News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by aresant on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @12:08PM (#11807364)
So what else is new.

If you work at Facebook or Google you're benefiting directly from the similarly shady practices they used to grow on their way to being "pillars of tech" today.

Do you remember when at LEAST 20% of Facebook's revenue came from Zynga? Like less than 5 years ago? Many speculated it was considerably higher, but Facebook never provided a full accounting (1).

Or do you remember when Facebook literally had an "affiliate marketing panel" that they worked with at the C-suite level packed with guys selling weight loss affiliate slop? Almost impossible to find reference of it now, was well known in many circles and you can still see references of it here and there. (2)

Or maybe when Google was caught colluding with a notorious gangster when he turned state's evidence to demonstrate to the DOJ how quickly Google was willing to skirt around laws to sell illegally imported drugs? They were fined $500,000,000.00. Google was. (3)

50onRed is clearly engaged in scumb-bag advertising practices, but at least they keep good company.

(1) http://allthingsd.com/20120423/zynga-accounted-for-15-percen...

(2) http://www.shoemoney.com/2009/11/16/dennis-yu-rise-and-fall-... & http://www.jimcockrum.com/blog/2011/10/19/the-biggest-dog-in... & http://techcrunch.com/2009/11/01/how-to-spam-facebook-like-a...

(3) https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/google-forfeits-500-million-g... & https://www.wired.com/2013/05/google-pharma-whitaker-sting/

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by notatoad on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @06:52PM (#11810904)
Or in a similar vein, when YC funded the adware distribution company InstallMonetizer.

https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20130115/17343321692/why-a...

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by eloff on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @12:36PM (#11807573)
Despite the examples you give, I don't think it's fair to lump Facebook and Google in with 50onRed. The former two are mostly above board, with some occasional exceptions, while the latter is completely, morally, underwater.
Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by aresant on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @01:44PM (#11808378)
Clearly it's not an analog comparison, I never said it was.

I wrote my comment because online advertising is a murky and often slimy place.

Facebook & Google are the world's two largest online advertising companies - they sell and influence your attention for a living.

Google now spends more money lobbying the government than any other corporation (1) including GE, Exxon, etc, etc.

Depending on Apple's stock performance Google is either the #1 or #2 most valuable company in the WORLD.

Facebook is not far behind in either category.

Companies, like people, are more complex than the shiny, white-washed PR version.

The 50onRed story is about a cockroach who will live & die quickly, like a million other cockroaches.

I am less interested in the cockroach and more interested in the elephant given it's weight and past propensity for bad behavior.

(1) http://www.dailydot.com/politics/google-political-lobbying-s...

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by kbenson on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @01:53PM (#11808481)
I'm pretty sure I understand your point, but you're going about it in a way that makes it hard to have a useful conversation. You've essentially said "online advertising is bad, because I say so, and these companies are big and they do it, so you should be worried about them."

Is all advertising bad? What makes advertising bad? To what degree do these companies participate in that behavior?

Is all lobbying bad? Should we assume them lobbying is bad because it exists? Is the total dollars spent lobbying the right value to look at? Perhaps lobbying dollars per revenue, pre profit, or per employee is a more important metric?

I would love to discuss any one of these topics, but your comment is too vague on any details to be able to start from any useful point, so I've resorted to asking for clarification.

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by TeMPOraL on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @03:21PM (#11809336)
I think the GP's points in the comment you replied to are basically:

- advertising in general is a "a murky and often slimy place"

- Google and Facebook are two behemots, who live in and out of that "murky place"

- given their side, influence over public life (as evidenced by lobbying efforts, besides the usual things), and "past propensity for bad behavior" (as the GP tried to evidence with some examples), they're much more interesting to look at than some random startup that's obviously evil, but also obviously not as influential

At least that's how I understood it.

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by kbenson on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @03:45PM (#11809566)
Sure, and that's the general idea I got too. My response was really meant to outline that there wasn't much concrete to discuss there, but I think there could be. For example, are we using bad as synonymous for illegal, or are we extending it to include non-illegal but generally frowned upon (at least the those that frequent here) behavior, such as issues to do with privacy or strong-arm tactics? Additionally, to cut through the media and perception of behavior, it would be interesting to explore what percentage of the company, by employee count, division, revenue or profit, has been party to the bad behavior we're talking about, and how high in the company structure were they?

