News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by thinkloop on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @02:15AM (#11852737)
I felt the same, it doesn't try to address the "hard" problem of consciousness, as described in the article you linked.

It's such an interesting problem because for one, its hard/impossible to prove consciousness. If you built an android that had every if-statement imaginable coded into it so that it behaved exactly like a human, including answering the question of whether it is conscious affirmatively, and showing signs of pain and suffering in bad situations, how will you ever know if it's all just a simulation, or if real feelies are behind it. At what point does it cross over from an extremely complex and useful behavior machine, to one that experiences actual qualia.

Another issue is the purposelessness of consciousness. Why does there have to be experience tied to our reactions to stimuli, if the resulting behaviors are identical. Isn't there quite a bit of wasted energy and skull space that could be better used for more survival oriented if-statements. All of our behavior seems possible without the associated feelings.

The issue of androids is going to be an annoying one in a thousand years. People will be polarized, with some championing android rights because they seem to be conscious, while others will be adamant that they are just complex machines that can be treated any which way. Personally I'd probably err on the side conscious, just in case.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by Houshalter on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @03:28AM (#11852961)
>Isn't there quite a bit of wasted energy and skull space that could be better used for more survival oriented if-statements. All of our behavior seems possible without the associated feelings.

Intelligence isn't about a giant list of arbitrary if then statements though. Think of artificial neural networks. They learn behaviors from experience and reinforcement. They take actions they predict will lead to reward.

How is that fundamentally different than what humans do? I mean our brains algorithms are probably much more complex, but the principles should be the same. Shocking a neural net with negative reward, and it will strongly desire to avoid that again. How is that different than pain?

Add on a bunch of hard wired goals and behaviors more complicated than "pain" and "reward", and you have yourself a conscious being. Not fundamentally different than a human.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by adwn on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @08:26AM (#11853945)
You do have subjective experience, don't you? I mean, you don't just process external stimuli, combine them with an internal state, and generate output signals, like a program would – you can actually "feel" things and see them with "your inner eye"?

I'm not being sarcastic here. Maybe there are people that don't have subjective experience, just like there are people that can hear colors.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by eli_gottlieb on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @01:43PM (#11856154)
> You do have subjective experience, don't you? I mean, you don't just process external stimuli, combine them with an internal state, and generate output signals, like a program would – you can actually "feel" things and see them with "your inner eye"?

Hold on. Did you just claim that people with aphantasia (ie: possibly an inability to feed causal models from someplace (probably the neocortex? IANANS, just work with some) back to the visual cortex and get the visual cortex's "portrayal" of the conditional simulation embodied in the model) have no subjective experience?

What if someone has no "inner eye", but does have "inner ears", an "inner tongue", "inner hands" and all the rest? Or do you group all possible "inner senses" used for imagining "what something is like" into "qualia" without separating them into distinct functionalities that are in bijection with the available physical senses?

Because you might have actually said something interesting here!

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by adwn on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @02:36PM (#11856659)
> Did you just claim that people with aphantasia [...] have no subjective experience?

I don't think so. I wasn't talking about imagination (as in: thinking of a cube and rotating it in your mind), but rather about experiencing the input from my physical eyes. It's as if there's someone inside my head that experiences and feels what I physically see. Of course, this doesn't help: the homunculus model is thoroughly debunked. [1]

> Or do you group all possible "inner senses" used for imagining "what something is like" into "qualia" without separating them into distinct functionalities that are in bijection with the available physical senses?

There are qualia like anxiety or restlessness that are not linked to physical senses, so that's a no on the bijection. I have no idea whether those "inner eyes, ears, etc." that link imagination to physical senses are related to qualia – it's so difficult to imagine myself into different minds. Besides, coming up with an objective, clear, non-recursive definition for subjective experience is way above my paygrade.

Another random thought that I just had: People with depression sometimes hurt themselves physically, because that's the only way they can still feel something (according to them). Maybe this is related to a dampened subjective experience, which allows only extreme inputs to be experienced?

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homunculus_argument

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by eli_gottlieb on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @07:07PM (#11858748)
>It's as if there's someone inside my head that experiences and feels what I physically see.

No, you only imagine that. And I'm being serious: people who aren't brought up being told that consciousness is like having a little homunculus in your head simply never feel "as if" there was one.

>There are qualia like anxiety or restlessness that are not linked to physical senses, so that's a no on the bijection.

I would normally call those emotions rather than qualia. Hmmm. Would you say the "qualia-ness" of things comes from the internal perception that the "feelings" are external to the person who feels, and impinge on them?

>Another random thought that I just had: People with depression sometimes hurt themselves physically, because that's the only way they can still feel something (according to them). Maybe this is related to a dampened subjective experience, which allows only extreme inputs to be experienced?

But dampened affect (dampened emotional signaling in the brain) is already a known and seemingly somewhat understood symptom of depression.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by aninhumer on Wednesday June 08, 2016 @11:56PM (#11867443)
>people who aren't brought up being told that consciousness is like having a little homunculus in your head simply never feel "as if" there was one.

So you're saying people brought up differently are p-zombies? Because that's the only way I can interpret that.

