News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by MBlume on Friday June 10, 2016 @08:53PM (#11881367)
The fact that you have to build an iOS app on a Mac, that you can't even set up a CI build on commodity hardware, or in the cloud, is pretty fundamentally developer-hostile. I'll start to feel wooed when they take steps toward fixing that.
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by mdorazio on Friday June 10, 2016 @10:16PM (#11881660)
Thank you for bringing this up since it's been massively painful for years. As an example, when I first started developing for iOS back in 2009, I had to buy a $500 used macbook before I could even get started coding. That hardware was obsolete within about 3 years (couldn't update to the latest OSX or XCode), so then I had to pony up another $800 for a refurbished mac mini just to still be able to develop. Meanwhile, Android Studio runs on... actually I don't know what it doesn't run on.

And yes, I know that leasing time on a mac for dev work is an option, but that gets rather pricey over time ($1 per hour or $20/month is not cheap if you need to work on and maintain apps for multiple years). And an RDC experience will never be as good as having the actual computer in front of you, even on a fast connection.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by gaius on Saturday June 11, 2016 @05:58AM (#11882863)
That hardware was obsolete within about 3 years (couldn't update to the latest OSX or XCode

I call shenanigans - latest OSX and XCode running on a 2008 Macbook right here on my desk. I plan to get 10 years usage out of this machine - that's value for money right there.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by k-mcgrady on Saturday June 11, 2016 @06:21AM (#11882907)
In my experience Apple laptops tend to hold their value pretty well so I'm guessing a $500 machine was 4-5 years old when purchased. So the fact OP could use it for 3 more seems about right. Personally I upgrade around every 4 years and the laptop is still in great condition for most people and sells for well over half what I paid for it.
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by Matt3o12_ on Saturday June 11, 2016 @07:42AM (#11883097)
Unfortunately this seems to be less and less true over the years. When I got my MacBook about 4 or 5 years ago, it only had 4GB of ram and a pretty slow hard disk. If have upgraded it to 12GB Ram and a pretty good SSD, this is why I can still use such an old MacBook. For the new ones, I have to decide the RAM, and disk upfront and can't replace them anymore (this is especially worrying with the small lifetime with SSDs).

I wish Apple made their pro products more bulky so we can upgrade the hardware and let the air products be the sexy, thin ones for Starbucks hipsters.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by csydas on Saturday June 11, 2016 @08:20AM (#11883192)
As a long time mac user, I do agree that the lack of upgradability in their Pro line is a problem, and it probably should be the defining factor of Pro versus the Air/Straight Macbook line.

That being said, Apple has gone to pretty crazy lengths to ensure that it's modern OSes work on legacy hardware; I was a bit shocked to hear from my parents that they were able to install El Capitan on my dad's 2008 iMac, as I was wary about putting it on my 2012 Macbook Air due to performance concerns. I don't know if this was a conscious decision by Apple to cater to the idea of "Apple = Longevity", but it's very nice to know that a single purchase takes you pretty far. I think Apple could take it a step further and really win over more people if they added the millimeter or two to the Pro line and allowed for the upgrades.

It's really a back and forth thing for me; on the one hand, I wish I had more options and the ability to customize later on. On the other hand, since ~2010, the appliance like nature of the portables has worked so seamlessly that my only complaint comes from the lack of an option to upgrade, not the need for an upgrade. For my previous Apple laptop, my own incompetence when trying to do a repair hurt the laptop's longevity; had I not had butterfingers when working on the insides, I'm sure that I could have had another 3 years with my already 5 year old Macbook.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by douche on Saturday June 11, 2016 @08:41AM (#11883249)
Performance has essentially plateaued for the last decade in laptops - aside from sticking SSDs and more memory in them, there isn't a ton of difference in specs. I have a 2006 Windows laptop that runs better now on Win 10 than it did originally on Vista. Except for power consumption, it's the same as my two year old laptop.

Of course, with a Windows PC, you've got a variety of options, and can buy something that is actually upgradable, rather than being locked into what Apple deigns to give you.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by matt4077 on Saturday June 11, 2016 @09:59AM (#11883453)
I believe the SSD is a pretty large aside, isn't it? GPUs have also vastly improved, I believe. It's just CPU that stagnate at the "good enough" level.
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by Matt3o12_ on Saturday June 11, 2016 @10:09AM (#11883486)
While I do agree with most things, there will be a need to upgrade something in the future.

When I bought my MacBook, 4GB of Ram were plenty but it is not anymore. Chrome takes to much ram and with 16GB, I don't have to worry about anything. Furthermore, apples new laptops are all dual core (until you buy the bigger one). This is also dealbreaker for me – quad cores are really awesome when using VMs. Sure a CPU cannot be updated on most laptops (and certainly not on apples but I can't blame really).

My point is that I'm afraid apples pro series has drifted into a state where their lifespan will shorten while the prices go up.

And apple's OS performs really good until you use third party applications that expect better performance then your sad 5-year-old MacBook.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by csydas on Saturday June 11, 2016 @02:43PM (#11884706)
Oh I'm not suggesting that it will never peak higher than what Apple offers; again, I do agree that it would be nice if the Pro line offered a little more to users looking for more oomph.

It's just that, again, by and large with everything with the Mac line up right now, you throw something at it and you're good to go. Even my 2012' Air can do moderately advanced video editing in Premiere, the only real bottlenecks being local storage and the CPU taking a bit to render video.

The current line up is not a perfect solution for absolutely everything, and Apple's power option in the Mac Pro line is just unacceptable for most people, even if it does bring a lot to the table. But in most cases, Apple's line ups do extremely well for a large majority of things you'd want to use a computer for. I too would enjoy a quad core in the Air/Pro line, or at least the Pro line, though I suspect the issue is heat, and as I said earlier, I'd happily take a bit of thickness to accommodate a heftier processor.

