News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by nfriedly on Thursday June 30, 2016 @11:12AM (#12009083)
4G is fast enough for me right now. My problem is the ridiculous pricing of wireless data. In ideal circumstances, I can hit nearly 75mb/s over LTE... but that just means that I could burn up my entire 3GB allotment in under 6 minutes. At $15 for the next 3 gigs, my marginal cost is nearly $1/minute for full-speed 4G data.
Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by mkane848 on Thursday June 30, 2016 @11:20AM (#12009129)
Even between wifi at home and work, streaming Spotify while driving and miscellaneous app usage off wifi gets me to basically 4GB a month. I can keep downloading more songs since I'm on Premium, but I think even with that I still actively have to watch my data usage and make a conscious effort to conserve data. I dunno, it's just nuts to try to do anything online without breaking your data cap in the world of 1080p and high quality audio streams
Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by bogomipz on Friday July 01, 2016 @02:05AM (#12014135)
Your carrier might be "zero-rating" your music streaming provider. A lot of them do now.
Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by bogomipz on Friday July 01, 2016 @02:12AM (#12014164)
Agreed. Don't need it, don't want it. Every new generation of wireless broadband has greater and greater spectral efficiency and yet none of that savings is ever passed on to the customer. The rates we pay to move bits over a radio interface is extortionate. The carrier will use 5G to sell phones and a largely uninformed public will line up to to buy them.
Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by anentropic on Friday July 01, 2016 @07:34AM (#12015215)
sounds like a lack of necessary regulation

enjoy your libertarian ideologies and try not to get shot

Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by pkaye on Thursday June 30, 2016 @11:23AM (#12009150)
I doubt wireless data will get really cheap give than wireless bandwidth has a physical limit. There is only so much capacity and the infrastructure is not cheap so providers need enough customer to subscribe to pay for it. That means oversubscribing customers or throttling in some manner. Ask yourself if you would prefer 75mb/s for burst use vs 75kb/s sustained use?
Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by vardump on Thursday June 30, 2016 @11:36AM (#12009265)
That's pretty much what the carriers want you to think. Their main talking points to convince you.

https://levels.io/korea-4g/. He used 4 TB of 4G data for $48. Yup. In high density South Korea.

Or maybe you'll want 200 GB plan in low density Sweden? 699 SEK/month (~$82), rather expensive as Nordic countries go, but at least no one can say I'm cherry picking. http://www.tele2.se/handla/mobilt-bredband-4g/.

Please don't buy the propaganda spread by the carriers. It's just full of excuses.

In their material you'll hear about how difficult it is to provide service for some unusual special case, like a stadium somewhere during a huge event and that's why. Stop asking, just buy our overpriced plan.

Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by gst on Thursday June 30, 2016 @12:12PM (#12009536)
Wireless is much cheaper in other countries. In Austria I can get a LTE flatrate (no hidden data limits, tethering allowed) for around 20-30 Dollars a month (depending on the speed, see https://www.drei.at/portal/de/privat/tarife/internet-tarife/...). The wireless carriers there compete with the cable providers and market their product as cable replacement. In the US the cheapest flatrate costs around 100 Dollars, and even then the amount of included data for tethering is still limited to some ridiculously low amount (I think something like 16 GB for T-Mobile).
Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by rayiner on Thursday June 30, 2016 @12:55PM (#12009887)
Boost and MetroPCS offers unlimited LTE with hotspot for $55-60/month.
Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by gst on Thursday June 30, 2016 @01:00PM (#12009934)
"For unlimited smartphone LTE data plan, full available speeds apply to 6 GB of hotspot data per payment cycle, then speeds slowed for remainder of payment cycle."
Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by jlappi on Thursday June 30, 2016 @01:26PM (#12010153)
For example, StraightTalk gives 5GB at 4G speed, however will slow you to 56Kbps (yes, dial-up speed) after.
Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by rayiner on Thursday June 30, 2016 @01:48PM (#12010343)
That's for the hotspot. You get unlimited LTE on your phone for that price.
Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by khedoros on Thursday June 30, 2016 @03:00PM (#12010872)
gst was talking about a mobile plan offering unlimited tethering/hotspot access. You're comparing that to a much more expensive plan with unlimited on-device LTE but limited hotspot access (8GB on Boost).
Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by Spooky23 on Thursday June 30, 2016 @04:13PM (#12011304)
It's a bullshit argument that exists because the US has allowed the industry to rebuild Bell System style telcos, unlike those anti-business socialists in places like South Korea.