Feeling like there's a homonculous is fundamentally what experiencing the world is like for me, and has been since long before I was able to understand complex philosophical questions about conciousness.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by eli_gottlieb on Thursday June 09, 2016 @12:14PM (#11870332)
>So you're saying people brought up differently are p-zombies?

No, I'm saying that people brought up differently actually identify our selves with our actual, physical bodies, and don't imagine/visualize a tiny little figurine in our head. We have a different experience of the world, not no experience.

To me it seems weirder to say, "When I get bitten by a dog, the little homunculus gets a loud alarm ringing in his little room saying, 'BITTEN BY DOG!'" than "When I get bitten by a dog, its teeth feel sharp and painful."

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by naasking on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @08:36AM (#11854010)
> I mean, you don't just process external stimuli, combine them with an internal state, and generate output signals, like a program would – you can actually "feel" things and see them with "your inner eye"?

You're assuming the conclusion that consciousness isn't just processing external stimuli with internal state to generate output signals, just a particular form of it.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by adwn on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @08:57AM (#11854123)
> You're assuming the conclusion that consciousness isn't just processing external stimuli with internal state to generate output signals, just a particular form of it.

Yes, that is my assumption, because that is what I observe (only in my own mind, of course – I don't know how to observe it in others). I'm not alone, many (most? all?) people are claiming to observe that.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by naasking on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @09:20AM (#11854265)
Except:

1. It isn't a valid observation, because you don't actually observe that consciousness is not part of the process of processing external stimuli. At best, you can observe that consciousness exists.

2. It isn't a valid conclusion even if it were a valid observation. Or do you also conclude that water magically breaks pencils and reconstitutes them when they are removed [1]?

[1] http://cdn.c.photoshelter.com/img-get/I0000KUS4vG.ZoqQ/s/860...

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by aninhumer on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @02:06PM (#11856354)
I observe that conciousness exists, and I can conceive of no way to logically deduce its occurrence from any physical processes, nor any way to consider them as the same thing.

To me, experience itself is fundamentally a separate thing from any process that might cause it to occur, and I don't know how to conceive of it any other way.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by naasking on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @03:56PM (#11857293)
> I can conceive of no way to logically deduce its occurrence from any physical processes, nor any way to consider them as the same thing.

That you cannot conceive of it does not make it inconceivable. In fact, scientific theories [1] exist to explain exactly the functional purpose of consciousness.

[1] http://journal.frontiersin.org/article/10.3389/fpsyg.2015.00...

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by aninhumer on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @04:08PM (#11857388)
>That you cannot conceive of it does not make it inconceivable.

True, but I find it sufficiently difficult to conceive of that I'm not convinced anyone else can. If you claim to be able to, can you explain it to me?

To me, saying experience "is" brain processing is like saying the image on the screen at a cinema "is" projector operation. One may cause the other, but they're still separate things.

> scientific theories [1] exist to explain exactly the functional purpose of consciousness.

But that doesn't explain the mechanism for conciousness to occur, it just explains why it might exist.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by mh-cx on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @04:51PM (#11857703)
> But that doesn't explain the mechanism for conciousness to occur, it just explains why it might exist.

Hmm, what if both, the physical mechanism and the subjective qualia are simply intertwined in a way, that can not be deduced any further?

Maybe it's a little like the relation between gravitational forces and curved space time. Both are basically the same thing. But if you're used to live in one system, it's hard to imagine how it feels to see things from the other perspective.

Still there may be a lot of value to the complementary theory. Much like the GTR opened up a whole new range of physical applications, a physical theory of consciousness may lead to computer systems that we will have to attribute being conscious the same way as we do with our fellow human beings - just because both will follow the same fundamental laws of consciousness.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by aninhumer on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @05:02PM (#11857798)
The two seem fairly trivially separable though. I can imagine a thing that has the same physical mechanisms as me, but does not experience conciousness (i.e. a p-zombie), and I can imagine something with no physical mechanisms that does (i.e. a soul).

Now it's possible neither of those things can actually exist, but the fact that I can imagine them demonstrates the distinction I'm making.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by mh-cx on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @05:15PM (#11857918)
> I can imagine a thing that has the same physical mechanisms as me, but does not experience conciousness (i.e. a p-zombie)

Hmm, really? How? To be honest, I can't. Honestly I think this is just a meaningless mind trick. The more I think about it, the less the notion of a p-zombie really makes sense to me. If a p-zombie existed, and I could never really tell the difference from the outside, this gives rise to many blind-alley-models of the world, for example solipsism: Maybe all others are just p-zombies and maybe I'm the only thing that really exists in the sphere of consciousness (=soul?). I can never know for sure. But if it's true, then there's not really much room for any further discussion.

So I have to assume that everything that behaves like being conscious in fact has a consciousness - even if it isn't even aware of its being conscious.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by aninhumer on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @05:44PM (#11858179)
Of course I assume that other people are concious, but I am nonetheless capable of imagining a person who is not.

And the point isn't whether such a thing is physically possible in our universe, merely that being able to conceive of such a thing identifies the distinction we're drawing. There is a notion of experience separate from the physical process that may cause it, because for any such process, we can imagine a world where it does not actually experience anything.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by naasking on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @04:21PM (#11857477)
> But that doesn't explain the mechanism for conciousness to occur, it just explains why it might exist.

