News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:End Geoblocking by mikestew on Monday June 06, 2016 @03:04PM (#11849377)
Edit: I mentioned the BBC because that was the example given.

I understand that you'd rather not pound on a singular example. But I think the BBC is a prime example. For the last Olympics I wanted BBC coverage, if only because in the U. S. you can...not...get coverage unless you have cable. One can either VPN or do what I did and setup a Linode in London for ssh tunneling. Knowing how the BBC is funded, I wanted to pay my fair share. At the time, unless one lives in the U. K., there is no way to do that. I put a fair effort into trying to find something to tell me how, too, not just "click...didn't find anything, time to enjoy free TV!". Sell me a three week license for $50, say "screw it, Olympics for everyone for three weeks!", something. Or leave money on the table while I give it to Linode.

To branch from the singular example, it annoys me to know end when I want to watch someone's content and they will not take my money. Fine, I can pirate in good conciseness, but I just to click, click, enter CC #, start watching, not go track down a torrent or find out if Linode has a data center in that country, et. al. The Oatmeal has a comic on this very topic that should hang in every content exec's office.

Re:End Geoblocking by samwillis on Monday June 06, 2016 @03:12PM (#11849440)
The olympics isn't just the bbc's content though. It's licensed to broadcasters based in region. The bbc couldn't have sold you a three week viewing license if it wanted to. There is no way they would have permission to do so.

In most cases the broadcaster isn't the content owner. They have a license for their region and nowhere else.

Re:End Geoblocking by mikestew on Monday June 06, 2016 @03:36PM (#11849647)
You're just the messenger so this is in no way directed at you, and I'm pretty sure you're right without any further sources, but I don't care. That's not my problem to solve, as (for this specific example) I already solved it. But while those responsible squabble over rights, and who's got permission to do what with which content, I'm over here giving money to people that have nothing to do with the production of the Olympics.

It's important to understand the "why" of a situation so as to propose reasonable solutions, otherwise one just pulls stuff out of their ass that'll never fly ("all content should just be free", or whatever). But the "well, it's complicated excuse" is just weak. Try that the next time your bug comes up in triage. Go refactor, make it less complicated, get your ass back out there and fix the bug. All the understanding of "why" in the content situation tells me is, "man, you guys are so screwed", because too many entrenched rent-seeking interests don't want to hear my solutions.

No matter, as I said I've solved the problem for me (including just watching less TV). But that isn't going to make the McLaren payments for Warner execs.