News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by 11thEarlOfMar on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:31PM (#11505584)
What is missing is that the total income in the state in 2012 was $1.1 Trillion.

So the top 1% earned 28% of the income, but paid 45% of the total taxes:

https://www.ftb.ca.gov/aboutFTB/Tax_Statistics/Reports/2013/...

Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by lisper on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:36PM (#11505622)
But that too is as it should be. Extra tax on the wealthy means they have to settle for the Citation Jet instead of the Gulfstream. Extra tax on the poor means they have to choose whether to pay for food or rent this month.
Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by mc32 on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:47PM (#11505708)
Right but that goes against the narrative which permeates indie media where the 1% are freeloading devils with offshore accounts who are running the state into the ground because they are not paying their fair share of taxes.

Mind you I'm not a 1%er. Not that that should have any bearing. But indie media have their dead horse they like to climb on and it wears thin.

Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by basch on Friday April 15, 2016 @02:17PM (#11506469)
who has more to lose if order and the fabric of society break down, those with or those without? if you already have nothing, and live in uncivilized territorty, the breakdown of order will make things worse, but marginally less so than for those isolated from the ills of poverty.

lets call a spade a spade and treat tax like what it is, a protection racket. you are protecting yourself from two things: alien invaders and zombie hoards. health care, food, housing, and, entertainment keep the hoards from destroying your logistics infrastructures and disrupting transportation routes. it also keeps them just alive enough to keep buying what you are selling. defense, police forces, and tough crime laws reduce your risk of having your factories and warehouses bombed or burned to the ground. in short, you are paying for muscle and placation, keeping the peace. (edit: forgot, you are also paying for intellectual property protection, so your inventiveness cant be cloned or repackaged.)

why should the 'rich' pay the majority of the taxes? because it benefits them the most to have low crime healthy consumers. whose problem does it end up being if the 99% are unemployed, homeless, starving, diseased, and unable to consume. whose house slash bunker is going to get broken into, the person with nothing, or the person with years of survival stockpile? why should the 'rich' pay the majority of the taxes? because they are the ones with something to lose (a business, a family, a lifestyle), worth paying to protect.

all that said, im not defending the current tax code or federal government as an efficient or effective way to put that "protection/socialorder" tax to good use.

Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by prostoalex on Saturday April 16, 2016 @03:06AM (#11509631)
Considering most of the rich can move at a moment's notice, aren't you over-estimating their reliance on "low crime healthy consumers"?

There's an entire cottage industry in places like Monaco, Panama or St Kitts & Nevis built on rejecting that thesis.

Additionally, is California with its high income tax rates significantly safer and healthier than states with no such tax, like Washington or Nevada?

Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by matthewmacleod on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:51PM (#11505752)
I'd point out though that the oft-cited '1%' is often shorthand for '0.1%' – that maybe lazy, but a different figure.
Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by philangist on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:54PM (#11505788)
It also generally refers to the top '1%' with regards to wealth, not income.
Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by blazespin on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:54PM (#11505779)
You don't understand. 45% of 1 million means nothing. Maybe skimp on the next vacation to Paris. 20% income tax on 60k means someone might never be able to retire or help pay for his kids college degree.
Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by bdcravens on Friday April 15, 2016 @01:31PM (#11506130)
As long as we can poke fun at what they spend their money on, and dehumanize them, we can justify any tax level. Maybe that extra 17% could have gone into angel investments.

Perhaps the idea that those that earn 28% of the income need to be taxed at 45% is an indictment on California's spending.

Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by fredrik-j on Sunday April 17, 2016 @05:02AM (#11513926)
If you look beyond the fun poking and focus on the facts, you'll still find that the trickle down economic policy your argument imply simply doesn't work.

https://psmag.com/the-imf-confirms-that-trickle-down-economi... http://www.imf.org/external/pubs/cat/longres.aspx?sk=42986.0

Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by ArkyBeagle on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:55PM (#11505795)
So change the 1% to the 99% "takers" and you have the other indie media ( which appears to be in rapid decline ).
Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by lisper on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:53PM (#11505774)
> the 1% are freeloading devils

Some are. Some aren't.

Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by humanrebar on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:47PM (#11505711)
Why not tax consumption if your concern is consumption? Tax (NET_INCOME-(NET_SAVINGS+POVERTY_LEVEL)) or something.

EDIT: The responses are all assuming the tax is regressive. Note the POVERTY_LEVEL constant in there. And the tax rate itself could be progressive. 0% under 20k (if that's the poverty level), 15% on the next 30k, 25% on the next 50k, etc.

Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by lisper on Friday April 15, 2016 @01:00PM (#11505850)
Because taxing consumption is regressive.