It does explain the mechanism actually. The mind builds representations for predictive purposes, it builds a representation of attention because that increases predictive power in achieving goals, a representation of attention is consciousness.

Certainly it's not sufficiently detailed such that you can build one, but that's not really needed to make it conceivable.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by aninhumer on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @04:27PM (#11857517)
That goes some way to explaining the mechanics, but there's still a vital last step needed to take it from a simulation process to an actual experience of that simulation.

You seem to be describing that step as "representation of attention", but I'm not sure what that's supposed to mean.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by naasking on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @06:30PM (#11858519)
Did you read the paper? Take a look at Figure 1 and contrast 1a and 1b. The combination of perceptions you're paying attention to + focusing on a model of yourself paying attention to your perceptions yields subjectivity. Your brain shifting between the signals from your direct perceptions and signals from your model of yourself focusing on your perceptions is the perceptive difference we call subjective experience. I think the description there explains it quite well if that's unsatisfactory.

Certainly it's lacking in sufficient detail to build an artificial consciousness, but it's not lacking in empirical data and testable hypotheses. It's also a perfect example of how subjective experience could be an illusion that exists, and yet still convince us that it's in some sense fundamental.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by Houshalter on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @12:19PM (#11855497)
Neural networks also have "inner eyes". From being able to "dream" images and sequences that haven't appeared in the training data, but look plausible.

Or being able to manipulate learned concepts. Like word2vec turns words into vectors that can be combined in complicated ways. E.g. words for colors will be different based on what the colors are associated with (e.g. red is associated with "danger", or green is associated with "nature", etc.)

Make this process much more complex, and intelligent, and then ask it what it "feels". It will probably give responses very similar to humans. It "feels" complicated internal experiences that it can't completely explain or understand.

It certainly wouldn't feel like it's "just combining stimuli with internal state to get output signals". Being an algorithm doesn't feel like you are an algorithm, from the inside.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by adwn on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @02:40PM (#11856692)
> It will probably give responses very similar to humans.

Being able to mimic a human's behavior is neither a necessary nor a sufficient condition for having subjective experience.

> Being an algorithm doesn't feel like you are an algorithm, from the inside.

How do you know that? How do you know that an algorithm "feels" anything at all, the way humans do?

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by mh-cx on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @05:06PM (#11857840)
> Being able to mimic a human's behavior is neither a necessary nor a sufficient condition for having subjective experience.

I think that's not the point he tried to make. It's just that it happens that we're human and thus it's easier for us to relate to human-like experiences/feelings. An algorithm is not limited to that.

If we accept that our "feeling like something" is just an emergent phenomenon of our complex model of reality I see no logical reason why we shouldn't ascribe any sufficiently complex model of reality an inherent feeling. Due to our limited physical configuration we will never have access to all kinds of feelings. Much like we will never know how it feels like to be a bat.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by Houshalter on Wednesday June 08, 2016 @11:19AM (#11862803)
>Being able to mimic a human's behavior is neither a necessary nor a sufficient condition for having subjective experience.

I am arguing that it is. Once you move past the "giant lookup table" idea to actual algorithms that explain human behavior. In fact once you find the smallest such algorithm, it must necessarily be an exact simulation of a human brain, and all of our internal experience.

>How do you know that an algorithm "feels" anything at all, the way humans do?

It must feel exactly the same way humans do if it produces exactly the same output.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by taneq on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @09:22PM (#11859353)
Isn't 'feeling something with your inner eye' a part of how 'processing external stimuli combined with my internal state' works?
Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by gnaritas on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @01:44PM (#11856167)
> and see them with "your inner eye"?

Interesting point, not everyone has an inner eye, see aphantasia.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by RivieraKid on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @06:05AM (#11853446)
> How is that fundamentally different than what humans do? I mean our brains algorithms are probably much more complex, but the principles should be the same. Shocking a neural net with negative reward, and it will strongly desire to avoid that again. How is that different than pain?

Because we feel the pain, why? Does neural net feel anything?

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by rdslw on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @07:34AM (#11853728)
There is nothing magical in 'feel the pain' (also love,hate etc).

What about hunger and others? Your body and brain evolved to a current state which releases chemical substances to signal to other parts of body what's going on. Here cut arm is signaling with pain it's hurt and this will/may (after many layers of reduction) hamper your survival chances, thats why you have such signaling in place.

In essence, your pain feeling (and others 'high feelings like love/child etc') is no different than automatic closing your eyes because your eyelashes touched something or you moving out of warm environment because it's not comfort anymore to you or you drinking some water because you're thirsty (BTW try to trink about how that 'I'm thirsty' thought just appeared in your brain - who did it? ;) ).

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by RivieraKid on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @01:45PM (#11856174)
> What about hunger and others?

The same as pain in principle, it's just a type of feeling. Physics can't not only explain them, it can't even define them, because they're subjective experiences.

> Your body and brain evolved to a current state which releases chemical substances to signal to other parts of body what's going on. Here cut arm is signaling with pain it's hurt and this will/may (after many layers of reduction) hamper your survival chances, thats why you have such signaling in place.

