News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:End Geoblocking by buro9 on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:11PM (#11847820)
The example given is the BBC.

A service funded by licence fee payers who are resident in the UK.

Why should a service, that is advert free and wholly paid for by the UK licence payers, be free to people elsewhere?

You may react that it need not be free... i.e. on different terms. And it is, BBC Worldwide exists and material is available for licencing by other television networks, one may watch Top Gear globally.

I'm not even sure that I agree that geoblocking should be removed for commercial copyright holders.

Is it being proposed that all copyrighted material be subjected to compulsory universal licensing? Actually, let's change the question: What is being proposed?

It's fine to say "end geoblocking", yes... down with that, we can all agree it's a pain. But there doesn't seem to be a solution being proposed to say what replaces the existing legal enforcement of copyrights and the resulting contracts which today have led to geoblocking.

Edit: I mentioned the BBC because that was the example given. The general gist of this comment isn't solely about the BBC. What is being proposed?

Re:End Geoblocking by davb on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:41PM (#11848087)
I'm not entirely fond of BBC programming and the licence fee model as a whole. I'd rather see it turn into a subscription service here at home too. That said, it's already funded and paid for so why not let others access it freely? Contribute some art and culture to the world. Unless they're actively marketing to a global audience, allowing free global access won't cost any more than allowing only domestic access†. The output is already paid for, I don't want to spite everyone else by saying "you can't have this".

I'd love to see more art be published as a public good [1], paid for by those who can and freely enjoyed by all alike.

And I say this as a licence fee payer and voter.

However, I'm not sure that legislation is the way to go. There's a fine line between the freedom to profit from your art and the freedom of all to enjoy it - I'd rather see a cultural shift where companies and artist who are well compensated are happy to let their art be freely enjoyed.

† I understand that for an internet-based distribution platform this isn't strictly true (bandwidth and server capacity). But if the will was there, I'm sure a balance could be struck involving liberal traditional syndication and rebroadcast rights, and syndicated CDN infrastructure.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_good

Re:End Geoblocking by takno on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:52PM (#11848179)
The BBC makes a substantial proportion of their revenue, and therefore covers a large percentage of the cost of production, from international sales. This means that rather than it all being paid for and ready to give away you'd see at least 50% budget cuts for stuff like Doctor Who and quite a lot things which are multi-country collaborations between the BBC and other broadcasters would never see the light of day at all.
Re:End Geoblocking by davb on Monday June 06, 2016 @01:28PM (#11848517)
And according to [1][2] from 2012 to 2017, the BBC will pay £1.10bn - £1.55bn to their contractor Capita to manage license enforcement.

A change in licensing model could result in cost saving in this and other areas, and not necessarily mean underfunded programming.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Television_licensing_in_the_Un...

[2] http://www.tvlicensing.co.uk/ss/Satellite?blobcol=urldata&bl...

Re:End Geoblocking by takno on Monday June 06, 2016 @01:36PM (#11848575)
The Wikipedia article you quote states that as the possible earn-out over a 15 year period rather than the 5 year period you suggest. Overall collection costs as quoted in those documents are roughly 2.7%, which isn't wildly off what you might pay for credit card processing fees. I'm no great fan of the license fee myself (although I haven't heard of a compelling alternative), but cost of collection isn't a strong argument against it.
Re:End Geoblocking by davb on Monday June 06, 2016 @01:52PM (#11848738)
You're completely right - I misread that period. Thanks for pointing that out. I'll leave my original comment so your correction still makes sense.

I do, however, think that a minimum of £73.3m per year (£1.1bn / 15yrs) is a disproportionately large figure to pay for license fee enforcement. I absolutely think that the high cost of managing the license fee infrastructure is a good argument against the model, and the removal of those overheads (and others) may offset a some of the lost revenue.

A change in licensing model and overall culture (which I do understand has been attempted several times in the recent past) might result in a more universally appealing BBC. I struggle to find BBC programming very compelling, particularly when compared with other domestic and international broadcasters. They always feel... out of touch.

Re:End Geoblocking by ucaetano on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:45PM (#11848108)
"I'd love to see more art be published as a public good [1], paid for by those who can and freely enjoyed by all alike."

Do you mean "can" as willing to, or forced to?

Re:End Geoblocking by davb on Monday June 06, 2016 @01:24PM (#11848460)
Ideally, "willing to". I'd like to see a cultural shift where everyone sees the value of broadcast media and news, and those who have the means feel it's their responsibility to contribute in order to further the development and sharing of knowledge and culture.

I hate to compare it to open source software (because I don't think we've really settled on an ideal and universally appealing method of funding); but currently depending on the license, open source software is generally freely enjoyable by all and funded by those individuals and corporations who can and wish to do so.

Humble Bundle is another great example. Everyone pays - those with little (money or will to pay) can pay £0.01, those with more can and do pay much more, effectively becoming patrons.

Edit: Humble Bundle is another great example (just to highlight that while not open source, their funding model is innovative and objectively quite successful).

