News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by JorgeGT on Friday May 06, 2016 @07:11AM (#11643057)
Good luck selling plushies, apparel, comics or animated cartoons of lil' fun Sir David Attenborough! Now instead of having the dream name for science outreach and awareness for kids, you have a stark, cynical lesson on democracy.
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by raldi on Friday May 06, 2016 @09:27AM (#11643781)
Everyone's missing the solution that would please everyone: just have Attenborough change his name.
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by eridius on Friday May 06, 2016 @02:17PM (#11645666)
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by Zikes on Friday May 06, 2016 @11:31AM (#11644630)
I could listen to Davey McDaveface talk about rare birds for hours.
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by uremog on Friday May 06, 2016 @12:38PM (#11645072)
Sir Davey McDaveface, even.
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by chris_wot on Friday May 06, 2016 @01:05PM (#11645239)
I just thought they were making fun of David Attenborough. I don't think it's very nice to say someone has a boat face.

Incidentally, I think that the boat isn't long enough to have his full name with honorifics painted on the side. It is David Frederick Attenborough OM CH CVO CBE FRS FLS FZS FSA.

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by Zikes on Friday May 06, 2016 @01:31PM (#11645396)
So it would be the RRS David Frederick Attenborough OM CH CVO CBE FRS FLS FZS FSA?
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by chris_wot on Friday May 06, 2016 @07:50PM (#11647559)
See, I would have voted for this.
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by zodPod on Friday May 06, 2016 @01:45PM (#11645484)
OMFG lol! Davey McDaveface!
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by shoveljump on Friday May 06, 2016 @02:04PM (#11645598)
Downvotey McDownvoteface.
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by cm2012 on Friday May 06, 2016 @07:14AM (#11643070)
If they kept the name, they would have had positive public attention for years. Now they get nothing...
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by JorgeGT on Friday May 06, 2016 @07:19AM (#11643089)
Everytime they visited a port could have been, "Hey, Boaty McBoatface is coming to port this Saturday! Why don't you bring your kids to a fun science tour?".

This is probably the first time that an open Internet poll has finally chosen a name that is fun and kid-friendly instead of "Hitler did nothing wrong" and they have decided to waste all the PR potential.

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by dragonwriter on Friday May 06, 2016 @12:43PM (#11645106)
> Everytime they visited a port could have been, "Hey, Boaty McBoatface is coming to port this Saturday! Why don't you bring your kids to a fun science tour?".

Since the research vessels advanced submersible ROV is being named "Boaty McBoatface", they still essentially can, though to be as accurate it would have to be "Hey, Boaty McBoatface is coming to port this Saturday onboard the Sir David Attenborough! Why don't you bring your kids to a fun science tour?".

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by tremon on Saturday May 07, 2016 @05:14PM (#11651377)
If I understand the article correctly, the submersible will simply be named "Boaty" though. Possibly because the entire name won't fit on its hull.
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by gaius on Friday May 06, 2016 @08:17AM (#11643395)
"Adults don't take this seriously and neither should you"

I'm being downvoted for this but trust me, that is the message teenagers would takeaway from the name Boaty McBoatface.

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by JorgeGT on Friday May 06, 2016 @09:21AM (#11643744)
Teenagers love when the people of the internet goes viral and manages to collectively upset/ridicule The Man.

Conversely, they really really hate when government bureaucrats show them that democracy can be a farce and people's choices are worthless.

Teenagers are on a complicated phase of life where adults ask them their opinions as if they were adults too, but then when they don't like the answers, use their power to override them. Which is exactly what transpires of this whole process.

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by visakanv on Friday May 06, 2016 @09:36AM (#11643838)
This is totally true. I still have strong memories of being passionate about being social activism, etc and then getting frustrated at being blocked over and over again (by school, govt bodies, etc).
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by yarou on Friday May 06, 2016 @11:31AM (#11644626)
A docile, numb, and drugged population is the holy trinity for authoritarians.
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by rdtsc on Friday May 06, 2016 @12:27PM (#11645001)
> Conversely, they really really hate when government bureaucrats show them that democracy can be a farce and people's choices are worthless.

Yap, it is a valuable lesson of how the real world works. The people can only choose as long as they choose what those in power let them choose.

