Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes
by humanrebar on Friday April 15, 2016 @01:22PM
(#11506051)
Note the POVERTY_LEVEL constant in there. And the tax rate itself could be progressive. I didn't say anything about a flat consumption tax.
Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes
by a_humean on Friday April 15, 2016 @01:43PM
(#11506218)
Ah sorry. Consumption tax is usually understood to mean a tax collected at the moment of transaction based on the value and type of product/service, not as a yearly calculation that is more akin to a variant of an income tax.
See this 2009 IFS report for the nuance in the context of UK VAT - in particular figure 10.1 and 10.2 (http://www.ifs.org.uk/budgets/gb2009/09chap10.pdf).
Often VAT regimes will not tax certain basic good such as bread, eggs, or essential household products, but in the UK most goods including many that you may consider basic have 20% VAT.
Someone being taxed say 20% on their consumption when their typical yearly consumption is $1 million has a much smaller impact to their marginal welfare than someone with a typical expenditure of $10k taxed at 10-15%. If someone has an income and consumption of $10k, then you probably don't really want tax them much or anything at all (you probably want to give them money/job/training/something!).
Provided you offset the increased taxation by consumption with increased services and benefits to the poorest, then you can mitigate most of the worst regressive effects.