This is a very common argument. It's also wrong.
Salesforce earned $6.7B of revenue in 2015^. It spent $3.2B of that revenue on sales and marketing, in other words getting new customers. It made $100M total profit.
If Salesforce stopped caring about acquiring new customers, it could cut sales and marketing spend by 90%, down to $300M. It would then have $3B of profits.
Financials (see page 7): http://s1.q4cdn.com/454432842/files/doc_financials/2016/Q4/C...
^ Technically between Feb 1, 2015 and Jan 31, 2016, and labeled in the report as Fiscal Year 2016.
It's sort of like saying, "If we stop investing in R&D and machine maintenance, our factory will be much more profitable." In an accounting sense, yes, sort of. But in reality, no, because you're eating your seed corn.
I grant that Salesforce is still in a "let's buy market share" mode, so we shouldn't expect to see a profit. So they could be just growing happily. But they also could be in a highly competitive market without much competitive advantage. Or it could be that they are using marketing spending to boost revenues well beyond what's sustainable. From the numbers, we can't tell. Which, I believe, was ericabiz's point.
I don't know if they are, but just because the numbers look good does not mean much.
things like profitability and sustainability are for suckers, plebe small businesses that they won't look at until they smell an opportunity. otherwise, you might as well be the taco joint they eat lunch at. they'll say great things about you and even use your products, but they wouldn't give you more than an hour of their time.
they have the best jobs on the planet, that's for sure. i'm not saying they don't do work, they certainly do, it's just extremely favorable for them, because they have all the money. so what are you gonna say, chump? nothing.
watch out for their lawyers, too. it's hard to tell which of the two are more full of shit.
I love it when I read an article, generally agree with it, feel like i'm wiser now, and then read the comments and someone like you shows me I automatically agreed with the author without thinking about it too much.
Gotta work on my critical thinking. Any recommendations on what to read?
This sort of awareness takes time to build, much like building muscle at the gym.
For the first article you read every day, take 1 minute and pay attention to how it made you feel. Are your biases and beliefs affirmed or challenged? Can you argue the other side of it fairly? Are there ways the author could be fooling himself or fooling you?
If you try that for a while, my guess is that you'll notice particular biases and develop reactions to them. E.g., lately I've been working on in-group bias. I'm more likely to agree with authors I perceive as "us", and more likely to disagree with authors I perceive as "them".
:)
Not only does it have a lot of excellent business advice, but he's also a pretty hilarious writer.
More recently, I enjoyed Dan Lyons' skewering of Silicon Valley culture with "Disrupted" (which just came out and has been getting a lot of press.) I didn't agree with everything he said, but it was a great read nonetheless.
An interesting analogy is steroid usage among men in fitness. I guess that is why the author used it.
Maybe using insane amounts of capital isn't a black/white issue and more dependent on your market/business type. Obviously, you are right about everything else just being cyclical.
Also, that is very illuminating about Salesforce.
Probably not them but other companies with less capital have achieved better long term results.
I think we should have a serious discussion about "startup dumping" and business inequality. I don't know how to solve the unfair competition pushed by companies who can spend a lot of money acquiring customers without a profit but it is important to increase the success rate of startups with less capital.
FTA: > If the cost of customer acquisition (CAC) is greater than the lifetime value (LTV), a startup can grow itself to death.
Oh, you mean like Salesforce? No, wait, they had an IPO and they still only rarely show a profit. And they hold their LTV very close to their chest, so we still have no idea if CAC is lower or higher than LTV.
> When investors talk about growth, we’re talking about sustainable growth.
No, you're not, because you continually fund companies that do the opposite. Salesforce, Webvan, Pets.com from the first boom. Instacart, Uber, Lyft, WeWork, HubSpot from the latest.
> The period of cheap capital and billion dollar checks has ended.
Same thing we heard in 2001 and 2007.
> In this capital constrained market, buying scale is no longer going to be a credible lever for the next generation of startups. ... Companies can no longer look to money as a performance enhancing drug for scale-up.
Until it is again. It wasn't OK to "buy scale" in 2001 or 2007, but it was in 1997-1999 and 2012-2014. And now in 2016, it's fallen out of fashion again.
Either we're going to have a raging depression, or the bubble will inflate again. Hypothetically, both of those scenarios could actually happen--a depression followed by bubble inflation yet again.
This is why I suggest that founders tune out the idiocy and focus on building a sustainable business. You probably won't build an Uber as quickly as Uber did. But you'll be hugely protected against the inevitable downfall, and won't find yourself cash-strapped and forced to switch gears quickly (notice Uber now singing the "we plan to be profitable in most U.S. cities this year" tune.) And, more importantly, you'll have built a life for yourself, your employees, and their families that are depending on you.