News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by HorizonXP on Thursday April 21, 2016 @12:21PM (#11543303)
What a level headed response by the transport minister. I love that he acknowledges that geofencing rules will easily be circumvented.

That said, I still think it's a good idea to implement. It will make it easier for casuals like me to quickly be warned when I'm venturing into forbidden areas. Sure, I could ignore it or hack around it, but at least it's an easy to implement safeguard that will keep most people away.

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by Splines on Thursday April 21, 2016 @01:20PM (#11543765)
There's a danger to this though; if drone pilots are universally expected to be warned when they fly in dangerous areas, then pilots will start flying "to the edge" and expect the technology to always keep them in line. I would be surprised if restricted areas were stable enough that drones could store a database of no-go areas and keep it up to date easily.

It would be more straightforward to set clear policy and provide a way for drone pilots to know where not to fly (e.g., provide an online map and require altitude telemetry to the controller at all times). Include a link to this information with every drone purchase.

My guess of what will happen if we go down the GPS route: Some incident with a drone will occur, and the pilot will say something like "the drone didn't warn me that I was in a restricted area".

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by Jtsummers on Thursday April 21, 2016 @01:36PM (#11543882)
With cars we have technologies called roads and lines and signs that tell us where we can and cannot go. But sometimes, those fail us. Particularly in areas with lots of dirt roads (no lines). And especially when there are many dirt roads (potentially no signs, too many locations to put them up). That does not excuse people from driving in restricted areas. It may be cause for mitigation. But, at least around here, driving in an otherwise unmarked (signs) wilderness protection area (on the map), will still get you a ticket and a fine if you're caught. Even if you did pass into it on a dirt road you were allowed to drive on and there were no signs.

The pilot can try that line of reasoning, it is (somewhat) valid. But reviewing maps would, ideally, only be made redundant. Since we don't live in an ideal world, it'd still be their responsibility to know where they were flying.

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by Retric on Thursday April 21, 2016 @03:37PM (#11544824)
This only helps if drones are not actually dangerous. If they are, and an Airbus is destroyed, then that's the problem.

Also, finding a drone operator is not necessarily easy.

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by hirsin on Thursday April 21, 2016 @01:33PM (#11543862)
That's actually good precedent to bring up - has e.g. Google Maps or more infamously, Apple Maps, ever been held liable for bad directions? I believe it's still seen as the end user's responsibility to obey the laws, especially when the safeguards fail.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by Jtsummers on Thursday April 21, 2016 @01:37PM (#11543895)
A friend recently (several months ago) was fined because he trusted Google Maps to be accurate and drove into an otherwise unmarked (by the route he took into it) wilderness protection area. He got the minimal fine because he demonstrated that he'd tried to obey the law (showed that Google Maps marked the areas, but marked them incorrectly), but he was still fined.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by tamana on Friday April 22, 2016 @05:26PM (#11552667)
Surely even without maps the problem is the same: the route is unmarked.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by Jtsummers on Friday April 22, 2016 @09:54PM (#11553743)
The maps exist and folks who go in those areas are expected to use them. Available cheaply (free?) anywhere you might get hunting supplies.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by ryanlol on Friday April 22, 2016 @11:54AM (#11550082)
Did he contest that fine in court? If not, why is this story relevant?
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by Jtsummers on Friday April 22, 2016 @12:11PM (#11550218)
He did. Because it's a demonstration of how the court system (at least in the US) generally works. Pleading ignorance of the law when violating it, even when you use tools that are supposed to prevent that violation, doesn't always work. Anyone using these systems should still be aware of what they're doing and where they're allowed to go and should consider them mitigators, at best, when they get caught in violation of air space.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by pmarreck on Thursday April 21, 2016 @02:11PM (#11544184)
Someone got killed recently because Waze took them to a same-named street but in a bad neighborhood in Brazil
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by lukeadams on Thursday April 21, 2016 @02:24PM (#11544283)
http://www.cnn.com/2015/10/05/americas/brazil-wrong-directio... seems to be the story you are referencing.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by emodendroket on Thursday April 21, 2016 @03:46PM (#11544868)
Waze seems like insanely dangerous software in the first place. The whole idea of a "social" driving application that constantly pops up little alerts that the driver is supposed to respond to seems to be inviting distracted, dangerous driving.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by Karunamon on Thursday April 21, 2016 @03:59PM (#11544944)
"Supposed to respond to?" Yes, by driving. The alerts take the form of "Traffic ahead". "Police ahead", etc. There is no interaction required, or even expected unless you really want to poke the thumbs up "yes, this alert is still valid" button.

