News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by naasking on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @12:26PM (#11855539)
> You separate each chunk and deal with them independently. Thus replace "The great big elephant" with Bob. "Bob, almost stepped on me." prevents N! word combinations.

You're changing the goalposts. The original post claimed to encode all language parsing and intelligent responses as a static set of if-statements; regardless of whether a sentence makes semantic sense, they must still be recognized in any combination in a fixed set of if-branches and responded to intelligently (like the question "why doesn't this sentence make sense?"). That's not feasible for the reasons I describe.

Parameterization like you describe is precisely the sort of model that an evolved intelligence would exhibit.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by Retric on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @12:33PM (#11855605)
Parameterization works with if statements. If (like("The great big elephant,%"))

Further, the structure of if statements can encode abstractions not explicitly expressed.

Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by naasking on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @12:48PM (#11855726)
I already responded to this point in my last post. Even if you were to parameterize as a form of compression, which is outside the scope of the original point to which I was responding, it still doesn't meaningfully compress the results because I can just generate a whole new impossibly large set of intelligible questions, like "why doesn't sentence X make sense?". The number of sentences that require intelligent answers is simply impossibly huge for a fixed set of if-statements.
Re:A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved by Retric on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @01:36PM (#11856074)
That might be the case, however you did not demonstrate it. My point was if statements can encode abstractions beyond a single huge case statement. You can for example encode a neural net as a set of if up to some granularity.

A much more central issue is context is important. ex: "Yes." is much harder than "why doesn't sentence X make sense?"