I'm sorry, but this is completely irrelevant. When I discuss this people always describe what happens in the human body when we feel pain and how it's evolutionary advantageous - I don't get what's the point of that.

What's happenning in the body when we feel pain is not the question. The problem is why do we feel pain when those physical processes happen. Or more specifically, why do we feel pain when the physical particles in the brain are in certain configurations.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by mnkmnk on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @04:40PM (#11857623)
Isn't feeling pain the equivalent of negative reward? Negative reward must be avoided, similarly, pain must be avoided. Isn't this a good enough reason to feel pain?
Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by RivieraKid on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @05:23PM (#11857982)
Feeling of pain is a type of feeling, a state of mind.

Negative reward (that's an oxymoron lol, let's call it punishment) is an action that leads to an unpleasant feeling such as pain, fear, hunger, etc.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by chillacy on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @02:51PM (#11856775)
Do dogs experience pain? Probably most would say yes, since dogs have been bred to convey their emotions better to humans (though you still have to look at their tail as much as their face).

How about pigs? Pigs are smarter than dogs on many levels, but we're largely okay with slaughtering them for food and not dogs. They haven't been bred to look cute.

Do bugs? Bugs are much simpler than mammals, but they also exhibit aversion to pain.

Have you squashed a bug before?

What I'm getting at is this: we have more empathy for those who look like us. This applies even among humans if you look at results from IATs.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by Houshalter on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @12:11PM (#11855441)
Yes I think a artificial neural net feels pain, perhaps even the same way we do (if it has the right algorithm, any way.)

If you shock it, it will experience a strong desire to avoid being shocked again. If you give it other instincts like "cry when experiencing a negative reward" and "focus all your attention on the source of pain to avoid distraction", etc, it starts to look much more human like too.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by RivieraKid on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @01:11PM (#11855894)
> Yes I think a artificial neural net feels pain, perhaps even the same way we do (if it has the right algorithm, any way.)

We can't even define the feeling of pain, let alone decide whether a neural net feels it.

> If you shock it, it will experience a strong desire to avoid being shocked again. If you give it other instincts like "cry when experiencing a negative reward" and "focus all your attention on the source of pain to avoid distraction", etc, it starts to look much more human like too.

Why would it experience anything? Why would a computer with specific values in its registers feel pain? Would I cause real pain by setting the CPU registers and memory into a specific state?

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by Houshalter on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @01:16PM (#11855932)
>We can't even define the feeling of pain, let alone decide whether a neural net feels it.

I never claimed there was an agreed on definition. But I think this is closer to one.

>Why would a computer with specific values in its registers feel pain? Would I cause real pain by setting the CPU registers and memory into a specific state?

Yes, obviously. The neural net would register your actions as an extremely negative experience, and do everything in it's power to get you to stop. How is that different than torturing a person?

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by RivieraKid on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @04:15PM (#11857431)
> I never claimed there was an agreed on definition. But I think this is closer to one.

If there's ever a "definition", it would be something like - pain is what I feel when this neuron gets activated. Not really a definition though.

> Yes, obviously. The neural net would register your actions as an extremely negative experience, and do everything in it's power to get you to stop. How is that different than torturing a person?

You could also create an analog computer that uses the position of pieces of sand instead of a memory. Does positioning the sand in a specific way cause pain? In fact, there are pretty much infinitely many ways you could encode the memory in sand positions (or atom or molecule positions). So are there infinitely many feelings of pain and joy around us?

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by Houshalter on Wednesday June 08, 2016 @01:21PM (#11863865)
>If there's ever a "definition", it would be something like - pain is what I feel when this neuron gets activated. Not really a definition though.

I would define it more like shocking a neural net with negative reward. A specific kind of learning process that learns to avoid a specific kind of situation, that's pain.

>Does positioning the sand in a specific way cause pain?

Of course not, because sand isn't a computer. The sand isn't doing any computation. It's static and unchanging.

But if you actually made a computer out of sand, and you ran it, then yes, running the computer would be causing pain.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by coldtea on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @01:53PM (#11856254)
>The neural net would register your actions as an extremely negative experience, and do everything in it's power to get you to stop.

Actually the neural net would just adjust some weights, i.e. make some calculations. No pain and no conscious "avoiding with everything in its power" either.

Or if there is, the burden on proof is on you.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by Houshalter on Wednesday June 08, 2016 @01:23PM (#11863878)
>Actually the neural net would just adjust some weights, i.e. make some calculations. No pain and no conscious "avoiding with everything in its power" either.

Yes and your brain does the exact same thing. If you are claiming the brain does magical non physical, non logical things, then the burden of proof is on you.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by aninhumer on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @01:33PM (#11856056)
The experience of pain is not the same thing as reaction to pain. Humans and neural nets both display the latter, but the only instance of the former we can observe is in oneself.

It's possible neural nets do experience pain, but we have no way of knowing that (any more than we do of knowing that other humans do).

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by Houshalter on Wednesday June 08, 2016 @01:30PM (#11863951)
>The experience of pain is not the same thing as reaction to pain.

I'm claiming the neural net does experience pain. It's not merely a reaction, like screaming "ow!" It's actually experiencing it.