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by maus42 on Friday May 06, 2016 @11:11AM (#11644492)
I hope teenagers don't consider Internet polls as a measure of democracy.
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by joshmanders on Friday May 06, 2016 @11:59AM (#11644816)
Could kind of equate it to elections. It's essentially a huge nationwide poll. If the people they wanted to vote's choice wasn't good enough for them to name the boat Boaty McBoatface, then who's to stop the US government from thinking "ya, know what? We want Trump anyway." and throw the votes out?

Far fetched I agree, but that's the message being sent.

That being said, I'm happy with their choice. Sir David is a great thing to name something after.

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by gaius on Friday May 06, 2016 @10:00AM (#11644000)
Tnis was not "the people", it was bored wind-up merchants on Reddit and Twitter. The lesson that those people should be ignored can only be a good thing.
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by icebraining on Friday May 06, 2016 @10:37AM (#11644255)
Then why do an internet poll at all? Nobody would be complaining if NERC had just decided on the name by themselves. By launching the poll and then reneging on it, they just look foolish for failing to predict an obvious outcome, and somewhat petty for not owning up to it.

And as I pointed out in an earlier thread, it's not like the Royal Navy ships never had playful names; some past examples include the HMS Speedy, HMS Child's Play, HMS Happy Entrance and HMS Arrogant (later renamed HMS Insolent).

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by sangnoir on Friday May 06, 2016 @10:11AM (#11644069)
> Tnis was not "the people", it was bored wind-up merchants on Reddit and Twitter. The lesson that those people should be ignored can only be a good thing.

Yes, let's ignore the people who bother to vote because they are not the right sort of people. Instead, we'll do what our idea of a 'rational' voter would want /s

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by tombrossman on Friday May 06, 2016 @09:00AM (#11643630)
I'll upvote because it's a fair point but I think it could use more nuance. Here's an example:

"The scientists on this ship have a sense of humour and are fun people" meaning that while they take the science seriously, the are approachable and not too worried about what you call their ship.

Also, Sir David Attenborough is a national treasure and while I would have preferred the funny name, this is a very solid alternative.

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by pbhjpbhj on Friday May 06, 2016 @09:52AM (#11643945)
Why not the message "you can have fun and do serious work".

Mind you the current outcome is more "adults don't take public opinion seriously".

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by partiallypro on Friday May 06, 2016 @10:59AM (#11644418)
Or Scientists aren't a bunch of stiffs and can have fun too, because it's a fun profession...that more people should get into.
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by rfrey on Friday May 06, 2016 @02:07PM (#11645617)
"Adults don't take this seriously and neither should you"

Alternately:

"Your suspicions are correct. There is no room for fun or playfulness in Science."

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by kingkawn on Friday May 06, 2016 @09:59AM (#11643988)
we must keep up the performance of propriety for the sake of teaching teenagers how to teach teenagers.
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by liveoneggs on Friday May 06, 2016 @09:03AM (#11643638)
who cares what teenagers think?
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by gaius on Friday May 06, 2016 @09:10AM (#11643677)
People who say the name will get kids into science. It really won't, it will have the opposite effect. And this is obvious, so it's disingenuous to claim that was their reason for voting for it.
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by lucozade on Friday May 06, 2016 @10:03AM (#11644018)
I'm not sure I know anyone who voted for it in order to make children interested in it. They voted because they thought it was amusing.

However, my children, many of their friends and some of their teachers are now aware that the UK is commissioning a polar research vessel. They definitely weren't before.

I know of at least one junior school science teacher who has used this to seed a lesson. It's a point of interest, it's the start of a conversation. It gives science a different angle and a bit of colour. This is a good thing even if it was by accident. Sometimes we should just take the hand we were dealt and play it.

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by zeristor on Friday May 06, 2016 @04:55PM (#11646674)
Do you mean they're using an ice breaker as an ice breaker to start conversations?

A rather impressive video [0] of RRS Sir Ernesto Shackleton being droned.

[0] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mbywX37mumc

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by justratsinacoat on Friday May 06, 2016 @08:30PM (#11647728)
A slightly peevish note to future viewers: the drone in question is owned by the RRS Sir Ernesto Shackleton. I was kinda hoping for a clandestine in-port surveillance, but no, the views are of the the vessel as it works in Antarctica.
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by fossuser on Friday May 06, 2016 @09:27AM (#11643778)
It may be obvious to you because you already think that's the case, but it isn't obvious.

