Statistical mechanical entropy and information theoretical entropy ('complexity in bits') are not the same quantities! But even if they were, your expression would still be incorrect because living system are definitionally not at equilibrium - so equilibrium statistical mechanics (whose predictions you are using to get that expression) does not apply.
No one is surprised when convection rolls spontaneously form as they boil a pot of water. But equilibrium statistical mechanics predicts that this should be extremely unlikely as convection roll states have very low entropy. That is, of all of the ways that the molecules in that pot of water could be oriented, vanishingly few of them correspond to convection roll states, where several Avogrado's numbers worth of particles conspire to all swirl around in a coordinated fashion to dissipate the heat of the burner faster than would occur just by diffusion.
The origin of life is very much analogous to the formation of convection rolls in the pot. And I believe is far more common than classical predictions imagine it to be - nearly everywhere there is an energy gradient in the universe, you will probably find life.
Citation: I have a degree in physics
This assertion (whether thermodynamic entropy and information theoretic entropy are equivalent) is an ongoing controversy open to debate - it shouldn't be stated as fact. See wikipedia for (a summary of) both sides of the story: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Entropy_in_thermodynamics_and_... (specifically the #Theoretical_relationship and #Criticism sections)
As an analogy, if I make a huge number of random files on my computer and execute them, the probability of getting a self replicating computer virus is really low. And one that successfully spreads itself to other computers over the internet should never happen.
If the first successful computer virus is 100 bits long, then probability of finding it in a single random search is 1/2^100. Which is just incredibly small and should never ever happen.
There could be 10 different ways to make a virus N bits long. There could be 1000 ways to do it in N+1 bits, and a billion ways in N+2.
The relationship between how many possible successful viruses exist to number of bits doesn't have to scale by any obvious pattern.
There could be a magic threshold where if you're shorter than that you don't work.
For ex, maybe a valid file has to be at least 100 bytes, or the OS can't treat it as a file. Any random file 100bytes or longer could have a 10% chance of being a virus (the actual number depends on how the os works).
This would mean a really high chance of randomness creating a virus, even though N is 100.
The probability of vitality depends on the specifics of the operating system, and we can't infer it by looking at the size of the smallest possible virus.
There is a reasonable theory that I remember discussing/reading once that proteins may have started out as long sequences and were then selected for shorter more stable versions. Presumably the early proteins were partly disordered, and only optimised for having stable cores and domain structures later on.
In any case, it is not as simple as the number of bits in a program, as macromolecules are not 'just' software, but actual physical devices that have to (self)-assemble and carry out functions at various temperatures, pressures, pH, etc.
Saying that "the odds of abiogenesis are ~1/2^n" isn't an assertion of fact, it's merely defining n = -log2(probability of abiogenesis). (Of course, the probability of abiogenesis occurring in any particular body of water is not a constant, it depends on conditions; but all the oceans on Earth are only 80 binary orders of magnitude bigger than a single mL [1], so n for a lab experiment and n for the entire Earth can't be more than a couple decimal orders of magnitude different, so it's immaterial.)
In other words, your argument about convection rolls is an excellent argument that the n for abiogenesis is much, much lower than -log2(probability of organic molecules in solution spontaneously assembling themselves into bacteria), which grandparent claimed is ~1 million. I have no reason to believe ~1 million is accurate, but I don't care, because grandparent has convinced me that the upper bound is many orders of magnitude greater than 73. Your argument that n could be much less than that upper bound is convincing, but unless you're arguing it's so much lower that it isn't much greater than 73, grandparent's counter to the paper still holds.
[1]: http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=log2((volume+of+ocean+i...)
Of course it can be easy to over-do the analogies between things like convection rolls and the emergence of lipid bilayers (or whatever). However, the origin of life necessarily came about through purely physical processes and only once that bootstrap phase was over did evolution come into play as biological systems took over acting upon themselves.
As I understand it the idea is that a closed system that is driven far from equilibrium by a constant influx of energy can undergo 'symmetry breaking' where the symmetries of the system are changed. So the symmetric situation of the boiling pot is broken such that convection rolls are formed - which is new structure.
Similarly, a uniform soup of primitive chemical compounds could have been broken into less-uniform patches by some energy gradient (black or white smokers, for example). This diversity of chemical conditions then helped to form the initial replicators that could then further exploit various temperature, chemical, or proton gradients to create primitive life.
