Re:How to Fall 35,000 Feet And Survive (2010)
by jor-el on Sunday May 22, 2016 @10:42PM
(#11751471)
Another good place to land is ant mounds, as in case of Joan Murray. "She approached the ground at 81 miles per hour (130 kilometers per hour), landing on a mound of fire ants. Doctors believe that the shock of being stung over 200 times by the ants released a surge of adrenaline which kept her heart beating" [1]
Re:How to Fall 35,000 Feet And Survive (2010)
by grizzles on Sunday May 22, 2016 @11:57PM
(#11751765)
If there is any decent vertical feature, a good skydiver could try flying into it and sacrificing an arm. It probably wouldn't help but if we are talking optimal strategy here, that's probably near the top.
A friend of mine had his primary fail and he passed out. He woke up before the ground and fired his reserve. That broke his neck. He fell hard, there was no one in the area he fell in, but he was able to gather his chute and walk back to base with his chin on his chest without passing out. Though I think he crawled the last kilometer or so.
He started skydiving again, pretty much as soon as they took off the neck brace that had been screwed into his skull.
Re:How to Fall 35,000 Feet And Survive (2010)
by datashovel on Sunday May 22, 2016 @09:21PM
(#11751160)
There's probably room here for a niche consumer product. Something that one could wear on a flight discretely, that would behave as a makeshift parachute should one find oneself in this circumstance. If it were cheap enough (and not ridiculously uncomfortable) I'd probably consider buying one.
Re:How to Fall 35,000 Feet And Survive (2010)
by tim333 on Sunday May 22, 2016 @09:48PM
(#11751249)
A related niche thing I'd go for would be flight that when arriving at the destination city would drop to 10,000 feet, open a door and allow any passengers carrying parachutes to jump out before continuing to the airport. Much more entertaining than getting a cab.
Re:How to Fall 35,000 Feet And Survive (2010)
by throwaway049 on Monday May 23, 2016 @07:32AM
(#11753150)
Sign me up. When I'm flying home I get very irritated passing over my house on the way to the airport, knowing that it will take me another couple of hours to get back to my house.
Re:How to Fall 35,000 Feet And Survive (2010)
by JoeAltmaier on Monday May 23, 2016 @07:40AM
(#11753186)
I used to get up before the sun, drive 30 miles to the regional airport, wait an hour to get on a plane to Chicago, fly there, wait an hour for another plane to San Jose, get on that and fly for half an hour and then...look down and see my house. THAT sucked.
Re:How to Fall 35,000 Feet And Survive (2010)
by hueving on Sunday May 22, 2016 @10:56PM
(#11751533)
There's a pretty narrow case where that would be useful. If the plane breaks apart at 500mph at cruising altitude you will most likely die immediately.
Re:How to Fall 35,000 Feet And Survive (2010)
by paulddraper on Sunday May 22, 2016 @11:51PM
(#11751737)
Absolutely. If a commercial plane is too damaged to make a reasonable emergency landing, you probably won't get to use your parachute.
The only case it would be useful if if there's nowhere in range to make a reasonable landing -- no airports, no water, no roadways, no flat land. Given that your fly thousands of feet above the ground, it's unlikely that would happen.
Re:How to Fall 35,000 Feet And Survive (2010)
by mistersquid on Sunday May 22, 2016 @11:52PM
(#11751749)
One of my favorite resources in the how-to-survive-a-fall-from-a-plane genre is wikiHow's "How to Cope With a Double Parachute Failure: 10 Steps." [0] My favorite paragraph is the last step in the second scenario "Alternative: Lack of Companions".
> 5 Expect impact. You are unlikely to have the time or ability to aim for a soft landing-spot, body of water, or other impact site that might improve your chances of survival. There is a minuscule chance that your impact will result in non-life-threatening injuries; if this seems incredibly far-fetched, comfort yourself that double chute failure in modern times is also extremely unlikely, and that you have already beaten worse odds.