The real problem is the positive feedback loop where money buys political influence, which then results in laws that favor the already-rich at the expense of everyone else. Taxing consumption won't fix that. Taxing political contributions might fix it, but you can't do that because political contributions (a.k.a. bribes) are now protected under the First Amendment thanks to Citizens United. High marginal income tax rates or a wealth tax (or reversing Citizens United) are the only ways to fix the problem AFAICT.

Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by prostoalex on Saturday April 16, 2016 @03:10AM (#11509640)
> Because taxing consumption is regressive.

How come? There are entire categories of consumption that open up with significant wealth? Private aviation, yachts, fine arts are all categories with spending heavily concentrated up top - a poor person is unlikely to own a proportional 1/1000th share of a Gulfstream jet or a Picasso.

Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by lisper on Saturday April 16, 2016 @11:48AM (#11510999)
Because people who buy Gulfstreams are so rich that the cost of the Gulfstream is only a small fraction of their wealth. It's really hard to fathom how filthy stinking rich some of these people are. A Gulfstream V, the absolute top of the line, costs $50M. That's one year's salary for e.g. Rush Lumbaugh (just to pick a random example out of a hat whose income is publicly known).

Also, most jets are not bought by filthy stinking rich people, they are bought by businesses, mainly airlines, which operate on pretty thin margins. If you raised taxes on jets significantly you would probably put a lot of them out of business. If you tried to raise taxes on jets that were disproportionately bought by filthy stinking rich people they'd just go out and buy different jets to avoid the taxes.

On the other hand, if you're poor then just the bare necessities of life will cost a significant fraction of your income.

The only equitable taxation scheme is a progressive income tax and/or a wealth tax.

Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by prostoalex on Saturday April 16, 2016 @12:47PM (#11511248)
The way the things are set up now, things that are considered basics (rent, utilities, food) are exempt from consumption tax (which in the US is mostly sales tax). Exempt a category like clothing, and most of the basic consumption remains untaxed.
Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by a_humean on Friday April 15, 2016 @01:11PM (#11505937)
Well if the problem is general excessive consumption, then a tax on consumption will help. But consumption tax is not necessarily progressive (or at least not sufficiently progressive enough to warrant the label) as its impacts on the poor (as a matter of marginal welfare as opposed to % of income/consumption) are usually much greater than on the most wealthy.

See this 2009 IFS report for the nuance in the context of UK VAT - in particular figure 10.1 and 10.2 (http://www.ifs.org.uk/budgets/gb2009/09chap10.pdf).

Often VAT regimes will not tax certain basic good such as bread, eggs, or essential household products, but in the UK most goods including many that you may consider basic have 20% VAT.

Someone being taxed say 20% on their consumption when their typical yearly consumption is $1 million has a much smaller impact to their marginal welfare than someone with a typical expenditure of $10k taxed at 10-15%. If someone has an income and consumption of $10k, then you probably don't really want tax them much or anything at all (you probably want to give them money/job/training/something!).

Provided you offset the increased taxation by consumption with increased services and benefits to the poorest, then you can mitigate most of the worst regressive effects.

Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by humanrebar on Friday April 15, 2016 @01:22PM (#11506051)
Note the POVERTY_LEVEL constant in there. And the tax rate itself could be progressive. I didn't say anything about a flat consumption tax.
Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by a_humean on Friday April 15, 2016 @01:43PM (#11506218)
Ah sorry. Consumption tax is usually understood to mean a tax collected at the moment of transaction based on the value and type of product/service, not as a yearly calculation that is more akin to a variant of an income tax.
Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by ecnal on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:56PM (#11505806)
Progressive consumption taxes based around this enjoy a great deal of support among economists and very little support among politicians, unfortunately.
Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by ArkyBeagle on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:56PM (#11505808)
Consumption taxes are quite regressive. The wealthy have the means to define consumption down.
Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by cmdrfred on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:52PM (#11505760)
Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by daveguy on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:35PM (#11505618)
As they should. That's what happens when you have a progressive tax structure. Do you think we should we shift some of that tax burden onto people who make less than $25k per year?
Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by aantix on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:42PM (#11505664)
I never understand why the term "progressive" gets painted in a positive light?

If I eat a steak, the restaurant doesn't come to me and say "Hey, you make 10% more than the guy two tables down, so you'll pay 10% more for your steak".

Why did this sliding rule ever get enacted for taxation? If you use something, you pay for it at the established price.

Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by matthewmacleod on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:49PM (#11505732)
Oh, come on. I know you get it.