Put another way, I think they are definitely very interesting to look at, but I'm not sure whether they are as relevant to look at in a discussion about bad corporate behavior without exploring some of these topics. As such, I'm just doing my best to try to entice people into what I think is a more interesting conversation in this sub-thread. :)

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by neumann on Wednesday June 01, 2016 @11:41AM (#11815282)
Then make an argument for it.

If you want to do your best, then don't try to lure the discussion in a different direction with semantics, random questions and flashcards, just state a clear point of view and it will become the starting point of the debate if others agree or disagree.

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by kbenson on Wednesday June 01, 2016 @07:19PM (#11819103)
Not all discussions require you have a fully formed opinion about a topic. Arguments do (or at least should), but I'm not trying to argue, I'm trying to discuss. Not everything has to be an argument or debate, but a discussion may contain one or more of those.

More succinctly, I'm not sure what the best way to handle the questions I posed is, but I do think those are questions worth asking. Should I have just stated that not all online advertising is bad? Maybe it is all bad, and someone can make a cogent case for that. If it's not all bad, I think it's important to consider how much bad behavior each company is responsible for, either in total or relative to other behavior. There are a lot of unknowns, but I think one extremely important point is that each of these unknowns weakens the absolutist and unsubstantiated statements the parent of that comment was putting forth. You don't have to show evidence to weaken an unsubstantiated statement, you can just show how it wasn't supported through data or critical thinking.

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by cortesoft on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @06:28PM (#11810791)
All advertising is not bad, but the best part of advertising is the signaling aspect of it.

Targeted advertising breaks that part of advertising: http://zgp.org/targeted-advertising-considered-harmful/

Facebook's entire pitch to advertisers is its ability to target ads, so I do think they are bad for the market.

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by TeMPOraL on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @03:17PM (#11809280)
> Google now spends more money lobbying the government than any other corporation (1) including GE, Exxon, etc, etc.

Didn't realize that, thanks. I wonder where that money goes though; I don't see any big successes in fighting with MAFIAA over not screwing up the Internet.

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by duaneb on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @03:27PM (#11809391)
> The former two are mostly above board, with some occasional exceptions

I'd say the exceptions are where the corporate interests align with moral ones. It's a pity we now view traditional ad providers and ad "injectors" as separate entities with clearly distinct morals—both are still preying on people who probably don't realize they're clicking on ads at all. Google and facebook simply do the footwork on user experience to not alienate the people who do realize a) what a bullshit experience online ads are and b) that they are perfectly able to block them.

I'd prefer the perks over a false sense of integrity in my business. Not that one would have to choose in this case.

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by thefastlane on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @07:34PM (#11811111)
facebook is 'mostly above board'? you're far too kind.
Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by eanzenberg on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @12:34PM (#11807556)
Not sure how you compare 1) and 2) to ad-injections. Those are companies which purchase ad-space on websites which sell ad-space, solved by visiting those sites less. Not ad-ware installed to deliver ads to your browser, solved by switching browsers..? reformatting hard-drive..? replacing your computer..?
Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by Apocryphon on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @01:12PM (#11807994)
Facebook and Google at least have products that are mostly consumer-facing. One wonders what it would be like to work for Palantir.
Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by trhway on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @05:07PM (#11810247)
>One wonders what it would be like to work for Palantir.

these young excited guys running around on University look to be quite happy to be on the cyber front line of defending Motherland against internal and external terrorists and various other enemies.

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by Apocryphon on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @05:20PM (#11810350)
"enemies foreign and domestic"
Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by linkregister on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @01:22PM (#11808114)
It's interesting that you mention Palantir. Can you give some more detail as to what unethical business practices are conducted there, or are you simply referring to the HBGary business proposal scandal revealed in the Stratfor leaks in 2012?

Disclosure: if you look through my comment history, I have a moderate pro-Palantir bias. So "shill" accusations are slightly appropriate.

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by Apocryphon on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @01:36PM (#11808301)
It's more of a general perception of shadiness: https://www.designernews.co/comments/85691
Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by linkregister on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @01:54PM (#11808495)
Why didn't you just post the links themselves instead of the indirection to Designer News?
Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by Apocryphon on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @02:03PM (#11808584)
I wanted to cite the original poster who found and assembled those links as a secondary source.
Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by morgante on Thursday June 02, 2016 @12:21AM (#11820341)
> It's interesting that you mention Palantir.

