News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 ... by foobarian on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @08:39AM (#11533897)
The author repeatedly expresses regret at having made poor financial decisions using the savings or debt as a metric. But it seems to me he has done quite well in fact: his daughters went to private schools, elite universities, had a nice wedding. What family, poor or well off, wouldn't sacrifice as much for their kids? Then he managed to stay true to his calling of a writer without compromising or cutting corners (this is a big one!). Look at the many quintessential immigrant families who used to be doctors or lawyers in their native countries who take up menial jobs to scrape by and still do a lot worse than the author. Or others who swallow their pride and go into more well-paid professions that they don't necessarily have passion for.

I'm probably lowering the standard of living target reasoning like this, which is not fair to the article which focuses on what middle class should be like, or was in the post-war boom decades. But still it could be a lot worse.

Re:Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 ... by iainmerrick on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @09:00AM (#11534011)
His specific complaints seem pretty reasonable to me:

We haven’t taken a vacation in 10 years. [...] We have no retirement savings, [...] We eat out maybe once every two or three months. Though I was a film critic for many years, I seldom go to the movies now.

They're not destitute, but shouldn't most people expect to get at least some of those things more often than that?

The lack of retirement savings seems particularly bad, as the author notes they used their parents' savings to pay for their children's educations. Their children won't be able to do the same.

And as another commenter has noted, it's not just a "woe is me" sob story, the idea is that the author is representative of a secret 47%(!) who are ashamed to admit how badly they're doing. The comparison with impotence seems apt.

[Edit: spelling]

Re:Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 ... by true_religion on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @09:30AM (#11534196)
It's a choice.

Is private schooling for children worth losing out on the opportunity to eat out as a family of 4 at a good restaurant every week (that's 250 per meal, so $1000 a month)?

Is funding your daughter's wedding (2000-10,000), worth skipping a vacation?

I think being middle-class is all about making choices between giving up luxuries of the body (e.g. resturant food), for luxuries of opportunity (e.g. schooling). If you are rich, you can have both your yatcht and private school. You can go to the country club, and keep a maid at the same time.

Being poor on the other hand is about making choices between necessities like "should we have water or power this week? pick one" or "should our food be nutritious or should we clean our clothes? pick one".

Re:Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 ... by cableshaft on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @10:17AM (#11534524)
What planet are you living on where a wedding only costs $2,000, and no more than $10,000? In the US, the average wedding cost is $30,000 (http://money.cnn.com/2015/03/12/pf/planning-for-wedding-cost...) now. That being said I personally think that's ridiculous and I'll do my damnedest to try to keep mine under $5k, but I know it won't be easy, and there will have to be many things sacrificed.

If they're even wanting to have a modest wedding with 80-ish guests nowadays, I can't imagine paying less than $15k (which is why I'm going to try to make it less than 20 people for mine. Hell, I'd be happy with 2).

That being said, I wouldn't want to eat out at a $50/person restaurant with a family of four once every week. You could take them to a bbq or pita or chinese restaurant and they'd eat well for under $15 per person.

I don't really disagree with your main point, just your numbers seem to be bad estimates to me.

Re:Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 ... by MatthewMcDonald on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @11:40AM (#11535234)
> What planet are you living on where a wedding only costs $2,000, and no more than $10,000? In the US, the average wedding cost is $30,000

The idea of spending $30,000 on a wedding seems insane to me, and it reminds me of the Dave Ramsey quote “If you will live like no one else, later you can live like no one else."

> That being said I personally think that's ridiculous and I'll do my damnedest to try to keep mine under $5k, but I know it won't be easy, and there will have to be many things sacrificed.

My wedding (2 years ago, in the midwest) had about 100 guests and cost us about $5000 total (doesn't include the rehearsal dinner or the bar tab, which our parents covered). There were probably some things that we could have spent even less on, but it would have required us doing more things ourselves. A few things we did that might be different than the norm:

* My wife, mother, and grandmother made many of the decorations themselves

* The reception venue was less expensive because we had the wedding in April, because it wasn't during "wedding season"

* We had the grocery store make our cake for us

* We didn't pay anything for the ceremony location (there are many beautiful public venues that you can book for free)

* My wife chose a dress that was beautiful, but wasn't obscenely expensive. She also recovered about half of the cost by selling it afterwards.

Re:Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 ... by true_religion on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @05:20PM (#11537841)
> If they're even wanting to have a modest wedding with 80-ish guests nowadays,

It's kind of funny. I've been to six weddings in the past five years and none of them had over 50 people.

I guess some people just have more friends and family or are under some kind of custom wherein they invite 2nd or 3rd cousins or minor acquaintances to their weddings.