I certainly don't endorse letting Apple tell me what hardware I need; I also don't have too many complaints with what they've given. Price exaggerations aside, I find the price tag for the Macbook Air/Pro lines appropriate for the base models, and comparable to other 13" sized machines with similar specs and amenities (for lack of a better word). Such is sort of the nature with Apple and being a long time user - there's a lot Apple does that bugs you, but at the same time, there is a lot of good you get with the hardware and the OS.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by gaius on Saturday June 11, 2016 @03:19PM (#11884879)
I too would enjoy a quad core in the Air/Pro line, or at least the Pro line

The 15" Macbook Pros are quad-core http://www.apple.com/uk/macbook-pro/specs-retina/

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by gaius on Saturday June 11, 2016 @11:25AM (#11883757)
The question is why the software takes up so much more. Firefox is the pain point for me on my 2008 Macbook, for everything else, it's perfectly snappy. I block ads, don't play games or look at animation heavy sites, but even doing nothing but displaying pages, it sits at 2.5G RAM (out of 4) and 100% of one of my two CPU cores. I'd run an old version if it wasn't for the security updates. Utterly ridiculous.
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by astrange on Sunday June 12, 2016 @04:34PM (#11890111)
Check about:memory. It's probably not Firefox but the websites.
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by phamilton on Saturday June 11, 2016 @11:27AM (#11883764)
I think this sentiment (pro users want to upgrade their hardware) is inaccurate for most professionals. Hobbyists and freelance/self-employed may want to upgrade their hardware but a professional generally doesn't care. They just want a machine that works and a reasonable path to a new machine that doesn't affect their productivity. That upgrade path is really smooth on OS X. Migration assistant plus thunderbolt cable plus target disk mode makes it really easy.
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by gaius on Saturday June 11, 2016 @06:25AM (#11882917)
8 years from a laptop is still more than you would expect from almost any other manufacturer, save maybe IBM/Lenovo tho' I have heard the build quality of Thinkpads has really deteriorated lately.
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by vetinari on Saturday June 11, 2016 @08:28AM (#11883211)
2009 Thinkpad T400 still working fine, although with updated RAM and SSD. Another 2012 T430s also working fine.

Refreshing current Apple computers won't be that easy. Even if you are capable of opening it, compatible M.2 drives won't be easy to find and you won't be able to swap soldered RAM. I'm not sure that my 2015 rMBP will be able to serve so long as that T430s will.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by Jyaif on Saturday June 11, 2016 @06:13AM (#11882892)
Not shenanigans, happened to as well: couldn't upgrade OS X, so couldn't upgrade to latest xcode, and Apple required using the latest xcode... so I had to buy a new mac. That was a long time ago though, now Apple seems to support HW for much longer.
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by developer2 on Saturday June 11, 2016 @05:30PM (#11885421)
This is shenanigans. You only need the latest XCode to take advantage of bleeding edge features released in the latest iOS. 90% of apps never take advantage of the bleeding edge; you can continue to develop apps for all versions of iOS - including the latest release - with a 5 year old laptop.
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by Udo_Schmitz on Saturday June 11, 2016 @06:18AM (#11882900)
Could be a polycarbonate model. Models of those up to 2008 stopped receiving upgrades after OS X Lion (2011):

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MacBook#Model_specifications

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by Mikhail_Edoshin on Saturday June 11, 2016 @06:15AM (#11882895)
I have MacMini Late 2009 and it can hardly run the OS itself, let alone something else :) It's practically unusable. It doesn't have much memory though, only 2 GB.
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by gaius on Saturday June 11, 2016 @06:20AM (#11882904)
4G in mine. The memory compression feature in 10.9 was a godsend for older hardware, proof that Apple is serious about longevity of older kit.
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by Philipp__ on Saturday June 11, 2016 @07:44AM (#11883100)
I still use my 21" iMac 2007. It does the job for household computer, usually my mom use it for web browsing and emails, but I can do dev work relatively nice on it, El Captain installed btw.

It will hit 10 years mark in May next year, I shelled out $1.6k at the time for it, 2 years ago upgraded RAM from OCW, and installed SSD, upgraded magic mouse, and it works really nice! I think I used the hell out of it, and it is amazing machine!

While your concerns and gripes about Apple Dev. environment are 100% true, there are some reasons why are they so. And in a few years I think that will change, Swift will change it! Imagine you can compile swift code on Linux now! It's nowhere near usable for serious development work, but I think with Swift, Apple addressed that problem too, so I think in 5 years you won't need exclusively OSX to dev for Apple devices. I'm sure it would be the best way to do it, but who knows we shall see.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by gurkendoktor on Saturday June 11, 2016 @10:51AM (#11883625)
> And in a few years I think that will change, Swift will change it!

The compilers for Swift and Objective-C are command-line tools that are (relatively) easy to port to Linux.

But for a real iOS dev environment or CI server you'll need the iPhone Simulator, which is built on a large stack of proprietary frameworks. I don't see Apple porting it to other platforms anytime soon.

The trivial fix would be to allow virtualisation of OS X on commodity hardware.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by runamok on Sunday June 12, 2016 @02:34AM (#11886935)
Yeap. Afaik you are not even allowed to virtualize OS X on an OS X server. If you could I'd assume AWS et al would do so for CI and such.
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by ianlevesque on Sunday June 12, 2016 @11:16AM (#11888447)
This is false
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by runamok on Monday June 20, 2016 @06:07PM (#11941969)
Fair enough. It appears my knowledge is outdated and perhaps was true with an older version of OS X. http://superuser.com/questions/904884/is-it-possible-to-run-...

