News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by JupiterMoon on Monday March 21, 2016 @04:41AM (#11326833)
No! If an offence is criminal it can't be magically made OK by a contract.

I am not a lawyer. This is not legal advice.

Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by wojt_eu on Monday March 21, 2016 @04:50AM (#11326859)
Wouldn't it make it impossible under California law to have an agent that impersonate me? Have them tweet from my account, reply to emails in my name etc.
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by bryanrasmussen on Monday March 21, 2016 @09:09AM (#11327789)
These are two different things:

1. Hi, my name is John, I am contacting you on behalf of wojt_eu to confirm that he has been added to the "Cool New Project" as lead DEV.

2. Hi, it's me wojt_eu, I just wanted you to confirm that I've been added to the "Cool New Project" as lead DEV.

You can legally authorize someone to act on your behalf, in basically any Western Nation - although rules as to how this work will vary, but authorizing someone to impersonate you I don't believe would be made legal anywhere because impersonation is not just something one does on your behalf but also something one does to someone else. Both the person that acts on the impersonation as being real and the person being impersonated can be harmed by an impersonation, and therefore it is not adequate that the person being impersonated gives the impersonator the right to do so.

Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by bostonpete on Monday March 21, 2016 @01:18PM (#11329730)
> authorizing someone to impersonate you I don't believe would be made legal anywhere

I think you're confused. Celebrities hire third parties to tweet for them all the time. That's essentially impersonation.

Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by bryanrasmussen on Monday March 21, 2016 @04:27PM (#11331640)
well, no, I guess in a non-legal context it might be considered impersonation but if you gave me that example and asked me would you consider that impersonating someone I would say uh, no, not if you were hired by that person.

Then it's more like acting/broadcasting.

If you had an account on twitter and said you were The Real Steve Jobs and everyone believed you were the real steve jobs and not a joke then I would say yes that would be considered impersonation - at which point the context I left out of my answer, considering it a given because I thought it was quite apparent from the top of the thread was that laws against impersonation also have to identify in some way the harm the parties affected by the impersonation suffer.

In the original post a statute was linked to http://www.leginfo.ca.gov/cgi-bin/displaycode?section=pen&gr... ,this describes a number of ways harm can be incurred in the act of impersonation.

Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by thaumasiotes on Monday March 21, 2016 @12:19PM (#11329139)
You are not describing the facts on the ground.

http://semanticcompositions.typepad.com/index/2004/03/flexib...

Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by bryanrasmussen on Monday March 21, 2016 @04:49PM (#11331877)
no, I was very much describing the facts on the ground, I was not describing highly abstract semantic analysis that doesn't relate to legal usages.

I was also not describing linguistic usage in telephone conversation, I was describing linguistic usage in email correspondence. I don't think a correspondence would exist with a structure similar to the conversation the blog post discusses.

It can certainly be that when a conversation or correspondence moves into the realm of impersonation should be determined by the court. I think in the case under discussion here it would determined to be impersonation, the question then becomes what the harm was.

Looking through the statute referenced http://www.leginfo.ca.gov/cgi-bin/displaycode?section=pen&gr... I don't think I can see a harm defined that matches what was done very well. I think the most relevant section is 530 and it does seem a stretch.

Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by robzyb on Monday March 21, 2016 @05:35AM (#11326982)
It is, of course, perfectly legal to do that with permission.

The problem here is that it was done without permission.

The OP is claiming that the impersonation without permission is a crime, and that it is impossible to waive the crime-ness of it through a contract.

Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by OJFord on Monday March 21, 2016 @06:21AM (#11327127)
Parent is replying to a comment stating:

    > If an offence is criminal it can't be magically made OK
    > by a contract.
I think this must be mistaken (IANAL either). Boxing, assisted suicide, and voting by proxy come to mind.
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by svckr on Monday March 21, 2016 @07:34AM (#11327363)
The quote sounds right to me. If the act of impersonating someone is indeed a criminal offense, you can not smooth that over with a contract.

Voting by proxy is not impersonation, you give someone the right to act (vote in this case) in your name. Thus, no criminal offense.

The other cases: Assisted suicide is a criminal offense in many countries. For example (similar, but not the same), there has been some legal struggle over "Sterbehilfe" here in Germany which garnered quite some media attention.

Boxing – I might be mistaken, but perhaps "beating someone" is not a criminal offense as long as it is not against the other persons will?

All these things hinge on very subtle differences in wording. For example the terms might say: "AngelList reserves the right to send mails on your behalf" which grants them the right to send mails to third parties in your name, but I'd be surprised if law would allow them to state "AngelList reserves the right to claim your identity".

Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by OJFord on Monday March 21, 2016 @08:21AM (#11327529)

    > you give someone the right to act (vote in this case) in
    > your name. Thus, no criminal offense.
Right, it would be an offence, except that you've given express permission; so it isn't.