Without a strong regulatory hand, the carriers' incentive in the US to to provide the highest return for the spectrum they've acquired. That extracting the highest revenue for the smallest capital investment -- means fewer towers optimized for coverage vs speed. Performance optimization requires more smaller facilities, which is capital intensive and appears wasteful from a Verizon/AT&T POV.

Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by norea-armozel on Thursday June 30, 2016 @12:02PM (#12009447)
The reality is the scarcity of bandwidth is minimal because the infrastructure itself gets cheaper the more customers you have. So adding a new tower or just adding more hardware to existing towers is a fixed cost which it's effects go down with the number of paying customers. This is classic economies of scale working in the favor of the Telcos they just don't want to admit it.
Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by rayiner on Thursday June 30, 2016 @12:17PM (#12009578)
"Economies of scale" means that your per-customer costs go down as you get more customers.[1]

Cellular deployment has almost no economies of scale. Deploying a new cell tower costs the same whether you already have 10 towers or 100. Meanwhile, just a handful of users can saturate a tower and/or its backhaul, so more customers requires smaller cells and more towers.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economies_of_scale.

Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by Retric on Thursday June 30, 2016 @01:42PM (#12010293)
Most towers peak below 50% utilization as bandwidth decreases with range. So, your average cost drops.

Put another way, to have good coverage and 1 customer would be ridiculously expensive. There are always going to be areas with few customers. You add towers in areas with lot's of customers.

Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by rayiner on Thursday June 30, 2016 @01:53PM (#12010389)
Your average cost only drops over a relatively narrow range: from where N towers is enough to support your users to where N+1 towers are necessary. After N is big enough to cover your area, cost still goes up basically linearly with the number of users (just in a saw-tooth fashion rather than a straight line).

It's totally unlike the costs of any service with real economics of scale, such as software.

Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by Retric on Thursday June 30, 2016 @02:12PM (#12010523)
Your thinking in terms of a small coverage area. Networks needs to be nationwide and users are not limited to a single tower.

As density increases infrastructure can more closely map to usage.

Net effect if 50 million people take X towers then 100 million people take less than 2x towers.

Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by TheCoelacanth on Friday July 01, 2016 @12:37PM (#12017600)
For vast swaths of the country, usage would be low enough that it doesn't even fully use one tower. For those areas, the marginal cost of adding a user is effectively zero.
Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by bogomipz on Friday July 01, 2016 @02:01AM (#12014127)
There is no causal relationship between scarcity of bandwidth and the price of infrastructure. That makes no sense.
Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by jacquesm on Thursday June 30, 2016 @11:34AM (#12009252)
All bandwidth has a physical limit. Without seeing the books on capacity planning for your average wireless provider it is impossible to know what the current situation really is but with what I know of telcos if they can get away with billing for 'air' they definitely will.

Note how it is just about impossible to get any usage statistics other than 'per person' from the various providers.

See also: 'roaming charges' and 'air time'.

Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by rayiner on Thursday June 30, 2016 @12:12PM (#12009534)
Everyone bills for what they can--that's why you pay $2/GB for more flash on an iPhone. The question is: why do data caps persist despite pretty much everyone having four different major carriers to choose from, plus often one or more MVNOs?
Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by jacquesm on Thursday June 30, 2016 @12:15PM (#12009564)
> why do data caps persist despite pretty much everyone having four different major carriers to choose from, plus often one or more MVNOs?