Re:End Geoblocking by __jal on Monday June 06, 2016 @02:18PM (#11848957)
> Why should a service, that is advert free and wholly paid for by the UK licence payers, be free to people elsewhere?

Why should libraries, wholly paid for by local citizens, not demand citizen-units' papers to ensure they are local before allowing them to partake of all that juicy, non-rivalrous knowledge?

Because they are in the business of providing knowledge, not being gate keepers. (They have to gate-keep to some extent, of course, but that is more about keeping the collection healthy.)

Mike Masnik (Techdirt), I think, was the first to make the case that people's understanding of economics seems to break down when encountering zero-cost. It is a real problem.

The BBS example reflects a time when a island nation-state was looking for a way to fund public TV. The non-rivalrous nature of airwave reception led them to a (much mocked and hated, but functional) taxation system.

Now that "broadcast" generally means "internet", for that model to work, artificial scarcity must be employed, denying people benefits that could be provided at zero marginal cost to protect a funding mechanism that only makes sense in hindsight.

Fixing the mechanism to function in a changed world would seem to make more sense to me. But then I'm not British, a politician or dependent on an out of date system for my dinner, so what do I know.

Re:End Geoblocking by brdd on Monday June 06, 2016 @10:29PM (#11852004)
Wait-- not that I necessarily disagree with your entire point, but I have moved several times in my life and every single U.S. library system I have been part of (Houston, Boston, etc) has required some form of confirmation that I live in their taxation/service region. Some of them are nicer--we'll mail you a postcard to confirm you get mail!--but the verification is there.

So I think there is some warrant to restricting access to those who have contributed.

Re:End Geoblocking by studentrob on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @06:13AM (#11853476)
I think it has to do with cost. Most websites are not geo-blocked. It's primarily video that gets blocked.

In the future I imagine geo-blocking will be less common as (1) the cost of video-capable CDNs goes down, and (2) the use of geo-targeted ads go up.

Ultimately it's up to the content provider to decide how to share their content. Those who want their messages to be seen will allow them to be viewed by everyone for whom the provider can do so in a cost-efficient manner.

Re:End Geoblocking by untog on Monday June 06, 2016 @04:38PM (#11850133)
That example doesn't really work - the BBC enforces geo-restrictions because it sells its content internationally, to those who do not pay the license fee. There isn't really a library equivalent of that.
Re:End Geoblocking by eldondev on Monday June 06, 2016 @09:23PM (#11851791)
You could call Inter Library Loans a version of this, but it's free. If my library doesn't have a piece of media, it is very possible that I could get that piece of media from another library across the country. I might pay postage, but depending on the library, it might still be free. Like the non-brit who has not paid the licensing fee, I paid no taxes to the other library, but in this case I can still take advantage of that resource. This sort-of already happens with BBC and US Public Broadcasting, but I don't think BBC probably licenses anything back from WABE here.
Re:End Geoblocking by kevincox on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @09:32AM (#11854366)
But the library that you re borrowing from probably also borrows books from your library. So you have "paid" by sharing the books that your taxes have paid for with that library.
Re:End Geoblocking by narag on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:17PM (#11847877)
Why should a service, that is advert free and wholly paid for by the UK licence payers, be free to people elsewhere?

So, UK license payers enjoy the service they paid for when they're travelling outside the UK, right?

Re:End Geoblocking by mynameismonkey on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:37PM (#11848059)
More to the point, as a Brit living in the USA, I'd be more than happy to pay my license fee from here and keep watching. Right now I "steal" it, which makes me feel bad every time I fire up the VPN. BBC: I will pay you. Others will pay you. This will lower the license fee back home.
Re:End Geoblocking by soneil on Monday June 06, 2016 @04:35PM (#11850105)
> I will pay you. Others will pay you. This will lower the license fee back home.

As I understand it, this isn’t necessarily the case. I understand that the BBC actually investigated making iPlayer available in the US previously. The outcome was that cable networks told them they’d drop BBC America if it was to go ahead. For most networks in the US, BBCA sits in the middle tier - not a premium channel (eg HBO), but not in the basic package. It’s used as bait/value-add to provide incentive for customers to upgrade from the basic package. So for the networks, having the same content available online lowers its value.

This is the basic crunch when it comes to geo-free online streaming vs traditional cable networks. We (customers) want both models available to us, but the two are in direct opposition. And in this case, it’d appear the traditional model is still winning, since BBC International decided that preserving BBCA’s income was more important.

We tend to paint it as rather protectionist, but in most cases, the content-providers do have the option of walking. That they don’t want to, tells us that the existing model is still the more profitable. There’s not much we can do to fight it until this changes.

