News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Racist hosts, not hotels, are the greatest threat to Airb... by herbst on Thursday June 23, 2016 @09:46AM (#11960771)
I dont see how this is related to AirBnB. They may are a good case to study this phenomen but in reality it is the society that creates this fears.

Ironically it isnt to far off ether. Where i live the majority of black youth have a bigger criminal history than their white peers. Sure this again fully depends on how the society treats them.

Re:Racist hosts, not hotels, are the greatest threat to Airb... by hyperbovine on Thursday June 23, 2016 @10:00AM (#11960865)
Discrimination at hotels and other public accommodations is unequivocally illegal in the US.
Re:Racist hosts, not hotels, are the greatest threat to Airb... by jasode on Thursday June 23, 2016 @10:17AM (#11961003)
Those discrimination laws don't apply to hosts' private homes or bedrooms.[1] Paraphrase of law: "All persons shall be entitled ..., and accommodations of any place of public accommodation,..., without discrimination ... other than ... a building which contains not more than five rooms for rent ... which is actually occupied by the proprietor ... as his residence"

If a homeowner has a spare bedroom across the hall from her 13-year-old son's room, and doesn't want to rent to transgender, black, or 65-year-old guests, it is legal for her to discriminate on those attributes.

On the other hand, if the AirBnb host is renting out a non-owner-occupied beach house, the discrimination laws would apply.

[1]https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/42/2000a:

Re:Racist hosts, not hotels, are the greatest threat to Airb... by return0 on Thursday June 23, 2016 @10:41AM (#11961213)
> Those discrimination laws don't apply to hosts' private homes or bedrooms

Well, they should, and if airbnb is not willing to comply, the lawmaker should force them to.

Re:Racist hosts, not hotels, are the greatest threat to Airb... by jasode on Thursday June 23, 2016 @11:16AM (#11961597)
>Well, they should, and if airbnb is not willing to comply,

You seem to be confused. The cite I provided (42 U.S. Code § 2000a) is the actual anti-discrimination law and the law's text is explicitly written to exclude residences such as personal homes. You can't make AirBnB "comply" with a law that doesn't exist for homeowners and their spare bedrooms.

Re:Racist hosts, not hotels, are the greatest threat to Airb... by return0 on Thursday June 23, 2016 @11:35AM (#11961795)
I apologize, what you say is correct. I wonder if airbnb should make it clear to people that they can be discriminated in most of their properties.

That law screams for reform, however.

Re:Racist hosts, not hotels, are the greatest threat to Airb... by Cshelton on Thursday June 23, 2016 @10:46AM (#11961261)
Here in America, we have the 4th Amendment. Don't like it? Leave.

Airbnb is not responsible for this, nor is doing anything wrong. If I do not want somebody in my private home, they will not step a foot in my private home. In fact, if they do, I have the right to take defensive action, including the use of lethal force when necessary. Don't like it? Leave.

Re:Racist hosts, not hotels, are the greatest threat to Airb... by dang on Friday June 24, 2016 @02:00AM (#11967016)
> Don't like it? Leave.

Please don't use flamewar tropes on HN.

Re:Racist hosts, not hotels, are the greatest threat to Airb... by chris11 on Thursday June 23, 2016 @02:41PM (#11963394)
But the problem is Airbnb is blurring the line between personal and business use of the home. You shouldn't able to claim all the the legal benefits of a non-commercial/personal property if you are using it for a business. I'd think it would be reasonable if some anti-discrimination laws for businesses were changed or viewed as applying to Airbnb hosts. You don't need to advertise your personal home on Airbnb.
Re:Racist hosts, not hotels, are the greatest threat to Airb... by panzagl on Thursday June 23, 2016 @10:50AM (#11961300)
Don't know why parent is being downvoted- when you offer a room to the public it is no longer your private home or bedroom.
Re:Racist hosts, not hotels, are the greatest threat to Airb... by Cshelton on Thursday June 23, 2016 @10:55AM (#11961374)
Your private residence is always your private residence. That never changes. And Airbnb is not a public offering. It is on an offer-acceptance basis. Basic contract law. I can reject a contract for any reason I please and there is not a thing you can do about it.
Re:Racist hosts, not hotels, are the greatest threat to Airb... by scarface74 on Thursday June 23, 2016 @11:15AM (#11961589)
Well "basic law" in many jurisdictions make it illegal to rent your home out for less than x number of days. So if they want to scream what is legal in one case then why not the other case? I wouldn't want anyone to be running what basically is a hotel right next to me.
Re:Racist hosts, not hotels, are the greatest threat to Airb... by panzagl on Thursday June 23, 2016 @11:19AM (#11961632)
The article describes a whole home rented out, not occupied by the owner, unclear whether it's a private residence.
Re:Racist hosts, not hotels, are the greatest threat to Airb... by timv on Thursday June 23, 2016 @07:10PM (#11964986)
The rejection of the trangender guest was, seemingly, a room in the host's house (she mentions her son being across the hall).
Re:Racist hosts, not hotels, are the greatest threat to Airb... by gohrt on Thursday June 23, 2016 @02:55PM (#11963513)
This is true, and is shameful shortcoming in the law, a throwback to a less enlightened time, when racism was still a core value in a large segment of American society.

