Re:Some Silicon Valley Tech Workers Get Home Loans with No M...
by phamilton on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @02:20PM
(#12175293)
That was really informative. Thanks.
My point, however, isn't about collateral. It's about future cashflow. A Senior engineer at Google might have a salary of $150k, but total compensation package including 270 shares of GOOG distributed per year (~23 shares per month) for a total comp of $350k. For such an individual, do you lend based on salary alone or do you factor in the stock?
I imagine that with a correct discount the stock can and should be used in the cashflow calculation.
Liquidity is a surface over the time in which a transaction must occur, transaction size and price. If you have a large amount to sell or buy (relative to the market), want it sold or purchased quickly (relative to the market) and/or don't want to eat more than an X% discount (if selling) or premium (if buying) (relative to the market), you will find the securities illiquid, i.e. not able to be turned into cash (or purchased) within your size/price/time parameters.
For a liquidator, time is usually same day or a few days. Size is fixed to the balance of the loan. That leaves price. In a turbulent market, the liquidator may end up selling your securities for pennies on the dollar - your collateral may insufficiently cover your balance. That leads to the lender eating a loss or the borrower coughing up cash. $100 of stock may cover less than $100 of balance; $100 of cash will always cover $100.
Retail margin lending is capped at 2:1, so a 50% discount would wipe out your collateral, but institutions and mortgages can go 5:1 and beyond, meaning smaller drops become dangerous faster. When everyone is rushing for the doors simultaneously, these price drops can be precipitous, if short-lived.