Re:End Geoblocking by xg15 on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @04:24AM (#11853133)
Excuse the stupid question, but why is BBC still dependent on cross-selling to other cable networks and therefore to bow to their strategic interests? Why couldn't BBC market directly to ent-users as an internet streaming service?
Re:End Geoblocking by jonlucc on Monday June 06, 2016 @01:14PM (#11848383)
I've never been to any part of the UK, and I'd gladly pay BBC similar to Netflix or Hulu rates for access without a VPN. I just like following British shows, and it's very difficult and expensive to get them through other channels (with long delays, for some reason).
Re:End Geoblocking by ptaffs on Monday June 06, 2016 @03:14PM (#11849470)
In simple terms, also a Brit living abroad, I agree. But I think the problem is Entertainment Industry layers of licensing. I believe the BBC pays actors, images and incidental music by industry association (eg BMI), license which may not be global, but only for UK territories. Geo-blocking is more of a problem of super complex royalties and intellectual property management, not simply they don't want to share. Compare with sports events which are licensed by territory for no practical reason except negotiating rights, the successful bidding media outlet is often required by the producer to geo-block.
Re:End Geoblocking by stoozer on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:18PM (#11847891)
So why not provide login access with TV licenses.
Re:End Geoblocking by jwdunne on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:37PM (#11848058)
They don't even do that here. You are only forced to pay the fee by law if you have a device that you use to watch TV as its aired (along with some other rules). The way this is enforced is by someone who goes round to each house and verifies you have a license. They can't force their way in. There isn't a way, as far as I know, where they can just turn your TV access off, unlike cable companies can.

A pass for international use would be a bit odd without doing something like that here at home first.

Re:End Geoblocking by vetinari on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:44PM (#11848107)
This would be actually simple. Encrypt the broadcast and require CAM for decoding. Each card has a number and while there is a payment coming for the card, the card is active.

So next time the broadcast is changing and requires updated tuners (i.e. DVB-T2 and HEVC with 4K), just require one with CI.

Everyone is happy - those, who want TV get TV, those who don't, do not have to pay.

Re:End Geoblocking by IanCal on Monday June 06, 2016 @01:24PM (#11848465)
> They don't even do that here.

They've not been allowed to until very recently, and it's likely that this will be added soon(tm).

Re:End Geoblocking by DanBC on Monday June 06, 2016 @01:33PM (#11848551)
The iPlayer loophole is closing pretty soon though.
Re:End Geoblocking by NTripleOne on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @07:05AM (#11853620)
How so?
Re:End Geoblocking by DanBC on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @09:21AM (#11854271)
The culture secretary has said the loophole is going to be closed soon.

Here's an article about it:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-35708623

Re:End Geoblocking by Cypher on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:25PM (#11847960)
As a paying member, why can't other people around the world experience the shows I've funded. It doesn't cost anything to release a torrent and I'm happy to spread our culture.
Re:End Geoblocking by mpswardle on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:36PM (#11848051)
Since the BBC create a large amount of revenue from licensing the shows out. If it was distributed free then either our license fee would have to go up or they'd have to drop the quality of the content with the reduced funding.
Re:End Geoblocking by ucaetano on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:50PM (#11848161)
Not to mention that they can't legally do it in many places, since they already sold the rights to part of the content in other countries.
Re:End Geoblocking by hardwaresofton on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:30PM (#11847996)
If the organization (and it's paying members, depending on the governance model) could come to that decision, that'd be great, but that's certainly not the default for most organizations that produce such high-value content (I personally think the BBC is one of the best news outfits in the world).

Also, some paying members might prefer to charge those who don't directly contribute to offset the cost of their own contributions.

Re:End Geoblocking by philipov on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:47PM (#11848139)
Except that charging more people doesn't offset; the goal will never be to offset, it will be to generate the greatest possible revenue. Even non-profit corporations have executives who personally benefit from salaries and the power to distribute them.
Re:End Geoblocking by DrJokepu on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:25PM (#11847955)
> Why should a service, that is advert free and wholly paid for by the UK licence payers, be free to people elsewhere?

Because UK residents would have access to the online streams of other EU public broadcasters for free as well.

Re:End Geoblocking by ascorbic on Monday June 06, 2016 @03:46PM (#11849729)
Not much of a balanced trade. The UK is by far the biggest exporter of TV content in Europe. Nowhere else is even close.
Re:End Geoblocking by programLyrique on Monday June 06, 2016 @05:21PM (#11850495)
Source?

According to http://www.digitaltveurope.net/527032/france-and-turkey-join..., worldwide, France ranks 3rd (but I've not been able to find the numbers, and the numbers just for Europe).

