News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by prostoalex on Saturday April 16, 2016 @03:10AM (#11509640)
> Because taxing consumption is regressive.

How come? There are entire categories of consumption that open up with significant wealth? Private aviation, yachts, fine arts are all categories with spending heavily concentrated up top - a poor person is unlikely to own a proportional 1/1000th share of a Gulfstream jet or a Picasso.

Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by lisper on Saturday April 16, 2016 @11:48AM (#11510999)
Because people who buy Gulfstreams are so rich that the cost of the Gulfstream is only a small fraction of their wealth. It's really hard to fathom how filthy stinking rich some of these people are. A Gulfstream V, the absolute top of the line, costs $50M. That's one year's salary for e.g. Rush Lumbaugh (just to pick a random example out of a hat whose income is publicly known).

Also, most jets are not bought by filthy stinking rich people, they are bought by businesses, mainly airlines, which operate on pretty thin margins. If you raised taxes on jets significantly you would probably put a lot of them out of business. If you tried to raise taxes on jets that were disproportionately bought by filthy stinking rich people they'd just go out and buy different jets to avoid the taxes.

On the other hand, if you're poor then just the bare necessities of life will cost a significant fraction of your income.

The only equitable taxation scheme is a progressive income tax and/or a wealth tax.

Re:Top 1% of Income Earners pay 45% of California's Taxes by prostoalex on Saturday April 16, 2016 @12:47PM (#11511248)
The way the things are set up now, things that are considered basics (rent, utilities, food) are exempt from consumption tax (which in the US is mostly sales tax). Exempt a category like clothing, and most of the basic consumption remains untaxed.