(And if you can't do that safely, given the size and consistent location of the button, you probably shouldn't have a license anyways)

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by wildmusings on Friday April 22, 2016 @02:59AM (#11547490)
And how do you suppose Waze gets that information? People enter it while driving.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by emodendroket on Thursday April 21, 2016 @04:38PM (#11545167)
> unless you really want to poke the thumbs up "yes, this alert is still valid" button.

Which is precisely what the app encourages people to do.

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by emodendroket on Thursday April 21, 2016 @04:45PM (#11545216)
The problem is not the mechanical difficulty of pressing a large button, the problem is that the application popping up alerts and encouraging you to press the button means taking your eyes away from the road.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by enzanki_ars on Friday April 22, 2016 @08:29AM (#11548605)
You are encouraged to use the "hands free" option of reporting in the app by waving your hand over your phone.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by emodendroket on Friday April 22, 2016 @09:15AM (#11548847)
"Hands free" technology is intuitively appealing but in reality it's about as distracting as regular operation.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by Karunamon on Friday April 22, 2016 @02:56PM (#11551690)
At some point we've moved into the point of diminishing returns and pointlessness. Carrying on a full conversation might be one thing - barking the words "acknowledge alert" or similar at your phone probably doesn't cause a measurable or significant distraction.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by emodendroket on Friday April 22, 2016 @03:06PM (#11551777)
> It takes drivers up to 27 seconds to return to full attention after using voice commands to make a hands-free call, turn on the radio or perform other tasks, according to two studies released Thursday by the AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety. Traveling at 25 miles per hour, that would equal the length of three football fields.

http://bigstory.ap.org/article/8135f446be2e4922b27dc3881155e...

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by Karunamon on Friday April 22, 2016 @03:47PM (#11552089)
No link to the actual study, not even so much as a DOI. Never mind "make a hands free call" implies carrying on the call...

I'm calling shenanigans anyways. What on earth is the driver doing for those 27 seconds? How are they determining "full attention"?

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by emodendroket on Monday April 25, 2016 @09:30AM (#11564018)
http://unews.utah.edu/up-to-27-seconds-of-inattention-after-...

"Attention" isn't a binary; it's a gradient from full attention to no attention at all.

"With researchers in the car, the drivers were tested for the extent of their distraction, even as they kept their eyes on the road and hands on the wheel after hitting a voice-command system button. A head-mounted LED light flashed red every three to five seconds at the edge of a driver’s left eye. Drivers pressed a switch attached to a thumb when they saw the light. The researchers measured how voice interactions with a car or smartphone reduced drivers’ reaction times and accuracy at seeing the flashing lights. The drivers also completed surveys about their perceived level of distraction, and videos measured how much of the time they kept their eyes on the road, mirrors or dashboard."

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by tamana on Friday April 22, 2016 @05:31PM (#11552685)
"Researchers measured the return to full attention by timing participants' response to a flashing light."

The description in the article suggests that the time was counted from the start of the voice command action.

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by emodendroket on Monday April 25, 2016 @09:31AM (#11564027)
http://unews.utah.edu/up-to-27-seconds-of-inattention-after-...

That's not correct. "The most surprising finding was that a driver traveling only 25 mph continues to be distracted for up to 27 seconds after disconnecting from highly distracting phone and car voice-command systems, and up to 15 seconds after disconnecting from the moderately distracting systems."

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by enzanki_ars on Friday April 22, 2016 @08:28AM (#11548597)
You are encuraged to use the "hands free" option of reporting in the app by waving your hand over your phone.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by Karunamon on Thursday April 21, 2016 @04:41PM (#11545191)
See last line. Nobody's getting into wrecks because of Waze.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by astrange on Thursday April 21, 2016 @06:34PM (#11545814)
The alert I see the most with Waze is "Vehicle stopped on shoulder", which is not only distracting when the yellow sign pops down and animates out, but can't possibly be relevant to my life when I'm driving in the left lane.

Most of the rest are fine.

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by holyoly on Thursday April 21, 2016 @07:15PM (#11545995)
You can turn on and off each individual notification. And it also has voice commands built in to control the app. You don't even need the phone's screen on. It can be in your pocket while driving.