Taxation is a generally accepted necessary evil way to fund projects and services for the common good. A progressive tax policy recognises that a person with a high income can bear a greater burden; taxing a minimum wage earner 30% of their income would have a much higher proportional effect on quality of life that someone earning, say, 200k. We seem to accept progressive taxation as fair, in the sense that it causes no more inconvenience to low earners than high earners.

The comparison with a private commercial service is flawed, in the sense that engagement with it is an entirely personal choice.

Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by djsumdog on Friday April 15, 2016 @01:07PM (#11505897)
I agree entirely. I just moved to a tech city and make totally insane amounts of money. I looked at my tax burden and it's close to 30%..and I'm totally okay with that. My take home is still insane, even after the insane housing costs.

It bothers me a bit though. I'd actually rather earn less and things be more affordable. The homeless situation in the city I moved to is truly insane and unsustainable. Tech companies drive up prices. I have a friend who lives in a neighbourhood where all the homes were around $100k when she was a kid; and now the same homes can go anywhere from $500k to nearly a million!

You see some of the average working class taking those big payouts and moving further from the city (and potentially driving more; increasing the traffic problem).

I'd rather earn less, my housing be more affordable and things be more equal for everyone. Supply and demand for housing really drive these crazy swings in gentrification.

Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by jacobush on Friday April 15, 2016 @01:52PM (#11506296)
Move to Sweden. We are on the same curve but far behind...
Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by msandford on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:59PM (#11505836)
> The comparison with a private commercial service is flawed, in the sense that engagement with it is an entirely personal choice.

That's exactly what a lot of people are up in arms about, they get taxed hugely but get no real say in how the money is spent. Sure they get a vote, but if your candidate loses it's not as though you're exempt from paying taxes.

In some way these people are right; if they choose to engage in commerce they aren't being forced to do anything and as such "whatever the market will bear" is a good metric.

Taxes aren't about "whatever the market will bear" though because you don't have a choice to not consume and therefore not pay.

Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by theseatoms on Friday April 15, 2016 @01:06PM (#11505889)
An argument I've heard for income tax progressivity is that the very wealthy have far more to lose if the state crumbled and society devolved into a state of nature.

In other words, the state, by upholding the rule of law (particularly property law), is providing the ultra wealthy with a service of far greater value than that which it provides those with lower wealth/income.

Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by prostoalex on Saturday April 16, 2016 @03:18AM (#11509667)
Those who are wealthy are generally not high-income (at least they can heavily tweak their income by using asset-backed loans and accrue capital gains only when it's beneficial).

Those who are high income in California are generally not wealthy (as opposed to everyone's favorite high income poster boy - the NY hedge fund manager), but are subjects to windfall effect - a few years of work at below market wages in hopes for a giant payback (royalties in Hollywood, stock options of a successful tech startup in the Valley).

Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by oldmanjay on Friday April 15, 2016 @01:00PM (#11505849)
A "progressive" tax policy is so named because it hijacks the positive associations of the word for political gain. Patiently explaining why we should all love the definition doesn't actually address the point being made.
Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by matthewmacleod on Friday April 15, 2016 @01:11PM (#11505932)
Wait, what? I'm pretty sure it's called 'progressive' because the rate of taxation 'progresses' as income increases – not because of any association with progressivism per se.
Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by avalaunch on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:59PM (#11505837)
When two people order a steak, regardless of their income, they get the same thing. On the other hand, one of the largest services a government offers its citizens is protection of the citizens' persons and wealth, both from domestic and foreign threats. The value of that protection is relative to how much each citizen is worth. If you're in debt, like many Americans, you're basically getting protection only for your person, as you have little to no wealth to protect. On the other hand, if you're worth billions, the government is protecting your wealth as well. It only makes sense that the more you have to protect, the more you should have to pay.
Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by jasode on Friday April 15, 2016 @01:17PM (#11505994)
> The value of that protection is relative to how much each citizen is worth. [...] On the other hand, if you're worth billions, the government is protecting your wealth as well. It only makes sense that the more you have to protect, the more you should have to pay.

Fyi, those sentences in your reasoning are already handled by a hypothetical flat tax percentage. It's the percentage that handles your cases as you stated them. For example, if a flat 15% tax was applied for everyone, the billionaire earning $30 million pays $4500000 in taxes, while the Walmart earning $20k pays $3000.

Mathematically, 4500000 is greater than 3000. In that case, the billionaire has paid more taxes which satisfies your reasoning.

On the other hand, the previous posters were emphasizing "progressive" taxes. That means that the percentages themselves are increased as income increases. Your rationale isn't specific to that. Probably the most common math rationale for progressive taxation is the concept of marginal utility of money[1]. In other words, a billionaire's $1 million of money made between $29 million and $30 million is less significant to him and therefore, can be taxed at a more "progressive" tax rate of 40% instead of 15%. On the other hand, the Walmart employees $1000 from $3000 to $4000 pays for food and rent and is not discretionary play money.