Internally, the neural net would experience directing its attention at the source of the pain, a deep desire to avoid it, and everything else that humans do.

>It's possible neural nets do experience pain, but we have no way of knowing that (any more than we do of knowing that other humans do).

That's just silly. Clearly pain, like everything else, must be a real physical thing that exists and can be observed.

If it's a real process that is casually connected to us and the universe, that is. If it's not real or causally connected to us, then how can it exist or be relevant?

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by catawbasam on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @02:11PM (#11856406)
One difference is that you wouldn't be morally condemned, and perhaps imprisoned, for setting CPU registers to a state the neural net was programmed to avoid.

Also, the neural net evolves to meet an objective -- a purpose -- bestowed upon it by an outside power. Do you believe this is true of humans too?

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by Houshalter on Wednesday June 08, 2016 @01:26PM (#11863917)
>One difference is that you wouldn't be morally condemned, and perhaps imprisoned, for setting CPU registers to a state the neural net was programmed to avoid.

Of course you should be though. At least if we are asserting the neural net was advanced enough to be sufficiently human like. Torturing simulations of humans is no different than torturing actual humans.

>Also, the neural net evolves to meet an objective -- a purpose -- bestowed upon it by an outside power. Do you believe this is true of humans too?

The neural net serves humans the same way humans serve evolution.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by sokoloff on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @07:18AM (#11853668)
Is the fact that we feel pain a bug, a feature, or no different from a neural net that learns to avoid that negative reward via electrical impulses rather than electrochemical impulses as we do?
Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by RivieraKid on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @01:15PM (#11855926)
It's not a bug or a feature, the fact we feel or experience anything at all is the most fundamental aspect of our existence. If you think about it, subjective experience is the only thing that exists. All of physics stems from subjective experience. Physics is basically a systematic describtion of the patterns and regularities that we experience and perceive. Example - we see that objects always fall down when dropped - we use gravity to describe this pattern.
Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by aninhumer on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @01:32PM (#11856044)
Certainly experience is the only window we have into existence, and in that sense it is fundamental, but many people believe that matter itself exists regardless of whether we're around to see it.
Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by RivieraKid on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @04:25PM (#11857503)
Depends on what you mean by "matter exists". The way I look at it, only consciousness exists, physical world is just a mental model consistent with what we perceive (see, hear) through consciousness / mind / subjective experience.
Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by aninhumer on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @04:31PM (#11857541)
Well epistemology is hard, which is why I said "believe".

However, the evidence for materialism is that many different consciousnesses exist, and seemingly come into being and cease during the temporal process of the physical world. That would seem to suggest that the consciousnesses are functions of the physical world, rather than vice versa. (Unless you're a solipsist?)

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by RivieraKid on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @05:16PM (#11857929)
Perhaps I'm a solipsist, I generally agree with most of what's on the wiki description. I define consciousness as my feelings, perceptions, thoughts. We imagine other people have consciousness because they act like us. We could define consciousness in a non-solipsistic, objective way, but it would be a fundamentally different thing. Maybe one reason why the hard problem of consciousness is hard is because people hate that solipsism is part of the answer.

By the way, one important argument I forgot to mention that leads to a possible way to define the "third-party" / objective consciousness (in the last point):

- Consciousness is not physical.

- Physical brain can obviously affect the state of consciousness.

- Can consciousness affect the physical brain though? I believe yes, because otherwise we would not be talking about this, I would not write here about consciousness not being physical. However, I'm less convinced about this than the above.

- The consequence is that we should be able to observe something fishy going on in the brain, for example supposedly random quantum processes not being random, which would "break" current physical laws.

- Brains with this fishy behavior are conscious. A fun theory - most likely wrong though - is that you can "tune" / connect physical systems to a consciosness by arranging them in specific way or whatever. And during evolution, the brain has learned to do that, because it was evolutionary advantageous.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by aninhumer on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @05:37PM (#11858109)
More generally, I believe your position is a form of Monism (the universe is made of one thing) called Idealism (that one thing is the mind). Other forms of Monism are Materialism (everything is matter) and Neutral Monism (both mind and matter are made of something else).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monism

>We imagine other people have consciousness because they act like us. We could define consciousness in a non-solipsistic, objective way, but it would be a fundamentally different thing.

I think most people would say conciousness just refers to the experience of qualia, which doesn't require redefinition to allow other people to have it.

>Can consciousness affect the physical brain though? I believe yes, because otherwise we would not be talking about this

I don't think it's necessary. We could essentially be p-zombies, but with a mind along for the ride. We experience making decisions but that's just a projection of the physical brain's processes.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by simonh on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @08:40AM (#11854031)
I think the problem of androids, sometimes referred to as zombies, is based on a fallacy because I don't think it's possible for non-conscious systems to exhibit the behaviours of conscious systems.

I do believe that the experience of consciousness is based in a model of consciousness in the brain. This also leads to our ability to form mental models of other beings, systems and processes which enable us to predict or form theories about their behaviour. It's this existence of a model of our mental world in the brain and our brain's interrogation and interaction with it that leads to concious experience. I don't know the details of how that works and I'm no Philosopher so maybe I'm over simplifying, but it seems to me that something along these lines is the most plausible theory.

