News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

Am I the only person to not understand how HN works?

I've just lost loads of Karma for posting in agreement with someone else rather than clicking on the little triangle.

:(

So, how does the little triangle work? It's not really explained totally in the help. I've never really clicked on it as I wasn't sure whether we had to.

Does clicking on links have any effect, too?

( 29 comments | 15 points | on HN )
Re:Am I the only person to not understand how HN works? by modoc on Wednesday March 17, 2010 @08:53AM (#1198421)
Don't worry about karma. Post replies that you think give something to the discussion. Many of your comments seem to be one-liners (but not funny ones) which I think is the issue. I don't see hardly any comments from you that teach me anything, make me understand your viewpoint, make me ponder your question, etc... Stuff like "sigh", "cheat", "please don't", etc.. don't really add to the thread. This isn't AIM or IRC so the bar of minimum usefulness is higher.
Re:Am I the only person to not understand how HN works? by philk on Wednesday March 17, 2010 @09:22AM (#1198467)
Three additional points:

1) Funny one liners have to be fucking hilarious to be voted up. Best to avoid attempts at humor altogether when it comes to HN.

2) If you're going to post something, remember to make it concise. Just like in the real world, tight and digestible comments get better play than huge walls of text.

3) Ignore karma in general. People will often vote you up or down for stupid reasons so if you're going against the prevailing opinion you'll get a much lower score than anything people agree with [1]. Also time spent worrying about karma is time you could spend worrying about things that actually matter in your life.

[1] This isn't unique to HN, people naturally think more favorably about people who agree with them.

Re:Am I the only person to not understand how HN works? by brk on Wednesday March 17, 2010 @08:44AM (#1198402)
Here's the quick summary:

Don't post in agreement with someone, click the up arrow to vote the comment you agree with up.

Don't try to be funny/witty in your comments unless you're REALLY good at at and/or can make a particularly insightful joke. If your comment even remotely looks like a rehashed Internet meme you'll probably get knocked down to -4 within the hour.

Try to add something of value to a conversation. It doesn't have to be a post filled with academia and algorithms, but it should in general be something that has a value at least slightly above the time someone will spend reading your post.

Re:Am I the only person to not understand how HN works? by 3pt14159 on Wednesday March 17, 2010 @09:06AM (#1198440)
Look dude, no offense at all, but I'd wager your still in high school, maybe younger, or fairly new to online communities. The thing about Hacker News is that people here are very blunt about who they vote down or vote up. Most people here have been on the internet for a very long time and don't want to be bothered by "me too" posts. If you are interested in tech and want to be a part of Hacker News the most important thing to do is read other peoples comments for a long time before trying to get in on the discussion. For example, I waited 200 days until submitting something to Hacker News.

Lastly, if you get blasted or down voted don't take it too personally. You're going to forget about it within a couple of days, so why stress so hard now?

Re:Am I the only person to not understand how HN works? by markkanof on Wednesday March 17, 2010 @09:11AM (#1198446)
Most people that visit a site called hacker news probably like to understand the inner workings of things. Your comment seems a bit dismissive of someone just trying to figure out how the site works instead of viewing it as a mystical black box.
Re:Am I the only person to not understand how HN works? by mixmax on Wednesday March 17, 2010 @08:38AM (#1198394)
This is interesting, and there's a lesson to be learned. Your profile shows that you've been a member for 352 days, and yet you don't quite understand the karma system. You've also spent some time trying to figure out how it works, but haven't succeeded.

Most people take the karma system for granted, and think it's simple. But if you haven't encountered it before it clearly isn't as your post shows. Many people come here from Reddit and thus have an implicit understanding of the arrows and the karma system. But if this is your first experience using such a system how are you to know?

Founders should look at their own software with this post in mind - things may seem simple once you understand how they work, but do your customers really understand your product? If they aren't you are probably missing some big opportunities.

