Actually, you'd be hard pressed to find anyone who doesn't use Scots to some degree. I realise the 30% figure came from census data, but most people here use Scots without recognising it themselves as a distinct 'Scots' language. It's a tricky thing to word in a census to get real numbers.
> However it's insane to think that this means speaking Scots is sufficient if you want a good job
Absolutely true. Myself and everyone I know use Scots in daily life, both at work and at home. But most recognise that (rightly or wrongly) it's not socially acceptable to use it in formal situations, such as during a job interview, talking to clients etc.
Scots or AAVE might not actually be "deficient English" but to a non-Scots or non-AAVE speaker of English they might as well be because the only thing that matters (biases aside) is intelligibility.
For an absurd example: if you're a German company and hire a sophisticated Dutch native speaker who doesn't speak a word of German it doesn't matter how sophisticated their Dutch is, you'll still only understand a fraction of what they say and think they have a really strong accent (because the words you understand as German are actually Dutch and just happen to have the same origins).
Of course it's less of a problem with Dutch because there's actually a language where Dutch is the official language and there is a large regional population of people all speaking the language and learning standardized rules for the language in schools.
Scots at least has the large regional population. AAVE outside majority-black areas might as well be Scots because the majority of people won't find it mutually intelligible.
The "even if" part of your concluding paragraph was a nice touch, suggesting as it does that there might be a live dispute about whether AAVE is a proper dialect of English. I have a hard time understanding how someone could get even 3 pages into this (incredibly fascinating) essay and retain any doubts about that.
If you skimmed the essay and jumped to HN to make a political argument, you've cheated yourself. Go back and read it more closely. It's fantastic.
I don't know what beef you think you have with me and maybe this is my failure to communicate clearly (English is not my native language) but you seem rather hostile to me and it reads like you think I'm somehow questioning AAVE's status is a distinct dialect of English alongside GA, RP, Scots and so on.
BTW, my comment was a response to a comment that has apparently been flagged and my comment seems to have been detached, which is why my argument reads like it's in opposition to the article rather than the comment I responded to (which in turn was actually in opposition to the article): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12030560
It's that tangent I reacted to here.
Elsewhere on the thread I simply disagree with your description of AAVE.
My comment was not a top-level comment when I wrote it. That is why it doesn't seem to be relevant to the article. I actually responded to a top-level comment that has since been flagged. Apparently the moderation fairies saw something useful in it and detached it without leaving any traces. Or I'm an idiot and managed to respond to the article instead of the comment I was actually replying to.
The comment I responded to introduced an ideological tangent on whether AAVE harms the job prospects of its speaker, not me. I merely agreed that regardless of the status of AAVE and its acceptance (which really only seems to be a problem because of ideological reasons -- it's literally self-evident that AAVE is a "real language" if that qualifier carries any meaning at all) there's no point in trying to give AAVE a special status in the expectation that it helps its recognition or the preservation of black cultural heritage (which is the general idea behind minority language movements like those in Europe).
That indeed has nothing to do with the article and only re-iterates the specific point from the parent I responded to with something more productive than simply "if you teach AAVE in school black kids won't find a job because they think knowing AAVE is all they need".
I actually find your argument that recognition of AAVE as a distinct language can help teaching AAVE native speakers English in school interesting and wonder if the creole children from Turkish immigrants in Germany speak has been studied similarly and if treating it as a distinct language and teaching German as a second language would work here as well.
Lastly, please note you're not disagreeing with my description of AAVE. You're disagreeing with what I described as the (obviously biased) perception of AAVE by non-AAVE speakers of GA/RP. Of course it's disagreeable, but it seems like you mistake my "is" for "ought":
* AAVE sounds stupid if you only know GA/RP. This impression is caused by AAVE being close enough to GA/RP to be intelligible but different enough to feel wrong, like a linguistic Uncanny Valley. This is just what happens if you feed unexpected input to the built-in language parser in your head.
* AAVE is not actually stupid. This should be obvious but apparently I need to repeat this statement every time I make the previous statement.
* Because of the race problems in the US and because AAVE signals being black, AAVE speakers face special discrimination even beyond those other non-GA speakers of English (or non-fluent non-native speakers of GA/similar) face in the US.
Sorry I made discussing this so tedious for you!
Almost no one is suggesting that. What is being suggested is that AAVE shouldn't be derided as talking "like hoodlums" (to quote the parent comment). Employment discrimination based upon someone retaining elements of AAVE is considered acceptable to some, but I've never seen them argue that discriminating against someone who speaks New England English is acceptable (or seen them address how showing the influence of one dialect is much more harmful to your employment chances than showing the influence of the other).
