News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by Theodores on Saturday April 23, 2016 @09:54AM (#11555522)
It is quite hard to think of a tax haven that is not part of the Commonwealth or former British Empire, Panama being one of the few. A true tax haven is a different thing to mechanisms like the 'Double Irish', seems UK PLC is getting even with that.

The Square Mile - 'City of London' - is like a country within a country too, so lots of strange finance things go on with London being one big black hole that money orbits, mysteriously.

This is how Britain punches above its weight to make London a 'world city' as far as global capitalism is concerned. This has been going on for centuries.

Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by cylinder on Saturday April 23, 2016 @10:27AM (#11555634)
Australia also has very lax money laundering laws, it is said that Mossack Fonseca would have faced less regulation being based in Australia vs Panama.

Tories are all about extracting wealth through property and money management (tax avoidance and money laundering are forms of asset management really).

Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by jamessb on Saturday April 23, 2016 @11:10AM (#11555846)
Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by nixisfun on Sunday April 24, 2016 @02:47AM (#11558831)
Australia has reasonably strong money laundering laws. Australia also has quite strong financial tracking via AUSTRAC and the big four banks. Do you have any sources?
Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by twic on Saturday April 23, 2016 @10:23AM (#11555625)
None of Macau, Monaco, Liechtenstein, or Switzerland are former British possessions.
Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by bb101 on Saturday April 23, 2016 @10:32AM (#11555651)
But they all share the same similarity - culturally and historically connected to their larger counterparts, enabling well-connected citizens to hide their money.
Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by rmc on Saturday April 23, 2016 @09:04AM (#11555380)
And don't forget the Channel Islands and Isle of Mann. Lots of sorta-British tax havens there.
Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by anexprogrammer on Saturday April 23, 2016 @09:54AM (#11555519)
You missed a few British territories.

Cayman Islands, British Virgin Islands, Jersey, Isle of Man, and Bermuda is the full list I think.

Makes statements from Cameron on the topic especially hypocritical.

Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by loopbit on Saturday April 23, 2016 @10:52AM (#11555753)
You forgot Gibraltar, but your point stands.
Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by dghughes on Saturday April 23, 2016 @11:19AM (#11555892)
What about the City of London within London does it have separate banking rules?
Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by pjc50 on Saturday April 23, 2016 @05:28PM (#11557497)
The "city" as a social group has a lot of indirect influence. The City of London Corporation is an unusually-shaped local authority with a long history. It's not the banking regulator, that falls between the BoE and the FSA. The City does however have control of the anti-fraud police.
Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by vermontdevil on Saturday April 23, 2016 @12:15PM (#11556132)
Probably the biggest one of all
Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by return0 on Saturday April 23, 2016 @12:09PM (#11556110)
Cyprus, malta, seychelles ...
Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by anexprogrammer on Saturday April 23, 2016 @01:50PM (#11556555)
All independent nations with no legislative connection to London unlike the territories.

Cyprus and Malta aren't even tax havens.

Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by hackerboos on Saturday April 23, 2016 @02:02PM (#11556604)
Cyprus was the preferred incorporation location for US companies doing business in the EU.
Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by return0 on Saturday April 23, 2016 @04:43PM (#11557342)
Agreed, but it seems all those small countries occupied by the British ended up becoming low-tax jurisdictions attracting foreign investments. Cyprus & malta are popular destinations in europe for online businesses and royalties collection.
Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by mentos on Saturday April 23, 2016 @10:31AM (#11555648)
Anyone else feel like the problem here isn't tax havens but the tax system.

Is there a better approach than collecting taxes?

What if inflation was used as a tax (printing money)?

Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by throwaway7456 on Saturday April 23, 2016 @11:01AM (#11555804)
Inflation wouldn't work since its used by governments as a tool to adjust import and export rates.

A alternative system to taxes would be to demand payment whenever someone uses a state resource. A shop uses roads to have goods delivered, so they should pay a percentage to the state. Customers use the road to travel to the shop, so a small price is paid by the shop to the government per customer. If someone don't want to use the roads, they are free to buy the land necessary and build their own road system.

A factory has also transported goods and employees traveling to work, but they also uses the public education that those employees has. That mean for each hired employee, the factory should pay the relative price as compensation to the state. If a factory don't want to hire state educated citizen, they are free to find a workforce elsewhere.

A internet service sends bits traveling in copper and fiber that goes through state owned land. A price per bit then is reasonable. Same goes to radio waves traveling through state owned air space. If someone don't want to pay, they are free to build their own network.

Then there is the protection racket where police and military prevents theft. Those costs has to be recovered, so a monthly price in relation to the assets being protected sounds perfectly reasonable. If someone don't want to pay, the military can always go and make a visit.

Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by mvc on Saturday April 23, 2016 @11:44AM (#11555994)
That last point is why the rich should quit whining about paying proportionately more tax. They have more to lose given a leviathan state.
Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by F2468 on Saturday April 23, 2016 @10:39AM (#11555679)
Wouldn't people just store wealth in things that are out of reach of politicians inflation policies? Bitcoin, gold etc?

Another approach is to lower taxes and create less of an incentive to circumvent them in the first place...

Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by Hermel on Saturday April 23, 2016 @12:00PM (#11556073)
That's why VAT is such a popular tax in Europe. It is very hard to evade. As soon as you spend money, you pay taxes.
Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by scurvy on Saturday April 23, 2016 @12:23PM (#11556162)
What about VAT fraud? A couple of shell companies and not only have you evaded the tax, you've now profited from it.
Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by Hermel on Saturday April 23, 2016 @12:45PM (#11556256)
It's certainly possible, but still much harder to evade than a sales tax or an income tax.
Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by lucaspiller on Saturday April 23, 2016 @12:31PM (#11556197)
> It is very hard to evade.

Its pretty easy to get residence in a non-EU country and then reclaim the VAT when you return 'home'. Your 'non-EU' country can even be as close as Jersey.

Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by Hermel on Saturday April 23, 2016 @12:47PM (#11556267)
That works for physical goods, but not for a diner in London.
Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by crdoconnor on Saturday April 23, 2016 @10:54AM (#11555775)
Other than as a disincentive (e.g. cigarette taxes), the whole point of taxes is to clamp down on inflation.

The government certainly doesn't need taxes to create money to pay for things.

Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by dragonbonheur on Saturday April 23, 2016 @12:53PM (#11556299)
Like Zimbabwe? Seriously?
Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by mavhc on Saturday April 23, 2016 @11:37AM (#11555976)
So is USA of course, as shown on The Daily Show. 15 second clip: https://youtu.be/pm_a58S1NjU?t=27
Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by known on Saturday April 23, 2016 @09:29AM (#11555445)
Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by guard-of-terra on Saturday April 23, 2016 @08:38AM (#11555296)
Для многонационалов.

If you understand what I'm getting at.

Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by mtmail on Saturday April 23, 2016 @09:16AM (#11555416)
That translates to "for multinational". I don't understand what you're getting at though.
Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by guard-of-terra on Saturday April 23, 2016 @09:31AM (#11555456)
A person who fits a profile:

- Born in Russia

- Speaks Russian

- Holds or used to be holding Russian passport

- Does not really consider oneself Russian or answers "I'm Russian, but"

- Does not respect Russians, not really, but knows what's better for them

- Probably has ancestors who were important Soviet officials, often in some now-independent Republics

- Liberal political outlook but ends up backing Putinism when acting

- Probably owns something in London, Miami, Nice

- Family members living in aforementioned locations

- Probably sits in government or duma or connected to such officials

- In a position for which it's hard to reason if they are competent and how their life trajectory landed them there

That's the people who run & own Russia for all its sorry state.

Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by mtmail on Saturday April 23, 2016 @10:23AM (#11555624)
Thanks a lot!
Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by vixen99 on Saturday April 23, 2016 @08:56AM (#11555354)
Tangentially - if there's no tax rate competition which seems to be the desired goal of many, there's nothing to stop politicians continuing to bribe their electorate with bread and circuses paid for by that electorate's money. The gigantic debt mountains in the US and the EU demonstrate the degree to which they do that. And when it's all over, out of office, out of responsibility! Companies have of course to keep prudent accounts or go out of business.
Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by toyg on Saturday April 23, 2016 @09:53AM (#11555518)
> Companies have of course to keep prudent accounts or go out of business.

Wrong comparison. A politician is to government what a CEO is to a company. Loads of CEOs make terrible decisions to appease the stock market short-term, then leave the company before shit hits the fan. Replace "CEOs" with "prime ministers" and "stock market" with "electorate". Human nature is what it is.

Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by Ontheflyflyfly on Saturday April 23, 2016 @10:02AM (#11555548)
" if there's no tax rate competition"

The point is, these executives are not living in Ireland or Panama but in the valley or some highly developed country in Europe. So while the enjoy the benefits of those countries, the want to avoid paying taxes.

No one has anything against people who want to enjoy Irish tax laws who move to Ireland. Or people who want to have a company in Panama to move to Panama.

Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by icebraining on Saturday April 23, 2016 @01:59PM (#11556592)
That's a novel position. So US companies, whose executives presumably live in the US, shouldn't open an EU subsidiary, and vice-versa? Is it wrong for Toyota to open a subsidiary in the US?

Not to mention that executives don't "have" companies, shareholders do.

Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by Ontheflyflyfly on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @12:31AM (#11569454)
Yes, if the executives at Apple decide that they want to pay corporate taxes in Ireland instead of the US to reduce their taxes and increase their income, they should move Apple to Ireland from the valley.

You can twist my words to "Is it wrong for Toyota to open a subsidiary in the US?" as you like, it doesn't change the point.

Some people bring arguments, some play word games "Not to mention that executives don't "have" companies"

Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by icebraining on Saturday April 23, 2016 @09:11AM (#11555401)
Considering that currently "tax rate competition" exists, and as you point out the US and EU have "gigantic debt mountains" anyway, the argument that such competition is important to keep states from accumulating too much debt seems to be defeated by your own claims.
Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by sievebrain on Saturday April 23, 2016 @09:34AM (#11555466)
It's the other way around - if all tax rates were uniform around the world, borrowing (or variously disguised forms of tax rebate) would be the only way for governments to control their own budgets.
Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by ssmoot on Saturday April 23, 2016 @09:15AM (#11555411)
You can have a different political opinion without being hyperbolic and going all "wake up sheeple!".
Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by dragonbonheur on Saturday April 23, 2016 @08:01AM (#11555186)
Speaks volumes why Obama wants the UK to remain in the EU. His corporate handlers know that it is inevitable that taxes will increase if there is a Brexit.
Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by vidarh on Saturday April 23, 2016 @09:13AM (#11555406)
That makes no sense. The EU countries with higher tax levels are constantly pushing to reign in the EU "tax havens", whereas outside the EU, the UK will be free to use even lower tax rates and more tax breaks as a means of retaining and attracting international business, and may need to, in order to prevent an exodus from the City etc.
Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by dragonbonheur on Saturday April 23, 2016 @10:26AM (#11555632)
According to http://www.proeuropa.org.uk/twelevereasons, the UK enjoys all of this thanks to the EU:

1. Jobs

Around 3.5 million British jobs are directly linked to British membership of the European Union’s single market – 1 in 10 British jobs.

2. Exports & investment

The EU buys over 50 per cent of UK exports (54 per cent of goods, 40 per cent of services). Over 300,000 British companies and 74 per cent of British exporters operate in other EU markets. American and Asian EU firms build factories in Britain because it is in the single market.

3. Trade

The EU negotiates trade agreements with the rest of the world. Outside the EU Britain would have to renegotiate trade deals alone. While the EU is the world’s largest market, a UK outside the EU would not be a high priority for other counties to negotiate a trade deal.

4. Consumer clout

British families enjoy lower mobile phone roaming charges, lower credit card fees, cheaper flights and proper compensation when flights are delayed or cancelled. These sorts of benefits could not be achieved by Britain alone.

13. Research funding

The UK is the second largest beneficiary of EU research funds, and the British Government expects future EU research funding to constitute a vital source of income for our world-leading universities and companies.

A Brexit could mean that there will be increased taxes on all of this to compensate from these lost advantages, which will surely translate to increased corporate taxes.

Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by fauigerzigerk on Saturday April 23, 2016 @11:32AM (#11555955)
The UK is completely free to set its taxes inside the EU as it sees fit. Just look at Ireland with its 12.5% corporation tax and its position at the center of numerous tax evasion schemes.

You say other countries are constantly pushing, but Ireland was only recently bailed out by exactly those other Eurozone countries, and even in that precarious situation, Ireland was not forced to change its tax rates.

Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by varjag on Saturday April 23, 2016 @10:18AM (#11555609)
To be fair, exiting EU would put the UK at disadvantage as EU tax heaven / headquarters beachhead. Common customs and VAT space goes out of the window, as well as hundreds other compliance regulations tying the EU together. Luxembourg and Cyprus will certainly get a lot of new business.

But I really doubt Obama rationales have anything to do with that.

Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by dragonbonheur on Saturday April 23, 2016 @10:28AM (#11555637)
Obama by himself, no. But the executives from which he raised money will make him do and say anything they want.
Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by fauigerzigerk on Saturday April 23, 2016 @11:46AM (#11556006)
No one can make a US president in his last year in office say anything.
Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by dragonbonheur on Saturday April 23, 2016 @12:13PM (#11556126)
Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by fauigerzigerk on Saturday April 23, 2016 @12:24PM (#11556167)
Please explain to me how this proves or even just suggests that Obama was forced to say anything.
Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by fredley on Saturday April 23, 2016 @08:36AM (#11555289)
I would have thought remaining in the EU would result in (eventual) greater regulation, and Brexit would make the situation worse (for non-corporations).
Re:UK 'a tax haven for multinationals' (2014) by ryanlol on Saturday April 23, 2016 @08:50AM (#11555336)
Are the people taking advantage of these arrangements non-people?