News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Virtual Weapons Are Turning Gamers into Serious Gamblers by levemi on Thursday April 21, 2016 @03:37PM (#11544826)
This story isn't about Valve but the author sure made it seem like it was. A third party site uses Valve's API to enable users to bet skins on esport competitions. This third party site uses Valve's API. Valve is in no way involved in betting. The only thing they haven't done is turn off access to the API for this third party company.

This is probably more because of Valve's management structure than it is about any policy. Valve is a flat company with no managers. People work on what they want to work on. Jobs like customer support and policing API use are akin to taking out the trash, nobody wants to do it but someone has to. It just isn't a priority.

Anyway, ignorant article with a dishonest attempt at trying to spin two things together "illegal betting!" "valve" and failing.

Re:Virtual Weapons Are Turning Gamers into Serious Gamblers by thrubbery on Thursday April 21, 2016 @04:37PM (#11545162)
No, Valve sells scratch-off tickets. Or if you like, they give you the ticket ("case") and sell you the coin to scratch it with ("key"). Same thing.

They're not directly involved in the sports betting aspect, but they'd be running an illegal lottery without the fiction that their digital goods have no real world value, which is the same fiction maintained by the betting houses.

It stretches credibility to say they aren't very involved.

Re:Virtual Weapons Are Turning Gamers into Serious Gamblers by Rmilb on Thursday April 21, 2016 @05:52PM (#11545593)
I don't buy "scratch-off ticket" analogy. How are those crates with randomized prizes different from a pack of pokemon cards that are randomized with cards with differing value? They are pretty identical in the terms we are talking about.

A failed suite was brought against pokemon in 1999. [http://www.nytimes.com/1999/09/24/nyregion/suit-claims-pokem...]

Re:Virtual Weapons Are Turning Gamers into Serious Gamblers by thrubbery on Thursday April 21, 2016 @07:29PM (#11546050)
To the extent that there is a liquid secondary market in trading cards, I'm not sure there is a real line between them and retail gambling instruments. But, some things cases have more in common with scratchers than Pokemon booster packs:

- They're available instantly in effectively unlimited quantity, as many as you want to buy.

- Although technically there are many gradations, the quality label of an item ("Factory new", "battle-scarred", etc.) is incontrovertible and easily verified.

- As a digital good, liquidation is extremely low-friction and virtually risk-free. In fact:

- You can click a button from within the game itself to see the current market value in USD -- sorry, in "Steam credit" -- and another to immediately offer the item for sale at that price.

- Maybe most relevant to this thread, even without liquidating they can be easily used as currency to participate in unregulated online roulette, slots, sports betting and more.

So, yeah, there are some differences.

Re:Virtual Weapons Are Turning Gamers into Serious Gamblers by cmdrfred on Thursday April 21, 2016 @08:46PM (#11546359)
Astute analysis, Valve's proximity to the secondary market seems to be the issue here. They also appear to allow you to generate keys for games that can then be sold[0][1]. This provides you with an indirect way of cashing out your earnings.

[0]https://www.g2a.com/call-of-duty-modern-warfare-2-steam-cd-k... ($7.23 USD vs Steam price of $19.99 USD)

[1]https://www.g2a.com/mass-effect-trilogy-origin-cd-key-global... ($13.66 for all 3 Mass Effect games or $34.99 on Steam)

Re:Virtual Weapons Are Turning Gamers into Serious Gamblers by jeeva on Friday April 22, 2016 @05:35AM (#11548015)
They don't allow end-users to generate keys for games - that is restricted to the publishers or game creators (in smaller cases).

The keys on those sites are generally sourced from physical copies in cheaper regions (as mentioned in a sibling comment), cheaply sold bundles (Humble Indie Bundle, and other similar sites), and other such sources.

You could possibly make an argument for gift-copies of games[0] being resalable, or games that can be added to third party systems (ME2 gives a CD key that can be added to Origin, for example) though the latter would be limited to one attempt per-game per-account.

[0]http://www.g2play.net/category/24773/factorio-steam-gift/

Re:Virtual Weapons Are Turning Gamers into Serious Gamblers by ac29 on Thursday April 21, 2016 @09:36PM (#11546514)
I'm under the impression those "cheap keys" are from other regions where games are sold for cheaper, and can potentially get your account locked.
Re:Virtual Weapons Are Turning Gamers into Serious Gamblers by 542458 on Thursday April 21, 2016 @03:50PM (#11544892)
> Valve is in no way involved in betting.

Valve makes money when people buy or sell skins, which in this case is akin to buying or cashing in one's poker chips. There's also no way that Valve doesn't know that this is going on. While they're not involved in the strictest sense, they continue to allow this gambling to happen (by not policing their API) and make money by doing so.