My anecdotes and general 'intuition' (as unscientific as these things always are) are opposite to yours.

I think it'd be viewed positively and wouldn't have the opposite effect as you suggest.

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by johan_larson on Friday May 06, 2016 @07:22AM (#11643109)
Or if not that name, then some other irreverent choice. RSS I Like Big Boats & I Cannot Lie was my personal favourite. RSS It's Bloody Cold Here was good too.
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by godshatter on Friday May 06, 2016 @06:06PM (#11647029)
These names remind of the names of Ship Minds in an Iain M Banks Culture novel.
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by dredmorbius on Friday May 06, 2016 @08:57AM (#11643611)
The ROV is (or will be) named "Boaty".

I agree though and hhave argued that the campaign was genius -- inspired or accidental. You can't buy this kind of publicity. Especially for science.

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by x2398dh1 on Friday May 06, 2016 @10:16AM (#11644112)
Why are you equating what was really a suggestion box to democracy? Isn't it really more of a tale of the UK Science Minister being better at saving public face rather than following empirical evidence?

Another way of looking at the situation is - the UK Science Minister is hired to fill a spot, and make science seem, "serious," and have "authority," so that the general public feels that their tax dollars are going to something worthwhile. That would actually mean that in a sense, democracy is prevailing, because the majority of society would rather abstract away the details of science, they just see it as some authority which brings, "good things." I'm not talking about people on the internet who vote on social media, I'm talking about everyone--including that grandma in Scotland who is not on the internet at all.

For those who are strictly practicing empirical data collection, who dare I say, are better pure scientists within the online data collection domain, they may say, "this result had the most votes, so therefore this is the name which wins." But if you're the UK Science Minister, you likely are afraid of losing your job, and afraid of a blowback, knowing that a lot of people will reject that name and have never heard of this voting system. He/she likely is aware of the plushy toy opportunity, but has evaluated that and it pales in comparison to how much money the British Government could continue to get from taxpayers. In effect what you are saying is that you could do a better job than him in evaluating where money comes from for these types of endeavors.

According to your logic we should all feel cynical and contemptuous that Mountain Dew is not now named, "Hitler Did Nothing Wrong."

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by lisper on Friday May 06, 2016 @11:35AM (#11644652)
> make science seem, "serious,"

Why does science need to seem serious? The Mythbusters tremendously advanced the cause of science, and they did it in no small part by not taking themselves too seriously.

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by r0fls on Friday May 06, 2016 @04:21PM (#11646476)
>Mythbusters tremendously advanced the cause of science, and they did it in no small part by not taking themselves too seriously.

Personally I think that's a bit of a stretch, but I'm not trying to say the show isn't great. While scientists could learn from their format (providing videos of their experiments, for instance) I wouldn't say that the mythbusters have advanced the cause of science at all. Would you say that the TV show Bill Nye the science guy advanced the cause of science? Science education he has definitely advanced the cause of, but science: not from the TV show. Similarly, I think the mythbusters have advanced engineering education tremendously, specifically television engineering education.

If you think they have actually advanced the cause of science, I would love to hear why. I'm not trying to be a jerk, I'm just speaking from having watched a few episodes, so I definitely could be wrong.

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by lisper on Friday May 06, 2016 @04:51PM (#11646654)
I have very mixed feelings about Bill Nye. I've never watched his show. The only time I've ever seen him in action is during his debate with Ken Ham, and that performance made me cringe. (If you want to know why, see the footnote in http://blog.rongarret.info/2015/02/this-is-why-prominent-ath...) More generally, I think he promotes a negative stereotype of scientists by choosing to wear a bow tie.

I just now watched this:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PGRRXKek8G0

and it's just horrible. To my eye, Nye is indistinguishable from a Creationist caricature.

Compare that to how the Mythbusters handled the moon landing conspiracy:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wym04J_3Ls0

The Mythbusters actually did real science, and they did it with style and panache and grace. They started with a problem, advanced a hypothesis, designed an experiment (often a series of experiments) analyzed the results, drew conclusions, and often went back and re-did things when a viewer pointed out something they did wrong. That is science. They democratized science in a way that no one else has ever done. A kid watching Mythbusters could come away thinking that science was something that they could do themselves. Ultimately, the Mythbusters advanced science by busting the myth that science can only be done by scientists.

