News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Am I the only person to not understand how HN works? by andrewcooke on Wednesday March 17, 2010 @08:38AM (#1198397)
karma at hn is broken. ignore it.

some quick example, taken these from my own history just because that's what i know (but you can see examples everywhere):

- voted down for no reason (it was a useful, informed comment) and no explanation - http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1190927

- receiving no votes despite being (closest to) the correct answer; a nerdgasm of technically correct but irrelevant info gets 9 votes - http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1194538

voting helps introduce "real world" social pressure into an online community, but here the feedback loop is way too strong. the result is an echo chamber, because people like affirmation, and because it's easier to vote on whether items "state the group consensus" rather than actual useful content.

things might be fixed by not displaying karma, or not displaying vote counts, or making voting "cost" karma, or similar, but the people who run the site don't have the time or inclination to experiment.

in short, as i said, the best thing to do is ignore karma.

Re:Am I the only person to not understand how HN works? by philk on Wednesday March 17, 2010 @09:50AM (#1198526)
For the first post, about Chavez, I suspect that it was downvoted because it wasn't negative enough about him. People will often downvote a comment they disagree with regardless of its merits.

(Although on the plus side it's already received a couple of upvotes since you posted this link.)

The second one I'm not really sure. I think the reply to yours got a boatload of votes because it speaks to the consensus here at HN.