It took modern astrophysics to determine the origin of the chemical elements. We observe stars (and) we know what goes on in their center. They explode, laying bare their contents. And what we have discovered is that the elements of the periodic table -that which we are made of- derive from the actions of stars that have manufactured the elements, exploded (and) scattered their rich guts across the galaxy, contaminating or enriching gas clouds that then form a next generation of stars populated by planets and possibly life.
And so, when you look at the ingredients of the universe, the number one ingredient is hydrogen, next is helium, next is carbon- sorry- hydrogen, helium, oxygen, carbon, nitrogen. Those are the top ingredients in the universe. And you say well, okay, that’s kind of cool. Well, and you look at Earth- cause we like thinking of ourselves as special- we say Oh! we’re special! What are we made of?
Well what’s the number one molecule in the body? It’s water. But what’s water made of? H-2-O. Hydrogen and oxygen. Hm. Hydrogen and oxygen. In fact, if you rank the elements in the human body, with the exception of helium, which is chemically inert- useless to you for any reason other than just to inhale it and sound like Mickey Mouse. You can’t die from helium unless that’s all you breathe. So, number one in the human body is hydrogen. Matches the universe. Number two? Is oxygen. Matches the universe. Number 3? Carbon. Matches the universe. Number 4? Nitrogen. Matches the universe. And for each of us the fifth element- other- is the same in both places. Ok? Other.
So, we learned in the last 50 years that, of course, not only do we exist in this universe. It is the universe itself that exists within us. And had we been made of some rare isotope of bismuth, you’d argue and say hey, we’re something special.
From https://tiainkorea.wordpress.com/2012/04/22/a-fascinatingly-...
Also, this is the most interesting explanation to the Fermi paradox that I've seen: http://accelerating.org/articles/transcensionhypothesis.html
Most common elements in the human body [2]: Hydrogen, Oxygen, Carbon, Nitrogen
I agree that we can skip helium and neon since those are noble gases, but I do find the lack of iron interesting.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abundance_of_the_chemical_elem...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Composition_of_the_human_body#... (look for table, sort per atomic percent)
However, iron does play an important role in life as we know it, even today. Earth's molten and rotating iron and nickle core is what creates our magnetosphere that shields us--and presumably early life--from deadly solar radiation.
I would have thought the iron in mammal blood would come to mind first, but other aquatic life forms have copper-based blood, so it's not exactly required.
I think what will really help us to get at a better estimate
is to answer the question whether there exists life in our
solar system that evolved independently of that on Earth.
That's definitely the big question. But you left out the elephant in the room: is there life right here on Earth that's evolved independently? Abiogenesis doesn't simply halt after it's achieved its "goal". Perhaps we take the common-origin hypothesis for granted (that the "tree of life" has one root, and is in fact a tree), but it's actually nontrivial, strong evidence about the rate of abiogenesis, right under our noses. If it's true.There's no hard reason why another, orthogonal family of life couldn't coexist with DNA/RNA life. We have 10^7 extant species of DNA/RNA life; that's an existence proof that hostile, competing "types" of life can coexist. Suppose we found terrestrial "XNA life" with a biochemistry totally unrelated to anything else, with no possible common origin or lateral gene transfer. Then we would know life on Earth developed independently N >= 2 times, instead of N >= 1. That would change a lot; we could update P(life | Earth-like planet) from the subjective probability range [10^-Graham's number, 1) to something more like [10^-4, 1).
What's really surprising is that this is completely untested! We genuinely don't know if there's "alien" life on Earth, because we don't know how to look for it. There's no black-box tool to approach unknown biochemistry:
Some have postulated the existence of a 'shadow biosphere'
on Earth, teeming with life that has gone undiscovered
because scientists simply don't know where to look. It could
contain life that relies on a fundamentally different
biochemistry, using different forms of amino acids or even
entirely novel ways of storing, replicating and executing
inherited information that do not rely on DNA or
proteins. [...] The trick is deciding what to look for and
how to detect it. The usual way that researchers search for
new organisms — by sequencing DNA or RNA — will not pick up
life that does not depend on them.
http://www.nature.com/news/life-changing-experiments-the-bio... ...We could even be oblivious to unfamiliar forms of life
right under our noses...
http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2015/02/shadow-biosphere-migh...v2.0 life would have to evolve in the changed environment - which would be considerably less hospitable, because the most useful chemical processes and energy sources will be colonised by v1.0 life.
v1.0 life will (more or less literally) get the low hanging fruit. v2.0 would have to evolve around the edges, which means the probability gradient is higher and therefore less likely.