I consider building software to purposefully enable dragnet surveillance one of the least moral things you can do.

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by smt88 on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @12:29PM (#11807521)
One major difference is that Facebook and Google also provide value to their users. They do good and bad things. The company in the article did only bad things.
Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by vthallam on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @01:18PM (#11808070)
Wow! So it balances out? I am not supporting 50onRed here, but the point that doing some good and some bad things is okay, is no good.
Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by kbenson on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @01:42PM (#11808362)
Nobody excused Google or Facebook for their problems, but this was presented as a comparison, and one between companies that have many legitimate and and non-problematic divisions and products to a company whose sole purpose is to circumvent control of the user and the authors of the content they are viewing.
Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by avs733 on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @02:04PM (#11808605)
I think the company in the article would argue that they provide value as well.
Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by rconti on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @02:58PM (#11809094)
Yup. They felt that they helped keep content free, even though $0.00 of the revenue they invented actually went to content generators.
Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by collyw on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @02:29PM (#11808815)
Ask the end users instead.
Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by cookiecaper on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @05:28PM (#11810409)
Who's the end user? The company that pays 50onRed for ad placement is presumably satisfied and sees a corresponding spike in conversions. In theory, the viewer of the ad is grateful that they were made aware of a product or service that was relevant to their interests and/or needs, as evidenced by 50onRed obtaining a good conversion rate for its client.

Pretty easy to rationalize it. The most problematic part would be the way it gets installed on user computers (covertly), but which could also pretty easily be rationalized away by saying that users don't understand all that tech mumbo-jumbo, and they just want to be sold things that they want and/or need.

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by morgante on Thursday June 02, 2016 @12:24AM (#11820355)
It's really not that hard. Find a person who uses 500onRed (as a consumer). Ask them how satisfied they are with it.

They'll probably have no idea what you're talking about and once you explain that it's inserting the advertisements into Wikipedia and such they'll hate it.

In contrast, Facebook is completely honest about what they're doing: providing a free service in exchange for the ability to advertise to you. Hundreds of millions of people are happy with that trade.

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by fiatmoney on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @12:43PM (#11807653)
Every nation is built on a hill of skulls. "Has done in the past" is not the same as "is currently doing".
Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by chao- on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @01:19PM (#11808081)
The logical extension of that is a justification for current, smaller players building new "hills of skulls" in their quest to build their own new nation. But hey! You know, once they're big too, they can put it all the shady dealings in the past and be one of the good guys, and it'll all be fine!

It's a weak justification.

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by kbenson on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @01:44PM (#11808387)
> The logical extension of that is a justification for current, smaller players building new "hills of skulls" in their quest to build their own new nation.

Maybe you can explain this logical extension, because I don't see it. At a minimum, it's not self-evident.

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by chao- on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @03:22PM (#11809344)
Precisely what lhc- says. When you wrote:

> "Has done in the past" is not the same as "is currently doing".

Because the "is currently doing" is predicated on a path to success that rested on "has done in the past", I interpreted that as promoting an "ends justifies the means" strategy of growing a company. That is: If you have to do bad things to get to be big enough to do good things, well so be it.

Similarly, you later wrote:

> In my experience, plenty of people do things when they are young that they are ashamed of later in life, and would not repeat. Why should I believe the same can't be said of a company, which is made up of people?

I don't disagree with your statements as observations. I disagree with the lackadaisical presentation of this sort of corporate behavior as something which, by-and-by, people should let slide, so why worry about it?

Furthermore, a young person is comprised (by definition) of a single young person. A young company can sometimes be made up of young people. However, a young company can also be made up of seasoned, cynical people who take seriously the attitude of doing bad when it helps you succeed, and well, maybe some good when you can afford to later on.

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by kbenson on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @04:04PM (#11809734)
> Because the "is currently doing" is predicated on a path to success that rested on "has done in the past"

Upon closer reading of the original statement, I agree. I think the core point I wasn't accounting for is "every nation". If every example includes an attribute, then it's not logical to assume the next item won't.

> I disagree with the lackadaisical presentation of this sort of corporate behavior as something which, by-and-by, people should let slide, so why worry about it?