Re:Am I the only person to not understand how HN works? by tokenadult on Wednesday March 17, 2010 @08:21AM (#1198364)
Examples of recent highly rated comments:

http://news.ycombinator.com/bestcomments

Re:Am I the only person to not understand how HN works? by sambeau on Wednesday March 17, 2010 @08:22AM (#1198369)
thanks.
Re:Am I the only person to not understand how HN works? by andrewcooke on Wednesday March 17, 2010 @08:38AM (#1198397)
karma at hn is broken. ignore it.

some quick example, taken these from my own history just because that's what i know (but you can see examples everywhere):

- voted down for no reason (it was a useful, informed comment) and no explanation - http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1190927

- receiving no votes despite being (closest to) the correct answer; a nerdgasm of technically correct but irrelevant info gets 9 votes - http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1194538

voting helps introduce "real world" social pressure into an online community, but here the feedback loop is way too strong. the result is an echo chamber, because people like affirmation, and because it's easier to vote on whether items "state the group consensus" rather than actual useful content.

things might be fixed by not displaying karma, or not displaying vote counts, or making voting "cost" karma, or similar, but the people who run the site don't have the time or inclination to experiment.

in short, as i said, the best thing to do is ignore karma.

Re:Am I the only person to not understand how HN works? by philk on Wednesday March 17, 2010 @09:50AM (#1198526)
For the first post, about Chavez, I suspect that it was downvoted because it wasn't negative enough about him. People will often downvote a comment they disagree with regardless of its merits.

(Although on the plus side it's already received a couple of upvotes since you posted this link.)

The second one I'm not really sure. I think the reply to yours got a boatload of votes because it speaks to the consensus here at HN.

Re:Am I the only person to not understand how HN works? by wallflower on Wednesday March 17, 2010 @09:35AM (#1198494)
I post frequently. Sometimes something gets 20 upvotes. Sometimes something gets no upvotes. Regardless of whether I was expecting upvotes, when I do get upvoted (especially for a submission), I like to know that I've been able to share with someone out there in our pseudo-anonymous distributed clan something that I personally find interesting - whether a story or opinion or simply a link.

Discovery and mini-recognition for sharing.

I can't remember how many times I've had a boring day and writing a comment or posting a favorite link has helped upvote my mood. Yes, HN is addictive but it is a community. Real people. Real opinions. Tons of wicked smart people and Renaissance men and women.

I lurked for a long time before even registering.

Re:Am I the only person to not understand how HN works? by messel on Wednesday March 17, 2010 @08:26AM (#1198378)
We learn through experience and reading docs. Many doc readers will shout RTFM, but I'm primarily an experience learner, if the software/language isn't something I can get my head around without pouring over heavy doc files, unless I need it, I skip it. The best tools are obvious or self explanatory.

The doc files and books will be waiting for me when I'm getting into nontrivial features.

HN's points are like Who's Line is it Anyway. They really don't matter outside. If your Nick name becomes recognized it can have an impact.

Re:Am I the only person to not understand how HN works? by ErrantX on Wednesday March 17, 2010 @09:38AM (#1198502)
Guys, I hang around a few forums where posters tend to be young or inexperienced in the internet arts. HN can be even more arcane than those places.

Generally you get a better response by being nice in threads like this - karma bombing the guys responses isn't going to help much. A 0 seems fair for some of the comments; but -4 (which some of the comments are oscillating to) feels a little OTT.

Maybe dial it off a bit; and hopefully sambeau will start to figure things out and in time we'll have another solid member :)

Re:Am I the only person to not understand how HN works? by swombat on Wednesday March 17, 2010 @10:08AM (#1198563)
You think -4 is harsh? Man, it used to be unlimited...

I can remember a few situations when someone posted something particularly controversial, got mobbed, and ended up with -100 or worse.

Re:Am I the only person to not understand how HN works? by duck on Wednesday March 17, 2010 @08:15AM (#1198359)
Lost loads of Karma? It looks like you lost -4 recently...

http://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=sambeau

Re:Am I the only person to not understand how HN works? by sambeau on Wednesday March 17, 2010 @08:21AM (#1198366)
Yeah - it was for saying ^^^ what he said instead of clicking on the arrow :)

Such is life. It's not real - but it hurts a little as this is my main source of internet.