Re:End Geoblocking by DrJokepu on Monday June 06, 2016 @05:36PM (#11850612)
We're talking specifically about the BBC (and perhaps Channel 4) here, not the entire British television industry. Even though the BBC have a few internationally successful hit shows, the vast majority of Europeans simply don't speak English well enough to be able enjoy these programmes without some sort of localisation so the audience of these streams would be rather limited in practice.
Re:End Geoblocking by izacus on Monday June 06, 2016 @06:08PM (#11850841)
That's just not true. Significant chunk (50%+) of other Europe speaks english and can easily watch those programs.
Re:End Geoblocking by c3o on Monday June 06, 2016 @06:43PM (#11851077)
I think you're overestimating this. German-speakers, for example, are proficient in English above the EU average but culturally used to watching exclusively dubbed content (widely available because their market is big enough to make it profitable), so mainstream audiences surely won't suddenly switch to consuming English content. I would wager that the Nordic countries are probably the only where both high proficiency and high comfort with untranslated content are close to being mainstream.
Re:End Geoblocking by izacus on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @03:15AM (#11852931)
What exactly are you arguing though? That there's "only" 25% english speakers and that they should still be forbidden from being able to BUY english content because not all their countrymen can speak it?!
Re:End Geoblocking by c3o on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @07:54AM (#11853792)
Ah no, I was arguing that "this would destroy our licensing/localization business" arguments are overblown. It would get rid of discrimination and barriers to the single market and also generate some extra cross-border income, but it would not make established business models unworkable overnight.
Re:End Geoblocking by c3o on Monday June 06, 2016 @03:15PM (#11849477)
Argument #1 has been made well by several sibling comments: I would argue that the TV license fee is not payment for access to BBC content, but a funding mechanism to enable the creation of high-quality public value content which, once successfully financed, should be disseminated as widely as possible.

Argument #2: Estonians pay Estonian TV license fees, Austrians Austrian fees. In a common market and a political union, why do we block eachothers' public-value, publicy funded content from eachother?

Re:End Geoblocking by pmontra on Monday June 06, 2016 @06:41PM (#11851064)
I second that, especially #2.

I also notice the irony of the BBC example with the UK possibly leaving the EU soon.

Re:End Geoblocking by mikestew on Monday June 06, 2016 @03:04PM (#11849377)
Edit: I mentioned the BBC because that was the example given.

I understand that you'd rather not pound on a singular example. But I think the BBC is a prime example. For the last Olympics I wanted BBC coverage, if only because in the U. S. you can...not...get coverage unless you have cable. One can either VPN or do what I did and setup a Linode in London for ssh tunneling. Knowing how the BBC is funded, I wanted to pay my fair share. At the time, unless one lives in the U. K., there is no way to do that. I put a fair effort into trying to find something to tell me how, too, not just "click...didn't find anything, time to enjoy free TV!". Sell me a three week license for $50, say "screw it, Olympics for everyone for three weeks!", something. Or leave money on the table while I give it to Linode.

To branch from the singular example, it annoys me to know end when I want to watch someone's content and they will not take my money. Fine, I can pirate in good conciseness, but I just to click, click, enter CC #, start watching, not go track down a torrent or find out if Linode has a data center in that country, et. al. The Oatmeal has a comic on this very topic that should hang in every content exec's office.

Re:End Geoblocking by samwillis on Monday June 06, 2016 @03:12PM (#11849440)
The olympics isn't just the bbc's content though. It's licensed to broadcasters based in region. The bbc couldn't have sold you a three week viewing license if it wanted to. There is no way they would have permission to do so.

In most cases the broadcaster isn't the content owner. They have a license for their region and nowhere else.

Re:End Geoblocking by mikestew on Monday June 06, 2016 @03:36PM (#11849647)
You're just the messenger so this is in no way directed at you, and I'm pretty sure you're right without any further sources, but I don't care. That's not my problem to solve, as (for this specific example) I already solved it. But while those responsible squabble over rights, and who's got permission to do what with which content, I'm over here giving money to people that have nothing to do with the production of the Olympics.

It's important to understand the "why" of a situation so as to propose reasonable solutions, otherwise one just pulls stuff out of their ass that'll never fly ("all content should just be free", or whatever). But the "well, it's complicated excuse" is just weak. Try that the next time your bug comes up in triage. Go refactor, make it less complicated, get your ass back out there and fix the bug. All the understanding of "why" in the content situation tells me is, "man, you guys are so screwed", because too many entrenched rent-seeking interests don't want to hear my solutions.

No matter, as I said I've solved the problem for me (including just watching less TV). But that isn't going to make the McLaren payments for Warner execs.

Re:End Geoblocking by terryf on Monday June 06, 2016 @02:42PM (#11849177)
Ok, but then let me pay for it. Because I can not pay for it a lot of the time.

Instead of the blocked screen show me "enter credit card for $.99 and watch all you want"

that would be hard to argue with.

Seriously, dragging the entertainment industry along until they realise that the internet actually is global is such a pain.

Re:End Geoblocking by c3o on Monday June 06, 2016 @02:56PM (#11849303)
Rightholders usually don't allow services to let you pay for it if you're from another country.

At least implicitly, their estimation is that accepting your money would damage their ability to exclusively license content 28 times in the EU, and that eroding that system would do more harm to the bottom line than the extra money they might make.

In practice, the vast majority of content is of course not successfully licensed 28 times, so they end up turning away/not even aiming for the majority of their potential customers for the majority of their works.