On the other hand Apple makes virtually no hardware that would be a good fit for a datacenter with many VMs on powerful multiprocessor hardware available in a compact form factor.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by msie on Saturday June 11, 2016 @02:06AM (#11882299)
If you wanted to program for Windows you still had to buy a computer. You could argue that you could get a Windows computer cheaper than a Mac but in the long run that difference is insignificant when you're spending many years with the same hardware.

I'm still programming iOS apps on a 2012 Macbook Pro because I'm not rich. Performance is still pretty good!

Android Studio runs on a lot of hardware but it's slow unless you have good hardware, which costs money.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by enobrev on Saturday June 11, 2016 @02:17AM (#11882325)
That's true, although Windows can be run in a VM. I'm not saying that would be the ideal means of developing for Windows, but it's an available option, and MS even offers free images for testing on various OS versions. Meanwhile OSX can only be run in a VM on Apple hardware.
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by douche on Saturday June 11, 2016 @08:29AM (#11883216)
So, I haven't tried actually doing this, but is there a real reason you can' load OS X up on a VirtualBox VM, etc, or is that just what Apple tells you you can do with the software you bought from them?
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by hobs on Saturday June 11, 2016 @09:13AM (#11883330)
OS X basically prevents this with default install, you will have to get a hacked OS X image to do this, and that is a legal grey area depending on your country.

You can find out more by looking up hackintosh.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by msie on Saturday June 11, 2016 @02:37AM (#11882366)
Ok, so Apple hardware for the win!
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by tomjen3 on Saturday June 11, 2016 @02:38AM (#11882372)
He isn't developing for the Mac though, he is developing for the iPhone. You don't have to have a Linux machine to write code for Android.
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by msie on Saturday June 11, 2016 @04:12AM (#11882609)
Forgive the rambling but it's getting late and I'm sleepy:

I'm just saying that people are complaining too much about having to buy a Mac to write code for iOS. If not must, then you should buy a Windows machine to develop for Windows but you don't hear anyone complain about that. You have to buy an Oculus Rift to develop Oculus Rift software. You have to buy an Android device to test your Android program. etc... You don't have to buy a Linux machine to write code for Android but if you don't have a computer at all then you have to buy one. There's stuff you have to pay for to get into programming...To build software that will make you money. Windows/Linux developers are complaining that Apple didn't release free tools for their platform and overreacting.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by chipperyman573 on Saturday June 11, 2016 @04:41AM (#11882688)
>Windows machine to develop for Windows

There are so many ways to develop Windows apps on OSX (unless I'm misreading, which I might be because this point is so blatantly wrong)

>Oculus Rift to develop Oculus Rift software

You can download the SDK without the Rift, you just can't test how it will work on a rift without... a rift

>You don't have to buy a Linux machine to write code for Android but if you don't have a computer at all then you have to buy one

I mean... you're not wrong but the point is you can buy any computer you want, not some overpriced, under-powered laptop with an apple on the lid

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by microcolonel on Saturday June 11, 2016 @09:59AM (#11883454)
You can easily write good Windows applications on Linux and OS X; and Microsoft distributes standard virtualization images for free which you can fire up in a VM to test your Windows applications. In addition to those virtual machines, Wine implements much of the Win32 library and can be used to test your Windows applications with some minor limitations. For iOS you cannot run your build process on a remote machine without jumping high hoops, you cannot build without OS X at all, you cannot sign code for your own device without their IDE and a certificate from their website.
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by ci5er on Saturday June 11, 2016 @07:21AM (#11883061)
I will stand up and be prickly here and say: please do not judge the world by your (apparently) Apple-centric circumstance.

I (personally) am a nomad. I can not carry 27 computers with me. My world would be best served by having one computer that does all the jobs. Apple hinders me in this; it does not help.

Yes, I can (and do) do Hackintosh VMs, but it makes me feel dirty.

Whenever I have to deploy on an iphone, to test I buy a bank of iphones (and give them to the neighborhood children when I am done). That should be good enough.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by matt4077 on Saturday June 11, 2016 @09:53AM (#11883435)
Run Windows on a Macbook? They're pretty excellent for travelling. Just the other day I dumped half a Caipirinha over the keyboard and I booted right up afte two hours in the Cuban shade :)
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by WayneBro on Saturday June 11, 2016 @10:48AM (#11883611)
Windows runs any hardware or virtual machine.

OS X does not.

So, no...you don't have to buy a computer to run Windows because you can run it on your existing computer.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by microcolonel on Saturday June 11, 2016 @09:55AM (#11883441)
You can program and build programs for Windows and OS X on Linux, Windows Phone I'm not entirely sure about.
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by titanix2 on Saturday June 11, 2016 @10:25PM (#11886346)
You need some precise combinaison of Windows and Visual Studio to target a given version of Windows Phone. At least if you want to use emulators, you'll need a Windows 8 to target WP8 (otherwise Win7 is fine IIRC).

Windows 10 is required to build Win10M apps targeting UWP. You can still use WP8 tools (thus Win8) to make WinPRT or Silverlight apps.

That's the theory. In practice the last insider build have a bug which forbid app deployment, and for some builds nows the Silverlight app runtime had its own bugs (keyboard related for example).

For having used this tools since WP7 I really feel a decline in quality on the mobile OS and I wouldn't recommand to bother anymore.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by giarc on Friday June 10, 2016 @10:19PM (#11881670)
I've never heard of leasing but $20 month is a steal. At $20/month, it would take 7.5 years to pay off a $1800 laptop. If you are leasing in that time you would have upgraded a few times.
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by mdorazio on Saturday June 11, 2016 @12:52AM (#11882133)
You don't get root access or a dedicated server, but it is an option:

http://www.macincloud.com/pricing/compare

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by giarc on Saturday June 11, 2016 @09:29AM (#11883377)
My mistake - I thought the leasing program was for a physical machine. Still an interesting option.
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by copperx on Saturday June 11, 2016 @11:39AM (#11883819)
Imagine being able to lease such a machine for $20/mo ...
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by zootam on Saturday June 11, 2016 @01:21AM (#11882205)
have you looked into hackintoshing?
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by derefr on Saturday June 11, 2016 @04:10AM (#11882604)
I would note that, if you want to Mackintosh specifically for the sake of compiling OSX/iOS executables, it's far easier to set up a computer to run a bare-metal hypervisor that knows how to run OSX virtual machines (e.g. VMWare ESXi), than it is to directly set up the same computer to run OSX directly. (Source: did both over the last month.)
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by kybernetyk on Saturday June 11, 2016 @05:16AM (#11882768)
IIRC I had "build platform nut supported" errors coming back from iTunes Connect when I tried submitting a build from my Hackintosh.

