News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The rational exuberance of 5G by jacquesm on Friday July 01, 2016 @12:43AM (#12013912)
You mean: 'without evidence that I'm willing to consider about these specific competitors in this particular market'. But you are willfully ignoring the evidence from all the other competitors in all the other markets doing exactly that.

In other words: you are establishing that the competition must be efficient in spite of the fact that the prices for data transfer in your neck of the woods happen to be the same as they are in areas where carriers have already been established to collude.

Now I'm really happy that that is the standard that you'd apply to find say a defendant guilty in some court of law, but this is not a court of law and circumstantial evidence is fine by me in the case of multinationals that refuse to open their books to the point where one could establish whether or not their margins are artificially inflated or arrived at in ways that are not kosher.

But, since you seem to be very much of the opinion that carriers are entities that deserve a lot of sympathy for their present day miserable situation (rather than that they offer vast amounts of money for spectrum and then overcharge consumers in order to make this money back) I hope you will decide to strike out for the underdog here and to offer your carrier an even larger premium than they are already extracting from you for the data that you use.

I find it interesting that you begin the whole discussion on a note of 'everybody will charge what they will' with Apple as the example (of clear graft) and end on the present one, the cognitive dissonance is so strong that I really wonder how carriers have managed to pull the wool so thoroughly over your eyes that you can't see what's going on. You have to commend them for managing this, it's a long time since the break-up of Bell in the US and all the ugliness that has come to light in countries all over the world but to see it so successfully papered over that they could essentially get away with it in broad daylight is interesting to me.

If there is one aspect of technology that is rotten to the core when it comes to extracting money for nothing from the populace it is telcos and the industry requires very careful monitoring and the occasional government intervention to stop them from their worst excesses. Any and all appearance to the contrary may safely be interpreted as successful marketing.

Note that since it requires a license to operate the market is far from efficient in the present and that in quite a few countries with so-called free markets when it comes to telecom the various governments still have a large chunk (if not an outright absolute majority) of stock in their former monopolist telcos. And that this is one reason why governments do not feel all that motivated to do something about this problem.

There are no comments on this comment yet.