Are they letting it slide? The Google pharmaceuticals ads scandal was resolved with Google forfeiting the gross revenue of the program to the tune of 500 million. That can be interpreted multiple ways, depending on whether you believe that was an adequate punishment, or whether you think that could have been a learning experience. Is having the government punish Google, given their mandate by the people to police this, sufficient to consider it accounted for? Does the bank robber who gets out of jail after 10-15 years still deserved to be ostracized by the community, or has the punishment already been paid?

> Furthermore, a young person is comprised (by definition) of a single young person. A young company can sometimes be made up of young people. However, a young company can also be made up of seasoned, cynical people who take seriously the attitude of doing bad when it helps you succeed, and well, maybe some good when you can afford to later on.

I wasn't trying to focus on young vs old in company or employee age, but that time can cause change in a person as well as a company (it's entirely possible 10 years on that a company may not share a single employee or board member with the prior incarnation). This is the Theseus' Paradox[1] applied to corporate entities, past behavior, and current standing.

1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ship_of_Theseus

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by lhc- on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @02:14PM (#11808693)
You're saying we should ignore past bad behavior because Google, Facebook, etc. are good guys now. Logically, that would lead us to excuse current bad behavior by smaller companies because everyone does it, and they'll do good once they are big enough.
Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by kbenson on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @02:33PM (#11808872)
> You're saying we should ignore past bad behavior because Google, Facebook, etc. are good guys now.

No, I simply asked for someone to explain on their reasoning.

> Logically, that would lead us to excuse current bad behavior by smaller companies because everyone does it, and they'll do good once they are big enough.

I don't think that's necessarily logical at all. It assumes a lot of things which we don't know. For example, what rate of companies that exhibit bad behavior survive to become companies that later exhibit good behavior? Does whether the bad behavior was endemic to the company or restricted to specific divisions matter? How much does a change in management affect outcome?

In my experience, plenty of people do things when they are young that they are ashamed of later in life, and would not repeat. Why should I believe the same can't be said of a company, which is made up of people?

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by phjesusthatguy3 on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @02:13PM (#11808685)
>Every nation is built on a hill of skulls

Did you quote that from somewhere? Because that is an amazing turn of phrase.

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by phonon on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @03:27PM (#11809392)
Probably thinking of the founding of Rome. (Fratricide) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Romulus_and_Remus
Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by mcguire on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @04:48PM (#11810099)
No one who eats meat can have a stronger ethical position than the guy who kills the chickens. If you enjoy the results, you cannot avoid responsibility for how the results were achieved.
Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by tropo on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @06:49PM (#11810884)
You have a very different perspective. I think it leads you to believe that other people are all in denial, and would obviously be upset (feel shame, horror, etc.) if forced to accept the reality of chickens being killed. In other words, "meat is murder" for you.

I assure you, this is not how we all feel. I look at an animal and I see food. Trips to the zoo make me hungry. The only ones I don't want on the menu are the biohazards, the toxic ones, and the bad-tasting ones. My only reservation about killing them is the same as with changing the oil on my car: it's messy, dirty work.

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by mcguire on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @08:32PM (#11811342)
That's perfectly fine (though if you don't mind, I'll ask you to stay away from my pets). Why would you think it would be?
Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by tropo on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @09:21PM (#11811512)
Why what? Are you asking why I'd see it that way?

I think it has to do with making a sharp distinction between human and non-human. I feel that there is a strange commonality between animal rights activists and the people who enjoy torturing animals, with both sides seeing the animals as being relatively human, to love or to torture. The animals are being personified, then treated to good or evil. We don't have to personify animals. We can view them more like vegetables. Pretty much nobody sheds a tear when chopping vegetables, onions excepted. Pretty much nobody can sadistically enjoy it either. It's just food.

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by dbdr on Wednesday June 01, 2016 @03:18PM (#11817325)
Vegetables do not suffer. Animals suffer.
Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by alaskanloops on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @01:35PM (#11808285)
Considering 50onRed started as an ad network on facebook helping companies like Zynga, as explained in the article, point 1 can most likely in part be blamed on them.
Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by prostoalex on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @02:48PM (#11809012)
I think what you're describing as dirty transgressions is a natural cycle in evolution of auction-based ad systems. When early marketplaces price the leads at several pennies an action, weight loss and herbal supplement affiliates crowd in, as it makes financial sense for them.