For the same reasons that it took government intervention in Europe to get rid of roaming charges.

Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by rayiner on Thursday June 30, 2016 @12:18PM (#12009586)
Which is what? What market failure was that a response to?
Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by tacostakohashi on Thursday June 30, 2016 @03:55PM (#12011193)
Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by jacquesm on Thursday June 30, 2016 @12:22PM (#12009611)
Carrier collusion.
Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by rayiner on Thursday June 30, 2016 @12:33PM (#12009701)
Not only is there no evidence of carrier collusion in the U.S. market, the idea doesn't even make logical sense. Cartels are inherently unstable.[1] Participants only have an incentive to continue colluding when everyone is making money. T-Mobile is barely breaking even, and Sprint is actively losing money. It's absurd to argue they are colluding to protect a status quo they don't benefit from.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cartel#Long-term_unsustainabil...

Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by tcoppi on Thursday June 30, 2016 @01:43PM (#12010305)
T-Mobile and other wireless carries barely break even in the same sense that Amazon barely breaks even - They are reinvesting most of their profits to increase their profitability in the future. T-Mobile actually has one of the highest gross profit margins in the sector, along with Verizon[1]. Their net profit is indeed low, but again, mostly due to continually investing in infrastructure upgrades and spectrum purchases.

I don't think these types of businesses will ever be inherently extremely profitable, but Verizon was making a nice chunk of change from ~2009-2014 until T-Mobile basically defected from the dominate market pricing contract scheme.

1. https://ycharts.com/companies/TMUS/gross_profit_margin

Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by jacquesm on Thursday June 30, 2016 @12:36PM (#12009719)
I think you missed the word 'Europe'.

And of course, in America there would never be such a thing as carrier collusion, that's totally unthinkable, so what those carriers in Europe were up to would not at all be done on other continents.

Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by rayiner on Thursday June 30, 2016 @12:51PM (#12009859)
T-Mobile and Sprint might be evil companies, but what incentive do they have to collude to protect a status quo under which they don't make any money? You're not just accusing them of being "bad companies"--you're accusing them of being irrational.
Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by jacquesm on Thursday June 30, 2016 @12:55PM (#12009890)
And you're assuming that T-Mobile and Sprint are incapable of hiring accountants capable of minimizing their profits for tax reasons.

Let's turn this around: if the market is so thin why are they still pursuing it?

Wouldn't it be irrational to pursue a market in which no profits can be made?

Especially while pushing forward with enormous marketing budgets and tech upgrades?

Maybe we should set up some kind of donation spot for those poor carriers that supply us with all this technology out of the goodness of their hearts.

Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by dforrestwilson on Thursday June 30, 2016 @02:05PM (#12010482)
Sorry but you are wrong here.

In the case of TMUS and S, and any other publicly traded company the imperative is to maximize shareholder value. Sprint especially is on the ropes. Investors worry a lot about a bankruptcy in the next couple of years. It has every incentive to change the status quo, and is cutting rates across the board to bring in subscribers.

It's not irrational if T-Mobile and Sprint believe they can eventually turn a profit, and probably compress the margins of T and VZ due to greater competition.

Sprint hasn't invested in its network in part due to cost-cutting. All of the carriers have to market. They are retail consumer facing.

I am not saying we should feel sorry for them, merely that the likelihood of collusion from Sprint especially is very low.

Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by jacquesm on Thursday June 30, 2016 @02:19PM (#12010588)
On the contrary, it would seem that Sprint has more to gain from collusion in such a situation because it allows them to use their network for bigger margins even if they don't upgrade.

See, there is no downside to collusion for parties, only upside.

And it even 'maximizes shareholder value'.

Sprint cutting their rates is a bit like pissing in your pants, as the Finnish say, it will only keep you warm for so long.