Assisted suicide is, yes. But my point is that we have separate legislation for it, implying that is required.

Boxing, again, that's my point.

Regarding identity specifically, what I imagine we're talking about here is an automated message much like LinkedIn's:

    > Hi, I'd like to add you to my network! *
Do we have a problem with this too?

* Or whatever it is. Point being, it says "I"; not "Mr Ford".

Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by rspeer on Monday March 21, 2016 @12:20PM (#11329159)
I definitely have a problem with that. It's an abuse of e-mail to automatically impersonate someone, especially for a purpose as banal as expanding a social network.

The Gmail warning that "this message may not be from who it claims to be" never worked well, but I wish they'd make it work for cases like this.

It's too bad e-mail is so unverified and insecure. A smartphone app can be prevented from making calls or sending text messages from your number: all you have to do is deny it that permission. But there's no way to prevent a website that has your name and e-mail address from sending e-mails as you.

Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by ams6110 on Monday March 21, 2016 @08:17AM (#11327521)
Yes, I think the difference would be are they representing you or impersonating you. I.e. did the other party know.

I can give my voting proxy or power of attorney to someone else, but it's pretty clear to anyone paying attention that's what's going on. If the email said "This is AngelList on behalf of J. Random Employee" that would be different than sending an email that had every appearance of being from the employee.

Even if this is allowed in their TOS, it's pretty underhanded if they buried something like that in boilerplate that they know nobody reads.

Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by drdaeman on Monday March 21, 2016 @11:51AM (#11328900)
> If the act of impersonating someone is indeed a criminal offense, you can not smooth that over with a contract.

IANAL, but it's like having sex: it's perfectly okay if all participants are consenting adults, but without this important condition it's a felony.

From what I understand, the important part here is consent, and only lack of one makes it a criminal offense. I.e. the act of impersonating isn't a crime (on its own) - the act of doing so without consent is. Well, to be certain, I guess one should take penal code of the jurisdiction in question, find the article and check the exact wording used.

Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by huac on Monday March 21, 2016 @11:41AM (#11328832)
Contracts must have 'legality of object' - the 'thing' that is contracted cannot be criminal, tortious, or against the prevailing public policy.

You will find that in each of your examples that there is a particular statute legalizing that activity in a particular state.

Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by throwaway049 on Monday March 21, 2016 @07:39AM (#11327376)
Are you saying assisted suicide is illegal, but _can_ be made OK by a contract? That's not the case in England. By contrast, proxy voting is fine if you register your proxy with the local electoral office in advance.
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by OJFord on Monday March 21, 2016 @08:14AM (#11327503)
No, I'm wondering why would there be a separate law if it was automatically covered by not being able to consent your way out of being murdered.
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by ams6110 on Monday March 21, 2016 @09:55AM (#11328041)
Probably because it's not murder, it's suicide. Assisted suicide is generally not asking another person to kill you, it's asking another person to set up some situation so you can more easily kill yourself. And though suicide is illegal, such laws further define that assisting another person to commit suicide is also illegal.
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by protomyth on Monday March 21, 2016 @12:08PM (#11329043)
Boxing is not illegal. Boxing is regulated under certain conditions.
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by abritishguy on Monday March 21, 2016 @06:23AM (#11327139)
Agreeing to the terms could be giving permission though...
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by JupiterMoon on Monday March 21, 2016 @08:14AM (#11327505)
That would be for a court to decide and I doubt that any of us are qualified to advise the GP (I certainly am not!).
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by morninj on Monday March 21, 2016 @08:59AM (#11327715)
There are lots of competent tech lawyers on HN.
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by JupiterMoon on Monday March 21, 2016 @08:16AM (#11327516)
I have no idea. My post was more general and about principles rather than specifics. I have no knowledge of the specifics of the relevant terms of service for this company, I also don't know whether they form a binding contract in the relevant jurisdiction or what things are specifically legal to do in contracts in the relevant jurisdiction.

I repeat that I am not a lawyer so if this is important to you then hire a lawyer in your local jurisdiction to advise you, don't listen to random people on the internet.

Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by sqeaky on Monday March 21, 2016 @09:10AM (#11327798)
I bet you can hire a tax preparer in California. That is someone hired to represent you and do things on your behalf for tax purposes. That is a highly regulated financial specialist though.

In principle it sounds similar. The details do matter though. Did they provide reasonable explanation of what they were doing? Did they attempt to do this in secret? Did they misrepresent anything? Are they any laws saying a person cannot sign away liability for things like this?

Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by ams6110 on Monday March 21, 2016 @09:47AM (#11327995)
They also don't sign the tax form as you. They sign it as a "preparered by" and you sign it as the taxpayer.

Most tax preparers are liable for their own mistakes, but not for omitting anything you didn't tell them.

Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by oldmanjay on Monday March 21, 2016 @10:44AM (#11328383)
What is it about not being a lawyer (psychiatrist, economist, whatever) that makes people feel their contributions, though unqualified and generally incorrect, are still valuable? Is there a magical state of not-being that I've never picked up?
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by logfromblammo on Monday March 21, 2016 @11:03AM (#11328515)
Generally, it's because we feel that layman opinions on how the law work should affect how it actually works in a democratic society.

For instance, civil forfeiture, wherein property can be taken from a person who has not been proven guilty of a crime in a fair trial, is widely rejected by the public, even when the opinion poll uses the most biased questions possible. (i.e. Should drug dealers be allowed to keep the profits from their crimes if they escape conviction and punishment on a technicality?)

Also, a jury verdict is little more than an aggregated bunch of layman opinions.

The opinion of the general public is that software should not have bugs in it. Also, it should be gratis and always keep up with the latest GUI and HID fashion trends. As a software professional, I often do additional work to meet those public expectations, even if it has no technical merit. That's because the opinion of the customer matters, when they are employing the experts to work on their behalf.

Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by JupiterMoon on Monday March 21, 2016 @01:08PM (#11329601)
I include that I am not a lawyer partly to provide a warning that I am probably wrong and that what I am saying is not particularly valuable. I welcome someone that is an expert jumping in and correcting me...
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by tamana on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @04:32PM (#11339763)
Pro-tip: don't make exclamations when you don't know if what you are saying is true.

The entire point of a contract is to get permission to do something that otherwise is not allowed.

Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by toyg on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @05:08PM (#11339974)
No, the point of a contract is to agree on mutual conduct. The conduct itself is still subject to laws, unless the law itself explicitly allows to be overridden with contracts.

We can agree in a contract to sell you my daughter's virginity, but that does not mean you can actually buy it.

Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by donatj on Monday March 21, 2016 @08:15AM (#11327511)
There are many things that would be illegal without a contract that are legal with one. That's kind of the point.
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by DrJokepu on Monday March 21, 2016 @08:31AM (#11327570)
Illegal is not the same thing as criminal, the latter being a very special subset of the former.
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by lisper on Monday March 21, 2016 @12:05PM (#11329016)
Of course it can. Lack of consent is a key element in many crimes. Rape, for example.
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by TheLogothete on Monday March 21, 2016 @01:39PM (#11329968)
This is not an appropriate analogy. You are reversing the situation.

Terms and conditions and even contracts are often inadmissible. Just because you signed something, doesn't mean it's valid. Being handcuffed to a contract happens only in the movies,

I am not a lawyer.

Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by lisper on Monday March 21, 2016 @01:58PM (#11330145)
One can argue over whether Angellist's ToS constituted valid consent. But the original blanket claim that an action "can't be magically made OK by a contract" is just flat-out false. It can.
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by JupiterMoon on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @04:31AM (#11335114)
The claim I made was that a specifically criminal action can't be made non-criminal by a contract if the action is inherently criminal.
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by TheLogothete on Monday March 21, 2016 @02:05PM (#11330222)
It can in some circumstances. If the action is illegal in the first place, no contract can make it OK.
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by lisper on Monday March 21, 2016 @02:23PM (#11330417)
But being "illegal in the first place" almost always hinges on consent, at least in the case of crimes that have victims. (Victimless crimes obviously cannot hinge on consent because there's no one to consent.) I think you'll find it very challenging to come up with an example of an action that is a crime with a victim that doesn't involve lack of consent as an essential element. The only example I can think of offhand is statutory rape, and in that case it's only independent of consent because the victim is explicitly barred by law from giving consent.
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by JupiterMoon on Monday March 21, 2016 @02:56PM (#11330756)
Here in the UK I can add: assisted suicide, many sexual activities particularly on camera (even between very enthusiastic participants), driving in a vehicle on the public highway without a seatbelt, working for under the minimum wage, corporal punishment and polygamy.
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by huac on Monday March 21, 2016 @02:43PM (#11330636)
Question isn't consent here. Consent is part of what constitutes a contract, but you've clearly consented to their TOS. More importantly, their TOS cannot allow or compel a party to perform a criminal or tortious act. If impersonating you is criminal, then the contract is invalid.
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by pavel_lishin on Monday March 21, 2016 @12:13PM (#11329091)
But in your example, the act in question would be sex - which is not itself a criminal act.
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by lisper on Monday March 21, 2016 @12:25PM (#11329207)
Impersonating someone isn't a criminal act either. It is impersonating someone without consent that is the criminal act. Read the statute:

"...any person who knowingly AND WITHOUT CONSENT credibly impersonates another actual person..."

(Emphasis added.)

Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by ktRolster on Monday March 21, 2016 @01:57PM (#11330133)
Elvis impersonators.....
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by lisper on Monday March 21, 2016 @02:01PM (#11330181)
Another element of the criminal statute is that the impersonation has to be "credible".