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by r0fls on Friday May 06, 2016 @05:43PM (#11646907)
Debunking conspiracies is not science, although surely it uses similar methods. Few scientists question whether we landed on the moon. Being a scientist relies on the ability to see true from false accurately -- Einstein and other great scientists questioned scientific phenomena and developed hypothesis to explain them. Whether some people believe we landed on the moon is a social phenomenon, and lies entirely outside the realm of science.

Also, before you start hating on Bill Nye so hard, please compare his reported scientific contributions[1] to Jamie Hyneman's and Adam Savage's (spoiler, theirs don't seem to exist). Last point about Nye: bow ties are ok. Seriously though, people don't hate on Feynman for having long hair or being a supposed sex swinger. I know Nye doesn't have the same prestige, but it's just a bow tie; I think you should give him a break.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_Nye#Scientific_work

Note: Bill Nye also engineered a part that was used in the 747 while he worked at Boeing

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by lisper on Friday May 06, 2016 @06:05PM (#11647026)
> Debunking conspiracies is not science

Why not?

> theirs don't seem to exist

http://mythresults.com

> bow ties are ok

Of course bow ties are OK. Nonetheless, a scientist wearing a bow tie reinforces negative stereotypes. It's sad, but true.

> people don't hate on Feynman for having long hair or being a supposed sex swinger

That's because Feynman didn't do those things on TV. If Bill Nye wants to wear a tutu in his private life, more power to him. But if he wears one on a TV show about science I think that would indicate some really poor judgement on his part.

> Bill Nye also engineered a part that was used in the 747 while he worked at Boeing

So? What does that have to do with the Mythbusters?

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by r0fls on Friday May 06, 2016 @06:22PM (#11647128)
>> Debunking conspiracies is not science >Why not?

In the general sense of the word, it does qualify. However, my personal definition of doing science requires devotion toward advancement in a specific scientific field. I don't think that definition is actually uncommon. Specifically, few scientists (physicists, chemists, astronomers, biologists, etc...) will ever reference the work of the Mythbusters in their studies or attempts at explaining the universe or aspects of it. Bill Nye would be more likely to be referenced (at least by an aeronautical engineer), in my opinion, but like I said I don't imagine that's either's main focus; that is education. Mythbusters is specifically devoted to applying the scientific method to debunking myths, and that's awesome, but since they're not devoted to advancing a scientific field, I don't see what they do as science. As a far fetched analogy: if I apply the scientific method to blogging, it doesn't mean I'm doing science.

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by lisper on Friday May 06, 2016 @06:39PM (#11647216)
IMHO it is important to distinguish between doing science and being a professional scientist for the same reason it's important to distinguish between (say) playing a sport or a musical instrument and being a professional athlete or musician. Sports and music are democratized in ways that science is not. It is taken for granted that people can play sports or musical instruments without being professionals, but for some reason this is not the case in science. The profession of science oozes with disdain bordering on contempt for those who are not members of the club. This is a very serious problem in our society. It's the reason that climate-change denialists and young-earth creationists get as much traction as they do.

The Mythbusters were not professional scientists (they were professional entertainers), but they absolutely did science. And they did good science. Your dismissal of them is IMHO a symptom of the problem that they more than anyone else took a step toward solving.

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by Nadya on Friday May 06, 2016 @06:10PM (#11647051)
>Nonetheless, a scientist wearing a bow tie reinforces negative stereotypes. It's sad, but true.

Can you extrapolate on this? Is there something about bow ties that I'm completely ignorant about?

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by lisper on Friday May 06, 2016 @06:24PM (#11647148)
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by Nadya on Friday May 06, 2016 @06:32PM (#11647185)
I'm not seeing how his wearing a tie reinforces any negative stereotypes. If anything it just shows he's "an example of the stereotypical perception of a bow tie wearer" (a professor/teacher wearing a bow tie) which is... uh.. harmless? I see nothing else but some out-of-context quote form a short term Times writer.

Unless you're going to argue people should never do anything that is "stereotypical" of "that kind of person" I see no reason he shouldn't wear a bow tie.

