News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is ‘grit’ overrated in explaining student success? by alexc05 on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @10:28AM (#11769985)
I worked for 5 years as a high school teacher. In my observation, the "smartest kid in class" could be left in the dust by a "dumb kid" who decided to work hard.

I use quotes because it does raise the question of who is really the smart one there.

In this case, I do mean that the smart kid was the one who immediately showed an understanding of the material and could demonstrate proficiency sometimes beyond the course material... but was too lazy to actually hand in his work.

The other kid needed massive amounts of extra attention, came in every day at lunch to see if he could just put a bit more time in, handed in the work six times with improvements each time... he crushed it.

If anything, `grit` would be underrated in measuring student success if we pegged it at 100% of the variance.

That said, "student success" is only one measure and is, in a number of ways, wildly artificial.

There was an adage to the effect of "you only learn what you pay attention to", but in this case we might also say "you're only graded on what you do"

If student success is measured in grades, and you're only graded on what you do, then doing work (aka: grit) is the only thing that matters.

Re:Is ‘grit’ overrated in explaining student success? by frickinLasers on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @11:38AM (#11770516)
As the "smart kid" I was never able to grasp why all this busy work was important. I thought the point of homework was to prepare the student to pass tests. If I could already pass, why should I be forced to perform countless hours of pointless labor?

Fortunately I still have a work ethic when it makes sense to do work, but fifteen years after high school my lack of study skills is hampering attempts to further my education.

Re:Is ‘grit’ overrated in explaining student success? by pjc50 on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @11:58AM (#11770717)
Yeah, it's a real problem that if you spend your entire education far ahead of the material with no real effort it teaches some very bad habits. Students need to be adequately stretched to remain engaged.
Re:Is ‘grit’ overrated in explaining student success? by Balgair on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @12:47PM (#11771145)
Fantastic. But how is the teacher supposed to know that you are just that smart?

There was likely ~25 kids in the class, and the teacher had no way of knowing that you cheated on the tests or got really lucky. The HW acted as a bulwark against the luck and cheating hypotheses that a teacher should entertain for each of the ~25 students in one of their ~6 classes (~150 students total). So what if you are a just that smart as a teenager? We all knew we were smarter than everyone at that age too. You have to prove that to the teacher in terms of consistent work at a consistent level (Sorta, things happen, Granpas die, parents get in accidents, etc. and teachers know that). 1 person out of ~150 showing up and acing a test tells a teacher nothing. And for the pay levels they get these days, the teachers are there because they want to be.

Re:Is ‘grit’ overrated in explaining student success? by qb45 on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @02:30PM (#11771997)
> But how is the teacher supposed to know that you are just that smart?

For starters, notice that some kids are doing whole lesson's worth of material in the first 15 minutes and figure out that they have no reason to be at this lesson.

The hard question, to which I don't claim to know a silver bullet answer, is where should they be instead. Recognizing who is wasting their time at school isn't that difficult if you spend several hours per week with those kids.

Re:Is ‘grit’ overrated in explaining student success? by forthefuture on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @04:21PM (#11772747)
Yeah maybe my experience was uncommon, but every teacher I've ever had knew I was smart in the first week. When everyone else is a child and you have an adult brain it's hard not to notice.
Re:Is ‘grit’ overrated in explaining student success? by WalterSear on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @05:19PM (#11773205)
> But how is the teacher supposed to know that you are just that smart?

It's part of their job.

Re:Is ‘grit’ overrated in explaining student success? by alexc05 on Thursday May 26, 2016 @02:05PM (#11780159)
Unfortunately there's the drawback brought on by standardized testing and "evidence based" grading systems.

As a teacher in the united kingdom, I do not actually do the marking myself. I gather and estimate the evidence of their grades, but then submit their work to a central exam board.

If a student will not produce the work, they can't get the grade.

My personal evidence that they are smart is actually 100% irrelevant in the context of non-progressive school systems. (virtually anything with standardized testing, league tables, school rankings, etc..)

"it's part of my job" is a wonderful platitude and is really easy to spout while waving your hands in the air to denote "details happen"

but the realities are that the second-smartest kids typically don't do the work and can't get the grades no matter how much coaxing, cajoling and whatnot I try.

Fact is, in a single room with 30 kids, and an annual working student body of ~300 - it's part of the student's job to do the work.

And if we all face facts here, the smart student who squanders their own abilities will actually be fine at the end of the day.

One day they'll decide they want to work, will catch up with the world and land in a distinctly average position like they deserve.