Re:Virtual Weapons Are Turning Gamers into Serious Gamblers by eric_h on Thursday April 21, 2016 @03:55PM (#11544923)
I wonder what the legal implications are for valve here, vs the third parties that are facilitating the gambling. Surely the companies taking bets are also taking a rake (how else would you pay for your infrastructure/support overhead) and this is illegal in most of the US. Does Valve, by indirectly profiting from the wagering exchange actually bear some (legal) responsibility?
Re:Virtual Weapons Are Turning Gamers into Serious Gamblers by scotty79 on Thursday April 21, 2016 @04:48PM (#11545234)
Are the companies that issue stock responsible if people bet with them in poker games?
Re:Virtual Weapons Are Turning Gamers into Serious Gamblers by WorldMaker on Friday April 22, 2016 @01:35PM (#11550881)
A better question would be whether NASDAQ or any other stock exchange is responsible if people use them to trade poker bets. What if NASDAQ was making a large profit on those exchange fees?

Valve is not only issuing the stock, but it's also acting as the stock exchange and taking exchange fees. It may not make them any more "responsible", but there is a whole lot of moral gray area there.

Re:Virtual Weapons Are Turning Gamers into Serious Gamblers by Goronmon on Thursday April 21, 2016 @04:48PM (#11545233)
>Anyway, ignorant article with a dishonest attempt at trying to spin two things together "illegal betting!" "valve" and failing.

How is a system where you spend real money in the hopes of receiving a valuable item by random chance not considered betting/gambling? Because that's effectively what system like the skins in CS:GO is at its core.

Re:Virtual Weapons Are Turning Gamers into Serious Gamblers by Houshalter on Thursday April 21, 2016 @09:02PM (#11546415)
As someone pointed out above, that's not different than trading card games. It's arguably more restricted than real world trading cards because you can't sell them outside valves market.
Re:Virtual Weapons Are Turning Gamers into Serious Gamblers by eterm on Friday April 22, 2016 @05:12AM (#11547931)
But now imagine there's a company that lets you bet on card games using those cards.

There are two main gambling themes in CSGO which people here are conflating.

There's the slot machine like gambling of buying keys and opening cases.

But there's also sites which literally let you gamble on sports or even just virtual roulette etc using skins as currency.

Re:Virtual Weapons Are Turning Gamers into Serious Gamblers by Houshalter on Friday April 22, 2016 @09:47AM (#11549100)
I'm aware of the gambling sites, but that's not Valves doing. If people gambled with pokemon cards, no one would care.
Re:Virtual Weapons Are Turning Gamers into Serious Gamblers by Aelinsaar on Thursday April 21, 2016 @11:39PM (#11546918)
You play with those cards, you don't play a game with the skins. The cards are the game in a CCG, skins are the not the game in CS:GO
Re:Virtual Weapons Are Turning Gamers into Serious Gamblers by paulddraper on Friday April 22, 2016 @01:36AM (#11547255)
> you don't play a game with the skins

Except you do play a game with them. (though they affect that gameplay aesthetically)

Re:Virtual Weapons Are Turning Gamers into Serious Gamblers by Aelinsaar on Friday April 22, 2016 @10:17AM (#11549351)
That's what I meant. The game is not centered around skins. It is not a "Collectible Skins Game", but an FPS. CCG's are, as the name implies, all about the cards and what you can do with them.
Re:Virtual Weapons Are Turning Gamers into Serious Gamblers by imtringued on Friday April 22, 2016 @02:50AM (#11547467)
Yu-Gi-Oh does have identical cards with cosmetic differences. Are those not part of the game?
Re:Virtual Weapons Are Turning Gamers into Serious Gamblers by Aelinsaar on Friday April 22, 2016 @10:17AM (#11549356)
I have to admit to knowing nothing at all about Yu-Gi-Oh, and therefore have no basis to make an informed response, sorry.
Re:Virtual Weapons Are Turning Gamers into Serious Gamblers by nfbush on Thursday April 21, 2016 @07:17PM (#11546006)
Valve do not provide a public trading api that is needed to run these sites, they mostly use steamkit2 an open source library that was made from re
Re:Virtual Weapons Are Turning Gamers into Serious Gamblers by dvanduzer on Thursday April 21, 2016 @09:00PM (#11546410)
This problem applies to any app store.
Re:Virtual Weapons Are Turning Gamers into Serious Gamblers by eric_h on Thursday April 21, 2016 @03:46PM (#11544872)
Good catch, I blew right by that detail on my first read.
Re:Virtual Weapons Are Turning Gamers into Serious Gamblers by osweiller on Friday April 22, 2016 @07:39AM (#11548379)
Assuming that Valve just hasn't gotten around to closing this loophole seems remarkably charitable, if not naive.

Valve is making untold millions on people gambling for items in the game itself. They're looking the other way as secondary markets allow for monetization. I respect Valve as a game maker, but I have no respect for this extremely dubious, gray-market gambling. Claiming that the article is "dishonest" when Valve is one of the largest beneficiaries of this seems dubious.

It's also worth noting that this is very real money. I can put $70 on my Steam account and buy a new triple-A game....or in the land of Valve I can sell some skins and buy the game. It is trading things in CS:GO for real world value, so comparisons to closed-systems (throughout this thread) seems deeply suspect. I can also use that CS:GO loot to "gift" a new game to a friend who then pays me in the real world. And so on.

Re:Virtual Weapons Are Turning Gamers into Serious Gamblers by squozzer on Thursday April 21, 2016 @03:47PM (#11544873)
With us, it fails. With state attorneys general, it's another pound of flesh.