So although it's a very valid point I'm not sure if it's a sufficient argument against the hypothesis of having two independently evolved and fundamentally different types of life on a given planet.
The only way to die if a UV ray split you, or you fall into a volcano (there are no fire, because the atmosphere has very few oxygen), or a nasty oxygen molecule reacts with you, or ...
Well, there are many ways to die, but they are not targeting you, so perhaps you can hide from the sun under a rock. Or to be more clear, since you doesn't have any kind of senses or mobility, perhaps you are lucky and get beached under a rock. Perhaps the rock also makes a nice place to concentrate other molecules during the low tide.
Perhaps it's not a good idea to be near the surface and it's better to be lucky and get near a underwater sea vent with tasty hydrogen. I think the details of the first steps are not clear for anyone (in particular for me).
Once a stupid life for appears, the first thing it would do is eat all the free food. In particular, before the first life form the half of the amino acid were L and half D. We have used all the L amino acids (and created many more than the original supply), and we have also eaten all the original D amino acids. So there are very few of them floating around freely, it would be very hard to start an alternative D-tree.
A new life form will be targeted by the existing life form, like the free D amino acids. The competition will be extremely hard. So I think it's a winner take all task.
Moreover, then some moron decides to release a lot of oxygen to the atmosphere. Oxygen is extremely toxic for most life forms, and more toxic for isolated molecules that are barely alive ...
About the shadow biosphere: Perhaps we (humans) can't detect or identify them, but the bacteria and archaea can probably live there and eat them barely-alive. Our cousins can keep all the out-of-tree competition at bay.
If you are the first almost live form, you have plenty of
time, and can evolved in an environment that has plenty of
food. Something like the brown goo of Titan, with lots of
hydrocarbons and other small molecules that you can pick up
for free.
But there's no food on Titan anywhere! There's no oxidizers for hydrocarbons to react with; hence no accessible chemical energy.That's likely generic for pre-biotic environments. Planets don't naturally form redox gradients; if there's a large redox potential, that's reactive chemistry, which will react away to equilibrium over geologic time. It takes work to maintain such a gradient; for example, Earth's oxidizing atmosphere is actively maintained by life. Oxygen is geologically removed from atmospheres, reacting with exposed rock surfaces (oxygen weathering). It takes active expenditure of work (solar energy) to keep it existing.
There is some chemical energy in abiotic planets, but only small amounts, at very low power levels compared to Earth's aerobic biosphere (which eats something like 10^14 watts!). There's photochemistry caused by solar UV light, and there's atmospheric lightning (which is a major player in the Earth's N2 cycle). Most important is geochemical energy; i.e. primordial chemical gradients that aren't yet at equilibrium, because the two reactants are physically separated by rock layers. On Europa for example, a very slow process brings rocks into contact with the ocean, where slow serpentinization reactions can occur: oxidation of Fe++ to Fe+++ by water, with the production of H2. This would be the food source of Europa life, if it's there.
I'm not sure if this is for or against your comment, but I hope you find this interesting:
"A cave in Romania that was sealed for 5.5M years" http://www.bbc.com/earth/story/20150904-the-bizarre-beasts-l... HN discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11682816 (889 points, 38 days ago, 163 comments)
This would be good stuff for a science fiction story as well.
If the odds of abiogenesis are 1/2^128, and if that is the source of life, then we're the only life in the Universe. As the article indicates, there are only 2^73 stars.
Quote Martin Amis's The Information:
“The history of astronomy is the history of increasing humiliation. First the geocentric universe, then the heliocentric universe. Then the eccentric universe – the one we’re living in. Every century we get smaller. Kant figured it all out, sitting in his armchair. What’s the phrase? The principle of terrestrial mediocrity.”
And the author even asserts it's "irrational" to think real-world probabilities are this small!
It's easy to construct "unreasonably" small probabilities: take a few small ones and multiply them. If you path-sum all the evolutionary state transitions summing to P(intelligent life|planet), is it a shallow graph with many alternatives (additive probabilities), or a deep graph dominated by long, conjunctive sequences (probabilities multiply)?
