Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved
by Retric on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @12:33PM
(#11855605)
Parameterization works with if statements. If (like("The great big elephant,%"))
Further, the structure of if statements can encode abstractions not explicitly expressed.
Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved
by naasking on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @12:48PM
(#11855726)
I already responded to this point in my last post. Even if you were to parameterize as a form of compression, which is outside the scope of the original point to which I was responding, it still doesn't meaningfully compress the results because I can just generate a whole new impossibly large set of intelligible questions, like "why doesn't sentence X make sense?". The number of sentences that require intelligent answers is simply impossibly huge for a fixed set of if-statements.
Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved
by Retric on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @01:36PM
(#11856074)
That might be the case, however you did not demonstrate it. My point was if statements can encode abstractions beyond a single huge case statement. You can for example encode a neural net as a set of if up to some granularity.
A much more central issue is context is important. ex: "Yes." is much harder than "why doesn't sentence X make sense?"
You're changing the goalposts. The original post claimed to encode all language parsing and intelligent responses as a static set of if-statements; regardless of whether a sentence makes semantic sense, they must still be recognized in any combination in a fixed set of if-branches and responded to intelligently (like the question "why doesn't this sentence make sense?"). That's not feasible for the reasons I describe.
Parameterization like you describe is precisely the sort of model that an evolved intelligence would exhibit.