Whether the current model is really best for rightholders' (maybe just publishers') bottom lines is up for debate -- in their calculation, they are probably biased towards prolonging the established business models that come from the times of terrestrial TV broadcasting/physical media sales.

What is clear, from an EU point of view, is that the geoblocking that is required to enforce this model artificially limits the audience of a lot of European cultural products, forces people to seek out copyright-infringing channels, reinforces digital borders between EU member states, harms lingustic minorities etc -- and is just in fundamental conflict with both the idea of the common EU market and the internet as a global medium.

(Disclosure: I made the campaign site.)

Re:End Geoblocking by PeterisP on Monday June 06, 2016 @05:39PM (#11850630)
Right, so if legislators and voters feel that the current use of the law-granted rights results in undesirable results, they can alter the conditions so that the publishers are not allowed to region-lock or do exclusive licencing limited to a particular part of the EU.

Just as they do with many other industries to facilitate the goal of a single EU market.

Re:End Geoblocking by geodel on Monday June 06, 2016 @03:04PM (#11849379)
Right. Just to add for example HBO's content is way cheaper in India than US itself because they would have to figure what local population can afford there.
Re:End Geoblocking by ascorbic on Monday June 06, 2016 @04:09PM (#11849893)
I'm sure the BBC would love to be able to sell subscriptions around the world. The trouble is its only worth doing that if they can make more money from it than they can from licensing their content to local broadcasters. They're probably not there now, but even if they were, there are years of deals in place everywhere.
Re:End Geoblocking by geodel on Monday June 06, 2016 @02:59PM (#11849331)
How did you figure out $.99 should be sufficient to watch all the content you like?
Re:End Geoblocking by terryf on Monday June 06, 2016 @04:36PM (#11850121)
It's called an example. Please do take it very seriously.
Re:End Geoblocking by click170 on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:20PM (#11847913)
> Why should a service, that is advert free and wholly paid for by the UK licence payers, be free to people elsewhere?

Free would be great, but for the BBC I would settle for being able to pay a fair fee for access.

On the whole I dislike the way every company has their own streaming service these days but BBC pretty consistently produces good quality content and they don't focus exclusively on entertainment, their educational shows are actually what I prefer.

I'm no expert but I can think of a couple ideas.

- stop doing exclusive agreements for a region

- explicitly exclude streaming from agreemnets that do region locking

- treat the internet as a new region entirely

Thoughts?

Edit: mobile typos & formatting

Re:End Geoblocking by josteink on Monday June 06, 2016 @02:21PM (#11848980)
> - treat the internet as a new region entirely

This is actually how the internet work, or at least worked, until the olde guard discovered that it could be used for digital distribution.

Here they had the most perfect distribution mechanism on earth. A global market at their hands, at zero cost, without the need for middle-men.

So what did they do? Did they see the potential this gave them? No, because it didn't match their existing broadcasting licence contracts.

Nope. They did the only thing natural: Instead of changing the contracts, they're trying to change the internet.

Invest everything they could into systems which makes digital distribution painful, less functional, and intentionally delivering all content in incompatible formats not playable by most players and devices (DRMed), and ensure that nobody anywhere any benefits from the new technology, except them.

Why do we even allow them to do this?

If this is how the future is going to work, I might start longing for the 80s again.

I can't wait for these dinosaurs to die. They're ruining this great internet we have here, one bit at a time.

Re:End Geoblocking by mikestew on Monday June 06, 2016 @03:14PM (#11849463)
Here they had the most perfect distribution mechanism on earth. A global market at their hands, at zero cost, without the need for middle-men.

This is the part that mystifies me: sacrifice sales to preserve an old model. Oh, I know that the guilty parties don't think they're sacrificing sales because licensing models, blah, blah, blah. And maybe I need to sit down, do the math, and find out they're right. But it'll take some convincing for me to believe that between these two choices: 1. Hey, 7 billion people on the planet, if you have internet access and $5, you can watch this. 2. Hey, Brits, wanna watch a cool show? Tune in tomorrow. 'mericuns? No, we won't be taking your money right now. But we'll take it next year. When? Oh, we don't know, we have some deals to cut first. Okay, we'll take your money now. What? You found something else to occupy your viewing time in those six month? What's that, Costa Rica? No, I don't even see you on the list. Maybe next year.

...#2 makes the most money. While taking little interest in the whole business, were I to guess it's due to fifedoms and entrenched interests. That Costa Rican distributor wants his cut, too.

Re:End Geoblocking by pmontra on Monday June 06, 2016 @06:54PM (#11851150)
AFAIK it works like this.

Distributor: You want to bypass me and stream your movies to my country? Help yourself but I won't show your movies in theaters and nobody else will do.

Major: sees a sure immediate loss and a possible future gain. The CEO doesn't take risks and keeps getting the money.

However this leaves the door open for new companies with original content that can't be blackmailed by local distributors. Example: Netflix.