Re:How to Fall 35,000 Feet And Survive (2010)
by nickpsecurity on Sunday May 22, 2016 @09:03PM
(#11751097)
Take the easy way out why don't you! Meanwhile, I think it's more fun to contemplate the possibilities.
I'm thinking I'll build a multi-story, Tempur-Pedic mattress maybe on top of shallow lake. Put some nets around it that extend high into the sky. The person landing on it gets cushion from the water and compression along with soft surface. Will hit it, slow down, and any bouncing contained within nets. Just need some idi... brave adventurer to both fund this structure and use it.
Note: Too great a chance of bouncing outside the nets. A spring or rocket activated top could help but hurts as much as the ground. Make hamburger out of them probably. So, a parallel, Tempur-Pedic surface that springs across the top or is moved into place with helicopters. That should be safer for high-energy, upward bouncing.
Re:How to Fall 35,000 Feet And Survive (2010)
by viacoffee on Sunday May 22, 2016 @09:08PM
(#11751108)
Yeah, about that... None of what you said would work. People think water is this "cushion" like thing. In reality it is as solid as a brick unless the surface is broken (the mattress is not enough). A human would just end up breaking every bone in their body attempting to do this.
Re:How to Fall 35,000 Feet And Survive (2010)
by tunap on Sunday May 22, 2016 @10:23PM
(#11751393)
If a large article of debris hit prior and you entered the churning, bubbling water(and not hit the debris), you may get off with just broken toes, feet, hips...maybe. Of course, you'd likely drown before you could swim back to the surface.
Chris MaClugage jumped a ski over three houseboats in Havasu a few years back. They aerated his landing area to buffer the landing/impact. Seems to have worked...
Dropping Buster with an internal accelerometer from a crane led to difficulty because the dummy continually lost parts on each control impact. Eventually, they managed consistent drops (mostly just below 300 g), finding that the hammer reduced the impact slightly, but the 150-foot (46 m) fall would still be lethal.
Re:How to Fall 35,000 Feet And Survive (2010)
by slavik81 on Monday May 23, 2016 @12:31AM
(#11751891)
It seems they tested whether a hammer could break the surface enough. Larger debris would create a significantly larger disturbance and would probably be more effective.
Re:How to Fall 35,000 Feet And Survive (2010)
by nickpsecurity on Sunday May 22, 2016 @11:37PM
(#11751689)
Did they test proper landings or drop it randomly? That's a critical thing left out of many analysis. You learn its importance to preventing injury in both martial arts (esp relaxing or break falls) and military, jump school. The methods for high falls should be tested on each of those techniques given prior effectiveness.
Re:How to Fall 35,000 Feet And Survive (2010)
by vatotemking on Monday May 23, 2016 @01:59AM
(#11752182)
Perhaps an air filled cushion is better than a mattress. Once the subject hits the cushion, it deflates. That would absorb much of the impact and prevent bouncing.
Re:How to Fall 35,000 Feet And Survive (2010)
by nickpsecurity on Sunday May 22, 2016 @09:13PM
(#11751131)
I've dove in water enough to know this is true. Couldn't recall mechanics of breaking surface properly, though outside basic dives. Modification: something between the mattress and water to break the surface. Maybe repeating structures that do that in a single layer. What now?
Re:How to Fall 35,000 Feet And Survive (2010)
by nickpsecurity on Sunday May 22, 2016 @09:50PM
(#11751259)
Yeah, I'm thinking along those lines. I had the thing in mind I see in movies rescuing jumpers and a BouncyCastle. It works for small distances. How to get it to work for larger distances and with potentially other materials?
Re:How to Fall 35,000 Feet And Survive (2010)
by tim333 on Monday May 23, 2016 @08:39AM
(#11753445)
I imagine the big airbag/bouncy castle thing would work for free fallers. You'd need it to be quite thick like 50ft and quite large so you don't miss it jumping out of the plane. From mountaineering I think polyester tends to have the best strength to price ratio. There's a supplier here that can make 800 tons / month at about $2000/ton. Say 1 kg/m2 and .5 km x .5 km = 250 tons = $500k. Plus airpumps etc. Kickstarter?