In the meantime, all carriers not being created equal, there may be some re-shuffling of name-tags and call signs but as long as carriers can get away with charging for thin air (SMS, Air Time) they've always done so, I see absolutely no reason to assume goodwill on their part without some pretty strict oversight.

And of course they have to market, just like everybody else that wishes to sell a product. But just like everybody else that wishes to sell a product, if there is no margin there will be no marketing, and if there is a way to improve the margin then surely it will taken.

Maybe Sprint is the exception, and they are really doing as bad as you say (a bankruptcy in the next couple of years does not sound like a huge threat to me, usually a bankruptcy in the next 3 months is the kind of thing you'd worry about) then maybe Sprint will go under and its assets and subscribers will end up with one of the other parties.

Such is the nature of doing business. But that says absolutely nothing about whether or not there is a profit to be made for all players by placing caps on data plans and by colluding to keep prices for data plans artificially high.

Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by harryh on Thursday June 30, 2016 @02:21PM (#12010610)
> See, there is no downside to collusion for parties, only upside.

The downside is that collusion preserves market share status quo. For those hoping to gain market share (like Sprint and T-Mobile) collusion gets in the way of that goal.

Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by jacquesm on Thursday June 30, 2016 @06:13PM (#12012252)
You're missing the point. You are presuming the market is functioning, my point is that if it does not the only losers will be the consumers all else being equal.

It is perfectly possible to compete for market share while at the same time colluding on the price of a part of your offering. All the parties competing will come out ahead in that scheme at the expense of the consumers.

You can compete on the kind of handsets you offer, your marketing message and the various demographic selectors. You can compete on coverage of the market, availability of the service, quality and so on.

Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by rayiner on Thursday June 30, 2016 @08:03PM (#12012899)
He's not. Economic theory tells us that in a market with multiple competitors, collusion is inherently unstable: while in the short run companies may be able to keep it up, in the long run there is a strong incentive to break the collusive pact because whichever company does so will rapidly gain market share at the expense of the others.

Your argument to the contrary is based on piling speculation on top of speculation. Not only are we to assume--without evidence--that the carriers are colluding, we must also ignore what we know about T-Mobile's and Sprint's incentives to break the collusion and grab market share because they are, in fact, making tons of money but hiding it through clever accounting.

It's not that collusion isn't a possibility in cellular markets in the abstract. It's that it's highly unlikely in a market where one of the alleged colluders is bleeding money and customers and faces bankruptcy.

Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by jacquesm on Friday July 01, 2016 @12:43AM (#12013912)
You mean: 'without evidence that I'm willing to consider about these specific competitors in this particular market'. But you are willfully ignoring the evidence from all the other competitors in all the other markets doing exactly that.

In other words: you are establishing that the competition must be efficient in spite of the fact that the prices for data transfer in your neck of the woods happen to be the same as they are in areas where carriers have already been established to collude.

Now I'm really happy that that is the standard that you'd apply to find say a defendant guilty in some court of law, but this is not a court of law and circumstantial evidence is fine by me in the case of multinationals that refuse to open their books to the point where one could establish whether or not their margins are artificially inflated or arrived at in ways that are not kosher.

But, since you seem to be very much of the opinion that carriers are entities that deserve a lot of sympathy for their present day miserable situation (rather than that they offer vast amounts of money for spectrum and then overcharge consumers in order to make this money back) I hope you will decide to strike out for the underdog here and to offer your carrier an even larger premium than they are already extracting from you for the data that you use.

I find it interesting that you begin the whole discussion on a note of 'everybody will charge what they will' with Apple as the example (of clear graft) and end on the present one, the cognitive dissonance is so strong that I really wonder how carriers have managed to pull the wool so thoroughly over your eyes that you can't see what's going on. You have to commend them for managing this, it's a long time since the break-up of Bell in the US and all the ugliness that has come to light in countries all over the world but to see it so successfully papered over that they could essentially get away with it in broad daylight is interesting to me.