Eventually the majors will bypass distributors when theaters won't be so important anymore. It's going to take time.

Re:End Geoblocking by soneil on Monday June 06, 2016 @04:44PM (#11850172)
> This is the part that mystifies me: sacrifice sales to preserve an old model.

The only one I’m familiar with is BBC America in the US. In this case, they’re “sacrificing sales” so preserve the more profitable model. It’s okay to sacrifice sales if those sales are going to cause you more losses than they’re worth (in this case, networks threatening to drop BBCA)

Re:End Geoblocking by csydas on Monday June 06, 2016 @03:50PM (#11849759)
I think what is particularly frustrating about this model is that the locking applies to content even when you've already paid for access. I am an American expat living in Russia currently, and one of my larger regrets is that I cannot watch the content I legally have access to under Amazon Prime because of geo-locking. Prime's original content is not geo-locked in the slightest, but for any other show, movie, music, or book which I have already paid for access to, I am unable to view it simply because I'm in the wrong IP block.

edit: strangely though, as I just noticed on my FireHD, content I downloaded to the device using PrimeVideo in the US is viewable; it's simply streaming Prime content which is forbidden. The technical difference between a copy sitting in a browser cache that was downloaded in Russia and a copy sitting in the temp storage for the FireHD video player that was downloaded in the US is so insignificant it's baffling that one is allowed and the other isn't. Ultimately, both methods (would) accomplish the same goal; watching a licensed show from Prime in the Russian Federation.

I understand, to a degree, that the reason is a complex web of licensing and distributor agreements. But I feel like these agreements have a very tenuous relationship to streaming content as it differs significantly from the purpose of the original agreements, which was to allow local distributors to profit on the licensed content with localized versions; but that was for an entirely different medium. It's an incredibly weird scenario to me because an agreement over physical media from probably a decade or two ago is preventing me from viewing digital media which wasn't even an option at the time of the original agreements.

There's no extra cost to Amazon to let me watch my stupid shows in St. Petersburg, and as I'm not interested in DVDs/Bluray anyways, it's not as if access to said streams is costing any distributors anything; the "potential sale" was already missed the moment that I got access to the streaming service in the US, both for US distributors and for any foreign distributor.

Individual game companies seem to be able to handle regional distribution even when the economies vary enough to encourage regional pricing; I'm not sure why non-interactive media thinks it cannot do this, or that it would somehow be bad. But it's particularly frustrating that these services, once purchased, work in some places on the planet, but not others, and the only reason is a bunch of agreements made well before the services even existed.

Re:End Geoblocking by ucaetano on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:15PM (#11847865)
I had the same feeling. I read through the site and have no idea of what's being proposed.
Re:End Geoblocking by joaorj on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:23PM (#11847936)
I hate geoblocking, but looking trough the site I only felt like facepalm. It's the same as poverty sucks so let's give 1000$ a month to everybody and somehow where the money will come from will be figured out by someone.
Re:End Geoblocking by rat87 on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @12:24AM (#11852388)
Universal minimum income is a lot nuanced then that.

It's meant to replace a lot of service like food stamps and housing vouchers and let the poor pick what they spend their money on and avoid bureaucracy. It's also meant to prevent the "welfare trap", an over-exaggerated but real problem, where getting a job and earning money can cost you more in benefits then you gain from the job.

There's been interesting studies lately on the effects of direct cash charity and a lot of study showing the effects of the earned income tax credit, 2 things which have strong similarities to universal income.

Re:End Geoblocking by ucaetano on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:28PM (#11847984)
Well, we Swiss just rejected that same idea. No such thing as a free lunch. http://www.swissinfo.ch/directdemocracy/vote-june-6_basic-in...
Re:End Geoblocking by c3o on Monday June 06, 2016 @04:50PM (#11850238)
Can you go into detail how we could improve https://endgeoblocking.eu/#todo ?

I'll expand, at the risk of indulging in jargon:

1. Pass EU law that applies the country of origin principle as seen in the Cable and Satellite Directive to online "broadcasts" as well, establishing legal grounds for services to make passive (non-advertised) sales to customers from countries they have not acquired distribution rights for.

2. The European Commission clarifies that contractual clauses requiring inner-EU geoblocking are null because they do not constitute justified exceptions from the anti-discrimination/antitrust provisions Article 20 of the Services Directive and/or Article 101 TFEU.

3. Parliament & Council pass the Portability Regulation before them today without adding undue restrictions, enabling European to take their paid content subscriptions with them across borders for temporary stays.

The result of these 3 easily doable actions would be to massively reduce geoblocking within the EU by removing the most common obligations to geoblock: Contractual clauses by rightholders and legal uncertainty/risk that causes overblocking/geoblocking-by-default.

Rightholders could continue to bind distributors/services to the release window system (cinemas first, then DVD, then VoD), to restrict which countries they may actively target/advertise to, and of course retain full autonomy over dubbing/subtitling and other localization. Services could continue to geoblock to comply with other local laws (e.g. gambling, child protection).

