That said, there will be teething pains but this is a net positive thing that is happening. Growing up I lumped solar into the perpetual 10 years away category. It looks like I am going to see solar be competitive after all.
[0] I implement trading and risk management software in the energy sector, including Crude, NGL, NG, and electic.
[0] Work for a multinational in their energy & utilities consulting practice; above comment is my own.
[1] http://www.brattle.com/system/news/pdfs/000/000/749/original...
[2] https://www.texastribune.org/2014/12/15/state-law-could-shor...
A lot of people are willing to make confident, but very wrong, statements based on out of date information. It serves to protect entrenched interests and stop competition, but I have a feeling that disruption is far closer than anybody is publicly saying.
You're amazing
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pumped-storage_hydroelectricit...
m = 10^9.10^5 / (10*100) = 10^11 kg of water. = 10^8 m^3
This is not a big reserviour, being 1/20th of the size of Warragamba dam's reserviour (in Sydney). One valley could provide 20GW for a day. Compare that with demand for where I live:
http://www.aemo.com.au/Electricity/Data/Price-and-Demand/Pri...
Peak demand for 7.5M people is 9GW, with an average closer to 7GW. One valley could provide overnight storage for over 20 million people, with first world demands (all of Australia). The limitation is transmission and generating/pumping capacity, rather than storage volume.
The highest summer peak appears to have been just above 13GW. http://www.wattclarity.com.au/2016/02/highest-electricity-de...
However your point still stands I believe.
http://www.fastcodesign.com/1672202/you-deserve-a-house-with...
Could I efficiently use excess solar to pump water in to a house roof storage area and generate electric from that?
The energy in one gallon of gasoline is equivalent to the potential energy stored in 13 tons of water one kilometer up
Gravity potential energy = mgh. Suppose pool is 10 meters up, then you need 239,000 kg of water = 63K gallons or 8400 cu ft. This is a huge pool: 29 ft. x 29 ft x 10 ft.
You could use the city water supply: borrow water through a turbine at night, and return it during the day :-)
Or have pool up very high, for example on a cliff overlooking the Mediterranean:
http://inhabitat.com/crazy-home-carved-into-a-coastal-cliff-...
;)
Has Flywheel storage every been seriously used in large-scale commercial applications? Someone mentions it on every energy-storage thread, and I'd like to know if the people suggesting it are just spinning our wheels.
FES has 10x specific energy than supercapacitors or batteries with no memory and precise state of charge. Magnetic bearings and hard vacuums make them quite efficient.
I believe some electric cars used capacitors to store regenerated electricity from breaking.
"More Ampères please Mister Woodbine." - Road to Welville
[1] - http://pia.sagepub.com/content/200/2/95.abstract
[2] - http://www.euro-fusionscipub.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/11/...
Edit: Seems the purpose is purely frequency regulation, rather than storage per se.
Interestingly, it does not use a dam. There's a natural lake at the bottom of a mountain and a man-made reservoir at the top, and the entire pumping facility is completely inside the mountain; it's not at all obvious that there's anything there at all from the outside. I think about that whenever people moan about the environmental impact, or flooding valleys.
And it allows you to push some levers and dials as to whether it's cheaper this year to increase your water capacity or your power capacity. City planners love that kind of thing.
I remember parking at the lower reservoir and hiking to the upper one and being amazed at how big the water pipe is.
Demand side response is already used in industry to regulate electricity demand and smooth peaks. Smart meter penetration will allow utilities to do this more and more in the residential sector too.
Supergrids are also starting to emerge and indeed, some large grid companies are pushing hard for international interconnects. (China wants a supergrid). Countries are building out more and more HVDC interconnects, both across borders and within countries. Once you have a network of utility scale renewable sources across multiple countries, meeting peak demand becomes more a matter of coordination between grids. Europe for example, is looking like a very interesting area for this right now with planned interconnects between North Africa and Southern Europe.
Since we're all citing employment, I work for a renewable energy company :)
There are already programs for industrial users to get electricity for much cheaper, if they can tolerate power cuts during peak demand. Those programs will become more and more rewarding to join and extend and automate as supply gets spikier.
It'd be interesting to see a study comparing the two options.
If you have an industrial process that can cope with intermittent power supply, it may be only slightly more expensive to design or build so that interruption of power won't result in interruption of production. If the overall cost increase is less than the decrease of energy costs due to incentives, there is no downside.
The energy producers likewise price the incentives so that their loss of revenue is lower than their cost savings.
Unless of course the market is created and operated by Enron, then we're all fucked.
Where I live, I pay five times more for electricity between peak hours of 2pm and 8pm than I do between off-peak hours of 10pm-8am. (The remaining hours are priced at a medium level.) This has changed my behaviour, in that I now tend to wait until bedtime before switching on the clothes dryer and dishwasher.
http://products.openadr.org/?posts_per_page=-1
See also Ecobee vs. Nest: http://controltrends.org/controltrends-news/news-and-informa...
