't let replies go this deep?): Fed has been trying to normalize rates, and employment/gdp/cpi has been stabilizing. See the link above for implied prob from Fed Futures for how people are betting on Sept.
Is it? It doesn't really seem like it, they raised them .25% in December and haven't done diddly since then, with no signs that they will. Like it or not it is incredibly difficult for us to get out of the ZIRP trap, we most likely won't see anything more than 2% out of the fed for a decade or more. Barring massive inflation, it definitely won't go up fast enough to have a major effect on housing prices like that.
What in the considerations that drive monetary policy (employment and inflation, mainly) suggests that another interest rate hike is imminent?
a) it's illegal and grounds for penalty if you merely write up such a contract, ("mayn't") or
b) it's not common practice to use them as collateral? ("aren't")
Because if there's someone who thinks it's valuable, then there's someone who's willing to accept it as collateral.
Stock is not cash. It is less liquid and more volatile. But if one properly discounts to accommodate those factors, it's just another deferred cash flow. This time, not relinquishable by the company. (If the stock goes to zero the employment cash flows do, too.)
That argument is good until it is not. Unfortunately, when it is not is precisely when one needs it.
Edit: Additionally, salary falls in the same boat. If your stock in your S&P 500 employer tanks, you salary will tank too. Also, I'm talking about a "sell as soon as it vests" strategy, which makes it pretty much just a variable form of salary.
Liquidity is a surface over the time in which a transaction must occur, transaction size and price. If you have a large amount to sell or buy (relative to the market), want it sold or purchased quickly (relative to the market) and/or don't want to eat more than an X% discount (if selling) or premium (if buying) (relative to the market), you will find the securities illiquid, i.e. not able to be turned into cash (or purchased) within your size/price/time parameters.
For a liquidator, time is usually same day or a few days. Size is fixed to the balance of the loan. That leaves price. In a turbulent market, the liquidator may end up selling your securities for pennies on the dollar - your collateral may insufficiently cover your balance. That leads to the lender eating a loss or the borrower coughing up cash. $100 of stock may cover less than $100 of balance; $100 of cash will always cover $100.
Retail margin lending is capped at 2:1, so a 50% discount would wipe out your collateral, but institutions and mortgages can go 5:1 and beyond, meaning smaller drops become dangerous faster. When everyone is rushing for the doors simultaneously, these price drops can be precipitous, if short-lived.
My point, however, isn't about collateral. It's about future cashflow. A Senior engineer at Google might have a salary of $150k, but total compensation package including 270 shares of GOOG distributed per year (~23 shares per month) for a total comp of $350k. For such an individual, do you lend based on salary alone or do you factor in the stock?
I imagine that with a correct discount the stock can and should be used in the cashflow calculation.
That's one of the reasons that in Spain you have such amazing mortgage rates compared to the US: The banks are taking less risk.
Even where allowed in the US, they tend (not always, it varies by state) to increase the judicial oversight of (and thus extend timelines for) the foreclosure sale, and often reduce the finality of a foreclosure sale by providing a post-sale redemption period. Both of these things are things that lenders might prefer to avoid in many cases where a deficiency would, in theory, be available.
How much lower are they in Spain?
ECorps have a lot of trouble doing that.
In some US states, when a mortgage defaults the borrower is personally responsible for the full repayment of the loan. That is, the asset is first sold and if that fails to cover all expenses, the borrower must fork over the difference.
In no-recourse states, the asset turned over to the lender and even if it fails to cover the debt, the borrower gets to walk away.
http://www.investopedia.com/terms/n/nonrecoursedebt.asp
In California all mortgages are non-recourse debt.
http://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/whats-the-difference-...
Searching for no-resource state brought up a huge number of programming links - sometime I worry about user customization in search and other UI elements
They don't go into much detail, but this part scares me.
I'm assuming the "model" estimates some sort of future value for the stock. "You only make $150K, but don't worry, our model says that once your stock starts to vest, you'll be making $250K per year thereafter".
Of course that assumes their "model" of the stock price is correct.
However, California is a no-resource [edit:non-recourse] state, so if the owners get to the point where they can't afford payments, then it's the lender that is on the hook for the loss.