Re:End Geoblocking by elviejo on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:45PM (#11848109)
What do the UK licence payers win by the current situation?

Why would they loose if people in other contries could see it?

That is the point of post-scarcity economics... The knowledge and information of the BBC could impact millions instead of billions, and the current payers wouldn't miss a thing.

Re:End Geoblocking by stoozer on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:55PM (#11848198)
But they would though. They would lose out on the quality programmes that could have been made with revenue from outside the UK.
Re:End Geoblocking by Faaak on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:22PM (#11847933)
I guess that I somebody wants to see show X, then it will see show X. That can either be done via the provider's website (BBC/YT), via DVD, or via illegal download.

Now, if a british expat is living in Spain and wants to watch the show, they will go on BBC's youtube channel. Video not available ? Well then, go to TPB or any streaming website. Better earn a bit than nothing (eg: GoT).

You only see one end of the problem: if all the countries "open their contents", well then everybody pays for everybody.

Re:End Geoblocking by ucaetano on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:41PM (#11848085)
The vast majority of content isn't owned by countries. BBC content outside the UK isn't (usually) owned by the BBC.
Re:End Geoblocking by Spooky23 on Monday June 06, 2016 @04:21PM (#11849989)
The gist that I came away with was that if you have one market, copyright should be portable across that market.

The iTunes thing is a better example, IMO. Why shouldn't a Slovenian be able to buy something that a Spainard cannot?

Re:End Geoblocking by stormbrew on Monday June 06, 2016 @03:29PM (#11849591)
> Is it being proposed that all copyrighted material be subjected to compulsory universal licensing?

Personally, I think this would be a far better copyright reform than any we've gotten in the last hundred years. Compulsory licensing for music, which is largely in effect for public performance and broadcast performance (in North America at least), enables all sorts of great things that just aren't possible in the modern copyright environment.

I can think of far worse things in the world for owners of copyrighted works who want to sell that work than for them to have to do so in a fair market.

Re:End Geoblocking by zanny on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:17PM (#11847881)
There is certainly an argument to be made for the UK to just let internationals access the BBC content for free, since, one, they get significantly less per view outside of the UK for it (relative to the taxes per Brit that funds the BBC) and two, BBC content can drive demand for the rest of the British entertainment sector globally. There are plenty of films and third party studios operating in the UK, and they would probably appreciate more broad adoption of British media around the world.
Re:End Geoblocking by vertex-four on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:21PM (#11847919)
> There are plenty of films and third party studios operating in the UK, and they would probably appreciate more broad adoption of British media around the world.

On the other hand, they might very well see the BBC providing free access to iPlayer etc to the world as competition within a niche market.

Re:End Geoblocking by IanCal on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:19PM (#11847900)
What is provided by the BBC and provided by BBC Worldwide is entirely different.

Aside, it also depends on what you mean by geoblocking. Should I, who pays for the BBC each month, suddenly lose access because I'm away in France for business?

Or more generally, if people are willing to pay the licence fee, why should it matter where they live? Nobody says it has to be free for everyone outside the UK, but could people outside the UK not pay exactly the same and expect to get the same back?

Re:End Geoblocking by ucaetano on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:26PM (#11847965)
The issue is that the BBC already sold the rights to those other countries. In most cases, it can force the local rights-owners (who paid good money to BBC) to hand them back.
Re:End Geoblocking by return0 on Monday June 06, 2016 @03:37PM (#11849656)
An issue is that there is no option to overcome the limit, by paying for example.

But still, even the BBC argument is weak. I can watch many free streams, which don't even have ads (because they don't have local advertising inventory), made by commercial entities (e.g. sky news, bloomberg) or state-supported (France24). BBC is just pandering to its "proud supporters". The content is already produced. Britons should be proud to show it to the world.

Re:End Geoblocking by K0nserv on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:21PM (#11847921)
Doesn't say the content should be free, it says it should be available. Classic case of "please take my money".
Re:End Geoblocking by ucaetano on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:24PM (#11847948)
It is (usually) available through licensing. And there's a major cost (deal, legal, infrastructure) to making content available in a new country. Who should cover that cost if the demand is too low?
Re:End Geoblocking by K0nserv on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:33PM (#11848032)
I was only correcting the parent regarding the BBC. I don't have enough knowledge about the industry to comment on the surrounding costs, but I imagine that there's a lot of content where it would be worth it.
Re:End Geoblocking by FreeFull on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:24PM (#11847945)
The part that sucks is that you can't access BBC Worldwide content from the UK, only from other countries.
Re:End Geoblocking by lgbr on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:19PM (#11847909)
In order to be fair to people elsewhere, it need not be free. You simply need people elsewhere to pay the same license that the people in the UK do. Currently it's not at all possible to pay the license fee and watch from outside the UK, and this is where the discrimination lies.