My best friend's wedding was 40 people, total cost to the bride and groom $1000. Location: a beautiful beachhouse owned by his aunt. Food and the such done by the family, and everyone who flew in stayed in houses of relatives. Photography done by my wife, music by his brother.

Save money on your wedding, spent it on your honeymoon.

> I wouldn't want to eat out at a $50/person restaurant with a family of four once every week.

I like exotic food with ingredients and cooking conditions I can't replicate at home, so $50 a plate it is.

> I don't really disagree with your main point, just your numbers seem to be bad estimates to me.

Right :)

That's really the issue at heart. Everyone makes choices that X is worthwhile, and Y isn't worthwhile. Some people choose no luxury at all, save all their money and cash out at 35 to retire.

Re:Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 ... by PhantomGremlin on Thursday April 21, 2016 @06:01AM (#11540754)
What planet are you living on where a wedding only costs $2,000, and no more than $10,000?

Oh, come on! When a friend decided to get married, he and his fiancee went downtown and got married by a judge. Just the two of them. They fed each other french fries at the nearby McDonald's. They're still married 30 years later.

And, partially as a result of that frugality, they recently had the enviable problem of how to invest $1,000,000 cash, when they sold their big house after their kids grew up. They're currently living in a simple 3 bedroom, 2 bath tract house because they don't need more.

Another friend also got married downtown by a judge. I was there as best man, there was also a maid of honor. That totals 4 people. That was 1990. They're still married.

Weddings don't have to be expensive.

Re:Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 ... by scarface74 on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @12:28PM (#11535571)
Our "wedding" cost $25 at the court house and we had a reception later on for around $3000.
Re:Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 ... by ansible on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @10:11AM (#11534484)
(that's 250 per meal, so $1000 a month) ... your daughter's wedding (2000-10,000)

Those numbers struck me as very strange. I've rarely eaten at places that are $62.5/head. But spending just $2000 on a wedding seems low. $10,000 isn't unheard of in the circles I travel in.

Re:Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 ... by brewdad on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @01:37PM (#11536157)
$250 per meal is certainly towards the higher end in most places, but my family of 3 does that, in total, almost every weekend. Figure $100 for dinner Friday night. Another $30 for breakfast Sat morning. Add in $50-$70 for lunch Sat and Sun and there you are.

We rarely eat out during the week, and we don't usually eat dinner out both Fri AND Sat nights, but the above is fairly typical for us. I don't think it is too atypical for our peers either.

Re:Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 ... by ogsharkman on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @01:42PM (#11536202)
maybe it's that new vegan place down the street? /s
Re:Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 ... by tamana on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @03:07PM (#11536894)
The vegan place at my street costs $12per adult and $6/kid. And the menu is constantly rotated seasonally.
Re:Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 ... by iainmerrick on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @10:21AM (#11534560)
I think being middle-class is all about making choices between giving up luxuries of the body (e.g. resturant food), for luxuries of opportunity (e.g. schooling).

Maybe so, but that definitely didn't used to be the case, which is pretty much the thrust of the article. Its other point is that the scale of the problem is hidden because people are ashamed to talk about it.

Re:Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 ... by refurb on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @10:46AM (#11534766)
Maybe so, but that definitely didn't used to be the case

What makes you say that? I talk to my parents and my grandparents and they all had to sacrifice for their family.

I can't think of a single time in history when people generally had so much disposable income that they didn't need to worry about money.

Re:Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 ... by harryh on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @10:29AM (#11534618)
Why do you think that it didn't used to be the case that people had to make choices about what luxuries they wanted to buy? I think that people have always had to make these kinds of choices.
Re:Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 ... by iainmerrick on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @10:52AM (#11534815)
I'm thinking of the middle class of my own parents' generation. They did not have to worry too much about choosing between restaurant food and schooling.

There are always going to be luxuries that you can't afford to indulge in regularly. That's what a luxury is!

Colleges and restaurants didn't used to be luxuries. I didn't fully appreciate that they now are, so this article is eye-opening for me in that respect.

(I'm from the UK where the college setup is different from the US, but it's moving in the same direction, a decade or two behind the curve.)

Re:Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 ... by harryh on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @11:11AM (#11534970)
I don't know about the UK, but 30 years ago in the US 20% of the population graduated from a 4 year college. Now it's 30%. Access to higher education is becoming easier not harder.

Similarly, more people are eating out in restaurants more of the time.[1]

I think you have a rosy view of the past that isn't supported by evidence.

1. http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-04-14/americans-...