[0] http://www.nytimes.com/2005/06/26/fashion/sundaystyles/a-red...

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by lisper on Friday May 06, 2016 @07:51PM (#11647566)
So let me put this in perspective by saying that Bill Nye's bow tie is a minor detail compared to the bigger problem, which is that his pedantry is atrocious. And reasonable people can certainly disagree about fashion. So what follows is just my personal opinion of what is (or at least should be) ultimately an unimportant matter.

The relevant quotes from the wikipedia article are:

"the bow tie is ... an instant sign of nerddom ... not the mark of a ladies' man ... not sexy. Most men ... only wear bow ties with formal dress."

The last sentence is significant. Wearing a bow tie in an informal setting broadcasts an unawareness of (or an uncaring for) social norms (specifically, the social norm that bow ties are formal wear). Hence, it reinforces the negative stereotype of the scientist as someone whose social status is outside the mainstream, an "other", a position to be avoided rather than aspired to.

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by Nadya on Friday May 06, 2016 @08:35PM (#11647745)
>Wearing a bow tie in an informal setting broadcasts an unawareness of (or an uncaring for) social norms

Which to me is a good thing. The sooner "social norms" die out, the better. They're the source of many issues - and especially the source of the form of identity politics that exist today. The refusal to accept people who are "outside the social norm" and instead ostracize them for failing to "fit in" is the problem, in more ways than one, from my point of view.

>Hence, it reinforces the negative stereotype of the scientist as someone whose social status is outside the mainstream, an "other", a position to be avoided rather than aspired to.

Another way of saying this: It sends a positive message that you can be whatever you want to be, no matter how "weird" or "different" you are from society. That you can be yourself instead of what others wish to see you as. Even if you have a quirky or dated fashion sense.

I'll agree with you on the pedantry. I feel there is a time and place to be a pedant - and most of that is when it is mission critical or in academic work. It gets in the way of communication more times than it helps.

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by lisper on Friday May 06, 2016 @09:35PM (#11647907)
> The sooner "social norms" die out, the better.

You surely don't mean that. What you probably mean is something more like, "The sooner social norms that I don't like die out, the better." Humans are social animals, and hence social norms are an indispensable part of the human condition.

I totally agree that the world would be a better place if people didn't have to worry so much about what they wore. But you have to pick your battles, and I think there are bigger fish to fry.

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by dragonwriter on Friday May 06, 2016 @07:58PM (#11647596)
> Wearing a bow tie in an informal setting broadcasts an unawareness of (or an uncaring for) social norms (specifically, the social norm that bow ties are formal wear).

Its actually not that at all. While "most men ... only wear bow ties with formal dress" is true, that is not because bow ties in general are formal dress. The specific forms of bow ties which are formal dress are not what the small minority of men who wear bow ties in other contexts generally wear. They wear forms that are understood (or were, when they were in fashion) as informal dress, which are quite distinct. They just aren't currently popular fashion.

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by lisper on Friday May 06, 2016 @08:14PM (#11647662)
> The specific forms of bow ties which are formal dress are not what the small minority of men who wear bow ties in other contexts generally wear.

Well yeah, sure, but that doesn't help the situation at all. Clowns, for example, wear bow ties informally, but that's not exactly the kind of image I would like scientists to associate themselves with either. Yes, there was a time when bow ties were fashionable as non-formal wear among non-clowns, but as you yourself point out, those days are long gone.

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by NegativeK on Friday May 06, 2016 @04:43PM (#11646607)
I believe the point was that they draw positive attention to science, not that they do science or improve on scientific methods.

Science classes in school rarely advance anything other than the number of scientists in the world and the lay public's understanding.

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by lisper on Friday May 06, 2016 @04:54PM (#11646670)
No no no! The Mythbusters actually did real science! And most (though not all) of the time they did it quite well.
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by dbcurtis on Friday May 06, 2016 @01:00PM (#11645209)
Your comment makes me envision a large research vessel exploding at sea in a giant fireball.... :/
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by squeaky-clean on Friday May 06, 2016 @04:43PM (#11646601)
You mean similar to this?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4cvGGxTsQx0

(Video of the first SpaceX attempted landing and explosion).