I guess Apple can detect if you're running on a Hackintosh. For example Netflix won't play on my Hackintosh without installing Silverlight. Invalid DRM keys or something.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by mdorazio on Saturday June 11, 2016 @11:54AM (#11883891)
Yes, I did. As others have pointed out, that tends to go poorly if you plan to actually develop, test, and publish OSX or iOS apps for a few reasons. I've read reports of some people getting it to work, but it's generally a hugely painful process and tends to break whenever there's an update.
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by tcdent on Saturday June 11, 2016 @02:33AM (#11882356)
I don't even develop platform-specific apps and I'm happy to pay the cost of a new machine every few years. Three machines, purchased new, have provided my sole income source for over a decade, at a cost of about $1000 per year. Not too bad considering what I profited after paying that ghastly fanboy tax...
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by timthorn on Saturday June 11, 2016 @03:10AM (#11882440)
For the first few years of the Mac, you had to buy a Lisa to do development at somewhat more than $500!
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by kybernetyk on Saturday June 11, 2016 @05:08AM (#11882755)
Well, you should be able to recoup those $1300 you spent on the Macs pretty easily if you do professional iOS development.

And if you're not in for the money but just as a hobby: don't develop for the iPhone then if you don't like the costs. (Even though $1300 over 5 or 6 years is a pretty cheap hobby in my books).

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by knucklesandwich on Friday June 10, 2016 @09:07PM (#11881417)
I don't disagree with your general point that it's ridiculous how locked down the tooling is, but I think you can build an iOS app on a CI in the cloud, can't you? TravisCI and CircleCI at least offer options for this, I believe.
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by joshdickson on Friday June 10, 2016 @09:54PM (#11881597)
They said CI build on commodity hardware. Yes folks like Circle have CI for iOS and OS X apps, but (1) it's on Apple hardware and (2) as a result, way more expensive.
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by knucklesandwich on Friday June 10, 2016 @10:09PM (#11881644)
The above person said or in the cloud.

Agreed that its a pain. I only have experience with OS X builds (not for cocoa apps, but for a CLI tool) in TravisCI, but I can tell you that their build box offerings are much weaker than what you can get for Linux (presumably because of the cost).

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by Fr0styMatt88 on Friday June 10, 2016 @09:14PM (#11881442)
I think Unity Cloud Build is another example. They say it supports iOS (I've personally never used it though).

https://unity3d.com/services/cloud-build

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by viktorbenei on Monday June 20, 2016 @03:51PM (#11940865)
I completely agree, just wanted to add that there are options for iOS / macOS CI in the cloud, like ours ( https://www.bitrise.io - we have a free plan for freelancers ) or Travis / Circle. Not on commodity hardware of course, and you most likely won't have macOS as an option on AWS/GCE/Azure in the near future either.. (we use a private vSphere system right now)
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by msie on Friday June 10, 2016 @09:28PM (#11881507)
So what? I have to build a Windows app on Windows, most likely using Visual Studio.
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by justabystander on Friday June 10, 2016 @09:59PM (#11881610)
Cross-compiling Windows apps from Linux using Mingw has been a thing for a very long time. Mingw itself is 18 years old. There are also options for using LLVM or compatibility layers like Midipix. So, no, Windows is not required and hasn't been for a long time.

As far as Visual Studio, it's not required, either. 3rd party compilers have always been a thing for MS operating systems. In fact, for a long time, you weren't even able to use VS to build drivers for Windows. Microsoft is also currently going out of its way to create neutral tools to enable developers to use the workflow and tools they desire. Omnisharp exists for providing intellisense to editors and IDEs. VS Code is a new, cross-platform IDE that works for both node and C#, among other languages. MonoDevelop still exists and can be used to write Windows-compatible applications.

But for Apple, you have to own a mac or, as is common, lease a mac to build and sign on. So, no, these things aren't even in the same realm of control. MS treats Windows as its primary platform for innovation. Apple treats OSX as the only platform in existence.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by sjtgraham on Saturday June 11, 2016 @06:32AM (#11882944)
I have a feeling it wouldn't be that difficult to do codesigning on another platform. It's a case of sha all the things, encrypt the sha with the cert private key, and render a plist with the signatures. IIRC there is a code signature load command in the Mach-O headers too?
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by steeve on Saturday June 11, 2016 @10:44AM (#11883599)
The issue is not so much technical as it is about legality. Codesign is itself open source (Darwin), but Apple TOS forbids you from building OSX/IOS apps to be distributed on the App Store on non Apple Hardware. I guess you could do it anyway, but I don't think people would risk it for the price of a mac mini...
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by msie on Saturday June 11, 2016 @02:33AM (#11882354)
> Cross-compiling Windows apps from Linux using Mingw has been a thing for a very long time. Mingw itself is 18 years old. There are also options for using LLVM or compatibility layers like Midipix. So, no, Windows is not required and hasn't been for a long time.

Sure, develop for Windows without using Windows. But why spend time developing for a platform that you don't use regularly? What about testing? How far can you go without Windows?

> As far as Visual Studio, it's not required... VS or Windows is not required but the majority of developers develop using VS on Windows. You could cheap-out by avoiding these but you're being penny-wise and pound-foolish.