And it is relevant to you no matter what lane you are in. If there is a car on the shoulder, someone in the right lane could be not paying attention, and swerve into you to avoid that car. Though you should be always on high alert while driving, having a little extra notification and awareness could save your life.

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by astrange on Friday April 22, 2016 @03:31PM (#11551977)
> If there is a car on the shoulder, someone in the right lane could be not paying attention, and swerve into you to avoid that car.

Then on 101 they'd still be a lane or two away from me, so most of the time it doesn't matter. But someone's car is guaranteed to be broken down somewhere every day, so it just comes up all the time.

BTW, you actually can't turn it off without disabling all Hazards, but the rest of them like "object in lane" seem pretty good.

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by emodendroket on Friday April 22, 2016 @09:16AM (#11548857)
Wouldn't it be safer to pay attention to the road and notice someone swerving your way than to get an alert, look over your phone to read it, then look up to catch the swerving car?
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by pmarreck on Friday April 22, 2016 @01:23PM (#11550775)
What if the vehicle is around the next bend?

Are you actually arguing that drivers should have less information available to them?

Disclaimer: I use Waze and think it's fucking fantastic and do not understand this stupid brouhaha in this thread.

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by emodendroket on Friday April 22, 2016 @01:36PM (#11550885)
> Are you actually arguing that drivers should have less information available to them?

I'm arguing that drivers should be paying attention to operating their cars instead of their phones.

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by pmarreck on Friday April 22, 2016 @01:21PM (#11550761)
Yeah, God forbid someone touches a radio dial while they're driving or anything. Someone could get killed!
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by cpncrunch on Thursday April 21, 2016 @12:41PM (#11543453)
>That said, I still think it's a good idea to implement. It will make it easier for casuals like me to quickly be warned when I'm venturing into forbidden areas. Sure, I could ignore it or hack around it, but at least it's an easy to implement safeguard that will keep most people away.

Yes, it's definitely a good idea that will stop casual drone users from being somewhere they shouldn't be flying. Here is a good example (see the description):

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EH7y8-gkkN0

The vast majority of drone users won't bother looking up the aviation charts to see if they are inside a control zone or other controlled airspace, and won't have any idea how far away they are from an airport.

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by kawsper on Thursday April 21, 2016 @12:55PM (#11543575)
I fly my quadcopter in the UK. It would be nice to have an app that told me about the airspace I was in based on my current position.

However, right now I am not flying higher than 10 meters from the ground.

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by 6stringmerc on Thursday April 21, 2016 @01:07PM (#11543669)
Round up a team and put it in the ApplyHN sector - that could be a really useful, pay-for-app & updates type service. Definitely has value. The target market should be able to see the cost-benefit I presume. Good thinking!
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by zyxley on Thursday April 21, 2016 @01:26PM (#11543814)
It seems like there could be something of an aspirational market there for 'prosumer' drone pilots who follow the rules because it makes them feel more like professionals. Include some resources on interesting uses of drones, maybe a little marketplace for connecting camera drone pilots with marketers or landowners...
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by 6stringmerc on Thursday April 21, 2016 @03:33PM (#11544790)
Absolutely - if anything, the excuse of "ignorance" factor would be a lot less. Reducing the risk of liability is a reasonable avenue in my opinion. Also if "drone racing" and the like start to get more popular, having advertisements for regional facilities could be mutually beneficial.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by nathancahill on Thursday April 21, 2016 @01:13PM (#11543715)
Classic HN. Jumping from someone's annoyance to "create a startup" that "definitely has value" without knowing anything about the space.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by 6stringmerc on Thursday April 21, 2016 @02:35PM (#11544354)
>Classic HN. Jumping from someone's annoyance to "create a startup" that "definitely has value" without knowing anything about the space.

Haha joke's on you buddy, I grew up around aviation and know that log books and maps are what pilots must always have at all times in all situations otherwise they'll get popped by the FAA. Only recently have digital devices been allowed anywhere NEAR professional cockpits, having been slowly tested in civil aviation. Thus I concluded that an expanding sector with limited knowledge of traditional expectations - airspace 'n shit - might be marketable. Watching your comment turn grey and then to vapor is more "Classic HN" to me.

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by CraigJPerry on Thursday April 21, 2016 @03:41PM (#11544846)
To be fair to your parent, the feature is already deployed in popular drones (both dji and 3dr).

