News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by cookiecaper on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @12:40PM (#11807627)
Yeah, I think one of the dirty secrets that doesn't really come across until you've been in the entrepreneurial trenches for a while is that most people who make a lot of money end up doing so not by being paragons of morality, but by skirting rules and doing things other people may find questionable or unfair. YC itself acknowledges this to an extent by saying that good founders are moral, but that they are not "goody-two-shoes" and they break rules "that don't matter".

Of course, the material value of each rule is in the eye of the beholder; surely the cab drivers of the world felt that there was material value to adhering to their regulations and that it would not be moral or necessarily safe to circumvent those regulations. Then Uber came along and its founders entered the pantheon of those that break "rules that don't matter". Ditto for Airbnb.

Most types of marketing and PR are morally dubious. But you have to play that game if you're going to get anywhere.

That's the secret that entrepreneurs have to learn, the secret that doesn't get shown in the profile pieces or the television specials. "Might makes right" in this world and if you want to be a successful entrepreneur, you need to loosen from a theoretical moral ideal to a practical one that is informed by the competitive landscape of capitalism. You can nitpick and find fault with most money-making techniques, so you just have to try to do something you can be reasonably comfortable with, acknowledging that in a competitive landscape, sometimes uncomfortable choices have to be made.

If you do find something that makes money and has no competitors, thus allowing you to not worry about underhanded techniques to steal your marketshare, take advantage of your early position to decisively corner the market. That means employing the same techniques that would be employed against you, because those techniques will be employed against you pretty soon. I know this because one of my companies was roundly beaten after a spammer started a competitor and engaged SEO link rings to inorganically alter his ranking, among other tactics that I was morally "above" until my company was pwned that way. Now I understand you must play that game, that everyone plays that game, and they just don't talk about it because it doesn't help them to do so. It helps them to keep potential competitors naive.

Playing by the rules may be the cool way to do it, but in the real world, it doesn't work, because there is someone who is willing to break those rules. How many entrepreneurs started on something like Uber but quit because they saw the regulatory landscape and a) didn't have the millions to fight cities and the cab industry; b) didn't want to run afoul of city regulations in the first place? Do what YC does: break whatever rules are in your way and then afterwards say they were rules that "didn't matter". If you say this from a position of success, people will believe you.

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by TeMPOraL on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @03:28PM (#11809403)
> Now I understand you must play that game, that everyone plays that game, and they just don't talk about it because it doesn't help them to do so. It helps them to keep potential competitors naive.

Yeah, and that's the primary reason I increasingly don't want to be an entrepreneur. Call me naive, but even if I could somehow handle the necessary sacrifice of conscience to be able to compete in the marketplace, I think I wouldn't like the person I would become very much.

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by jpeg_hero on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @04:07PM (#11809757)
but then unfortunately you'll be an employee of an entrepreneur that crosses that line....

..and if you are morally above that, then you'll work as a rent-seeker in a government office that taxes that entrepreneur.

only way to win, is to not play.

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by TeMPOraL on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @04:17PM (#11809842)
I had an employer once who was about to cross the line, by getting a project from the gambling business. A cool software/hardware project (service interfaces for casino machines) that seemed to match my skills. I flat-out declined participation. He actually was very relieved, he was himself uncomfortable with it.

The other time I threatened my employer with leaving on the spot if I ever see the shady spam-marketing tactics they were discussing popping up on my blog. I'm not sure if it worked or if they decided to never again talk about marketing strategy in my presence.

There are many jobs out there that are morally acceptable. Not as many as I'd like, but fortunately I've managed to find one, and I'm sticking to it at the moment. But yeah, I get your point - after hearing stories about various shenanigans my non-tech friends were asked to do at their jobs, I'm under firm impression that most companies are in fact fucking over their customers whenever possible.

> only way to win, is to not play.

Let's get on with Basic Income. It will be much easier to stick to your morals without the threat of going hungry hanging over your head.

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by pjlegato on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @06:33PM (#11810808)
> Let's get on with Basic Income

Won't that just cause all the amoral people in politics to begin promising to raise the basic income more than the next politician will, reducing all policymaking to a race to bribe the populace, so that they'll ignore all the other amoral things the politicians are doing?

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by dragonwriter on Friday June 03, 2016 @05:11PM (#11833305)
> Won't that just cause all the amoral people in politics to begin promising to raise the basic income more than the next politician will

No, the same as all policymaking now isn't reduced to a race to bribe the populace with tax cuts.

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by danenania on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @10:14PM (#11811683)
At least they'd be bribing the populace rather than the wealthy.
Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by pjlegato on Friday June 03, 2016 @04:52PM (#11833201)
The wealthy would still get bribed, and a lot more than the pittance that the populace would get.
Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by TeMPOraL on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @06:47PM (#11810877)
Like in Honor Harrington? Let's hope not.
Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by vthallam on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @01:25PM (#11808166)
> If you say this from a position of success, people will believe you

So true! But the founders has to make a call on the extent of this. The Uber and Airbnb example is not a good analogy, since they tried to break/overcome the archaic rules made by cities many years ago. Otherwise I kinda reckon with your argument that in many areas of customer acquisition(SEO/Spammy mail marketing), all companies do have to involve in not so moral things.

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by anon1385 on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @01:29PM (#11808209)
Uber also tried to overcome the "all drivers on the road should have valid insurance" rules.
Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by hueving on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @01:18PM (#11808061)
>you need to loosen from a theoretical moral ideal to a practical one that is informed by the competitive landscape of capitalism

Not necessarily. It's very easy to think that existing industry protection laws are immoral and operate a company that skirts those laws without breaking morals.

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by st3v3r on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @02:28PM (#11808806)
Can you? I mean, at that point, you're basically deciding that a people are not allowed to self govern themselves.
Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by hueving on Saturday June 04, 2016 @03:52AM (#11835427)
Yes, it's very easy to operate within personal moral boundaries when you fundamentally believe existing government laws support immoral stances. (e.g. drug dealers selling people marijuana for pain relief or people refusing to transact with slave owners)
Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by zeveb on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @02:53PM (#11809051)
Alternatively, it's existing-industry-protecting rules which have basically decided that people are not allowed to govern themselves. After all, without those rules people would be free to only patronise barbers who have acquired licenses, taxi drivers who belong to a cartel &c.

Working around that is deciding that people aren't allowed to govern others.

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by TeMPOraL on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @03:29PM (#11809428)
> After all, without those rules people would be free to only patronise barbers who have acquired licenses, taxi drivers who belong to a cartel &c.

And would then get screwed by them so badly they'd ask for those rules back. After all that's how they got introduced in the first place - to protect people from "entrepreneurs" who will happily exploit them.

That said, this subthread is also a nice example of how one can rationalize both sides in a way that sounds morally bearable :).

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by linkregister on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @01:24PM (#11808147)
> after a spammer started a competitor and engaged SEO link rings to inorganically alter his ranking, among other tactics

How did you find out about this? What could you have done to react to this? I think this would be a fascinating story.

Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by vthallam on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @01:28PM (#11808200)
I don't know what happened in this case, but i assume most companies do large PBN's to alter the pagerank and so the search footprint.
Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by j_s on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @01:26PM (#11808172)
YC has invested in and even defended a few companies that have caught flak here on HN for "breaking" the rules.
Re:The Perks Are Great, Just Don’t Ask What We Do by Bjartr on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @01:23PM (#11808129)
Or, to put it another way, [your company] will either die a hero or live long enough to become the villain.