> But for Apple, you have to own a mac But for Windows/Linux you still have to buy an Intel machine. You just don't want to buy another machine to develop iOS or OSX apps.

Anyhow, I think Windows/Linux owners are complaining they have to spend more money to develop on a different platform. You never hear this from Mac owners who want to develop for Windows or Linux.[Edit: Not trying to start a flame war. I'm really trying to understand the outrage...]

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by Tiksi on Saturday June 11, 2016 @04:52PM (#11885261)
Because neither windows or linux restrict which hardware or vms you can install them on like osx does? Obviously you won't hear it from Mac owners, because they can still develop for windows or linux, the inverse isn't true thanks to Apple's artificial restrictions.
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by kartickv on Friday June 10, 2016 @10:40PM (#11881735)
If your OS of choice is OS X or Linux, you can set up a Windows VM on it. But not the other way around.

Besides, Windows machines are much cheaper, so if you're from a developing country or a student, you have access to a Windows machine, not a Mac.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by msie on Saturday June 11, 2016 @01:55AM (#11882286)
Ok, you can't setup an OSX VM on Windows but don't ignore the cost of that computer you are developing Windows software on.

I am developing iOS apps on a 2012 Macbook Pro. Those aren't expensive nowadays.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by quanticle on Saturday June 11, 2016 @05:26AM (#11882793)
>I am developing iOS apps on a 2012 Macbook Pro. Those aren't expensive nowadays.

I would be willing to bet that a used Thinkpad is even cheaper, and has the benefit of having more upgrade options.

To make a car analogy, your argument boils down to, "Well, you need a car anyway, so why not buy a Lexus?" I think a lot of the people replying to your posts are arguing that requiring luxury hardware (and, let's face it, Macs are luxury hardware) adds a pretty huge barrier to entry for software development. Trying to argue that the price difference between Apple hardware and Windows/Linux hardware is "insignificant" in the long run just doesn't cut it. Even the cheapest Apple laptop is a thousand dollars in the US. It costs even more overseas. Meanwhile, you can get similarly spec'd Windows machines for a half to three quarters of the price.

There is a Mac premium, and it is a barrier to entry for developers. You can't make that barrier disappear by blindly asserting that it doesn't matter.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by joshmn on Saturday June 11, 2016 @01:33AM (#11882231)
I've never had a problem setting up an OS X VM. Just need to look in the right places.

Linux VM on a Windows machine was a thing in the early 2000s.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by enobrev on Saturday June 11, 2016 @02:21AM (#11882332)
I'd like to hear more about this. Are you saying you've set up an OSX VM on non-apple hardware? I haven't tried in at least a year, so maybe things have changed, but I have put a significant amount of effort in trying to get an OSX VM running on non-apple hardware and was not even close to successful.
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by sigjuice on Saturday June 11, 2016 @02:27AM (#11882341)
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by enobrev on Saturday June 11, 2016 @02:42AM (#11882383)
Thanks for this. Searching around for the title of that article[1] opened up plenty more resources as well. I ended up grabbing a refurb'd Mini last time I needed to do OSX-specific testing locally, but it's great to know progress is being made to open the possibilities on non-Apple hardware.

1: "Running Mac OS X as a QEMU/KVM Guest"

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by derefr on Saturday June 11, 2016 @04:18AM (#11882631)
I've gone down that path; it was a big pain—Apple just doesn't bother to make drivers for what most hypervisors consider "generic" hardware. You basically need to do the same stuff Hackintosh builders do, to your VM, to get even some of the features working.

By contrast, you can just create an OSX VM in VMWare Fusion in OSX and then copy it over to VMWare Workstation on Windows (or an ESXi server, or whatever else) and it'll work fine after being convinced[1] that it's allowed to try.

[1] http://www.insanelymac.com/forum/files/file/339-unlocker/

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by mtrpcic on Friday June 10, 2016 @09:53PM (#11881591)
You can set up build servers for your app on Microsoft Azure, or AWS' Windows Server instances. Microsoft produces articles on how to do Windows development on a Mac (Bootcamp, Parallels, etc.) [1]. Microsoft has shown commitment to bringing it's core offerings to other platforms. Apple has in no way done that. You literally, absolutely need an Apple computer for every step of the development process for iOS. Your comparison is not valid.

[1] https://blogs.msdn.microsoft.com/interoperability/2012/12/21...

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by jboles on Friday June 10, 2016 @10:46PM (#11881759)
And Windows used to be considered the more closed platform. How times change.
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by msie on Saturday June 11, 2016 @03:03AM (#11882430)
Is it really developer hostile that Apple is not bending over backwards to provide free tools to Windows and Linux users? I think it's prudent of them not to waste money on such a small segment, some of which vehemently hate Apple. And when you talk about build servers you are still spending money on some machine to build your iOS app. You can get pretty good used Mac hardware if you really want to. For all those developers sitting on the sidelines refusing to develop iOS apps because they can't setup a build server on Azure, etc. Well, you're just making excuses.
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by WayneBro on Saturday June 11, 2016 @11:20AM (#11883726)
I've been in computers since the early 90's and as far as I can see, Apple has always been hostile towards developers (and users).

> For all those developers sitting on the sidelines refusing to develop iOS apps...

I've made a ton of money building Ionic and Xamarin apps and recommend those to anybody building for iOS because both of them will let you spend as little time using OS X as possible. The way my workflow is now, I could totally rent a cloud Mac and just compile and publish stuff from there.