Re:Am I the only person to not understand how HN works? by DanielStraight on Wednesday March 17, 2010 @08:06AM (#1198349)
Karma is based on people voting on your comments. Nothing else.

The arrows (up and down) are to vote. If you don't have a down arrow, it because you don't have enough karma.

Re:Am I the only person to not understand how HN works? by X-Istence on Wednesday March 17, 2010 @10:22AM (#1198594)
How much karma is required for one to get the downvote buttons?

Also, in the past there have been times that I have accidentally clicked the upvote button in an attempt to re-activate my browser window, and found that there was no way for me to undo that, whereas on reddit if I hit the upvote button again it cancels out!

Re:Am I the only person to not understand how HN works? by sambeau on Wednesday March 17, 2010 @08:21AM (#1198368)
Ah. Ok. Makes sense I guess.
Re:Am I the only person to not understand how HN works? by plinkplonk on Wednesday March 17, 2010 @08:51AM (#1198415)
you are still doing it. Avoid these "Ah ok " type replies. This isn't chat.
Re:Am I the only person to not understand how HN works? by pvg on Wednesday March 17, 2010 @09:30AM (#1198481)
Good to remember it's also not 'vindictive pile-on'. The people continuing to downvote the user in this thread when he's obviously confused and asking for help are, frankly, douchebags.
Re:Am I the only person to not understand how HN works? by ErrantX on Wednesday March 17, 2010 @09:35AM (#1198495)
I agree with most of what you say; but, generally, statements like:

[people] are, frankly, douchebags

Are also discouraged :)

Re:Am I the only person to not understand how HN works? by pvg on Wednesday March 17, 2010 @09:52AM (#1198530)
Oh and I, generally, know. Bit of a non-general case here, though, so I figured spending a few karma points on calling some douchebags douchebags is worth a brief deviation from the How to disagree catechesis.
Re:Am I the only person to not understand how HN works? by ErrantX on Wednesday March 17, 2010 @09:56AM (#1198544)
Considering this thread is essentially asking the best way to behave on HN leading by example seems a sensible response :)

But fair enough.

Re:Am I the only person to not understand how HN works? by sailormoon on Wednesday March 17, 2010 @09:58AM (#1198546)
Could cost you more than a few points. An old account of mine was banned for calling another HN user a douchebag. Careful now.
Re:Am I the only person to not understand how HN works? by oozcitak on Wednesday March 17, 2010 @09:16AM (#1198455)
I like thinking of the voting arrows as a volume knob. If I like someone's comment, I turn up the volume a bit.

For me, voting doesn't have to do with agreeing with the poster. I tend to upvote comments if I believe they add some value to the parent topic, give me some insight, or teach me something new...

Re:Am I the only person to not understand how HN works? by adharmad on Wednesday March 17, 2010 @11:18AM (#1198735)
An interesting analogy. It would be nice, however, if the volume knob applied to the user and not to a specific comment. Say the user starts with a karma of 500, based on his comments, I can either turn his volume down to zero or up to 1000. (His volume for me that is).

It works similarly in a real conversation, wherein folks will automatically tune out someone (based on their preferences) after a while.

This has the downside of ignoring potentially interesting comments by someone having bad karma. But then again that's why its a reputation system - you make/break a reputation over a period of time.

Re:Am I the only person to not understand how HN works? by nevinera on Wednesday March 17, 2010 @11:23AM (#1198742)
The comments system here at HN reads more like a tree of information - these 'threads' are not conversations. It's the densest presentation of actual information and thought I've seen anywhere, and long-time posters are rather devoted to keeping it that way.

The long-and-short is that you shouldn't post a reply unless it contains new information that requires the context of the comment you're replying to. (New information that stands on its own probably should be a top-level comment.)

Re:Am I the only person to not understand how HN works? by pdebruic on Wednesday March 17, 2010 @10:41AM (#1198640)
Also, unless your name is Sam Beau you should change your handle.

Sounds like: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sambo_%28racial_term%29