Re:There Have Probably Been Aliens
by throwaway_yy2Di on Saturday June 11, 2016 @06:11AM
(#11882888)
"One in 10 billion trillion" sounds like a very large number, and it's put in italics for emphasis,"
And the author even asserts it's "irrational" to think real-world probabilities are this small!
It's easy to construct "unreasonably" small probabilities: take a few small ones and multiply them. If you path-sum all the evolutionary state transitions summing to P(intelligent life|planet), is it a shallow graph with many alternatives (additive probabilities), or a deep graph dominated by long, conjunctive sequences (probabilities multiply)?
And the author even asserts it's "irrational" to think real-world probabilities are this small!
It's easy to construct "unreasonably" small probabilities: take a few small ones and multiply them. If you path-sum all the evolutionary state transitions summing to P(intelligent life|planet), is it a shallow graph with many alternatives (additive probabilities), or a deep graph dominated by long, conjunctive sequences (probabilities multiply)?