As the cost per lead is bid up, they are eventually forced to drop out.

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by cookiecaper on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @12:40PM (#11807627)
Yeah, I think one of the dirty secrets that doesn't really come across until you've been in the entrepreneurial trenches for a while is that most people who make a lot of money end up doing so not by being paragons of morality, but by skirting rules and doing things other people may find questionable or unfair. YC itself acknowledges this to an extent by saying that good founders are moral, but that they are not "goody-two-shoes" and they break rules "that don't matter".

Of course, the material value of each rule is in the eye of the beholder; surely the cab drivers of the world felt that there was material value to adhering to their regulations and that it would not be moral or necessarily safe to circumvent those regulations. Then Uber came along and its founders entered the pantheon of those that break "rules that don't matter". Ditto for Airbnb.

Most types of marketing and PR are morally dubious. But you have to play that game if you're going to get anywhere.

That's the secret that entrepreneurs have to learn, the secret that doesn't get shown in the profile pieces or the television specials. "Might makes right" in this world and if you want to be a successful entrepreneur, you need to loosen from a theoretical moral ideal to a practical one that is informed by the competitive landscape of capitalism. You can nitpick and find fault with most money-making techniques, so you just have to try to do something you can be reasonably comfortable with, acknowledging that in a competitive landscape, sometimes uncomfortable choices have to be made.

If you do find something that makes money and has no competitors, thus allowing you to not worry about underhanded techniques to steal your marketshare, take advantage of your early position to decisively corner the market. That means employing the same techniques that would be employed against you, because those techniques will be employed against you pretty soon. I know this because one of my companies was roundly beaten after a spammer started a competitor and engaged SEO link rings to inorganically alter his ranking, among other tactics that I was morally "above" until my company was pwned that way. Now I understand you must play that game, that everyone plays that game, and they just don't talk about it because it doesn't help them to do so. It helps them to keep potential competitors naive.

Playing by the rules may be the cool way to do it, but in the real world, it doesn't work, because there is someone who is willing to break those rules. How many entrepreneurs started on something like Uber but quit because they saw the regulatory landscape and a) didn't have the millions to fight cities and the cab industry; b) didn't want to run afoul of city regulations in the first place? Do what YC does: break whatever rules are in your way and then afterwards say they were rules that "didn't matter". If you say this from a position of success, people will believe you.

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by TeMPOraL on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @03:28PM (#11809403)
> Now I understand you must play that game, that everyone plays that game, and they just don't talk about it because it doesn't help them to do so. It helps them to keep potential competitors naive.

Yeah, and that's the primary reason I increasingly don't want to be an entrepreneur. Call me naive, but even if I could somehow handle the necessary sacrifice of conscience to be able to compete in the marketplace, I think I wouldn't like the person I would become very much.

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by jpeg_hero on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @04:07PM (#11809757)
but then unfortunately you'll be an employee of an entrepreneur that crosses that line....

..and if you are morally above that, then you'll work as a rent-seeker in a government office that taxes that entrepreneur.

only way to win, is to not play.

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by TeMPOraL on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @04:17PM (#11809842)
I had an employer once who was about to cross the line, by getting a project from the gambling business. A cool software/hardware project (service interfaces for casino machines) that seemed to match my skills. I flat-out declined participation. He actually was very relieved, he was himself uncomfortable with it.

The other time I threatened my employer with leaving on the spot if I ever see the shady spam-marketing tactics they were discussing popping up on my blog. I'm not sure if it worked or if they decided to never again talk about marketing strategy in my presence.

There are many jobs out there that are morally acceptable. Not as many as I'd like, but fortunately I've managed to find one, and I'm sticking to it at the moment. But yeah, I get your point - after hearing stories about various shenanigans my non-tech friends were asked to do at their jobs, I'm under firm impression that most companies are in fact fucking over their customers whenever possible.

> only way to win, is to not play.

Let's get on with Basic Income. It will be much easier to stick to your morals without the threat of going hungry hanging over your head.

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by pjlegato on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @06:33PM (#11810808)
> Let's get on with Basic Income

Won't that just cause all the amoral people in politics to begin promising to raise the basic income more than the next politician will, reducing all policymaking to a race to bribe the populace, so that they'll ignore all the other amoral things the politicians are doing?