Re:How to Fall 35,000 Feet And Survive (2010)
by nickpsecurity on Sunday May 22, 2016 @08:55PM
(#11751075)
I remember this article. It was really fun. Now, anyone know of modern research or simulations that has made some headway on how these people might have survived? And best odds of duplicating that should one find themselves 10,000+ft in air with no parachute? Or just idiotic basejumpers trying to create a new category in Guiness?
Re:How to Fall 35,000 Feet And Survive (2010)
by tim333 on Sunday May 22, 2016 @09:55PM
(#11751280)
MythBusters did some research on The New Jersey airman mentioned. In general you need something that will slow you down in a relatively gradual way over 20 feet + or so. Things that have worked are deep sloping snow, branches of large trees and in the Jersey case the roof of the train station which seems to have been made of a metal lattice that presumably bent some distance when he hit it http://fly.historicwings.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/01/High...
Re:How to Fall 35,000 Feet And Survive (2010)
by nickpsecurity on Sunday May 22, 2016 @10:07PM
(#11751330)
Nice, nice. That's a start. I also recall in the original Final Fantasy movie that they landed by shooting gel packs that did exactly that. It spread out and up a certain distance. Then, they hit it with immediate slowdown. I wonder if that was forward thinking or leveraging something someone already heard about.
I'd worry about suffocating in the gel solution. If it's thick enough, you'd probably get stuck. So, something with give like other examples is better.
Re:How to Fall 35,000 Feet And Survive (2010)
by tim333 on Sunday May 22, 2016 @10:32PM
(#11751433)
I find it hard to visualise the gel pack thing.
I was thinking just now of Mike Basich kind of demonstrating the landing in snow bit. He aimed to jump out of a helicopter on a snowboard at 50ft for a magazine photoshoot but it ended up being nearer 130ft. I think that makes it about a 60mph fall so not terminal velocity but pretty quick.
Re:How to Fall 35,000 Feet And Survive (2010)
by JFlash on Sunday May 22, 2016 @09:36PM
(#11751214)
Would being drunk help? In drunk driving crashes the drunk driver survives more often than the others directly involved in the collision, but I've never gotten a definitive reason why...
EDIT: survive more often than others directly involved in the collision who were in a comparable vehicle or in the same vehicle as the driver.
Re:How to Fall 35,000 Feet And Survive (2010)
by passivepinetree on Sunday May 22, 2016 @10:14PM
(#11751356)
I believe the reason is related to the safety of the driver's position in the vehicle rather than the state of being drunk. The driver's seat is the only one guaranteed to be filled each time the car is driven, therefore car companies have a bigger incentive to care about the safety of that seat than any other seat.
Re:How to Fall 35,000 Feet And Survive (2010)
by pkroll on Monday May 23, 2016 @01:46PM
(#11755473)
They're relaxed. Tensing up in a crash means muscles don't absorb impact, they transfer it to bones and organs. A relaxed person has a better chance on a fall or crash... up to a point, of course.
Re:How to Fall 35,000 Feet And Survive (2010)
by vidoc on Monday May 23, 2016 @05:07AM
(#11752683)
The brother of a dad's friend survived a 5000m jump in the 60s. He was doing an airborne jump in the mont blanc area, both parachutes failed (super rare), and he freefalled into a tree. He basically broke most of his bones and spent 2 months at the hospital but made it!
Re:How to Fall 35,000 Feet And Survive (2010)
by crispytx on Sunday May 22, 2016 @08:30PM
(#11750993)
Whoever wrote this obviously has never seen a skydiver impact the ground at high speed. Watch a video of high performance canopy pilot, or "swooper", impact the ground at 60mph; they bounce off the ground like rag dolls, and are usually left with broken femurs. An impact at 100mph will most certainly kill you unless something extraordinary breaks your fall.