Anyway, even though I think OS X and iOS are quite possibly the worst operating systems I've ever had the displeasure of using and even though I know for a fact that Apple is hostile to developers and users, I don't mind making apps for them because I figure anyone who uses there stuff must not care about wasting money and it should be easy for me to grab some...and it is :)

And, like Spotify, all of my apps are subscription based with out-of-app signup, so Apple doesn't get 30% of my money. I also only buy used Macs because Apple doesn't get your money that way either. Right now I'm running a Mid-2012 Mac Pro with 32GB RAM that I got for ~$1,200. It was about double the money that I spent for a similar PC server, but I made all that back by taking money out of Apple's ecosystem and not putting it back in, so I feel like that's a win for everybody (except Apple of course, but hey - fuck them - if they're going to be hostile to me, I'm going to be hostile to them.)

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by cptskippy on Friday June 10, 2016 @10:51PM (#11881780)
I think his point, and one I agree with, is that the tool chain is incredibly expensive, obsoleted frequently, and requires lots of maintenance.

If you used Microsoft's tool chain to build Windows apps, you can do so with a VM under the Dream Spark license for free.

The barrier to entry for OSX/iOS development is hundreds to thousands of dollars.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by msie on Saturday June 11, 2016 @01:52AM (#11882283)
Well, Xcode is free. Apple Dev membership is free. You need a computer to develop software on. Windows machines aren't free. A legit Windows OS license is more expensive than OSX.
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by cptskippy on Saturday June 11, 2016 @10:50AM (#11883622)
Oh so you can buy the OSX upgrade and install it on any x86 hardware? No? Then it's not comparable to the retail Windows License.

You can pickup a Windows PC and an Android phone for half the cost of just a Mac Mini that still requires a display.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by smt88 on Saturday June 11, 2016 @03:44AM (#11882533)
Is a Dev membership free, or is it $99/year?
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by JimDabell on Saturday June 11, 2016 @05:27AM (#11882795)
A developer account is free, the $99 is to publish in the App Store, receive technical support, and receive free versions of various things (e.g. OS X Server).
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by bitserf on Saturday June 11, 2016 @05:21AM (#11882778)
$99 is when you want to distribute via App Store. You don't need that to do the development or use the tools.
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by JimDabell on Saturday June 11, 2016 @05:35AM (#11882816)
> the tool chain is incredibly expensive, obsoleted frequently, and requires lots of maintenance.

The toolchain isn't expensive or obsoleted frequently. A new Mac mini is $499 and can last more than five years. When you consider a professional iOS developer can easily make $100/hr, a cost of $100/yr for equipment is beyond negligible.

Not sure where you get "requires lots of maintenance" from – he doesn't seem to have said anything about that?

Obviously in rich Western country terms.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by cptskippy on Saturday June 11, 2016 @07:56AM (#11883128)
$499 is a big investment for the majority of the population and assumes you have a monitor and an iOS device already. It's not a sum many people will drop just to try it out. For a lot of people it means completely adopting the platform.

A new Apple device could potentially last you 5 years but Apple has also been known to obsolete hardware in as little as a year.

The majority of developers making iOS apps do not make $100 and that's not assured income, its potential.

If you happen to work for a professional shop with a team, chances are you want to do CI or automation. It's a pain. If your IT department manages your machines then they need someone dedicated to maintaining enterprise security policies on your Macs, it's a pain for the user and the admin.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by JimDabell on Saturday June 11, 2016 @08:43AM (#11883253)
> $499 is a big investment for the majority of the population

I think labelling a $499 computer as "incredibly expensive" isn't accurate when you're talking about typical Western countries. That's a pretty normal cost for a computer.

> and assumes you have a monitor and an iOS device already.

Most platforms require you to have an instance of the platform available to you. Yes, people who want to develop for iOS should reasonably be expected to have an iOS device, just like people who want to develop for Android should reasonably be expected to have an Android device, and people who want to develop for BlackBerry should reasonably be expected to have a BlackBerry device. Apple are not unusual in this respect – you appear to be holding them to a different standard to other platforms here.

> Apple has also been known to obsolete hardware in as little as a year.

I can't think of a case where this has happened – can you give an example?

> The majority of developers making iOS apps do not make $100 and that's not assured income, its potential.

I'm trying to put the cost/benefit into perspective. The cost of iOS development is minuscule in context.

> If you happen to work for a professional shop with a team, chances are you want to do CI or automation. It's a pain. If your IT department manages your machines then they need someone dedicated to maintaining enterprise security policies on your Macs, it's a pain for the user and the admin.

Again, you seem to be holding Apple to different standards than other platforms. If you have employees using computers, then IT needs to manage them. Yes, of course – but this is true for Windows developers, Android developers, and all other developers as well.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by cptskippy on Saturday June 11, 2016 @10:45AM (#11883603)
> That's a pretty normal cost for a computer.

That might be the normal cost of one of 50 different Dell laptops but for Apple it's their lowest end unit and it lacks a display.

> Most platforms require you to have an instance of the platform available to you.

Nope they don't, but it is better if you do. It's also considerably cheaper.

> I can't think of a case where this has happened – can you give an example?

The PPC MacBook after the Intel Switch, the first gen Core Duo MacBook after the 32-64bit switch, non-retina iDevices... I'm on a phone or I'd keep going.

> I'm trying to put the cost/benefit into perspective. The cost of iOS development is minuscule in context.

If your context is "successful developer with a hit app" then yes, but the reality is that the majority of devs won't be anywhere near that successful.

> Again, you seem to be holding Apple to different standards than other platforms.

See that's where you're confused. I'm holding them to the same standards. Microsoft offers tons of free tools for managing large pools of enterprise machines, maintaining their patch levels, group policies, access control, etc. Linux has similar support.

Apple on the other hand makes you invest in countless 3rd party tools to achieve the same level of control. And at the end of the day it's still Flaky and error prone.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by JimDabell on Saturday June 11, 2016 @11:30AM (#11883779)
> That might be the normal cost of one of 50 different Dell laptops but for Apple it's their lowest end unit and it lacks a display.