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by OnlineCourage on Friday May 06, 2016 @08:26PM (#11647711)
It doesn't need to seem serious...the Science Minister is following more of a risk mitigation strategy - e.g. the vast population of the public will most likely feel OK about the, "Attenbourough," name, whereas a small fringe will leverage, "Boaty McBoatface," to attack the cause of science and say that it's a waste of money. The small fringe's attack has a risk of loss, whereas the larger science fanbase has no risk of loss, only a risk of not as much gain.
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by jcoffland on Friday May 06, 2016 @01:56PM (#11645550)
If you call that science.
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by enraged_camel on Friday May 06, 2016 @11:45AM (#11644716)
>>Isn't it really more of a tale of the UK Science Minister being better at saving public face rather than following empirical evidence?

Saving face how? It seemed to me he received a ton of criticism for not going with the name the majority voted for.

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by OnlineCourage on Friday May 06, 2016 @08:21PM (#11647686)
He would have received public criticism either way. However, he's going for the safer strategy, which is to mitigate attack rather than expand upon opportunity. Think about politicians like Sarah Palin who attack scientists for studying fruit flies, and then her tons of followers agreeing with her and lobbying to cut science funding because it, "sounds bad." The same effect could occur in the UK, although on a lesser scale.
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by qbrass on Friday May 06, 2016 @02:19PM (#11645683)
>According to your logic we should all feel cynical and contemptuous that Mountain Dew is not now named, "Hitler Did Nothing Wrong."

Gushing Granny was more popular.

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by cies on Friday May 06, 2016 @07:59AM (#11643305)
> Now instead of having the dream name for science outreach and awareness for kids, you have a stark, cynical lesson on democracy.

Well said. A "cynical lesson on democracy", and the hollow term is currently is (and maybe always was).

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by imgabe on Friday May 06, 2016 @01:13PM (#11645294)
I think you are seriously underestimating the demand for Sir David Attenborough plushies. The dude is up there with Neil Degrasse Tyson and Carl Sagan with the I Fucking Love Science crowd pantheon of science fandom.
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by BellsOnSunday on Friday May 06, 2016 @01:45PM (#11645483)
Most British people have never heard of those two but Attenborough is about as recognisable as the Queen and with far more positive associations. He has been on the telly since the 1950s and his broadcasting is part of the shared culture, like the footage of him hanging out with gorillas...Less of a thing nowadays of course, but if you are British and old enough to remember when there were only a couple of TV channels, Attenborough is the Don.
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by beat on Friday May 06, 2016 @01:58PM (#11645562)
Sir Attenborough is a wonderful choice, and I'm quite happy they named a research vessel after him. But Boaty McBoatface was a wonderful choice, too, and I'm very disappointed it was overruled by the fuddy-duddy bureaucrats.
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by foldr on Friday May 06, 2016 @03:45PM (#11646282)
Although I wouldn't want to encourage anyone to take the conventions surrounding the last vestiges of the feudal system too seriously, it's either "Sir David" or "Sir David Attenborough".
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by elcapitan on Friday May 06, 2016 @09:42AM (#11643870)
The fast feedback loops of online participation have always been the best measure to correct romantic views on the relation of democracy and governance. It seems like every online generation needs to learn the lesson that established systems of decisionmaking are there for a reason. That way they always transition from "everybody can come in, everybody can participate, everything is transparent, we're completely free in all decisions, let's create a new world" to "ok yeah we live in an existing world with rules and social order and we need to somehow reflect that in digital form just as well. sorry!".
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by mkempe on Friday May 06, 2016 @08:43AM (#11643540)
My daughter is 7 -- her hero is David Attenborough. She has in her bedroom a frame with the letter she received from him. He's been her hero since she was 4.
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by megablast on Friday May 06, 2016 @08:05AM (#11643335)
More likely it would have been forgotten about in 3 months. The internet is fickle. Remember snakes on a plane?
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by visakanv on Friday May 06, 2016 @09:38AM (#11643846)
I still fondly remember Mister Splashy Pants, and it's been almost 10 years: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mister_Splashy_Pants
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by wnevets on Friday May 06, 2016 @10:55AM (#11644389)
>Remember snakes on a plane?

yes. Using extremely famous memes only proves the effects they have had on our culture.