I wonder whether they create that signal artificially with electronics these days, or if it's still a natural consequence of the mechanics of the spinning generators they run in power stations?
Does anyone know more about this? Is this able to meet baseload demand?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crescent_Dunes_Solar_Energy_Pr...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermal_energy_storage#Molten_...
In areas with cold weather, one of the most interesting (and underrated, due to only making fossil use more adaptable) developments is the installation of huge, insulated hot water tanks, to make the power generation and the great generation of combined cycle plants individually dispatchable.
I can envision older warehouses in an industrial district being converted in to vacuum flywheel storage sites where power fed in to the grid earlier is buffered and then released back to it.
Changing our culture is another possible approach. Power is used in the evenings because that's when most people get off work/home/etc and they tend to have /that/ time to do cooking and cleaning (thermal cooling / heating are more solvable with changes in materials and building shape than culture change).
I'm not saying that markets should be unchecked but it's very strange to see such naked Marxism on this site.
Aggregating the preferences via price will drive new technology and business models.
The "duck curve" that your friend is referring to will be solved in a variety of ways, from wind to storage to HVDC interconnects to the rest of the nation, to peaker plants.
In the future, coal is dead. No need to build any more of it. Nuclear is too expensive to build anymore. (Unless somebody actually does thorium innovation, but I'm not holding my breath...)
When storing a kWh costs $0.10, and there's also adaptive pricing to match supply and demand better, these problems will melt away.
It does require a huge mental shift, but the cost savings will make that happen
If the math and assumptions in this article are correct, then that's exactly the (wholesale) price point Tesla is aiming for with the Powerwall:
http://cleantechnica.com/2015/05/09/tesla-powerwall-powerblo...
There are a couple other (not yet released) energy storage solutions mentioned there that might get the cost down even lower - Eos Aurora and Imergy Flow Battery
I wonder if there's enough raw materials to make that realistic. And how to you manage recycling, repair, replacement, end-of-life concerns for all those batteries on that scale?
Not asking a sarcastic hypothetical. Genuinely curious. It's hard to wrap my head around numbers that big.
For reference I used this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_electrici..., divided it by days, then the Powerwall's 6.4kwh capacity and then halved that number.
4,686,400,000,000 / 365 / 6.4 / 2 == 1,003,082,191.8 Powerwalls.
A single gigafactory is going to produce 35 GWh in a year, which is about 5.3 million power walls a year. If their lifespan is 10 years, than we need to produce 1e9 power walls / 10 years = 100 million powerwalls/year to maintain that capacity.
So we'd only need 20 gigafactories worth to do this. And with wind and proper grid interconnects we won't even really need much storage at all to keep the electricity going; the national weather is very very consistent.
We will need enough lithium for our ~300 million cars and their batteries, which are probably going to be 50-100kWh each, which is far far more than storing half a days worth of electricity.
Tesla has already planned on it: https://i.imgur.com/oLBNeW4.png | https://i.imgur.com/pectzXn.png
I'm not as concerned about the factory as the supply chain, can we actually supply that much raw material, and what will mining it do to the environment? I assume lithium is much rarer than iron or copper. But I don't really know.
For reference 16 million vehicles were sold in the US in 2013, but many (most?) of those were trucks and large SUVs, which AFAIK aren't on the roadmap for any EV manufacturer right now. And then there's fleet/work vehicles, single car families in states without long distance transportation or quick chargers (like TX).
It makes me wonder if 20 years from now fuel cells won't completely obsolete batteries?
https://www.eia.gov/electricity/data/browser/#/topic/5?agg=0...
It might not be possible to make all those batteries using lithium, but that doesn't really matter for stationary batteries.
He's mainly talking about lead but for lithium it's even worse.
A lot of things look great until you look at the scaling limits. Hydro storage is another example; Murphy's got a post on that too.
It's no use for everyone to argue over wether a completely implausible idea is financially competitive on a small scale when the implication is we're talking about scaling on a national level.
Variable electricity needs already mean we use less electricity at night time [0]. Shift electricity expensive processes preferentially run at night to the day and using 80%/120% seems like a reasonable rough approximation. So we need 4,686,400,000,000 / 365 / 2 * 0.8 ~= 513,5780,822 kwh in the '12 dark hours'
Between current supplies nuclear hydro and wind we account for approximately 30% of electricity generation [1], on the assumption that electricity generation from these is constant, but can't be ramped up during the night, we get about 4,686,400,000,000 / 365 / 2 * 0.3 = 1,925,917,808 kwh. Leaving 3,209,863,014 kwh needed from storage, or 501,541,095 powerwalls.
But this would mean turning a car-park with just 40 plugs into needing 1,600 amps at 240v. With those grid connected homes having modest 2kWh solar installations you're talking 80kw/h. If you only spent 3kWh getting to work on average (double that for the round-trip) you'd fully charge the cars in a couple hours.