Now you're shifting the goal from the cost of the toolchain to the cost of Apple's lineup as a whole. It doesn't matter what the top of the range Apple lineup costs, to get started with iOS development, you just need the cheapest Mac mini.

You can pick up a monitor for next to nothing. Here's a Dell monitor for under $40: https://www.amazon.co.uk/DELL-Monitor-Computer-Screen-Inch/d...

> The PPC MacBook after the Intel Switch, the first gen Core Duo MacBook after the 32-64bit switch, non-retina iDevices... I'm on a phone or I'd keep going.

Wait, you've moved the goalposts again. We're talking about the ability to buy a computer and continue to use it for development for a reasonable period of time. We're not talking about your computer not being the latest model. Just because Apple introduced retina screens on the iPhone 4, it doesn't mean that you had to go out and buy a new Mac to develop for it.

> If your context is "successful developer with a hit app" then yes, but the reality is that the majority of devs won't be anywhere near that successful.

I'm talking about typical professional iOS developers. The majority of them are successful. I suspect you're talking about app entrepreneurs, which is a whole different ballgame. Most iOS developers aren't making their own applications, they are making applications for other people. And yes, the cost of iOS development is trivial for them.

It's true, lots of applications don't make money – that's because they fit into the business in other ways. For instance, your bank's application is free, but I can assure you that the developers who built it aren't worried about the cost of an entry-level Mac mini.

The context is this: If you do this professionally, then you can afford the developer toolchain easily. If you're not employed as an iOS developer and you're just making applications for yourself? Sure, I can see how you'd consider it a moderately expensive hobby if you didn't already own a Mac. But we're really talking about two different things there.

> I'm holding them to the same standards. Microsoft offers tons of free tools for managing large pools of enterprise machines, maintaining their patch levels, group policies, access control, etc. Linux has similar support.

You've shifted the goalposts again. You were talking about having to hire somebody to manage Apple computers. IT manpower is required for any platform, so singling Apple out as special for requiring IT manpower is holding them to a different standard.

I really don't think the enterprise is relevant to your argument here. If a company employs enough iOS developers to require large pools of machines and more than a basic $2/month MDM solution, then they really aren't going to consider a $499 machine "incredibly expensive", whether it comes with or without a monitor.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by blisterpeanuts on Friday June 10, 2016 @10:08PM (#11881642)
Wouldn't it be a more fair comparison with Android? You can develop Android apps on Windows, Mac, and Linux (though in my experience the Mac is the best supported of the three).
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by asimuvPR on Friday June 10, 2016 @09:08PM (#11881421)
Great point. The whole process seems alien to me. More so when its forced by one of the biggest computer companies in the world.
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by cheez on Saturday June 11, 2016 @06:51AM (#11882994)
I'm running into this problem right now for my app, and there are reasonably priced cloud options out there. Mac OS doesn't run on commodity hardware so it isn't surprising that you can't set up a CI build on commodity hardware. Put another way, Mac OS is not like Windows and Linux: the software is inextricably linked to the hardware.
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by Roritharr on Saturday June 11, 2016 @03:14AM (#11882450)
You are correct. I've started Android Development since I did not want to work on Apple Hardware.

I don't like the "just different" attitude concerning some basic things (Why can't I order a MacBook with full printed special character keyboards AND none of those non-standard key bindings(especially horrible on German Keyboards)? Why can't they offer a Version of Finder that is not insanely infuriating to people used to Windows or Ubuntu?) that are just hostile to people who don't drink their brand of kool-aid.

I'm happily developing on Windows and if I ever feel badly served by this, switching to Ubuntu is a very warm well trodden road.

I really don't get what people See in Macs, other than the tribe factor.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by realworldview on Saturday June 11, 2016 @09:34AM (#11883392)
so angry
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by joshuak on Friday June 10, 2016 @09:44PM (#11881565)
Not Apple, but you have all of these features with Qt [1] which can be deployed to iOS.

1: http://www.qt.io

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by JonathonW on Saturday June 11, 2016 @01:32AM (#11882226)
You can develop your application with Qt on whatever platform you want, but you'll still need Apple hardware when it comes time to build and test on iOS, because Qt still has to build and link against Apple's SDKs and use Apple's codesigning tools to produce builds that are actually runnable.
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by JimDabell on Saturday June 11, 2016 @05:38AM (#11882821)
Building and linking is still an issue, but you can do the signing on other platforms now:

https://github.com/saucelabs/isign

Given that the Swift toolchain is now open-source and being ported to other platforms, I would expect that the building and linking issues will be solved fairly shortly. I wouldn't be surprised if there was something official announced at WWDC.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by ryanwaggoner on Friday June 10, 2016 @10:08PM (#11881639)
That's a feature, not a bug. What possible benefit could there be to helping people who are hostile to their platforms develop for them? If you want to develop for Apple platforms, you do so from Apple platforms. Fair and logical.
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by mkishi on Friday June 10, 2016 @10:15PM (#11881659)
So, developers who use other systems and want to publish iOS apps are "hostile" to Apple's platform? That makes no sense.

A polished iOS app with lots of users is worth much more for the whole Apple ecosystem than a few developers using OSX computers.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by ryanwaggoner on Friday June 10, 2016 @11:26PM (#11881889)
I think that if the hurdle of using OSX to develop for Apple platforms is so high to one that they'd describe it as "fundamentally developer hostile", then yes.

It just doesn't make sense to me why anyone thinks they're entitled to have Apple build and support a complex developer toolchain on their platform of choice, and if Apple doesnt, it's a sign of "hostility".

I don't think Apple wants that person building for their platforms. As an apple user and developer, neither do I.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by mkishi on Saturday June 11, 2016 @12:37AM (#11882097)
> What possible benefit could there be to helping people who are hostile to their platforms develop for them? If you want to develop for Apple platforms, you do so from Apple platforms.