If there is one aspect of technology that is rotten to the core when it comes to extracting money for nothing from the populace it is telcos and the industry requires very careful monitoring and the occasional government intervention to stop them from their worst excesses. Any and all appearance to the contrary may safely be interpreted as successful marketing.

Note that since it requires a license to operate the market is far from efficient in the present and that in quite a few countries with so-called free markets when it comes to telecom the various governments still have a large chunk (if not an outright absolute majority) of stock in their former monopolist telcos. And that this is one reason why governments do not feel all that motivated to do something about this problem.

Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by harryh on Thursday June 30, 2016 @07:06PM (#12012566)
Sprint & T-Mobile both aggressively compete on price.
Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by nitrogen on Thursday June 30, 2016 @07:31PM (#12012705)
They may market based on price, but that doesn't mean that the prices are going down / bandwidth caps going up as fast as they should, or at all.
Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by tcoppi on Thursday June 30, 2016 @08:04PM (#12012902)
Yeah, and they actually aren't dropping all that much. T-Mobile's prices have gone up the past year or two for new single/two person accounts with the same amount of data. Family prices seem to have dropped slightly but not very much. Sprint's situation is similar.
Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by rayiner on Thursday June 30, 2016 @01:57PM (#12010422)
> And you're assuming that T-Mobile and Sprint are incapable of hiring accountants capable of minimizing their profits for tax reasons.

I'm assuming their accountants aren't any better than AT&T's and Verizon's, which show substantial profits from wireless.

> Let's turn this around: if the market is so thin why are they still pursuing it?

To get a bigger piece of a large market and hopefully profit in the future, just like 90% of the companies we talk about here on HN. But that's precisely why they have no incentive to collude to maintain the status quo.

Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by jacquesm on Thursday June 30, 2016 @02:01PM (#12010451)
You are aware of the fact that 'To get a bigger piece of a large market and hopefully profit in the future' means that they are actually choosing not to profit today but to reinvest their profits?

This is a common strategy in a growth market, such as mobile. And of course they have every incentive to collude because it would increase substantially those profits that they can then re-invest.

In other words, there is no downside to such collusion, and lack of profits in the present does not count as evidence given that in other markets such collusion has already been widely documented.

Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by revelation on Thursday June 30, 2016 @03:50PM (#12011157)
Chances are they are just terrible companies or you're falling victim the infinite leeway public companies have in presenting their financials, certainly in regards to their various "divisions". You're basically trying to argue "cheap information exchange is impossible" on the basis that USPS isn't turning a profit.
Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by revelation on Thursday June 30, 2016 @03:45PM (#12011131)
Not giving a fuck what you charge customers from country X with provider Y that you can't sell to anyway? So you charge whatever, and provider Y does the same vice versa? I mean come on, "government intervention in Europe" was the hint here. Europe is all about turning all the countries into one market.

In any case, the fact that we have the internet as the perfect roaming network that all mobile carriers actively exploit yet absurd roaming charges persist is proof of market failure. There need be no more explanation.

Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by acdha on Thursday June 30, 2016 @02:14PM (#12010538)
It's true that it has limits but does a monthly quota make any sense as a way to prevent that? Right now, you pay the same for a photo upload during a 4am backup window as you do for uploading the same photo during e.g. a ballgame where 10,000 other people are doing the same thing.

If you were trying to run a network, wouldn't you instead have things like differential pricing based on traffic priority or payment plans which allow you to pay more for a greater share of the available capacity? That would directly align the users’ interests with the network operators’ and would provide a strong incentive for things like backup software to make sure they send traffic with a low QoS level and back off when the network indicates congestion. Most people aren't going to care if their phone waits until they leave the stadium to upload their photos but that'd make a huge different for the network operator having to handle 50,000 people in a small area.