Re:Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 ... by iainmerrick on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @12:51PM (#11535762)
I have a rosy view of the present, maybe!

The big question is how well the middle class is doing today. They did pretty well in the past and the expectation was that things would continue getting better.

(Edit to clarify:) I figured that things are actually still pretty good for many people, but this article's claimed "47% of people can't easily find $400 in an emergency" seems to fly in the face of that.

Re:Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 ... by true_religion on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @05:10PM (#11537776)
I'm not sure about college since its different in every locale, but as for resturants I think its more that the menu and clientelle changes which pushes up the price.

In my neighborhood, some restaurants are $20 a meal. These places have been in business for over 15 years, and serve decent quality food but only staple ingredients with spices.

The newer resturants that have openned serve fresh imports from another hemisphere away, and start at $50 a plate.

So there's a choice at least here---you can get $10 sushi with tilapia, or you can go get $35 sushi with blowtorch cooked kobi beef.

As I've gotten older, I trend more towards the Kobi beef place myself... and I think that's how it is with most of the middle class. Cheaper choices do exist, but we consider them 'below our standards for a night out' especially considering that age+experience leads to better home cooking.

Re:Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 ... by lr4444lr on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @10:22AM (#11534566)
Neal Gabler is teaching at Stony Brook Southampton, so I assume he lives there. The high school doesn't seem that bad, dare I even say above average: http://www.usnews.com/education/best-high-schools/new-york/d...

I'm not sure where he might have sent his kids for K - 8. In any event, people generally move out to Long Island suburbs for great schools. He could have just as well made the sacrifice of using that money for private schools instead on a house in a district that met his standards of schooling, which would have had a much lower NPV via a 30 year fixed mortgage than paying for private school annually. Plus, his house would likely have risen more in value.

It sounds to me like the author might just be a tad more financially illiterate than he should be given his lifestyle.

Re:Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 ... by tamana on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @11:22AM (#11535078)
Southampton is one of the wealthiest towns in the world. He probably thinks he is poor because all his neighbors drive new Lexus SUVs and Tesla's.
Re:Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 ... by kamaal on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @04:33PM (#11537509)
>>shouldn't most people expect to get at least some of those things more often than that?

Spend $100K on a wedding, and then save $15 on a movie a week/two-weeks to make up for the remainder of your life.

Why would you even get into this situation?

Re:Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 ... by Spooky23 on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @09:18AM (#11534114)
At the end of the day, you lie in the bed that you make. The trappings of prosperity are expensive, so you need to weigh the cost/benefit carefully.

My colleagues tease me about my 15 year old car with nearly 300k miles. My peers at work mostly lease BMWs and SUVs. But cars are an expense with a payout worth little to me. (If I was a hotshot salesdude, that trapping of success would have a high value.)

You can't have it all. If you try to do so, you're going to sacrifice something -- and in most cases you sacrifice your future.

Re:Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 ... by justinhj on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @01:43PM (#11536207)
I find modern cars are very expensive to fix and I have no interest in learning how to do it myself. I bought a car over a few years with the intention that when it is paid for I would enjoy a few more years for free. But the maintenance costs went up and it would breakdown. Frequently simple repairs would be $1-$2k because of the cost of labour to get to the broken parts and replace them. Maybe I was unlucky but I prefer to lease a modest vehicle so I'm always driving a newish one and I don't have to worry about breaking down or expensive repairs.
Re:Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 ... by FireBeyond on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @05:19PM (#11537834)
When I bought my first "luxury" vehicle (a mid level Audi), I was able to roll into the financing for about $5K more a "service" and "care" package that for the first 6 years covers of course all the usual scheduled maintenance and service, but basically "as long as you didn't break it yourself, everything will be fixed with no out of pocket".

That seemed a worthwhile investment to me.

Re:Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 ... by mikestew on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @02:13PM (#11536460)
Quit buying BMWs (or whatever). Our Scion xB, basically a Toyota Echo and long since paid off, after 80K miles needs gas and the occasional oil change. Seeing as how it's a Toyota, I don't expect that to change in the next 50-100K miles. Might have to throw a clutch in it at some point, it is hilly around Seattle.

Not that I'm blindly hating on BMWs. Love their cars, and I have two of their motorcycles in the garage (one for me, one for the wife). I'll say upfront that my R1200GS is probably the finest motorcycle I've ever owned. But cheap to run it ain't (for example, it apparently needs a $100 set of rear brake pads every 5K miles; no, I didn't drop a zero). If I wanted cheap-to-run, I'd have bought another Honda. "Luxury brand" means it will continue to be a luxury to own even after the initial price is paid off.

