Re:Why Uber Won
by wpietri on Saturday April 23, 2016 @05:33PM
(#11557509)
This seems to assume that the number of customers would stay steady if marketing costs drop to zero. That strikes me as implausible.
It's sort of like saying, "If we stop investing in R&D and machine maintenance, our factory will be much more profitable." In an accounting sense, yes, sort of. But in reality, no, because you're eating your seed corn.
I grant that Salesforce is still in a "let's buy market share" mode, so we shouldn't expect to see a profit. So they could be just growing happily. But they also could be in a highly competitive market without much competitive advantage. Or it could be that they are using marketing spending to boost revenues well beyond what's sustainable. From the numbers, we can't tell. Which, I believe, was ericabiz's point.
It's sort of like saying, "If we stop investing in R&D and machine maintenance, our factory will be much more profitable." In an accounting sense, yes, sort of. But in reality, no, because you're eating your seed corn.
I grant that Salesforce is still in a "let's buy market share" mode, so we shouldn't expect to see a profit. So they could be just growing happily. But they also could be in a highly competitive market without much competitive advantage. Or it could be that they are using marketing spending to boost revenues well beyond what's sustainable. From the numbers, we can't tell. Which, I believe, was ericabiz's point.