It's hard to see a market for something already built in for free (airspace restrictions) and anyone familiar with current drones would know this.

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by 6stringmerc on Thursday April 21, 2016 @04:22PM (#11545069)
Considering the cost of both DJI and 3DR and the inevitable down-stream development and access, unless each and every manufacturer is mandated to include "smart" flight restrictions, then I would say the point stands. Making a useful application and product is fun to spit ball. Whizzing out some sanctimonious pontification is feeble.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by nathancahill on Thursday April 21, 2016 @04:32PM (#11545132)
Thanks for putting "Intellectual Wannabe Inventor" in your profile, it wasn't clear from that comment.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by Karunamon on Thursday April 21, 2016 @04:01PM (#11544961)
Perhaps, but with the recent move to classify straight up toys as "drones", those things probably aren't going to have such intelligence built in.

There would be value in being able to pull up my phone and find out "Yes, there are no arbitrary restrictions on flying right here".

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by CraigJPerry on Friday April 22, 2016 @01:03PM (#11550632)
It's already there, i have either my phone or tablet out when i use my 3DR Solo (it displays the video feed). One screen of the app which displays the video feed, is airspace restrictions on a map of the current area (although you can pan and zoom around the world in order to plan future flights too).
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by tremguy on Thursday April 21, 2016 @01:43PM (#11543953)
I guess that's how most startups get started AFAIK?
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by nathancahill on Thursday April 21, 2016 @02:03PM (#11544122)
Unfortunately yes, which is why you get founders awkwardly trying to answer questions like.. "How does your product compare to X and Y that are dominating the space right now?" when they've never heard of X or Y.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by TheSpiceIsLife on Thursday April 21, 2016 @03:15PM (#11544643)
X and Y are dominating the space? Good, there's a proven market.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by nathancahill on Thursday April 21, 2016 @03:21PM (#11544704)
Oh dear, it's worse than I thought.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by bbcbasic on Thursday April 21, 2016 @07:43PM (#11546110)
Nothing can go wrong. And if it does: Pivot.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by jtuente on Thursday April 21, 2016 @02:52PM (#11544470)
> Classic HN. Jumping from someone's annoyance to "create a startup" that "definitely has value" without knowing anything about the space.

All that without specifying whether or not you have knowledge in the space. You probably should have specified X and Y are already in the space rather than assuming that someone already has taken up space there.

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by nathancahill on Thursday April 21, 2016 @03:06PM (#11544569)
Besides the established ones mentioned in siblings, there's https://airmap.io/ which is quite good.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by voltagex_ on Friday April 22, 2016 @12:05AM (#11547003)
I'm assuming it's not the first time people have tried to start a business without understanding the competition - I'm not sure it's startup-specific.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by nathancahill on Thursday April 21, 2016 @01:11PM (#11543699)
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by mrchucklepants on Thursday April 21, 2016 @01:11PM (#11543700)
Foreflight[1] does something similar already but they are focused on traditional flight. This is an interesting idea.

[1] https://www.foreflight.com/

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by cpncrunch on Thursday April 21, 2016 @02:54PM (#11544479)
Foreflight costs $99/year. There are free alternatives:

- FltPlan Go app for android and ios

- skyvector.com

I use the FltPlan Go app when flying, and skyvector.com to look at the charts from a browser.

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by DonaldFisk on Thursday April 21, 2016 @05:41PM (#11545544)
You mean 33 feet. Height and altitudes below the transition level are in feet, not metres.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by pj_mukh on Thursday April 21, 2016 @04:11PM (#11545012)
http://www.hoverapp.io/

Not sure of UK coverage though.

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by andygates on Friday April 22, 2016 @04:05AM (#11547676)
Hover used not to have any info in the UK. It now does! Sweet update.

But note that no-fly zones are pretty onerous: all the best parks in $town are occluded by the huge zone for an out-of-town airport.

Likewise a local beauty spot that occasionally activates for military training is marked without any timely activation data. Is it hot or not? The zone is larger than the current NOTAM, which suggests they're being completionist, which is maximum ass-covering and minimally useful.

This sort of blunt zoning mostly doesn't make sense, and will likely get ignored.

(in fact, if that same zoning applies to geofences, all the $town flyers own bricks)

Real pilot info is semi-useful: http://notaminfo.com/ukmap ; the legal 400ft limit is 120m, which is an invisible speck in the sky. Useful for setting ceilings for waypoint flight, etc.