Given this, the existence of such models in the processing system of a correspondent should be testable. You should be able to test the ability of the correspondent to form and generate models of itself, beings, processes and systems and interrogate and mutate those models. One example of such systems are games. My favourite ways to test a chat bot Turing Test style is to try and teach it a game or to introspect on itself and it's understanding and expectations of others. A correspondent that cannot form and process such models cannot be conscious, but if it can then if such models lead to consciousness, by definition it must be concious.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by naasking on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @08:34AM (#11853996)
> If you built an android that had every if-statement imaginable coded into it so that it behaved exactly like a human

Except this robot is inconceivable, because it would exceed the size of the universe. The conscious android becomes conceivable when you say its on the human scale and yet still exhibits the same behaviours.

> Another issue is the purposelessness of consciousness. Why does there have to be experience tied to our reactions to stimuli, if the resulting behaviors are identical. Isn't there quite a bit of wasted energy and skull space that could be better used for more survival oriented if-statements. All of our behavior seems possible without the associated feelings.

This theory does explain the purpose of consciousness and qualia, as this poster explains:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11853240

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by coldtea on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @01:57PM (#11856275)
>Except this robot is inconceivable, because it would exceed the size of the universe.

Actually doesn't have to exceed anything at all.

Parent described it as being able to react to every possible situation ever, but you can get the same effects by hard-coding reactions to just a few millions/billions of possible events/discussions that can happen inside a room (and with coarse definition of distinct events), and just let some person with it in a room for 1-2 hours.

Heck, people used to feel Elisa was real...

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by naasking on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @06:36PM (#11858541)
> Parent described it as being able to react to every possible situation ever, but you can get the same effects by hard-coding reactions to just a few millions/billions of possible events/discussions that can happen inside a room (and with coarse definition of distinct events), and just let some person with it in a room for 1-2 hours.

Honestly, I've always found any such construct absolutely trivial to identify. I've been able to stump every chatbot with my first question. No agent that doesn't actually understand would be able to pass a Turing test issued by a trained computer scientist, even if limited to 5 questions.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by coldtea on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @07:53PM (#11859010)
Would a person with Aspergers/autism/etc pass that test?

If not, how could you tell them from the "non understanding" robot?

I also think most robots would pass the "I couldn't tell its a robot" test with flying colors if they responded just like real people in the same settings as everyday conversations -- because those interactions are usually limited in scope, and you don't purposefully try to unmask those people with tricky questions.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by naasking on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @08:08PM (#11859068)
> Would a person with Aspergers/autism/etc pass that test?

Sure, my first question is always simple direct semantics test. Perhaps something like, what's the third word of this sentence if you start counting from the second word? Mitsuku chatbot that won the 2013 chatbot competition got this one right, but if I just slightly rephrased it to, "If I were to ask you what the third word of this sentence is if you started counting from the second word, what would you say?", it got it flat wrong despite having just answered it.

Reflective questions like this are good tests of understanding that are trivial for a person to answer, not so trivial for a system that doesn't truly understand what it's reading.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by tim333 on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @05:14PM (#11857912)
Ok, ask it "If Kim Kardashian was debating Bernie Sanders on whether machines can think, how do you think that conversation would go?" I bet that wasn't on your pre prepared question list.
Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by coldtea on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @07:52PM (#11858999)
No, but it can always answer: "I don't really care for the Kardasians" or "This is a silly question" -- same as I would have in real life actually.
Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by NobleLie on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @10:00AM (#11854530)
Surely there is a mistake when you say such an android would exceed the size of the universe, right? Have you done any calculation or can you cite any source which remotely claims this? Im interested.
Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by naasking on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @11:07AM (#11854986)
The English language consists of over 1,000,000 words. Let's suppose only 200,000 in common use, 1/7 are verbs, 1/2 are nouns. Even if you consider only simple sentences consisting of 3 words with subject-verb-object, the number of permutations of subject-verb-object sentences that an English-speaking human can utter are 28,000 * 100,000 * 28,000 = ~78.5 trillion = ~10^13. This doesn't include adjectives, adverbs, conjunctions or anything more complicated we see in real grammars.

Now consider that this sentence you're reading is 33 words long, so the number of permutations of such sentences is hundreds of orders of magnitude larger, on the order of 10^10000.

The visible universe is estimated to contain 10^80 particles, so even if you could encode a logic gate that could recognize a word in a single particle, it seems you're still just a tad short if you're looking to hard-code intelligent responses.

True understanding consists of building a model to generate new facts as needed, amounting to an impressive compression of facts you've already seen.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by Retric on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @11:53AM (#11855316)
"Blue time smell rainbow sleep die carrot." Like the vast majority of sentences don't parse into anything.

Also, you're assuming zero preprocessing and the vast majority of input meaningful input is reducible due to patterns. "The great big elephant, almost stepped on me." You separate each chunk and deal with them independently. Thus replace "The great big elephant" with Bob. "Bob, almost stepped on me." prevents N! word combinations.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by naasking on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @12:26PM (#11855539)
> You separate each chunk and deal with them independently. Thus replace "The great big elephant" with Bob. "Bob, almost stepped on me." prevents N! word combinations.