Re:Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 ... by justinhj on Friday April 22, 2016 @01:25PM (#11550805)
It was no BMW, just a Dodge. If I do buy a car again I'll definitely do more research on reliability repair and service costs. Or buy a $1000 car and consider it disposable.
Re:Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 ... by mikestew on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @05:46PM (#11575963)
A little late on the reply, but then again, so were you. :-) Disappointing that it was a Dodge. Back in the original Dart days, at least one comedian commented, "in the event of nuclear war, two things will be left: cockroaches and Dodge Darts", nodding to their near-indestructability. (Though rust appeared to be their Kryptonite.)

If I do buy a car again I'll definitely do more research on reliability repair and service costs.

I'll save you the trouble: Toyota. Boring as hell, and with "boring" come reliability and low maintenance. I seriously worry sometimes that I'm forgetting something on our Scion (a rebadged Toyota Echo) because it so rarely requires attention. And Toyotas have been known for reliability for decades. The old SR22 engine is the stuff of legend. Assuming Hondas are as good as they were 30 years ago when I last owned one, and are as reliable as their modern motorcycles, they would probably be a good bet as well.

Re:Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 ... by Spooky23 on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @04:58PM (#11537707)
You have to do what makes sense. I've been really lucky with my car (Honda Pilot). I probably have about $1k in annual costs, mostly due to wear items.

My goal for cars is to average $2,000/yr in vehicle cost over its lifetime. I hit a home run with my car, but my wife's minivan will miss the mark. (Because the sliding doors break annually)

Re:Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 ... by geerlingguy on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @08:48AM (#11533949)
The problem is that everything is done without a safety net of an emergency fund, retirement funds, etc. as a fallback. For some reason (keeping up with the Jones'?), many Americans have the idea they must spend so much on lifestyle (transport, bigger house, services, weddings, kids) that they never have much to save in retirement, emergency savings, or other investments.
Re:Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 ... by FifthSurprise on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @08:59AM (#11534007)
Not to mention there's this air of invincibility where someone ignores retirement/emergency savings because "If something happens, it happens and I'll just fail/declare bankruptcy/die". It would be very pessimistic except what that thinking really means is "I don't think it will happen to me at all."
Re:Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 ... by vintermann on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @09:41AM (#11534274)
As he says in the article, he's not so concerned about "keeping up with the Joneses", but he's concerned about his kids keeping up with the Joneses' kids. With rising inequality, it's hard to fault him for that.
Re:Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 ... by refurb on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @10:45AM (#11534754)
I'd argue most of the Joneses he's trying to keep up with aren't doing that well themselves.

The median household income in the US is ~$55K/yr. Most Americans don't send their kids to private schools or pay for expensive weddings.

He's not trying to keep up with the average American, he's trying to keep up with the upper-class. And guess what? There will always be someone richer than you.

Re:Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 ... by tamana on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @11:23AM (#11535090)
As rayiner said, people buy expensive things for themselves and pretend it is for the kids' benefit.
Re:Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 ... by enobrev on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @10:36AM (#11534673)
It seems "Keeping up with the Jones'" would have a domino effect, where Albert Jonesy is going broke to keep up with Brian Joneston, who is spending everything to keep up with Christina Jones, and so on. So everyone's broke, embarrassed, and behind, but still "better off" than the seemingly humble [n-1] Jones' next door.
Re:Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 ... by mcguire on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @09:23AM (#11534145)
On the other hand, would spending less on private schools, elite universities and so on have been worse than being in a situation where one major whoopsie leaves them living in a cardboard box?

Put your own oxygen mask on first. Aviate, navigate, communicate.

Re:Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 ... by lazyjones on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @09:19AM (#11534121)
What I don't understand is this: if he sacrificed so much for his kids, they went to private schools and elite universities, why would he have trouble asking them for $400 for an emergency? Is a good education worth nothing these days, are they making poor financial decisions too? I refuse to believe that you can send several kids to private schools/universities without being able to save some money for emergencies, or accumulate some assets/property that can be liquidated if needed.
Re:Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 ... by iSnow on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @11:28AM (#11535134)
>if he sacrificed so much for his kids, they went to private schools and elite universities, why would he have trouble asking them for $400 for an emergency?

Uhm, it's right in the article that he had to ask them to pay for heating...

Re:Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 ... by brianwawok on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @10:06AM (#11534454)
His parents paid for most of the private school, so it isn't like he came up with the 300k himself.
Re:Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 ... by cableshaft on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @10:27AM (#11534602)
Yes, a good education is worth nothing these days. Literally nothing. (I kid, but it doesn't seem too far from the truth nowadays)