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by DonaldFisk on Thursday April 21, 2016 @05:32PM (#11545490)
They should still know the relevant law instead of relying on technology. There isn't that much you need to know.

In the UK, article 166 and potentially article 167 of the Air Navigation Order (http://publicapps.caa.co.uk/modalapplication.aspx?appid=11&m...) are relevant. In any case, the drone should be within line of sight, lower than 400 feet above ground level, and not be in controlled airspace or near an airport (which should be checked on an aeronautical chart - they're only about £25 and look good on your wall).

This gives a quick summary of both articles: http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/drone-rules-everything-...

And bear in mind that there are cases where pilots might be flying light aircraft well below 400 feet AGL away from an aerodrome: during ag operations (crop dusting), during a forced landing, or during a practice forced landing under instruction, so even with the ANO rules there's still potential (albeit unlikely) conflict.

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by Zigurd on Thursday April 21, 2016 @12:52PM (#11543553)
As soon as drones are required to have geofencing, you will find they become useless for monitoring the police, factory farms, pollution, "black" sites, etc. Humans die because of those things, while no practical benefit to aviation safety has been proven. And yeah, controlled airspace has been used to prevent monitoring of police, in Ferguson, for example.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by sosborn on Thursday April 21, 2016 @01:04PM (#11543651)
If we argue that regulations don't stop criminals (DRM etc) then doesn't it also hold true that regulations wouldn't stop do-gooders? (sorry, not the best word).
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by iamnothere on Thursday April 21, 2016 @01:12PM (#11543710)
It wouldn't stop activists from filming "restricted" areas, no, but it could give authorities a way to tack on additional charges ("terroristic disabling of an aviation safety device" or the like) when they inevitably find the person who leaked the video.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by cpncrunch on Thursday April 21, 2016 @01:16PM (#11543739)
Another slippery slope argument. We're talking purely about controlled airspace here. Those things you mention have never been controlled airspace.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by setra on Thursday April 21, 2016 @02:05PM (#11544141)
In general the slippery slope is not actually a fallacy.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by jdietrich on Thursday April 21, 2016 @02:24PM (#11544282)
British law is very restrictive on the use of camera-equipped UAVs. Without specific permission from the CAA, it is unlawful to use a small unmanned surveillance aircraft within 150 metres of "any congested area" or within 50 metres of "any vessel, vehicle or structure which is not under the control of the person in charge of the aircraft".
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by jle17 on Friday April 22, 2016 @06:28AM (#11548173)
It's a common tactic used by governments to push a restriction under a (often emotional) motive that looks legitimate at first and then extend it further.

"We need to do this or that because terrorism and won't somebody please think of the children."

"Well, now that it's in place, it would be a shame not to use it against illegal <insert something harmless or subversive here>."

And usually they manage to design laws so that diverting their use doesn't require passing through parliament again.

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by deckar01 on Thursday April 21, 2016 @01:22PM (#11543781)
DJI products quite effectively indicate and restrict access to no fly zones. My controller starts to beep if I get within a few hundred feet of a border to a no fly zone. I haven't tested it, but I think it is supposed to come home and land if you somehow get into a no fly zone.

That said, 1,700ft is so high, no fly zones don't really mean much anymore.

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by SixSigma on Thursday April 21, 2016 @02:58PM (#11544507)
Drones are already forbidden by law from flying higher than 400ft.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by jsmthrowaway on Thursday April 21, 2016 @06:34PM (#11545817)
They aren't, actually, and people parrot this falsehood all the time.

If we assume you're referring to the United States, don't conflate proposed rules, rules, guidelines, and law, nor circumstances that require you to seek FAA authorization for the flight (which is different than "forbidden by law," itself inaccurate).

You are talking about Advisory Circular 91-57 (Model Aircraft Operating Standards) from June 1981. Not law, just standards for their airspace. Certainly not forbiddance by law.

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by SixSigma on Friday April 22, 2016 @05:03AM (#11547896)
The FAA doesn't have jurisdiction in the UK

The CAA sets the laws here

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-30387107

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by madaxe_again on Friday April 22, 2016 @07:23AM (#11548331)
Without any certification or registration, yes - if you're CAA registered then the limits are quite different.

Additionally, if you're flying FPV the ceiling is 1000ft, not 400ft, although you must have a spotter who can maintain unassisted line of sight. Get friends with good eyes, fly further!