Re:How to Fall 35,000 Feet And Survive (2010)
by nickpsecurity on Sunday May 22, 2016 @08:53PM
(#11751066)
Whoever wrote that isn't concerned about the people in almost certainly crowd. Writer is curious about the others that made it anyway and why. Much more interesting question with possible, practical applications. :)
Re:How to Fall 35,000 Feet And Survive (2010)
by pcurve on Sunday May 22, 2016 @09:25PM
(#11751175)
True. But over open water? It might be worth taking a stab at it, though you're probably going to die anyway from falling debris, drowning, hypothermia, sharks, or just bleeding out.
Re:How to Fall 35,000 Feet And Survive (2010)
by barrkel on Sunday May 22, 2016 @10:25PM
(#11751398)
Gravitational force is proportional to mass; in a vacuum, the only thing that stops heavier things from falling faster is the fact that acceleration due to applied force is inversely proportional to mass, so the mass cancels out.
Drag is proportional to cross-sectional area and the square of the velocity; mass doesn't factor in.
There are two main forces on the falling object, then: gravity pulling it down, and drag pushing it up. Terminal velocity is reached when both are equal. Lower mass means less gravity, but drag is unaffected. Thus it takes a lower amount of speed increase until drag equals the gravitational pull, and terminal velocity is reached.
Re:How to Fall 35,000 Feet And Survive (2010)
by todd8 on Monday May 23, 2016 @11:06AM
(#11754316)
Yes. Assuming a relatively consistent body density, mass will be proportional to the cube of the linear dimension (say height of person falling) and cross-sectional area will be proportional to the square of the linear dimension. This is why an ant can make it to the ground without a parachute.
So if an ant is say 10mm long and a human is 2m long (200 * the length of the ant) the human falls 14 times faster.
Furthermore, the forces on our bones at impact will be likely be proportional to the cube of our size while their strength will be proportional to their cross section, related to the square of our size. This give the ant a big advantage at impact as well.
Finally, I would probably die of fright on the way down, the ant wouldn't know any better.
Re:How to Fall 35,000 Feet And Survive (2010)
by D-Coder on Sunday May 22, 2016 @11:41PM
(#11751707)
Thus, take a compressed-air tank with you. Point it down and open the valve to increase the air density that you are falling through. Is this so complicated???
Re:How to Fall 35,000 Feet And Survive (2010)
by Nursie on Sunday May 22, 2016 @09:54PM
(#11751276)
Air resistance affects lighter stuff more, proportionally, and gives it a lower terminal velocity. A mouse can be dropped and survive (maybe with broken limbs) from almost any height, as there's not a lot of mass behind it and the air will keep it from going too fast.
This is in contrast to the Galilean experiment where you drop two things and they fall at the same rate regardless of mass - this is true in a vacuum but not in atmosphere.
Re:How to Fall 35,000 Feet And Survive (2010)
by barrkel on Sunday May 22, 2016 @10:27PM
(#11751411)
"Air resistance affects lighter stuff more"
This is nonsense. Air resistance is caused by drag and has nothing to do with weight. An arrow will fall faster to the ground than big balloon, despite weighing the same.
Re:How to Fall 35,000 Feet And Survive (2010)
by Nursie on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @08:13AM
(#11760889)
"This is nonsense. Air resistance is caused by drag and has nothing to do with weight. An arrow will fall faster to the ground than big balloon, despite weighing the same."
But if you had two arrows of different weights, air resistance would act to slow the lighter one more.
Re:How to Fall 35,000 Feet And Survive (2010)
by goodcanadian on Sunday May 22, 2016 @11:30PM
(#11751661)
It is not solely about weight. It is the ratio between weight and surface area. Surface area tends to go as the square of the size whereas mass tends to go as the cube. For objects of the same density (all people are about the same), smaller and thus lighter ones have a greater surface area to mass ratio, and thus a lower terminal velocity.