The hardest job and kid who deserves the most attention is the kid from a broken home, who might not get fed every day, whose role models are possibly drug abusing or alcoholic etc... If we invest our effort there we might be able to lift poverty into middle class.

Middle class to distinctly average is nothing we really have to worry about.

Re:Is ‘grit’ overrated in explaining student success? by Kapura on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @11:22AM (#11770415)
As somebody who was that "smart kid" I know that I personally felt that the easy-yet-time-consuming work was just boring. It wasn't until finding classes where I was adequately challenged that I began to care about the assignments, and it took years to develop the sort of persistence and drive that wasn't required of me in school.

Would I have been more successful at university and after graduating if I had more "grit?" I think so. But I didn't need it, so I didn't have it.

What can be done to prevent this? The obvious theoretical answer is to reduce class sizes, so that students can do coursework with other students who learn at a similar rate. If only America would adequately fund education...

Re:Is ‘grit’ overrated in explaining student success? by progressive_dad on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @02:30PM (#11771998)
How about creating federal guidelines under which churches may receive federal and local education funding for using their space as a school 5 days a week.

This would EMPHATICALLY not be vouchers. The funds would only be available to churches that do not currently run a private school.

Get more religious nut jobs out of my child's secular public schools. Reduce class size. Create more teaching jobs. Everyone's happy.

Re:Is ‘grit’ overrated in explaining student success? by Retric on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @10:48AM (#11770134)
HS and collage are both very low hanging fruit. The real question is how much of this do they maintain after 15 years and that's more complex. Some collage seniors forget basic algebra skills if they don't use them regularly.
Re:Is ‘grit’ overrated in explaining student success? by fiatmoney on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @11:18AM (#11770379)
High school is not particularly G-loaded, it rewards conscientiousness far more. That says more about how high school is set up (busywork, non-time-bounded effort signalling games via extracurriculars, rewarding reaching thresholds rather than exceeding them, rewarding generalism rather than specialization, etc), than the general usefulness of intelligence vs conscientiousness.
Re:Is ‘grit’ overrated in explaining student success? by lintiness on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @10:33AM (#11770019)
"I worked for 5 years as a high school teacher. In my observation, the "smartest kid in class" could be left in the dust by a "dumb kid" who decided to work hard."

my experience as a student at top 5 ugrad was similar: kids with top hs grades and work ethic destroyed the truly brilliant students (with top test scores) in terms of academic performance.

Re:Is ‘grit’ overrated in explaining student success? by emp_zealoth on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @07:40PM (#11774052)
I crushed HS. Admitted to top Polish technical uni, dropped out due to health/mental issues I fail at uni hard. But in part it is because how terrible the whole process is. I spend more time trying to find relevant-to-exam-information than actually learning stuff. You literally sit for hours on end, listening to someone drone on. The exams themselves aren't particularly relevant either. I usually get passing grades, maybe a B+. The hard workers get A's...but when you ask them to explain anything they just derp hard.

I will ace almost any actual project. I've signed up for a Rover Challenge team and learned so much more already...

I constantly regret that my knowledge is rather rickety/shallow But at the same time it's rather wide-encompassing

The point is, "academic achievement" is rather moot, IMO. You pick up tools, a soldering iron and suddenly learn there is much more to it

Re:Is ‘grit’ overrated in explaining student success? by Joof on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @11:17AM (#11770370)
It's not that surprising considering the metrics that school uses.
Re:Is ‘grit’ overrated in explaining student success? by stillworks on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @10:39AM (#11770063)
The same ideas are reflected in "Talent is Overrated" but that deals with topics outside of academics mostly.
Re:Is ‘grit’ overrated in explaining student success? by gadders on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @11:39AM (#11770520)
Hard work beats talent when talent doesn't work hard.
Re:Is ‘grit’ overrated in explaining student success? by NoMoreNicksLeft on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @11:43AM (#11770548)
Your comment reads like a parody of public education.

If the smartest kid "failed" because he "didn't hand in his work"... this is a plain and unambiguous confession that your job wasn't to educate, but to make the poodles jump through hoops.

Re:Is ‘grit’ overrated in explaining student success? by pjc50 on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @11:56AM (#11770692)
It's an accurate model of the real world, which very much belongs to those who show up and hand in the work.
Re:Is ‘grit’ overrated in explaining student success? by NoMoreNicksLeft on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @12:36PM (#11771049)
My current job has absolutely zero labor as part of my responsibilities. I do not move things, I do not shape things, I do not package, weld, bolt, grow, or manufacture.