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by matheweis on Thursday April 21, 2016 @08:58PM (#11546405)
Where? In the US it is still legal to fly over 400' for hobby purposes when flying under the safety guidelines of a community based organization.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by SixSigma on Friday April 22, 2016 @05:01AM (#11547890)
In the UK, where this incident happened.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by gus_massa on Thursday April 21, 2016 @12:38PM (#11543430)
It doesn't look so easy. First you must put a GPS in each device, I think the cheaper drones don't have one. Also, the forbidden areas may vary, so they have to provide a way to update it.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by cpncrunch on Thursday April 21, 2016 @12:44PM (#11543486)
>First you must put a GPS in each device

A gps costs under $1 today:

http://www.alibaba.com/showroom/gps-chip-price.html

>Also, the forbidden areas may vary

It's mostly airports that we need to worry about, and they don't tend to change much. Sure, TMA boundaries might vary occasionally, but that's not really much of a worry, because most drones won't be up at 1000+ ft.

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by amelius on Thursday April 21, 2016 @01:16PM (#11543734)
What about its weight?
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by EdHominem on Thursday April 21, 2016 @02:12PM (#11544195)
More importantly, what failure modes does it have? Do you have to have GPS lock to takeoff? What if you lose it while flying?

At DEFCON someone demonstrated dropping drones from the sky by spoofing GPS coordinates to inside an airport. Funny, but it guarantees I won't be buying one of them because of the potential for harm to my camera, etc.

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by caffinatedmonk on Thursday April 21, 2016 @03:59PM (#11544949)
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by cpncrunch on Thursday April 21, 2016 @02:31PM (#11544328)
I don't know, but Phantom have been doing it for years, so you could see how they do it.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by cpncrunch on Thursday April 21, 2016 @02:29PM (#11544313)
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by thescriptkiddie on Thursday April 21, 2016 @03:59PM (#11544946)
I haven't had good luck with style of GPS module on my models, even a <100 mW 5.8 GHz FPV transmitter tends to swamp the GPS signal to the point where getting a lock is impossible.

They're also prohibitively heavy on smaller models. A 10% increase in mass (for a 300g quadrotor) can shave an entire minute off of your run time.

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by MertsA on Friday April 22, 2016 @03:08PM (#11551788)
That's just the antenna. Also, you can't get an actual GPS receiver for under a $1, around $10 is a bit more reasonable for a low price.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by ceejayoz on Thursday April 21, 2016 @12:47PM (#11543507)
> First you must put a GPS in each device, I think the cheaper drones don't have one.

The cheaper ones are frequently controlled by a smartphone app, which can do the geofencing for it.

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by chipperyman573 on Thursday April 21, 2016 @03:20PM (#11544691)
That would return the GPS coordinates of your phone, not the drone. It would not help unless you started in an airport.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by k-mcgrady on Thursday April 21, 2016 @04:37PM (#11545164)
I'm nto sure exactly how these things work but would it not be possible to get the phone GPS and then determine the position of the drone relative to that using whatever wireless tech it's using to communicate? Probably not 100% accurate but it might be good enough to say 'this drone is within 100m of a no-fly zone, stop it.'
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by andygates on Friday April 22, 2016 @04:09AM (#11547681)
It's a reasonable technical solution, yes.

More useful would be a lower ceiling in no-fly zones, tbh; no-fly is appropriate for real aircraft, but for toys there is value in considering "no-fly" and "low-fly".

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by ceejayoz on Thursday April 21, 2016 @05:32PM (#11545493)
They can't go more than a couple hundred feet from the phone before the wifi connection craps out.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by Zigurd on Thursday April 21, 2016 @12:37PM (#11543413)
Geofencing has a downside, too. While you might think it enhances aviation safety, it may not do so at all. Planes spend so little time within flying/control range of commonplace drones that, when you read about a "possible drone strike" always bet against it.

Instead it will enable mission creep as more places get banned because embarrassing things, like protesters getting beaten, happen there.

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by ddispaltro on Thursday April 21, 2016 @12:40PM (#11543440)
Yeah mission creep would be the best way to describe what I'd be afraid of with geofencing.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by blakeyrat on Thursday April 21, 2016 @01:29PM (#11543841)
I'm not sure I agree with geofencing, but it's also true that drone operators appear to be, by and large, acting like complete jerks and someone needs to get the message across somehow.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by EdHominem on Thursday April 21, 2016 @02:14PM (#11544210)
A jerk owns a drone? Better pick on the non-jerks!

