Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p...
by lisper on Monday March 21, 2016 @12:05PM
(#11329016)
Of course it can. Lack of consent is a key element in many crimes. Rape, for example.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p...
by TheLogothete on Monday March 21, 2016 @01:39PM
(#11329968)
This is not an appropriate analogy. You are reversing the situation.
Terms and conditions and even contracts are often inadmissible. Just because you signed something, doesn't mean it's valid. Being handcuffed to a contract happens only in the movies,
I am not a lawyer.
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p...
by lisper on Monday March 21, 2016 @01:58PM
(#11330145)
One can argue over whether Angellist's ToS constituted valid consent. But the original blanket claim that an action "can't be magically made OK by a contract" is just flat-out false. It can.
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p...
by JupiterMoon on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @04:31AM
(#11335114)
The claim I made was that a specifically criminal action can't be made non-criminal by a contract if the action is inherently criminal.
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p...
by TheLogothete on Monday March 21, 2016 @02:05PM
(#11330222)
It can in some circumstances. If the action is illegal in the first place, no contract can make it OK.
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p...
by lisper on Monday March 21, 2016 @02:23PM
(#11330417)
But being "illegal in the first place" almost always hinges on consent, at least in the case of crimes that have victims. (Victimless crimes obviously cannot hinge on consent because there's no one to consent.) I think you'll find it very challenging to come up with an example of an action that is a crime with a victim that doesn't involve lack of consent as an essential element. The only example I can think of offhand is statutory rape, and in that case it's only independent of consent because the victim is explicitly barred by law from giving consent.
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p...
by JupiterMoon on Monday March 21, 2016 @02:56PM
(#11330756)
Here in the UK I can add: assisted suicide, many sexual activities particularly on camera (even between very enthusiastic participants), driving in a vehicle on the public highway without a seatbelt, working for under the minimum wage, corporal punishment and polygamy.
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p...
by huac on Monday March 21, 2016 @02:43PM
(#11330636)
Question isn't consent here. Consent is part of what constitutes a contract, but you've clearly consented to their TOS. More importantly, their TOS cannot allow or compel a party to perform a criminal or tortious act. If impersonating you is criminal, then the contract is invalid.
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p...
by pavel_lishin on Monday March 21, 2016 @12:13PM
(#11329091)
But in your example, the act in question would be sex - which is not itself a criminal act.
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p...
by lisper on Monday March 21, 2016 @12:25PM
(#11329207)
Impersonating someone isn't a criminal act either. It is impersonating someone without consent that is the criminal act. Read the statute:
"...any person who knowingly AND WITHOUT CONSENT credibly impersonates another actual person..."
(Emphasis added.)