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by dragonwriter on Friday June 03, 2016 @05:11PM (#11833305)
> Won't that just cause all the amoral people in politics to begin promising to raise the basic income more than the next politician will

No, the same as all policymaking now isn't reduced to a race to bribe the populace with tax cuts.

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by danenania on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @10:14PM (#11811683)
At least they'd be bribing the populace rather than the wealthy.
Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by pjlegato on Friday June 03, 2016 @04:52PM (#11833201)
The wealthy would still get bribed, and a lot more than the pittance that the populace would get.
Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by TeMPOraL on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @06:47PM (#11810877)
Like in Honor Harrington? Let's hope not.
Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by vthallam on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @01:25PM (#11808166)
> If you say this from a position of success, people will believe you

So true! But the founders has to make a call on the extent of this. The Uber and Airbnb example is not a good analogy, since they tried to break/overcome the archaic rules made by cities many years ago. Otherwise I kinda reckon with your argument that in many areas of customer acquisition(SEO/Spammy mail marketing), all companies do have to involve in not so moral things.

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by anon1385 on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @01:29PM (#11808209)
Uber also tried to overcome the "all drivers on the road should have valid insurance" rules.
Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by hueving on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @01:18PM (#11808061)
>you need to loosen from a theoretical moral ideal to a practical one that is informed by the competitive landscape of capitalism

Not necessarily. It's very easy to think that existing industry protection laws are immoral and operate a company that skirts those laws without breaking morals.

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by st3v3r on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @02:28PM (#11808806)
Can you? I mean, at that point, you're basically deciding that a people are not allowed to self govern themselves.
Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by hueving on Saturday June 04, 2016 @03:52AM (#11835427)
Yes, it's very easy to operate within personal moral boundaries when you fundamentally believe existing government laws support immoral stances. (e.g. drug dealers selling people marijuana for pain relief or people refusing to transact with slave owners)
Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by zeveb on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @02:53PM (#11809051)
Alternatively, it's existing-industry-protecting rules which have basically decided that people are not allowed to govern themselves. After all, without those rules people would be free to only patronise barbers who have acquired licenses, taxi drivers who belong to a cartel &c.

Working around that is deciding that people aren't allowed to govern others.

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by TeMPOraL on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @03:29PM (#11809428)
> After all, without those rules people would be free to only patronise barbers who have acquired licenses, taxi drivers who belong to a cartel &c.

And would then get screwed by them so badly they'd ask for those rules back. After all that's how they got introduced in the first place - to protect people from "entrepreneurs" who will happily exploit them.

That said, this subthread is also a nice example of how one can rationalize both sides in a way that sounds morally bearable :).

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by linkregister on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @01:24PM (#11808147)
> after a spammer started a competitor and engaged SEO link rings to inorganically alter his ranking, among other tactics

How did you find out about this? What could you have done to react to this? I think this would be a fascinating story.

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by vthallam on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @01:28PM (#11808200)
I don't know what happened in this case, but i assume most companies do large PBN's to alter the pagerank and so the search footprint.
Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by j_s on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @01:26PM (#11808172)
YC has invested in and even defended a few companies that have caught flak here on HN for "breaking" the rules.
Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by Bjartr on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @01:23PM (#11808129)
Or, to put it another way, [your company] will either die a hero or live long enough to become the villain.
Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by eyeareque on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @12:32PM (#11807542)
I had never heard about the (3) link and what Google was caught doing. Wow.
Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by yborg on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @01:31PM (#11808238)
I somehow completely missed this at the time as well (the settlement with the DoJ was announced in August 2011).

I also find this bit credible: “We simply know from the documents we reviewed and witnesses we interviewed that Larry Page knew what was going on,” Neronha said. Even for Google at the time, a $500M+ revenue stream from advertising illegal pharmaceuticals can't have escaped notice.

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by hkmurakami on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @01:04PM (#11807870)
> Do you remember when at LEAST 20% of Facebook's revenue came from Zynga? Like less than 5 years ago?

This was cited in the FB S1 filing, which was around March 2012, so you are correct.

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by wdr1 on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @06:11PM (#11810702)
Did you read the article?

It talked about how MS, Google, and others worked to prevent this type of behavior.

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by fredgrott on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @04:31PM (#11809955)
you act like its news..Yahoo use to take big ad partners to strip clubs not 5 years ago