You're changing the goalposts. The original post claimed to encode all language parsing and intelligent responses as a static set of if-statements; regardless of whether a sentence makes semantic sense, they must still be recognized in any combination in a fixed set of if-branches and responded to intelligently (like the question "why doesn't this sentence make sense?"). That's not feasible for the reasons I describe.

Parameterization like you describe is precisely the sort of model that an evolved intelligence would exhibit.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by Retric on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @12:33PM (#11855605)
Parameterization works with if statements. If (like("The great big elephant,%"))

Further, the structure of if statements can encode abstractions not explicitly expressed.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by naasking on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @12:48PM (#11855726)
I already responded to this point in my last post. Even if you were to parameterize as a form of compression, which is outside the scope of the original point to which I was responding, it still doesn't meaningfully compress the results because I can just generate a whole new impossibly large set of intelligible questions, like "why doesn't sentence X make sense?". The number of sentences that require intelligent answers is simply impossibly huge for a fixed set of if-statements.
Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by Retric on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @01:36PM (#11856074)
That might be the case, however you did not demonstrate it. My point was if statements can encode abstractions beyond a single huge case statement. You can for example encode a neural net as a set of if up to some granularity.

A much more central issue is context is important. ex: "Yes." is much harder than "why doesn't sentence X make sense?"

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by NobleLie on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @12:11PM (#11855442)
Your example makes sense. But your last paragraph is precisely why its grasping with the most simple and largest of solutions. Id expect the consciousness simulating robot to contain such a fact generator, not some brute force word combiner algorithm. In other words, it'd have a knowledge/concept/argument/etc network.

I recognize the grandparent poster mentioned something about having enough if statements, but yea, thats not how its going to work.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by Houshalter on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @12:38PM (#11855650)
The giant lookup table is objectively not conscious. I mean it has no internal state even. That is why giant lookup tables are often used as examples of processes which appear conscious but aren't.

But what happens when you start compressing that lookup table to an algorithm which is much smaller and produces the same output? It will almost certainly gain a complicated internal state. As you make it smaller and smaller to get to a reasonable size, it gets more like an actual human brain.

It will no longer be a static program - it will have to "learn" from experience and data. That would save a lot of hardcoded rules.

Eventually you will have the smallest possible program that produces the same output exactly. And it will probably be a perfect simulation of a human brain (if that is what you are trying to imitate.) It will produce exactly the same output as a human, and run exactly the same internal algorithm as a human. And now, how on Earth can you say it's not conscious?

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by NobleLie on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @01:28PM (#11856016)
Because it's a possibility that consciousness is not merely observable actions or even internal thoughts (the "output")... but the feelings which guide/cause those actions (where feelings are not defined as an algorithm or computation)

So even if a robot and human had the same input-outmap mapping, one could be "coded" by "consciousness", the other by whatever humans invent as an algorithm. Maybe they will be identical, maybe they wont be. Im certainly not sure.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by Houshalter on Wednesday June 08, 2016 @11:15AM (#11862778)
>Because it's a possibility that consciousness is not merely observable actions or even internal thoughts (the "output")... but the feelings which guide/cause those actions...

If it's actually "caused" by something, then that something must be a physical process which could be simulated. E.g. imagine there is some law of physics that says brains in a certain configuration will say they "feel consciousness" or whatever. That would be a real physical law we could simulate in a computer, and create a simulated brain which behaves exactly the same way.

If our behavior isn't caused by anything, if "consciousness" is casually disconnected from the world we live in, then it's irrelevant. It doesn't explain our behavior in any way, or have anything to do with us.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by joncrocks on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @05:58AM (#11853428)
In case you weren't aware, what you've described in your second paragraph is very similar to a famous thought experiment known as 'the Chinese room' - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_room
Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by codeulike on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @02:27AM (#11852774)
In a few decades I think the use of very sophisticated ais in computer games could become an ethical issue.
Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by tim333 on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @05:09PM (#11857875)
>Why does there have to be experience tied to our reactions to stimuli ?

Maybe because we learn stuff before reacting a lot of the time. Say you want to learn some new sport, you might watch it a while to try to figure out what was going on before trying to play. It's going to be hard to figure out if you are not conscious. You could try saying a p-zombie could also be replaying the goal in its mind to figure how the goalie could have stopped it while not being conscious what it's thinking about but it kind of gets to be a bit of a stretch.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by aninhumer on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @05:15PM (#11857920)
I'm not sure why that's a stretch? Actually feeling and experiencing things is not necessary for any part of that process.
Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by fpvracing on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @02:30AM (#11852782)
> The issue of androids is going to be an annoying one in a thousand years.

Do you really think it will take a thousand years for that situation to arise? I'm betting on less than fifty.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by thinkloop on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @02:41AM (#11852813)
The last 10% always looks really tough for me. For example we kind'of have self-driving cars right now - but when will we have self-driving cars without a driver's cockpit where I can play poker in the back with complete faith that it will handle all situations intelligently, navigate any terrain and manage any situation - seems like 50+ years to me for just that.
Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by adrianN on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @03:30AM (#11852965)
If you want your cars to literally never make a mistake you might have to wait a little longer, but reaching human or superhuman driving ability shouldn't be that hard. Humans are pretty badly equipped for driving, with our shitty reflexes, two eyes and easily distracted brain.
Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by astazangasta on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @12:31PM (#11855579)
Machines are pretty badly equipped for driving, with their shitty machine vision, total lack of socialization, poor ability to interpret context, etc.
Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by coldtea on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @02:01PM (#11856314)
Well, shitty machine vision can include sonars, see behind obstacles and solid objects etc.