It makes sense that people should learn General American and try to use it to facilitate communication, but the negative stigma attached to particular dialects and not others is problematic and encourages bigotry.
I think New England is a red herring. There's a similar negative stigma to the Southern Drawl -- and that's really as white as it gets. "White trash" or "redneck" is an actual existing stereotype.
Both AAVE and Southern American English have negative connotations. The only difference is that AAVE also marks the speaker with an ethnicity that also has negative connotations (going by studies into biases, even black Americans have negative associations with black people).
Fix the negative connotations of that ethnicity and people think of AAVE speakers no less than of uneducated white people.
The reason that AAVE even in isolation "sounds uneducated" is that it is not only related to Southern American English (which already "sounds uneducated" on its own) but also that it simplifies some grammar and phonemes from English. No matter what complexity it brings to the table by itself, those changes make it look simpler in comparison and speaking simplified language makes a speaker appear less sophisticated.
AAVE by itself sounds unsophisticated to GA or RP speakers. That simply cannot be helped. It's inherent to the language itself. The only thing you can hope for (short of replacing GA with something that makes AAVE sound less jarring -- or having AAVE somehow become the language of the sociopolitical elite) is that the association moves from "hoodlums" to "inbred rednecks".
Note: I'm not saying AAVE "is" objectively less sophisticated. I'm saying it objectively sounds less sophisticated to a speaker of GA or RP. Even if you had never met a black person before and never heard AAVE before, as a GA speaker you would think AAVE sounds less sophisticated than GA because of the objective reasons I laid out.
If you can think of a scenario where AAVE becomes a language everybody wants to speak in order to show off how sophisticated they are (like French in medieval England) or where GA is replaced by a language that is different enough to simply make AAVE sound completely foreign (like if the official language of the US was Chinese or Spanish), I don't see any plausible way to fight its negative connotations (unlike those of blackness in general).
You can't simply "simplify" Standard English and arrive at AAVE. If you try, you'll end up in the same hilarious place William Raspberry ended up in the Washington Post.
There's no question that Standard English speakers consider their dialect superior to AAVE, just as UK Standard English speakers consider theirs superior to Cockney, and Parisian speakers consider their dialect superior to, well, every other place French is spoken. What's worth noting is that the belief in the intrinsic superiority of one dialect over another is usually not well-founded.
It's this constant conflation between usage and morality that David Foster Wallace concerns himself in his review of Garner's dictionary. Your comments here are prime example of that confusion at work. You should consider reading DFW's piece --- but do it after re-reading this one. I read the AAVE essay today for the first time, and then re-read DFW's, and had a very different take on DFW as a result.
Those cognitive biases are called "understanding GA/RP" and "not understanding AAVE". As I have said elsewhere, this is no different from a German attempting to parse Dutch, except a Dutch speaker can actually point to a country that has Dutch as official language.
This is not a fault of AAVE. This doesn't make Dutch "realer" than AAVE. This is just how humans work. It's apparently relatively universal and not new, so it's naive to imagine we can "fix humans" to eliminate that bias.
The real problem is that Americans have negative associations with black people. That is fixable because it is largely an artefact of the US's incredibly unfortunate history. Once that is fixed the bias against AAVE is no less worth delving on than the bias against Southern American English in general.
The phenomenon you're trying to call out is called a "sociolect". These days almost every "non-standard" dialect acts as a kind of sociolect because the "standard" dialect is expected to be followed in all kinds of formal or even informal settings from political speeches to the workplace.
I'm not arguing anything is superior. I don't understand why you keep responding to every single one of my comments by arguing I'm making some kind of claim about superiority.
You can't simplify Standard English and arrive at AAVE, yes. That's what I am saying. But you can simplify Standard English, put it alongside actual AAVE and a non-AAVE speaker will likely find the two indistinguishable and think they're both "just simplified English". I'm talking about appearances in the context of another language here.
Of course no language is "superior". I'm making a pragmatic argument about why people act the way they do, not about some nonsensical cultural shouting match.
At any rate: thanks for clarifying. I think I have a nitpicky disagreement with your characterization of AAVE as sounding simpler because of actual simplifications, as opposed to misapprehensions SE speakers have about what constitutes simplicity. But it's just a nitpick.
Also, Pullum himself suggests, towards the end of the essay, that it's just an accident of history that we're all not speaking something closer to AAVE than SE.