http://harvardcrcl.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/07/Reaching-M...

Re:Racist hosts, not hotels, are the greatest threat to Airb... by herbst on Thursday June 23, 2016 @10:04AM (#11960894)
A hotel is something different than a private home. Alone the insurance makes this a whole different situation.
Re:Racist hosts, not hotels, are the greatest threat to Airb... by Cthulhu_ on Thursday June 23, 2016 @10:00AM (#11960869)
The part about a host not allowing a trans person isn't related to AirBnB either, it's one host's choice and there's nothing wrong with rejecting a renter for any reason. I've slept in hostels, they discriminate on age (nobody over 35 was allowed). There's probably plenty of hosts that won't accept men, or couples, or underage people, or people of a different faith.
Re:Racist hosts, not hotels, are the greatest threat to Airb... by herbst on Thursday June 23, 2016 @10:06AM (#11960913)
That was the worst about the article anyway, its a mum with a 13yo boy in puperty, it should be understandable that she does not want "special situations" IN HER HOME. That is nobodies business.
Re:Racist hosts, not hotels, are the greatest threat to Airb... by duiker101 on Thursday June 23, 2016 @10:03AM (#11960889)
Off topic but, do you know why no one over 35 would not be allowed? Just because it was a youth hostel?
Re:Racist hosts, not hotels, are the greatest threat to Airb... by Kinnard on Thursday June 23, 2016 @09:52AM (#11960810)
Yes, AirBnB exists in a country with an entrenched legacy of discrimination. What they do about that on their platform is what matters here.
Re:Racist hosts, not hotels, are the greatest threat to Airb... by herbst on Thursday June 23, 2016 @10:00AM (#11960868)
Thats my point, what should they do? They created a community run platform, everything they would do now would just make the users angry. Also seriously, what should they do? They cant forbid people to decline users, nobody would use such a platform.
Re:Racist hosts, not hotels, are the greatest threat to Airb... by gohrt on Thursday June 23, 2016 @02:59PM (#11963547)
> They cant forbid people to decline users, nobody would use such a platform.

That's absurd. The USA is full of business running on platforms that are forbidden to discriminate against protected classes.

Re:Racist hosts, not hotels, are the greatest threat to Airb... by drivingmenuts on Thursday June 23, 2016 @10:13AM (#11960963)
What can they do about it, though? AirBnB doesn't own the property being rented. If it did, an anti-discrimination policy would be easier to enforce. AirBnB is essentially a jazzed-up listing service, not an actual hotelier, that is gouging out a buck while revealing the worst of our society.
Re:Racist hosts, not hotels, are the greatest threat to Airb... by return0 on Thursday June 23, 2016 @09:53AM (#11960820)
Airbnb cant fix society, but they can easily enforce non-discrimination on their hosts.
Re:Racist hosts, not hotels, are the greatest threat to Airb... by MichaelGG on Thursday June 23, 2016 @09:59AM (#11960856)
They could try, if they want to sink their business. Telling people they no longer control who stays in their home does not seem like a smart move -- at least for actual home-sharers, not illegal hotel operators. And AirBnB doesn't want to really recognize the hotel operators, do they?
Re:Racist hosts, not hotels, are the greatest threat to Airb... by return0 on Thursday June 23, 2016 @10:42AM (#11961225)
I doubt they would sink their business. Airbnb is no longer a startup that is given free licence to go against established laws. Compliance at this stage will benefit their business.
Re:Racist hosts, not hotels, are the greatest threat to Airb... by MichaelGG on Thursday June 23, 2016 @11:09AM (#11961519)
AirBnB isn't discriminating. Private home owners are choosing to share their homes. For anti discrimination laws to apply, AirBnB would have to admit that many of their "sharing" people are just illicit hotels skirting the law.
Re:Racist hosts, not hotels, are the greatest threat to Airb... by timv on Thursday June 23, 2016 @11:06AM (#11961496)
Does that extend to requiring that single females be willing to rent out their sofa to males?