And "total lack of socialization" can instead be a full blown cooperative driving network of cars that inform one another for their course.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by astazangasta on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @02:09PM (#11856380)
No, it can't. They still need to be able to understand that a toddler has stepped into the street, that a pedestrian has fallen down drunk in the crossway, that dude X thinks he ought to be able to go first or simply doesn't give a shit what the car thinks. You can't solve this problem by blinking away the world.
Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by coldtea on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @02:37PM (#11856668)
Not sure what you're getting at.

All of the things you mentioned can (and most have) been solved even in the current bunch of self-driving cars.

A toddle stepping into the street? A modern self-driving car sensor can "see" it better than the average driver -- and it doesn't even have to involve actual vision.

I'm not sure what you're arguing against exactly. Actual current research problems with self-driving-car vision are totally different (e.g. disambiguating signals when raining or snowing etc). And nothing insurmountable about these either.

>that dude X thinks he ought to be able to go first or simply doesn't give a shit what the car thinks

Whatever he thinks, if it translates to an actual action in his car, other automatic cars can respond to it in the blink of an eye.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by astazangasta on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @05:49PM (#11858212)
Yes, if you've programmed the scenario in. We might solve specific problems, sure. But how large is the problem space? How much of it have we mapped, and how well does the machine cover it? If there is a long tail of obscure problems that the machine cannot handle because it was not taught how to, machines will remain shitty drivers because they can't respond with creative judgment to a new situation.
Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by coldtea on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @07:50PM (#11858990)
>Yes, if you've programmed the scenario in.

Explicitly programming scenarios in is not how it really works.

>How much of it have we mapped, and how well does the machine cover it?

Enough for Google cars for example to have logged over 300K miles in actual conditions with no incidents.

Also enough to have such things (besides Google's) in pilot operation in several cities the world other, for things ranging from cargo transport to mass transportation (self-driving busses).

It's not like "programming the scenario in" is some huge switch/case statement that needs to cover all possible arrangements of things on the street -- it's machine learning algorithms with several rules and invariants to check and various corrective responses when those are off, and the smartness comes from the combinations of such rules.

>machines will remain shitty drivers because they can't respond with creative judgment to a new situation.

The think is, with the appropriate machine learning algorithms they can both add experience and respond with creative judgement to new situations -- they don't have to have hardcoded responses to them from the start.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by astazangasta on Wednesday June 08, 2016 @01:27AM (#11860221)
https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/feb/29/google-se...

Here is an example of the car failing for precisely the sorts of reasons I describe above.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by coldtea on Wednesday June 08, 2016 @06:29AM (#11861246)
Note what it says: "“Our test driver, who had been watching the bus in the mirror, also expected the bus to slow or stop".

So he made the same assumption as the car did. So what else could it do, magically guess?

Self-driving cars are not infallible -- they model the same assumptions we do. But a benefit is that they can also react much faster than we do -- which won't always save the day of course: if some idiot driving against the traffic, for example, suddenly appears in front of such a car, they will still be an accident in all probability.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by astazangasta on Wednesday June 08, 2016 @09:11AM (#11862002)
This thing drove into a bus, and, also, didn't learn and needed to be reprogrammed so it would drive into buses again. You are being a credulous fanatic, and I am done.
Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by coldtea on Wednesday June 08, 2016 @12:59PM (#11863693)
>This thing drove into a bus

As have thousands of actual human drivers -- and worse.

The human driver also said that he thought the bus would do the same thing the car "brain" thought it would.

>You are being a credulous fanatic, and I am done.

Oh, the irony.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by taneq on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @09:13PM (#11859321)
Machine vision is the same (or at least was before all this convnet wizardry that's going on these days). You could get something pretty good (say 80% accurate) in an afternoon, or something good enough to demo (say 90% accurate) in a week. Then it'll take you 6 months to get to 99% accurate, and 5 years to get to 99.9% accurate. And if you're analyzing one image a second, that's still more than three failures an hour, which is nowhere near useful for any kind of production system.
Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by ajuc on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @02:49AM (#11852830)
> but when will we have self-driving cars without a driver's cockpit where I can play poker in the back with complete faith that it will handle all situations intelligently, navigate any terrain and manage any situation

We could have them now if we equipped all vehicles and pedestrians using roads with simple device to broadcast position, velocity, and planned route.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by brian_cloutier on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @04:21AM (#11853125)
Deer and fallen tree limbs and icy bridges too
Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by astazangasta on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @12:33PM (#11855597)
Light rain
Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by thinkloop on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @02:56AM (#11852855)
Yes we could cheat :)
Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by sharemywin on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @08:27AM (#11853954)
I think you need learning for consciousness so I think you would need to write to the if-then rules as well as read from them.