As to the nitpick: as a non-native speaker of English I'm well-aware that intuitions about actual mistakes people make are often wrong if that's what you're hinting at. I actually saw a nice example of that in a course on forensic linguistics back in university: a suspected criminal wrote a letter containing a number of glaring grammatical mistakes and the investigators at the time assumed it must have been a German immigrant but to us Germans it was obvious that those mistakes couldn't have been made by a native German speaker no matter how bad he was at English: even "broken English" follows rules.
Fun fact: the only person I've ever met who had a true Hollywood movie villain WW2 German accent in English was actually from Eastern Europe and had a thick accent in German as well.
Not sure how you can see this as a red herring. It's a pretty good example of how variations that aren't General American aren't held to the same standard. Some are considered a sign of poor education, while others are merely considered regionalisms. This reflects an underlying bias.
The fact that rural Southern dialects carry a stigma that New England dialects don't only provides more evidence of this.
You can say that it seems less sophisticated to you, but I doubt that this is merely an objective statement entirely disconnected from the culture that treats these dialects as less sophisticated. Linguists don't seem to consider them less sophisticated (kind of the point of the article, which was written by a linguist).
I never said AAVE is less sophisticated. I even went out of my way to make it clear that I'm not saying AAVE is less sophisticated.
AAVE contains grammar that is based on simplified English grammar. Simplified grammar sounds less sophisticated to a speaker of the original grammar. This makes AAVE sound less sophisticated to English speakers. Quod erat demonstrandum.
I'm not even a native speaker of English and this is obvious to me. Heck, this is immediately obvious if you try to learn English (or any language) as a second language: if you don't speak the language well people will treat you as less intelligent because you are not able to communicate at the same level of sophistication (simply because you lack the words and the grammatical details).
This isn't awesome. This certainly isn't how you'd want it to be if you could just define how things are. But this is how things are and it's certainly not unique to English. The same is true for German, Chinese, Japanese and I'm fairly certain I've heard similar anecdotes from people studying indigenous languages.
Please don't simply ignore my entire argument because you think I'm trying to go full Hegel and claim black people are less intelligent. You couldn't be further from reading me.
Again, this is showing inherent biases. An AAVE or Southern dialect speaker speaking GA as well as a speaker of a New England dialect will be treated quite differently. The former is much more likely to be thrown in the "not speaking the language well" category; the latter is much more likely to be dismissed as merely a regional variation.
> AAVE contains grammar that is based on simplified English grammar.
But that's not true, as the paper mentions. Again, shouldn't we be deferring to the linguistics here?
> Please don't simply ignore my entire argument because you think I'm trying to go full Hegel and claim black people are less intelligent.
I honestly have no idea how you got this from my comments.
I'm assuming you mean speaking perfectly fluent GA but throwing in a few loanwords. Indeed then the speaker isn't using simplified grammar, but they're still signalling that they're a speaker of the language they're importing loanwords from and this leaks into how people assess them -- just like using French loan words is often used (often unsuccessfully) to signal being "cultured".
I initially already said that people who speak AAVE also happen to fall into a socioethnic group who have negative connotations outside of their language. This is perfect evidence for that: speaking AAVE signals you are part of that group, so all biases against that group are applied to you. In that case AAVE itself isn't even relevant and might as well be Mandarin or French (as long as it uniquely signals association with the group).
Heck, you even see white kids try to emulate some form of AAVE to associate themselves with what they perceive as "black culture" (often based on their exact stereotypes).
> But that's not true, as the paper mentions.
It's actually not what the paper argues. Pullum argues against the misconception that AAVE is "English with mistakes" and gives examples how these idiosyncracies GA/RP speakers perceive as "mistakes" actually follow consistent rules.
Note how I said it is "based on" simplified English grammar. Dropping consonants and auxiliaries is superficially a simplification even if it follows rules. The production rules may be actually more complex because these rules come on top of whatever rules there were to begin with, but the produced result is simplified. The outcome is, to a GA but non-AAVE speaker's ears simplified (if only because they don't understand the additional production rules).
> I honestly have no idea how you got this from my comments.
You picked a single sentence from my comment and presented it out of context -- a context in which I clarified the exact meaning of that sentence and rejected what you were arguing I was saying.
I thought it was safe to assume you did this in bad faith. I may have thought wrong, in which case I apologize.
--
To reiterate: the reasons AAVE has negative connotations are twofold:
1. America really has problems with black people. As an outsider the entire situation seems absurd but there are a lot of historical nuances that have ultimately resulted in a standstill where white people pretend they're not racist and black people pretend everybody hates them. This is probably not easy to solve but is the real problem that needs solving (preferably by reducing the racism, not simply using less blatantly insulting language to discriminate black people).