And if you expect that of AirBnB do you expect the same for private apartment sharing arrangements?

Single [ethnicity undisclosed] [gender undisclosed] seeks whoever the law says I have to live with?

Re:Racist hosts, not hotels, are the greatest threat to Airb... by duiker101 on Thursday June 23, 2016 @10:02AM (#11960881)
I agree with you as a normal person, but let's put it in the perspective of the company. That is a move that might hurt them without bringing any (monetary) benefit, strict rules like that might mean that instead the user might try other services or avoid renting out completely. While I do not condone the discrimination I can understand that some people might still want to be able to chose who gets in their house and putting rules around that might scare away a lot of people. I do not think this is a problem of AirBnB and I do not think that they will implement rules, what they might do is try to teach more the benefits of cultural diversity.
Re:Racist hosts, not hotels, are the greatest threat to Airb... by caseysoftware on Thursday June 23, 2016 @10:05AM (#11960906)
I think the bigger problem is enforcement. If someone says "I'm not accepting your request because you're X" that's easy to detect and punish.

But if it's more subtle and no explicit reason, it's going to be way harder to detect and adds a lot of judgement calls to the mix.. which puts it up the whims of whoever is doing support at that moment.

I wrote on this last year on how it could be totally transparent and devastating as a result: http://caseysoftware.com/blog/social-apis-for-social-evil

Re:Racist hosts, not hotels, are the greatest threat to Airb... by dublinben on Thursday June 23, 2016 @09:58AM (#11960853)
>they can easily enforce non-discrimination on their hosts

From reading this article, it sounds like they actually can't. Ultimately, they have to be willing to banish hosts who discriminate, which diminishes their platform.

Re:Racist hosts, not hotels, are the greatest threat to Airb... by herbst on Thursday June 23, 2016 @09:59AM (#11960859)
But how and why? Will you seriously take people away the choice who they want to host? How will you enforce this? Someone who declines blacks 5 times gets banned?
Re:Racist hosts, not hotels, are the greatest threat to Airb... by return0 on Thursday June 23, 2016 @10:06AM (#11960909)
Then why have any anti-discrimination laws at all?

Very easy to enforce: if airbnb investigates and finds you discriminate, you are out of the platform.

Re:Racist hosts, not hotels, are the greatest threat to Airb... by herbst on Thursday June 23, 2016 @10:09AM (#11960931)
Against discrimination i assume. But not against people who dont want to share their privates with others because of prejudices. Honestly i cant see this as discrimination, thats real issues our society faces, but its more stupidity and fear based on shitty media than anything else, especially discrimination.
Re:Racist hosts, not hotels, are the greatest threat to Airb... by return0 on Thursday June 23, 2016 @10:40AM (#11961205)
They are selling their homes, not sharing them. I don't really understand how this is different from that gay wedding cake case AT ALL.
Re:Racist hosts, not hotels, are the greatest threat to Airb... by herbst on Thursday June 23, 2016 @10:49AM (#11961289)
I dont think we have the same understanding of the word "selling".

And even if i am wrong, there is still a huge difference between private selling and commercial selling.

Re:Racist hosts, not hotels, are the greatest threat to Airb... by return0 on Thursday June 23, 2016 @10:58AM (#11961410)
Apparently the american law doesn't require nondiscrimination at what is listed in most airbnb listings as pointed out elsewhere [not the case elsewhere]. Ergo, airbnb cannot stop hosts from discriminating in most US listings. Therefore, they should have never claim that they are against discrimination. Otherwise, they would have to prove it with actions.
Re:Racist hosts, not hotels, are the greatest threat to Airb... by chris11 on Thursday June 23, 2016 @02:56PM (#11963515)
I do see some difference. I might agree that there should be a difference between a person who owns a property primarily for their own use and rents on Airbnb and someone who owns a property primarily for renting on Airbnb. One is more commercial, and one is more personal.

But Airbnb hosts seem to be taking advantage of legal grey areas. Airbnb is directly competing with the hotel industry, but they are claiming those industry regulations don't apply to them. I'm not saying that they are necessarily doing anything illegal or definitely acting unethically. But I do think that they are operating in some legal grey areas, so it's not overreaching to try to increase or change how regulations apply to them.