That suggests you think every developer who wants to publish iOS apps should either do so from a Mac or they are automatically hostile towards Apple. That's the point I was touching.

I personally wouldn't call Apple's choices hostile and I don't think anyone is entitled to have cross-platform tools. But you made it clear you think I'm an "enemy" as long as I'm not on a Mac, and there would be zero benefits in allowing me to publish apps to my phone.

(ps. I do own a Mac)

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by ryanwaggoner on Saturday June 11, 2016 @01:25AM (#11882214)
No, I was responding to a particular user.
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by kitsunesoba on Saturday June 11, 2016 @03:44AM (#11882537)
They may not be "hostile" but they are most certainly more likely to treat iOS as a second-class citizen or an afterthought, which is obviously not all that desirable. Depending on who you ask a half hearted port is worse than nothing at all.

By requiring a Mac to develop for iOS, they're forcing a certain level of investment which makes it more likely that developers targeting the platform make their apps worth the time spent (for both the dev and the consumer). By opening it up they're welcoming those who port just to tick a box.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by Drakim on Saturday June 11, 2016 @04:51AM (#11882714)
That's ridiculous.

Sure, somebody who doesn't have an iPhone and yet wants to develop apps for the iPhone is likely to treat iOS as a second class citizen.

But you are saying that if somebody bought the iPhone on launch date, and has upgraded to every new model as soon as it came out, and is obsessed with all things iOS....then he is still gonna treat iOS as a second-class citizen because he doesn't own a OSX and a Mac, which are different hardware and a different OS from the device he wants to make an app for??

That's crazy.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by mkishi on Saturday June 11, 2016 @04:49AM (#11882706)
That's a much more reasonable argument. It's also likely the real reason there's no cross-development support.

It does open another thread of discussion, though: as far as I'm aware, there's no proven correlation between buying a Mac and caring about the quality of your iOS product.

I could just as well say that companies that want to tick a box for their sub-par apps farm invest in several platforms much more easily than starting devs who can't afford multiple setups and pride themselves in craftsmanship.

Which one is closer to reality or has the bigger impact, I have no idea.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by timecube on Friday June 10, 2016 @10:12PM (#11881654)
Lots of people use iPhones with Windows computers. What actual benefit does this completely arbitrary restriction give to anyone other than Apple?
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by kartickv on Friday June 10, 2016 @10:47PM (#11881764)
It's not an arbitrary restriction. All the tools will have to be reimplemented. Take the simulator, for example. It's implemented by translating iOS system calls into OS X system calls. It's not an entire OS running on a emulated CPU. That won't work on Windows. Will Apple have to implement an emulator? But that will be slower for developers using a Mac. Should have they to support both?

There are significant downsides. You can argue that the upside is still worth it, but you can't dismiss the downsides as "completely arbitrary".

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by sjtgraham on Friday June 10, 2016 @11:23PM (#11881877)
AFAIK this is incorrect the simulator runs x86/x86-64 binaries and links against x86/x86-64 versions of Apple's frameworks (including UIKit). There is no translation of syscalls happening, the instruction for a syscall, e.g SVC 0x80 on ARM wouldn't be happening in your binary but in a framework your binary (indirectly) links to.

Also the simulator is basically an x86 version of iOS, look inside for yourself and see. Someone correct me here but I don't see why it would be impossible to for apple to ship a simulator for Windows, n.b. how MS has shipped the Linux ABI translation.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by kitsunesoba on Saturday June 11, 2016 @03:49AM (#11882555)
The simulator doesn't run a full x86 version of iOS; it runs an x86 version of the iOS userland on top of the host kernel (Darwin) and components shared between OS X and iOS.

A port of the simulator would be possible but it'd be a good deal heavier than its OS X counterpart since it'd be running the entire OS instead of just the topmost layer.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by sjtgraham on Saturday June 11, 2016 @06:15AM (#11882894)
Both platforms share the same core OS (Darwin) and Kernel (XNU), so when I say the simulator is basically an x86 iOS I think that's fair.
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by kartickv on Sunday June 19, 2016 @02:19AM (#11932004)
You're again missing the point that that would be heavier and so perhaps not as good for developers that choose to use macOS.

The question is not whether "the simulator is basically an x86 iOS". The point is that requiring macOS to build iOS apps is not an arbitrary restriction — it's a tradeoff. You can argue for or against Apple's decision, but you can't argue that it's an arbitrary restriction on Apple's part.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by douche on Saturday June 11, 2016 @08:52AM (#11883274)
Why is the simulator not simply a VM loaded with iOS, like with Android, or Windows Phone, or most of the other targets that you can cross-compile and test for from Windows or Linux?
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by pcwalton on Friday June 10, 2016 @10:13PM (#11881655)
The same type of benefit that Apple gets from making iTunes available on Windows: a broader userbase.

A broader base of developers can mean more and higher-quality apps. A better selection of apps can lead to greater sales of iPhones and iPads.

(It also might not. But there is certainly a potential benefit for Apple here.)

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by paulcole on Friday June 10, 2016 @11:30PM (#11881900)
> A broader base of developers can mean more and higher-quality apps.

One word counter-argument: Android.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by pcwalton on Friday June 10, 2016 @11:47PM (#11881944)
I don't think that Android would have had better apps if Android developer tools were Mac-only. The reason behind the Play Store/App Store quality difference has more to do with the way the store is run, the system frameworks (Core Animation vs. the Java frameworks, etc.), and the inclination of users to purchase apps.
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by paulcole on Saturday June 11, 2016 @01:04AM (#11882159)
> I don't think that Android would have had better apps if Android developer tools were Mac-only.

Would it be worse?

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by ChrisLTD on Friday June 10, 2016 @11:14PM (#11881852)
Apple platforms already have the best consumer software, so maybe Apple's strategy is the right one?