2. AAVE to a GA/RP non-AAVE speaker sounds like a dumbed down version of GA/RP (because they parse it as GA/RP and it's close enough to work in "error compatibility mode"). There is no way to fix this but it's less of a problem if non-AAVE speakers don't already think the "kind of people" who happen to speak AAVE are stupid/criminal/undesirable (see #1).
Trying to fix #1 by fixing #2 or trying to fix #2 in isolation is futile and is simply not going to happen.
There's no doubt AAVE sounds, to users of SWE, like a "dumbed down" version of the language. But as the essay points out repeatedly, the irony is that it's the SWE-users who are demonstrating ignorance. AAVE is just close enough to SWE to trigger the cognitive biases that trick people into making judgements they aren't qualified to make.
So we are in agreement.
> But as the essay points out repeatedly, the irony is that it's the SWE-users who are demonstrating ignorance.
Because they don't speak AAVE and thus parse it as GA/RP/whatever. Yes.
> AAVE is just close enough to SWE to trigger the cognitive biases that trick people into making judgements they aren't qualified to make.
In other words: non-AAVE speakers look at AAVE and see broken GA/RP/whatever. So we are in agreement.
EDIT: I'm beginning to sound like a broken record, but: I'm not saying AAVE is dumbed down GA/RP; I'm not saying AAVE is unsophisticated; I'm just saying that how non-AAVE GA/RP speakers perceive AAVE is a result of their inability to speak AAVE (mixed in with the racial problems in the US because AAVE usage signals race) and that the gut reaction "semi-intelligible = stupid" is not unique to English or a race thing.
EDIT2: Also, for the umpteenth time: I'm not disagreeing with the article. I didn't comment on the article. I commented on someone (flagged) who disagreed with the article and actually argued that treating AAVE as a "real language" would result in bad consequences. Apparently my comment was deemed interesting enough to be detached, which is why you think I'm responding to the article itself.
No he's not! He's been extremely clear on this. He's saying that some rules are simplified, and other rules are more complex, and that when someone that doesn't understand the added complexity hears it they think it's a simplification.
EDIT: Also, that's not even quite what I said: I said the rules of AAVE can produce sentences that can be parsed as simplified English. I didn't even say there are rules that are simplified. AFAICT and as far as the article goes, there aren't actually any rules that are simplified at all.
I think it's very important to distinguish between the underlying rules and the product. A speaker knows the rules. A recipient only receives the product. As this comment thread unfortunately shows, meaning can be lost completely no matter how much care is put into the production if the recipient isn't able to properly extract it from the product.
However it's insane to think that this means speaking Scots is sufficient if you want a good job. I don't think anyone attempting to get by in life and pursue a career in business or politics or academia would be taken serious if they only spoke Scots.
Actually Scots probably has the advantage of nostalgia. AAVE on the other hand is (ultimately) an artefact of American slave ownership -- that's something we would much rather undo than remember.
I think there's an argument to be made for the preservation of obscure languages (and a pidgin that is being threatened to be displaced by a dominant language it is partially based on certainly qualifies) but ultimately I agree exactly with what you are saying: reassuring AAVE speakers that it is okay to only speak a minority language when living in a country that is entirely based on a different language is cruel to the speakers.
For comparison (according to Wikipedia's numbers): Irish Gaelic is spoken by 18.3% of people on the Irish island (i.e. both Republic and Northern); Welsh is spoken by 19% of people in Wales.
Again according to Wikipedia's numbers, 12.8% of Americans speak Spanish at home, while 17.4% of Americans identify as Hispanic or Latino. If we assume AAVE is as widespread among black Americans as Spanish is among Hispanic and Latino Americans (because there are no official numbers) that would mean only 9.3% of Americans speak AAVE.
Even assuming every black American is an AAVE speaker (and that seems extremely bold as even linguists admit that "AAVE" is more of a spectrum than a clearly defined language) that would still be only 12.6% of Americans who speak AAVE. In other words: even by the most generous estimate 87.4% of Americans don't speak AAVE -- and likely don't comprehend the more idiosyncratic variants of AAVE.
So, even if AAVE is a "real" language, it's not widely useful outside of the small circles of AAVE speakers. It's just not realistic to expect 87.4% of the population to accommodate the "native language" of the remaining percentage if they already both speak General American English (or some approximation thereof).