[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marginal_utility

Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by avalaunch on Friday April 15, 2016 @01:37PM (#11506177)
Well, despite using the term progressive, the poster I replied to was not emphasizing progressive taxes, because he used an analogy where everyone literally pays the same amount.

In any case, what I said wouldn't be covered under a flat tax percentage unless that flat tax percentage were on wealth, not income. A person making approximately 20k or less currently pays no income tax, which makes sense, because there's virtually no way they can accumulate any wealth at that income. On the other hand, as you move up each income tier, the amount of wealth you can accumulate goes up progressively. So a progressive tax is a close enough approximation to a flat tax on wealth, which is what I'm arguing makes the most sense.

Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by aantix on Friday April 15, 2016 @01:12PM (#11505947)
So, do you think you should pay more for Internet service if you consume more bandwidth?

Or is it just a commodity that we all utilize and is payed for with a flat rate, regardless of the value/un-value is provides?

Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by prostoalex on Saturday April 16, 2016 @03:19AM (#11509671)
Is California doing a better job at protecting its citizens than income tax free states like Washington or Nevada?
Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by sbov on Friday April 15, 2016 @01:05PM (#11505878)
Based upon your example, you seem to be arguing for a flat (as in dollar amount) tax. I have no idea how that would ever work unless there were no taxes at all.
Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by aantix on Friday April 15, 2016 @01:13PM (#11505954)
Yes. No taxes except for the flat tax.
Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by adwf on Friday April 15, 2016 @02:55PM (#11506733)
And how would the government pay for things? Clearly even with 200mn people, each paying $2000 in tax, you'd only have $400bn in tax revenue. The current total US tax revenue is $6.8tn (federal + state + other).

If you upped the tax to $10k, you'd still only be talking about $2tn, but you'd have huge swathes of the country forced into poverty as they'd be unable to pay it.

You'd need immense corporation taxes in order to make up the shortfall. Currently US business taxes make around 8% of the budget, compared to 36% for income tax. A flat dollar tax is nuts. The rich make their money from the labour of many, many people. They may only personally use the roads the same as others, but the thousands of their employees that need to drive to work need it a thousand times more. Without that, the rich would have no business. Ditto with healthcare. You need your workers healthy and they can't afford healthcare, you pay for it or you soon won't have many workers. $10k does not pay for much healthcare. Blindness to the social costs that are picked up by the government, does not mean that they don't exist.

The rich can pay a bit more and still be rich. They need to pay a bit more or they won't be rich for long, their workers and customers won't exist anymore.

Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by vannevar on Friday April 15, 2016 @01:19PM (#11506010)
That's how a progressive tax system works. The poor pay fewer taxes, because as is well documented elsewhere, ordinary life taxes them at a higher rate than the wealthy. At the other end of the spectrum, the wealthy earn additional income much more easily, so they are taxed at a higher rate. What's astounding is not the 160% ratio of tax share to income share for the wealthy, but the 2800% ratio of their income share to their population share. This illustrates just how powerful the "rich-get-richer" rules of our economy are in transferring money from the poor to the wealthy.
Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by foota on Saturday April 16, 2016 @01:23AM (#11509438)
Does anyone know why the tax liability/taxable income doesn't seem to reflect the state tax percentage? For instance the 9k to 10k bracket has tax liability = 2,970 and taxable income = 1,156,047 for liability/income = .0025 or .25%, which is significantly less than the tax rate of 1% for income under even 8k (http://www.bankrate.com/finance/taxes/state-taxes-california...)
Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by blazespin on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:57PM (#11505810)
That's declared income. If it's sheltered, than who knows what they are paying.
Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by GFK_of_xmaspast on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:45PM (#11505697)
Does that "income" count capital gains?
Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by infogulch on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:54PM (#11505776)
The link says "adjusted gross income," which is "gross income" minus deductions.

"Gross income in United States tax law is receipts and gains from all sources" [0] This includes wages, interest, gains etc.

I'd like to see the same data with un-adjusted gross income.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gross_income

Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by vixen99 on Friday April 15, 2016 @01:24PM (#11506067)
Maybe hard to take but these people are wealth creators and make a terrific contribution to society in general (everyone in the state, in this case). Of course they're propping up everyone else.

Assuming you're not subject to the naive 'wealth is a pie' fallacy, why are you so bothered about inequality of wealth? As a non-rich person, I don't get it! Questions of power and influence on the folk who sit in government and have really massive sums at their disposal with little ultimate responsibility if they foul up - are much more pertinent but should and can be dealt with separately.