Nevertheless the progress on the other factors in the Drake equation is very interesting and impressive.
I disagree with this.
It seems that, from what happened to other planets on the solar system, that nothing happened on Earth too much out of the ordinary. Mars had a similar story (except for the whole Moon coming out of a giant collision), and had water. But maybe it was too small to keep warm for enough time
Earth had 5 mass-extinctions, that "reset the game" before we got to humans. Doesn't seem too far fetched to me
I really don't buy that Earth is one in a billion unless Mars is one in a billion as well. Maybe one in 1000? One in 100000?
And that's limiting intelligent life to what we know. Yes, maybe the ideal speed of chemical reactions (for intelligent life) happen around 273K, or maybe there's another way
But it takes a lot of time to get to "life" as we know it.
(Now the right conditions are probably not what you have on Earth today except in a couple of places)
Life on Earth is at least 4Bi y.o. http://newsroom.ucla.edu/releases/life-on-earth-likely-start...
Anyway, what reason do we have to believe that Earth is special 2X? That we happened to have the right conditions plus some randomness occurred against all odds that gave rise to life? Why is that a rational proposition?
We know the chemical elements and processes that give rise to life, and we know why Earth is a suitable place. I suggest that, given the right (e.g. Earth-like) conditions, formation of life is not only more likely than the existence of the conditions, but the formation of life may even be likely overall. Hawking has expressed this possibility. [0]
There is fossil evidence suggesting that some forms of life existed on Earth as few as 500 million short years after it was formed. So, what are the odds that one astronomically improbable event (creation of a hospitable environment) was followed in such a short period by another alleged astronomically improbable event (abiogenesis)?
People base the idea that there should be other life in the universe on the fact that life developed at least once, which is here on earth. The odds are it would happen either 0 times or many times, but not exactly once.
This argument is reasonable if there is one universe. Another scenario is that there is some god awful large number of universes (for round numbers let's say 10^1000 raised to the 10^10000 power, which would be a huge underestimate), and that most of these universes contain no life, because the odds of life developing are also very, very small. We ARE special in that we are viewing one of the small fraction of universes that has life, because if it didn't we wouldn't be viewing it. This allows for life to exist exactly once in our universe. There could also be universe where life developed independently more than once, but the odds of us being in that universe are very small relative to the odds of being in a universe with one life.
But how would there be many universes? Here is one possibility that is surely controversial. In quantum mechanics, things happen in parallel. Is that electron spin up or spin down? It is both, but the electron in one state is not influenced by the electron in the other state. Each exists wholly on its own. This is true whether you believe the Stockholm or the Many Worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics. These two cases only differ when some special life form makes an observation, in which cases something very dramatic happens in the Stockholm interpretation (which is observationally indistinguishable from the "nothing different" that happens in the Many Worlds interpretation). If we think about the simplest form of life that can not make observations rather than looking for human-like life, the distinction between Stockholm and Many Worlds is mute. These parallel states of the system form our many universes, some that contain life and some that do not.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Von_Neumann%E2%80%93Wigner_int...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Many-minds_interpretation
More precisely, these interpretations require consciousness, but we can take that consciousness requires life.
This is terribly silly. It reminds me of the Onion talks:
"Step 1: Devise an idea to create a car that runs on compost. Step 2: Create the car. We’ve already completed Step 1. We’re half way there."
Increased certainty on three of the seven factors is irrelevant, because 99% of the uncertainty is concentrated in the other four. Specifically, the odds of abiogenesis are ~1/2^n, where n is the complexity in bits of the smallest self-replicator. n is bounded below by ~100 or so (or it would have happened in a lab somewhere), and is bounded above by ~1 million (the smallest existing bacteria), so we know it's somewhere in there. But where? We have only the vaguest guesses.
"Specifically, unless the probability for evolving a civilization on a habitable-zone planet is less than one in 10 billion trillion, then we are not the first."
"One in 10 billion trillion" sounds like a very large number, and it's put in italics for emphasis, but in information-theoretic terms it's tiny. log2(10^22) is just 73 bits. If all that we know about a number is that it's somewhere between a hundred and a million, saying that X would imply it's higher than 73 (well technically 73 + log2(#incidences of molecular combination), so probably a few hundred) is not a disproof of X, nor really even much evidence against X.