A bad guy used encryption? ...

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by icebraining on Thursday April 21, 2016 @03:31PM (#11544771)
The message shows be sent by levying fines, mandating community work and putting restrictions from operating drones for X years for anyone caught being a jerk.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by cpncrunch on Thursday April 21, 2016 @12:49PM (#11543529)
>Planes spend so little time within flying/control range of commonplace drones that

It depends where you're talking about. Close to airports is the major issue. 2nm from the runway planes will be at 600ft, which is well within the range of drones.

>Instead it will enable mission creep as more places get banned because embarrassing things, like protesters getting beaten, happen there.

We're talking about voluntary geofencing here, by the companies themselves.

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by nitrogen on Thursday April 21, 2016 @12:55PM (#11543576)
We're talking about voluntary geofencing here, by the companies themselves.

Much as I like the idea of keeping drones away from planes, just look at how governments have abused other "voluntary" restriction systems. For example, ISPs install filters for ostensibly noble causes, then governments commandeer them for more questionable uses.

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by cpncrunch on Thursday April 21, 2016 @01:14PM (#11543727)
Sounds like a slippery slope argument.

Which governments of civilized, democratic countries have commandeered ISP's filters for questionable uses? If you're talking about the UK porn filter, it is the other way around: government has instituted a law saying they have to do it.

Even if it were a law, I don't see the issue that you are arguing. You're essentially saying "I don't want a law that says drones are banned by default from controlled airspace, because the government might change it's mind and also ban drones from places that embarrass the government", which is just another slippery slope argument.

Are you saying you don't want any laws at all, and people should just be able to do anything they want?

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by EdHominem on Thursday April 21, 2016 @02:26PM (#11544291)
> Sounds like a slippery slope argument. [...] it is the other way around: government has instituted a law saying they have to do it.

Yeah, that's the point. When the technology has been demonstrated to work (even if badly) in some areas it's suddenly mandated in other areas.

Now we have a technology that was so-so at blocking unwanted porn being used for everything from catching pedophiles to checking for intel leaks. A false-positive in porn blocking was annoying, in pedo-detection it can ruin lives. Worse, when functioning properly it can prop up repressive regimes.

> Are you saying you don't want any laws at all, and people should just be able to do anything they want?

Is that the only choice? Egregious laws that harm innocents and don't actually solve the issue versus no law at all? Well in that case, it's clear. No law is better than being stuck with bad law that doesn't actually help...

But thankfully those aren't the only options. We can push back against bad laws (useless, abusive, etc) and accept the good ones.

> "I don't want a law that says drones are banned by default from controlled airspace, because the government might change it's mind and also ban drones from places that embarrass the government", which is just another slippery slope argument.

No, we don't want useless technological measures mandated that claim to block drones from airports, but fail to actually help in a real security context. Because those useless security rules have only one real purpose - banning civilians from inconvenient things.

Laws, like lines of code, have a distinct cost and we should only add the ones that will actually help.

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by cpncrunch on Thursday April 21, 2016 @02:36PM (#11544361)
>No, we don't want useless technological measures mandated that claim to block drones from airports, but fail to actually help in a real security context. Because those useless security rules have only one real purpose - banning civilians from inconvenient things.

It's not useless. Do you fly planes? If you look at the youtube video I posted elsewhere in this thread you'll see that the guy wanted to fly near the airport on the beach, but the geo fence wouldn't let him. The beach is <0.5nm from the end of the runways, so planes will be at <300ft crossing the beach. I fly there myself, and I don't want to hit a drone and risk losing the engine or having it crash through the windshield into my face.

Unfortunately we need laws like this because people aren't responsible, as that youtube video proves.

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by EdHominem on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @12:10AM (#11577775)
Useless because it's billed as stopping terrorists. Let's be honest, consider ham radios; the mandated but easily bypassed hardware lockouts are more useful for market segmentation than preventing bad guys from broadcasting on ATC frequencies.

So as a convenience feature that told me I the conditions for where I'm flying, it'd be great. And then it'd only need to be 4-nines, and wouldn't have to have fail-proof lockouts, etc.

But as a major portion of the defense of our air fleet - no. That's ridiculous. If we're that worried we need to figure out something to actually make us safer, not add another perpetual layer of theater.