What hard work?

They need me to think. Clearly, intensely, brilliantly at times.

Someone who 'shows up and does the work" will never be able to do what I do, because "showing up and doing the work" is the antithesis of thinking clearly and intensely. It's what unthinking people do.

Here on Hacker News, I suspect most are more like me, and less like those who "show up and do the work". However, there are some vestigial counter-productive work ethics from the early 20th century that haven't completely withered. Or maybe it's just a metaphor that we can't let go of, one that feels important even though whatever it once described is now gone.

Re:Is ‘grit’ overrated in explaining student success? by no_flags on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @01:39PM (#11771581)
I interpreted the parent comment differently. To me, people who "show up" are those who are present, engaged, and making an effort to succeed in good faith. People who "hand in the work" are those who get stuff done, maybe not perfectly but they give it their best shot. They try. I agree with the original comment that these are crucial elements for success, and perhaps more valuable than raw intelligence.

Thinking is an important part of the job for most people on HN, as you rightly noted, but thoughts must lead to actions to produce any sort of value for an employer. The action could be as "simple" as communicating a thought with others (not always simple!).

Re:Is ‘grit’ overrated in explaining student success? by NoMoreNicksLeft on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @04:34PM (#11772846)
My thoughts never lead to action.

I sit in an office chair all day. That's it. No actual work, no actions, ever occur.

It's not even fair to claim me clicking on a mouse or klacking on a keyboard are "actions"... at some point in the future they'll plug a jack into my skull and even those minimal physical movements will be a thing of the past. We're just not there yet.

The sum total of everything I do is thought. Not action.

Re:Is ‘grit’ overrated in explaining student success? by snowwrestler on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @01:42PM (#11771605)
Thinking only changes things if it manifests itself as work of some kind.

Perhaps you are a manager of a team. In that case your work is the communication with your staff, superiors, and peers, which must be complete, clear, and timely.

Or perhaps you are a programmer. In that case your work is the actual writing of code, testing, debugging, deploying, and communicating to manage feedback and plan the next round of work.

Knowing how to code up the next great new feature is not enough. It's not useful until it's coded and deployed, and that takes work.

Re:Is ‘grit’ overrated in explaining student success? by NoMoreNicksLeft on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @04:32PM (#11772834)
> Thinking only changes things if it manifests itself as work of some kind.

I never said I "changed" anything. Little bits get flipped on a hard disk somewhere, or in a ram chip. A computer spits out a different answer, or a new answer, or retains an old answer. Maybe it answers things it didn't answer before.

But "work" and "change", these aren't words I'd ever use to describe that.

> Perhaps you are a manager of a team.

Nope, just got passed over for that promotion a few weeks ago.

> In that case your work is the communication with

Nope, that's not work either. Thinking out loud, maybe.

> In that case your work is the actual writing of code, testing, debugging, deploying,

Not work.

My grandfather worked. Tried to farm on and off throughout his life. Also held down a job as a construction worker well into his 60s. He couldn't do what I do (he's pretty sharp, I think he would have had the mind for it... but his fingers are damn near 2 inches wide).

To call what I do work would feels like an insult to him. Though I think he's proud that I do what I do, rather than what he did.

Work is physical labor. Not everyone is employed to do actual work. Some are in offices, some supervise. They even (often) earn/deserve what they get. Doesn't make it work though.

In a way, considering that the software I produce reduces the need for actual work, I do anti-work. Less of it is accomplished because of my efforts.

Re:Is ‘grit’ overrated in explaining student success? by theorique on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @11:55AM (#11770683)
How can you assess a student who doesn't participate in assessment? It's not a moral judgment of the kid, but an observation that he didn't do the work that was going to be graded.

Or should the teacher award a subjective grade based on "well, this student's actually 'smarter', even though this other student worked a lot harder and completed the assigned work better"?

Re:Is ‘grit’ overrated in explaining student success? by NoMoreNicksLeft on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @12:32PM (#11771017)
You don't even ask the right questions.

Tests, exams, and quizzes are assessments. Homework is, nominally, an attempt to coerce the student into enough practice that they succeed at the real assessment. Most practice will inevitably result in wrong answers and bad scores... if you could complete the practice perfectly you wouldn't need to practice or even take exams. If a student does poorly at homework and gets a 98 on an exam, only the exam should count towards a grade. Their poor scores on homework only indicate initial practice which served its purpose and allowed them to do better on their second (or third, or tenth) attempt which was the exam.