Re:How to Fall 35,000 Feet And Survive (2010)
by arnarbi on Sunday May 22, 2016 @09:57PM
(#11751290)
Like a ping-pong ball vs a golf ball. The gravitational force is smaller on a light object, so less drag is required to counter it. Being the same shape, that drag is reached at a lower speed than for the heavy object.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joan_Murray_%28skydiver%29
A friend of mine had his primary fail and he passed out. He woke up before the ground and fired his reserve. That broke his neck. He fell hard, there was no one in the area he fell in, but he was able to gather his chute and walk back to base with his chin on his chest without passing out. Though I think he crawled the last kilometer or so.
He started skydiving again, pretty much as soon as they took off the neck brace that had been screwed into his skull.
The only case it would be useful if if there's nowhere in range to make a reasonable landing -- no airports, no water, no roadways, no flat land. Given that your fly thousands of feet above the ground, it's unlikely that would happen.
My feeling was that your best bet is to not have to try.
> 5 Expect impact. You are unlikely to have the time or ability to aim for a soft landing-spot, body of water, or other impact site that might improve your chances of survival. There is a minuscule chance that your impact will result in non-life-threatening injuries; if this seems incredibly far-fetched, comfort yourself that double chute failure in modern times is also extremely unlikely, and that you have already beaten worse odds.
[0] http://www.wikihow.com/Cope-With-a-Double-Parachute-Failure
EDIT: readability, grammar
I'm thinking I'll build a multi-story, Tempur-Pedic mattress maybe on top of shallow lake. Put some nets around it that extend high into the sky. The person landing on it gets cushion from the water and compression along with soft surface. Will hit it, slow down, and any bouncing contained within nets. Just need some idi... brave adventurer to both fund this structure and use it.
Note: Too great a chance of bouncing outside the nets. A spring or rocket activated top could help but hurts as much as the ground. Make hamburger out of them probably. So, a parallel, Tempur-Pedic surface that springs across the top or is moved into place with helicopters. That should be safer for high-energy, upward bouncing.
Chris MaClugage jumped a ski over three houseboats in Havasu a few years back. They aerated his landing area to buffer the landing/impact. Seems to have worked...
https://www.google.com/url?q=https://www.youtube.com/watch%3...
You still die:
Dropping Buster with an internal accelerometer from a crane led to difficulty because the dummy continually lost parts on each control impact. Eventually, they managed consistent drops (mostly just below 300 g), finding that the hammer reduced the impact slightly, but the 150-foot (46 m) fall would still be lethal.
I'd worry about suffocating in the gel solution. If it's thick enough, you'd probably get stuck. So, something with give like other examples is better.
I was thinking just now of Mike Basich kind of demonstrating the landing in snow bit. He aimed to jump out of a helicopter on a snowboard at 50ft for a magazine photoshoot but it ended up being nearer 130ft. I think that makes it about a 60mph fall so not terminal velocity but pretty quick.
Vid of jump https://youtu.be/OC42K5ex0iA?t=18s
Him talking about it from 22m30 https://vimeo.com/7732513
EDIT: survive more often than others directly involved in the collision who were in a comparable vehicle or in the same vehicle as the driver.
- crispytx (Wingsuit Pilot & Programmer)
How does this work?
Drag is proportional to cross-sectional area and the square of the velocity; mass doesn't factor in.
There are two main forces on the falling object, then: gravity pulling it down, and drag pushing it up. Terminal velocity is reached when both are equal. Lower mass means less gravity, but drag is unaffected. Thus it takes a lower amount of speed increase until drag equals the gravitational pull, and terminal velocity is reached.
Furthermore, the forces on our bones at impact will be likely be proportional to the cube of our size while their strength will be proportional to their cross section, related to the square of our size. This give the ant a big advantage at impact as well.
Finally, I would probably die of fright on the way down, the ant wouldn't know any better.
This is in contrast to the Galilean experiment where you drop two things and they fall at the same rate regardless of mass - this is true in a vacuum but not in atmosphere.
This is nonsense. Air resistance is caused by drag and has nothing to do with weight. An arrow will fall faster to the ground than big balloon, despite weighing the same.
But if you had two arrows of different weights, air resistance would act to slow the lighter one more.
So no, it's not nonsense.