That seemed a worthwhile investment to me.
Not that I'm blindly hating on BMWs. Love their cars, and I have two of their motorcycles in the garage (one for me, one for the wife). I'll say upfront that my R1200GS is probably the finest motorcycle I've ever owned. But cheap to run it ain't (for example, it apparently needs a $100 set of rear brake pads every 5K miles; no, I didn't drop a zero). If I wanted cheap-to-run, I'd have bought another Honda. "Luxury brand" means it will continue to be a luxury to own even after the initial price is paid off.
If I do buy a car again I'll definitely do more research on reliability repair and service costs.
I'll save you the trouble: Toyota. Boring as hell, and with "boring" come reliability and low maintenance. I seriously worry sometimes that I'm forgetting something on our Scion (a rebadged Toyota Echo) because it so rarely requires attention. And Toyotas have been known for reliability for decades. The old SR22 engine is the stuff of legend. Assuming Hondas are as good as they were 30 years ago when I last owned one, and are as reliable as their modern motorcycles, they would probably be a good bet as well.
My goal for cars is to average $2,000/yr in vehicle cost over its lifetime. I hit a home run with my car, but my wife's minivan will miss the mark. (Because the sliding doors break annually)