But, then again, if I pay a license fee in France, why shouldn't I be able to watch licensed content in the UK? This works for retirement schemes. If I live in the US and pay into Social Security, then after 20 years move to the UK and pay into their pension scheme, subsequently retire there, I will be credited for paying into Social Security despite being paid out by National Insurance.

Re:End Geoblocking by virtualSatai on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:15PM (#11847854)
Wouldn't it make sense for the BBC to sell their service to people outside of the UK? Aren't they allowed to? Or do they already?
Re:End Geoblocking by joaorj on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:21PM (#11847926)
I don't think it makes sense to force business plans on companies.
Re:End Geoblocking by ubernostrum on Monday June 06, 2016 @02:24PM (#11849008)
I don't think it makes sense to force business plans on companies.

And yet we've done it multiple times in the US. We routinely encounter situations in the media industry where a new medium is hated/feared by the entrenched players who try to use refusal to license content as a way to kill the new medium before it takes off. Up until very recently, the standard solution to this, in order to not have artifically-granted monopolies on content stifle technological innovation, was for Congress to impose mandatory licensing schemes on the copyright holders.

That's how cable TV originally got off the ground, for example; over-the-air broadcast networks didn't want to license their content to cable, but Congress imposed mandatory licensing on them. Result: brand-new multi-billion-dollar industry that kept those networks alive a while longer.

Re:End Geoblocking by mynameismonkey on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:40PM (#11848078)
BBC isn't a company in the traditional sense, it's a public service established by charter. The UK can and does "force" it to do many things.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BBC#Charter

Re:End Geoblocking by ucaetano on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:16PM (#11847871)
They do that already, through licensing.
Re:End Geoblocking by dceddia on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:20PM (#11847915)
To individuals, though? Licensing works great if some big company deems it profitable enough to license the show I want to watch, but isn't a full solution otherwise.
Re:End Geoblocking by ucaetano on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:30PM (#11848001)
Sure, but does the additional cost of licensing to individuals make economic sense?

It almost sounds as if people want companies to be forced to make their content available at a desirable price to anyone in the planet, no matter the cost of it.

In other words, people are talking as if they have the "right" to see that content.

Re:End Geoblocking by Karunamon on Monday June 06, 2016 @01:20PM (#11848423)
Rather, when dealing with post-scarcity goods, the seller has two, and only two options: Monetize the people that are getting that content, or spend money and resource playing pirate whackamole.

One of these two things makes money.

We're halfway through the 2010s, if a random web developer can paywall content and take money for access in hours, then the BBC can manage. I want to give them money. They won't let me.

Their loss. My conscience is clear when I watch Countdown through a UK proxy.

Re:End Geoblocking by 794CD01 on Monday June 06, 2016 @05:15PM (#11850461)
Both make money. If the second option didn't, as you disingenuously imply, they wouldn't be trying to stop the piracy.
Re:End Geoblocking by Karunamon on Monday June 06, 2016 @05:53PM (#11850730)
That implies a rational business. Rationally, new content ends up on the internet, unencrypted, within minutes of air, and all the whackamole in the world doesn't change that.

All the anti-piracy methods practiced by major content providers is inherently irrational.

Re:End Geoblocking by Fargren on Monday June 06, 2016 @07:16PM (#11851277)
Not all of them. The ones that convince people that piracy is immoral may actually get some people to buy content.
Re:End Geoblocking by 794CD01 on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @09:44AM (#11854436)
That argument is asinine. Murder happens even though we outlaw it and enforce the law. That doesn't make the law ineffectual or "irrational".
Re:End Geoblocking by Karunamon on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @12:45PM (#11855695)
...Please try to understand how "asinine" a comparison between copyright infringement and murder is.
Re:End Geoblocking by 794CD01 on Wednesday June 08, 2016 @10:09AM (#11862346)
Or maybe you should understand the point of the comparison. If it truly makes you feel better, pretend I said speeding.
Re:End Geoblocking by laktak on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:27PM (#11847976)
If I visit the UK I can watch the BBC (I did not pay). If a UK visits another country he can't (he payed). Geolocation does not make sense.
Re:End Geoblocking by yoz-y on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:30PM (#11848007)
But it is the simplest way to assure that vast majority of people who paid can watch and vice versa.
Re:End Geoblocking by ascorbic on Monday June 06, 2016 @03:52PM (#11849773)
If you visit the UK and watch in a hotel then the hotel paid for it. If you're watching on iPlayer then you'll have clicked-through a warning saying you need a licence to watch.
Re:End Geoblocking by pbhjpbhj on Monday June 06, 2016 @05:45PM (#11850676)
>If you're watching on iPlayer then you'll have clicked-through a warning saying you need a licence to watch. //

In the UK you can freely watch iPlayer content as long as it's not currently being broadcast [roughly speaking, it's more nuanced than that]. The laws surrounding license fees refer to broadcasts, on-demand is not broadcast in those terms.

This is a good thing IMO.