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by icebraining on Thursday April 21, 2016 @03:34PM (#11544802)
Yeah, that's the point. When the technology has been demonstrated to work (even if badly) in some areas it's suddenly mandated in other areas.

I'm not sure that seeing an actual implementation is required for politician to have harebrained ideas. Besides, as others have pointed out, geofencing has already been implemented by DJI, so we're past that phase anyway.

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by woodman on Thursday April 21, 2016 @04:47PM (#11545231)
> Sounds like a slippery slope argument.

Strange, I'm having a hard time thinking of a single US government program that hasn't expanded far beyond the original justification. Bureaucracies expand, water is wet. A classic example of a USG switcheroo would be the social security number being used for identification purposes beyond social security administration. A more contemporary example would be the NSA providing intel to the DEA for domestic law enforcement, which I'm sure wasn't part of the founding mission statement.

> Which governments of civilized, democratic countries...

So only a true Scotsman?

> Are you saying you don't want any laws...

Are you saying that if somebody caused an accident with a drone, then prosecutors would just throw up their hands? We already have enough laws on the books to charge anybody for anything. If causing a horrible accident isn't enough of disincentive for a drone operator then I doubt that they'd pay any attention to the FAA.

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by mindslight on Thursday April 21, 2016 @01:23PM (#11543785)
> We're talking about voluntary geofencing here, by the companies themselves.

That's not "voluntary" - the manufacturers are not the owners/operators of the drones.

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by cpncrunch on Thursday April 21, 2016 @02:32PM (#11544337)
I (obviously) meant voluntary on the part of the manufacturers. That is how Phantom do it, and it seems to work well.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by mindslight on Thursday April 21, 2016 @03:19PM (#11544678)
Sure, and creation of a law would be voluntary on the part of the government. The end result for the owner is the same - an involuntary restriction of their drone's software.

We don't need any more encouragement of device lockdown, treacherous computing, and the general erosion of ownership.

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by cpncrunch on Thursday April 21, 2016 @03:34PM (#11544805)
>We don't need any more encouragement of device lockdown, treacherous computing, and the general erosion of ownership.

Actually, we do, at least in this case. The majority of users don't know/care about flying close to airports. (See my other comments in the thread).

From what I can tell, however, all the larger drones tend to have geofencing already, so perhaps the current de facto situation is adequate.

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by mindslight on Thursday April 21, 2016 @04:35PM (#11545153)
I'm sympathetic to the criticality of airport approaches, but also sympathetic to people flying drones above their own property to arbitrary heights while informing ATC (perhaps it's time to revisit that previous uncompensated aeronautical space grab). But this balance is orthogonal to what I'm arguing about.

In any industry that adopts treacherous computing, it spreads like cancer. Phones, cars, entertainment, payment cards. Assumptions of the user being hostile get baked into the design and business models, and must be fortified ever-harder over time. In a computing-based world, perverted cultures that mandate closed devices are simply incompatible with individual autonomy and self-reliance. "Selling" a device while retaining control over it is basically fraud.

Pragmatically, I'd be in favor of the "default config" coming with built-in geofencing to avoid thoughtless idiotic situations. But then the ability to change and fully remove that code must also be provided, ideally through well-documented reflashing process. Anything less creates the unavoidable centralizing path down the slippery slope, and from the users' perspective it hardly matters whether it's the manufacturer or government driving the process.

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by dTal on Sunday April 24, 2016 @09:59AM (#11559696)
Fantastic comment.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by SixSigma on Thursday April 21, 2016 @02:59PM (#11544517)
> planes will be at 600ft, which is well within the range of drones.

not legally

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by cpncrunch on Thursday April 21, 2016 @03:21PM (#11544701)
Yes, it's already illegal, but most people aren't aware of - or don't care about - the laws. The youtube vid I posted here was < 1nm from the end of the runway at CYAZ, which means planes are at <300ft. The only reason the guy wasn't creating a hazard is because the geofence in his Phantom wouldn't let him use his drone there, so he had to move a few miles down Long Beach.
Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by SixSigma on Thursday April 21, 2016 @02:57PM (#11544502)
It is illegal for your drone to be more than 500m away from you laterally and 122m vertically.

How would you expect to hit a plane ?

Re:Drone believed to have hit British Airways flight 'may ha... by gruturo on Thursday April 21, 2016 @05:43PM (#11545552)
Illegally?