News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:There Have Probably Been Aliens by gus_massa on Saturday June 11, 2016 @11:03AM (#11883668)
I think it's a winner take all task. If you are the first almost live form, you have plenty of time, and can evolved in an environment that has plenty of food. Something like the brown goo of Titan, with lots of hydrocarbons and other small molecules that you can pick up for free. And nobody is trying to eat you. So the reproduction process can be slow and unreliable, perhaps a few reproductions per day/week?/month??

The only way to die if a UV ray split you, or you fall into a volcano (there are no fire, because the atmosphere has very few oxygen), or a nasty oxygen molecule reacts with you, or ...

Well, there are many ways to die, but they are not targeting you, so perhaps you can hide from the sun under a rock. Or to be more clear, since you doesn't have any kind of senses or mobility, perhaps you are lucky and get beached under a rock. Perhaps the rock also makes a nice place to concentrate other molecules during the low tide.

Perhaps it's not a good idea to be near the surface and it's better to be lucky and get near a underwater sea vent with tasty hydrogen. I think the details of the first steps are not clear for anyone (in particular for me).

Once a stupid life for appears, the first thing it would do is eat all the free food. In particular, before the first life form the half of the amino acid were L and half D. We have used all the L amino acids (and created many more than the original supply), and we have also eaten all the original D amino acids. So there are very few of them floating around freely, it would be very hard to start an alternative D-tree.

A new life form will be targeted by the existing life form, like the free D amino acids. The competition will be extremely hard. So I think it's a winner take all task.

Moreover, then some moron decides to release a lot of oxygen to the atmosphere. Oxygen is extremely toxic for most life forms, and more toxic for isolated molecules that are barely alive ...

About the shadow biosphere: Perhaps we (humans) can't detect or identify them, but the bacteria and archaea can probably live there and eat them barely-alive. Our cousins can keep all the out-of-tree competition at bay.

Re:There Have Probably Been Aliens by throwaway_yy2Di on Sunday June 12, 2016 @07:33AM (#11887631)

    If you are the first almost live form, you have plenty of
    time, and can evolved in an environment that has plenty of
    food. Something like the brown goo of Titan, with lots of
    hydrocarbons and other small molecules that you can pick up
    for free.
But there's no food on Titan anywhere! There's no oxidizers for hydrocarbons to react with; hence no accessible chemical energy.

That's likely generic for pre-biotic environments. Planets don't naturally form redox gradients; if there's a large redox potential, that's reactive chemistry, which will react away to equilibrium over geologic time. It takes work to maintain such a gradient; for example, Earth's oxidizing atmosphere is actively maintained by life. Oxygen is geologically removed from atmospheres, reacting with exposed rock surfaces (oxygen weathering). It takes active expenditure of work (solar energy) to keep it existing.

There is some chemical energy in abiotic planets, but only small amounts, at very low power levels compared to Earth's aerobic biosphere (which eats something like 10^14 watts!). There's photochemistry caused by solar UV light, and there's atmospheric lightning (which is a major player in the Earth's N2 cycle). Most important is geochemical energy; i.e. primordial chemical gradients that aren't yet at equilibrium, because the two reactants are physically separated by rock layers. On Europa for example, a very slow process brings rocks into contact with the ocean, where slow serpentinization reactions can occur: oxidation of Fe++ to Fe+++ by water, with the production of H2. This would be the food source of Europa life, if it's there.

Re:There Have Probably Been Aliens by gus_massa on Monday June 20, 2016 @07:50AM (#11937385)
A very late reply.

I'm not sure if this is for or against your comment, but I hope you find this interesting:

"A cave in Romania that was sealed for 5.5M years" http://www.bbc.com/earth/story/20150904-the-bizarre-beasts-l... HN discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11682816 (889 points, 38 days ago, 163 comments)