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by imgabe on Friday May 06, 2016 @01:14PM (#11645299)
What effect are you referring to other than "Oh yeah, I remember that thing that time" ?
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by wnevets on Friday May 06, 2016 @01:28PM (#11645379)
how else would you describe pop culture?
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by imgabe on Friday May 06, 2016 @01:31PM (#11645398)
Pop culture can and does change cultural norms and expectations. A famous example is All in the Family changing the conversation around race relations by showing a representative of the "old guard" having his mind slowly changed on the show. It was one factor that made relating to people from other races seem more "normal" than it had before.
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by sandworm101 on Friday May 06, 2016 @07:23AM (#11643111)
Kids are great, but they also want to appeal to young people who aren't still five. Silly names aren't a great marketing tool for pulling in recent college graduates or dedicated sailors.
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by JorgeGT on Friday May 06, 2016 @07:30AM (#11643149)
I would say that the fact that this is now the top story on HN, a place notoriously not populated by 5-year-olds, offers anecdotal evidence on the contrary.

In a more serious response, as a young researcher, let me assure you that when a position opens on a superb research facility such as this, we would fight for it even if it was called the RSS Hitler Did Nothing Wrong. The PR main target here is not researchers/employees, it is the public and specially kids.

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by tfm on Friday May 06, 2016 @07:29AM (#11643142)
What's in a name? That which we call a boat etc etc. "Silly" isn't necessarily a bad thing, although the term does seem to be used pejoratively.

As for recent college graduates, they might well take a look at the swift mending hands of bureaucracy in this situation, and draw some pretty accurate conclusions about the stiff deeply unsilly hierarchy under which they'd be working.

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by Aeolos on Friday May 06, 2016 @07:26AM (#11643126)
And who do you think voted for Boaty McBoatface? College students or 5 year olds?
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by gremy0 on Friday May 06, 2016 @07:30AM (#11643153)
I don't think any 'dedicated sailor' is silly enough to choose their next job based on the name of the boat.
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by noir_lord on Friday May 06, 2016 @08:46AM (#11643553)
I'm 35, Boaty McBoatface appeals more to me than calling it the Attenborough.

Whimsy is a good thing.

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by hkjgkjy on Friday May 06, 2016 @07:32AM (#11643163)
Remember that you can be playful without being childish - young and old both embrace that
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by enraged_camel on Friday May 06, 2016 @11:49AM (#11644746)
Only the most boring, humorless person would think a ship named "Boaty McBoatface" only appeals to kids.
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by logfromblammo on Friday May 06, 2016 @01:13PM (#11645293)
Indeed, the name would have been a hearty reassurance that the employer is not entirely lost up its own ass all the time.

I have always been a great fan of Dada, Surrealism, and Discordianism. So I am somewhat disappointed that it seems so dreadfully important to unwaveringly maintain the illusion that science is Serious Business. There is a time and place for both whimsy and gravitas in all aspects of life.

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by dubcanada on Friday May 06, 2016 @08:33AM (#11643480)
I'm not 5 and I would work on Boaty McBoatface.
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by nekopa on Friday May 06, 2016 @07:30AM (#11643150)
But it may make a 5 year old want to go into those fields. I think this boat has many decades of service ahead of it.
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by sheraz on Friday May 06, 2016 @07:24AM (#11643122)
Is this sarcasm?
Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by xexers on Friday May 06, 2016 @07:48AM (#11643238)
No.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mister_Splashy_Pants

> After their initial reluctance Greenpeace embraced the result of the popular vote and used the name at the center of its campaign. The added publicity, at no cost to Greenpeace, gave it enough impact to convince the Japanese government, and the plan to hunt Humpback whales was abandoned in December 2007.

> In Campaign Magazine, advertising guru Russell Davies praised Greenpeace's handling of the campaign as "one of the defining moments in New Media marketing." The name has since spawned clothing, logos, flashvideos, and the slogan "Save Mister Splashy Pants."

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by sheraz on Friday May 06, 2016 @08:06AM (#11643345)
Wow. Thank you for the link. Interesting story with a happy ending, I suppose.

Then there is this: http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation-now/2016/04/25/tru...

Re:'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough by goffley3 on Friday May 06, 2016 @09:30AM (#11643796)
Couldn't have said it better.