So I guess the goal would be to run your home off the unused capacity. But then you're putting a far heavier duty cycle on those batteries. Whose going to pay for them when that $10,000 pack needs to be refurbished in five years? Or do we just accept EVs depreciating down to zero when the pack replacement cost exceeds their value?
There may well be good answers to all this. Just some things that popped into my head.
It would seem at first glance to be very costly for the car park, the grid and the consumer. I'm not sure any technology with the depreciation schedule of lithium batteries makes sense financially or environmentally?
My modest intended implication was that if we only care about total sums, where the car is doesn't matter too much, as long as it has access to the grid.
The economics could work out, if the car park charges you more for electricity than they pay the grid; and the grid your home less that it charges the car park.
The car park and the grid both take a cut. For the home- and car owner, this works out to a slightly less efficient battery cycle. (If you convert the money charged back into the equivalent amount of energy.)
Of course, if you are going to use your electric vehicle like as a battery like this, it's going to affect the battery's useful life. The same would happen with the single purpose battery you have sitting in your home.
Now, the performance characteristics one looks for in a car battery and a grid storage battery are different. So I don't know whether using the car battery as a home battery even makes sense. (Ie home batteries can be bulky, but better be cheap. Car batteries have to be light and charge fast.)
On a more refined note, one can play the same game, but only do it during spikes. Ie the car can stop charging during a spike in demand, and even uncharge if the spike gets big enough or the battery is already full.
This won't do much for the diurnal cycle (that we discussed above), but a contribution during the spikiest peaks might already be worthwhile.
My gut feeling is that we will see the demand shaping for charging, but I am more doubtful about whether we'll see cars actively feeding back into the grid.
He is definitely biased against solar, but is acutely aware of the costs it presents to traditional power generation and definitely well qualified to comment on them.
They don't understand these things, they see less than half of the equation because they don't want things to change, and they only see the problems and have no interest in solving them.
IT wasn't that long ago that they were saying that solar was impossible, or that wind would never be affordable.
They were wrong about that and they will be wrong about how difficult it is going to be to adapt to lots of intermittant renewable energy powering the grid. They will complain vociferously, and they may be able to talk about some of the difficulties, but we can't trust their perspective on the big picture.
What about coking coal, for the production of steel from iron ore?
Fission plants are held to a much higher standards of safety in terms of eg decrease in quality adjusted life-years per Gigawatthour than any other form of producing electricity. Even solar.
(Though most deaths and injuries from solar come from people slipping off their roof when installing residential capacity. If memory serves right.)
The problem with nuclear is waste disposal (still not figured out, and a will be a problem for decades/centuries after the plant is closed) and amortization of billions of capital costs.
With the price disruption potential of other technology, it's a bad bet, and has been so for many years.
https://www.caiso.com/Documents/CaliforniaISOPeakLoadHistory...
I used to work at a power company as well.
(It's true that the daily peak is in the evening and that won't be helped by solar. But capacity is built to handle the annual peak, not the daily peak, and because the annual peak tends to be hot afternoons, solar actually will replace other generation in the long run.)
I bet this could even out demand quite a bit.
With the current flat rate pricing structure, there is no incentive whatsoever to shift demand to blunt spikes.
$$$ per kWh stored (and the lifetime/cycle life + operating costs of that storage) is a key benchmark.
It's already happening, but I predict we'll see more of that in the future.
Eg lots of industrial applications like smelting aluminium can do with short-ish power cuts. In return, they get a steep rebate on their electricity bill.
Would it be possible (in an utopian world) to actually have a global power network and route electricity produced during the day in one area across multiple timezones to an area where the demand is greater and no available solar? e.g. Electricity produced in West Africa at noon to be delivered to .. Tokyo, where it would be 9PM.
I understand that politically this is almost impossible, but I am curious whether there are any technological impediments for this to be feasible.
Assuming it's not a battery backed system, prices on those are dropping (or more correctly remaining stable while capacity slowly climbs).
It also makes coal less economical and makes gas plants, which are cleaner and safer to operate more economical.
Some countries need AC, others need heating.
Plus there is the problems of cities with not enough sunshine and otherwise problematic weather (snow on the panels).
You need local storage. As much as is said about batteries, the only real solution here is hydro. Expect to see every viable valley start to get dammed over the next decade or so.
Except that dams are instead being removed for a variety of environmental and associated reasons. Free lunches are rare.
http://www.csmonitor.com/Environment/2014/0803/Setting-river...
It is a problem, but not necessarily in the way you may be thinking. Peak residential power usage is in the evening when solar isn't available. Power companies therefore end up spinning down coal and natural gas during peak solar, then just spinning them back up again as the sun begins to set. [1]
So you haven't replaced the coal and natural gas plants, you're just running them less. This results in higher overall costs, because you pay $$$ to build huge plants then just let them sit most of the day, which results in higher per-watt cost of non-solar power because the infrastructure and maintenance is no longer amortized over whole-day usage.
[1] My friend, a manager of 30 years at a huge mid-west power company