However, less logical human instincts prevail. Teachers who see this improvement don't think "hey that practice paid off" despite that being the most likely explanation (and the only good faith explanation). So, they recursively turn homework into its own assessment. Surely if they cheated to get the 98% on the exam, then using their homework scores will expose the lie. More tests are added, more homework is added, all in the instinctive hope that they surely can't cheat all the time and the predicted inconsistency will prove a guilt that was only theorized due to unfounded suspicion and a moral need for the children to be too stupid to succeed. After all, if these children could do that well, why would they even need teachers at all?

How many public school teachers did you have that demanded that you "show your work" and gave you bad grades for failure to do that? How does that even serve the purpose of assessment? They watched you do the math right there, at your desk. Were you pulling a calculator out of your rectum every time they turned their head, stuffing it back in before they spotted it? If the answers were right, if you did it there in their presence, then this didn't serve the purpose of assessment.

But all this goes even deeper. They simply don't know what to assess. They're too incompetent, too unintellectual to be able to assess any student. They rely on these bad measurements to they can maintain the pretense of assessing a student's education. It's nothing of the sort.

They make the poodles jump through hoops, because that's what the show is.

> Or should the teacher award a subjective grade

This particular phrase is so whacked-out, I don't even know where to begin.

Are grades "awards"? If they are awards, what can they be awards for, other than behavior? You don't award someone a prize for having blue eyes, or any other quality of their being. Why would you award one for them being educated?

Why would you give them a grade, some arbitrary number, a score? "Look, my education penis is bigger than yours!".

How could it ever be anything other than subjective? When they do a double-blind medical study, they're not saying "this pill is 68% effective for Tim Johnson, but 92% effective for John Timson!". That's because the score just doesn't mean much other than in the aggregate. Tim's 68% doesn't mean it was ineffective for him. Too many confounding factors were possible. It doesn't mean that John did better... he might have been healthier at the start of the study.

And if those aren't a measure of the pill, how can that individual number be measure of the patient? Could Tim's 68% have been higher if he had just followed the protocols more diligently? Wouldn't you find it absurd if someone suggested that?

But with teachers and their grades, if the student gets an F it's a measure of the student's failure and not the teacher's. Teachers' unions fight tooth and nail to prevent that public perception from becoming the norm.

Let's not even get into whether John's 92% pill effectiveness grade means he will live longer or be more healthy or any of the other desired effects of the medicine.

Have you ever even thought about any of this? Or did you just keep your head down close to the desk as you slowly scribbled out answers you hoped the poodle master would like? Have you shrugged off every criticism like this your entire life?

Re:Is ‘grit’ overrated in explaining student success? by alexc05 on Thursday May 26, 2016 @02:13PM (#11780226)
I disagree - "does this kid work hard?" is actually a super valuable question to have answered.

Remember all those startup articles that say "ideas are worthless" and "implementation is everything"?

School is a lot like that, and it's a valid measure. It's the rest of us that have a "fundamental misattribution error" in thinking grades are a measure of intelligence.

Re:Is ‘grit’ overrated in explaining student success? by alexc05 on Thursday May 26, 2016 @02:09PM (#11780192)
yup. that's exactly what it is... though you might be taking the wrong lesson from it.

The lesson I took was "work hard, dummy" not "it's unfair that school is so dumb that it doesn't reward smart lazy people for not doing anything"

Just work hard - nobody cares if you feel like a poodle.

Re:Is ‘grit’ overrated in explaining student success? by metaphorm on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @11:50AM (#11770615)
some food for thought.

why did the "smart kid" not hand in her work? why did the "dumb kid? work more diligently?

what kind of environment is required to get the "smart kid" to work diligently on a consistent basis?

Re:Is ‘grit’ overrated in explaining student success? by jeffdavis on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @12:32PM (#11771024)
Recipe to help someone else:

1. Provide challenges near the edge of ability. 2. Ask tons of questions to help the child achieve the goal. 3. Congratulate. 4. Ask tons of critical questions. 5. Go to 1.

Re:Is ‘grit’ overrated in explaining student success? by metaphorm on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @01:10PM (#11771340)
good advice. is it possible to do in the context of American high school classes?
Re:Is ‘grit’ overrated in explaining student success? by jeffdavis on Thursday May 26, 2016 @01:00AM (#11775571)
High school is a resource if you already know how to learn.

Otherwise, it's a day care.