News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We Hire the Best, Just Like Everyone Else by RogerL on Friday March 04, 2016 @09:04AM (#11223718)
tl;dr: The only measure of on the job performance is on the job performance. The only thing that matters to your company is also on the job performance. Why not focus on that?

It is utter voodoo.

I came up in the late 80s. Interviews were maybe 2 hours long. You might be handed a piece of paper with a problem to aggregate some information distributed in a few different arrays and print them out. You know, write some for loops and a few logic statements.

Then you talked about the job. This is the job. Do you want to do it? What do you have to bring to us? Do you have a lot of experience and want to lead, or not a lot and want to learn - we'll adjust position and salary.

And you put a team together. Some were great, some were okay, some needed to be let go. In total, all sw people had a job.

Contrast that with today's voodoo, where proxies are weighed more than on the job performance (the only thing that matters).

In the end, you put a team together. Some are great, some are okay, some need to be let go. In total, all sw people have a job.

It's all exactly the same, except the absurdity of interviewing by proxies. It's simple logic - he average of everything is average. Why have we abandoned logic?

So many things matter more than remembering red-black trees from your midterm (I'm 49. I TA'ed a graduate level algorithms class back in the day, but I don't happen to remember it. That's what books are for). Like being able to run a project. Being able to write documentation. Being able to enter a room with a combative and upset client and keep the business. Being able to mentor your colleagues. Taking ownership. Leading by example. Ability to learn. So many things that are not even discussed in the current interview environment.

I've watched companies spin their wheels for months, rejecting perfectly good people, looking for that mythical person with exactly the right, esoteric combination of skills, who, for some unknown reason, wants to stall their career and get hired into a position where they learn nothing because they are expected to know everything already. People that are eager to learn? No, sorry, not rock-star material. All these prior successes mean nothing, no one could possibly learn a technology or new algorithm, right? And, more than once I've had people get downright snide about it. I'm sorry that you misread my resume, contacted me, and I didn't have that absurdly specific combination of skills. My fault, right?

Y'all have lost your minds. :) Which is okay, we're an eccentric bunch, but jeez, let's inject some reason and introspection into it. The faces are different, but the talent is no different than the 70s and 80s. There's zero evidence that any of these interview techniques are reliable. There's tons of evidence that interview techniques are horribly biased in many ways. Just stop.

Re:We Hire the Best, Just Like Everyone Else by sadlion on Friday March 04, 2016 @04:41PM (#11227052)
I recently had an on-site interview at a big SV tech company. I had 4 interviews and 3 of them flat out told me they haven't read my resume. I didn't do as well on the whiteboard hazing but I'm confident that I could have solved them if I had more than 30 minutes to come up with an efficient solution.

What disappointed me was, 3 of the interviewers had no idea about my background and weren't able to extract my strengths. Even though I am a new grad, I have interned for 2 years as an app dev and learned a great deal about design, code quality, testing and etc...

I have read Effective Java, Clean Code, and Head First Design Patterns. I'm reading Java 8 in Action now. I have not memorized them page-to-page and still need more experience to master them, but at least I know some of resources I can go to for more answers. I have participated in code reviews and enjoy them. I can implement LLRBT and many of the algorithms you can expect a new grad to know but I have not invested my time on hacker rank and uva.

I don't know what SV or big tech companies are looking for. I constantly hear interviewers say they want good engineers but fail to capture the essence of a potential good engineer well. What benefit is there in hazing anyone with problems many engineers don't deal with without the tools they use every day, and with an absurd time constraint. Kosaraju didn't come up with SCC in 30 minutes and he had a PHD. Sure I can spend hours studying for whiteboard questions but to what benefit. I am sure anyone of you can come up with a whiteboard problem you can't solve in 30 minutes, but what does that say about you.

Re:We Hire the Best, Just Like Everyone Else by jakobegger on Saturday March 05, 2016 @07:57AM (#11229357)
If you want to get a job as an app developer, the easiest way is to build the kind of app you'd like to work on and show it to people. If an interviewer sees that you can deliver exactly what they need, you're an instant hire.

Don't complain that interviewers haven't read your resume; it is your job to tell the interviewer about the relevant parts of your resume and why they matter for the job you are applying to.

Re:We Hire the Best, Just Like Everyone Else by PhantomGremlin on Saturday March 05, 2016 @08:55PM (#11232115)
Don't complain that interviewers haven't read your resume

I disagree. If you're going to interview me for an hour, the least you can do for both of us is to take 10 or 15 minutes ahead of time to familiarize yourself with my background.

it is your job to tell the interviewer about the relevant parts of your resume

Again, I disagree. A resume is only a very cursory overview. You can use it as a starting point to probe me about it, to at least determine if I've actually done what it says or if I'm just a buzzword bullshit artist.

IMO it's very shortsighted for someone to ignore a resume before conducting an interview.

Re:We Hire the Best, Just Like Everyone Else by jakobegger on Sunday March 06, 2016 @08:21AM (#11233655)
I agree that it is inpolite to not read a resume or a cover letter. But as a candidate, you can't change the fact that your interviewer is not well prepared. The job will go to the candidate that makes the best of the situation.

The bigger point I'm trying to get at is the following: do not expect the interviewer to discover how brilliant you are on their own. Being smart, hard working, is not enough -- you also need to tell people about it.

Re:We Hire the Best, Just Like Everyone Else by sadlion on Sunday March 06, 2016 @03:03PM (#11235294)
The first interviewer told me they haven't read my resume at the beginning of my interview. I tried to highlight my strengths. The other 2 tho told me during the conclusion of the interview, when I asked them what skills they'd want to me focus on if I was to start on their team or any advice for a budding engineer. They both started with something along the lines, I don't know your background; didn't get the chance to read your resume. It was too late to go over my resume as I was being escorted to my next event.

I will be more proactive on my next interviews. I did have my github on my resume; I will add more projects to it and get involved in OSS.

Re:We Hire the Best, Just Like Everyone Else by chatmasta on Saturday March 05, 2016 @08:27PM (#11232036)
Stop thinking of your career like a textbook. You don't need to memorize all that bullshit. Just provide value to the world and the rest will come naturally.
Re:We Hire the Best, Just Like Everyone Else by h0w412d on Friday March 04, 2016 @01:47PM (#11225923)
Couldn't agree more. The "innovations" SV has brought to the interview process are more to satisfy the need to "disrupt" the traditional way of interviewing, with no thought to whether they're actually improvements. Take-home tests that are 8 hours long, talking to 14 people over 12 hours (actually happened to me), and tricky questions that will never happen in the day-to-day at that company: all useless and/or unfair.
Re:We Hire the Best, Just Like Everyone Else by paulryanrogers on Friday March 04, 2016 @12:46PM (#11225439)
"Never memorize what you can look up in a book" --Einstein
Re:We Hire the Best, Just Like Everyone Else by beefman on Friday March 04, 2016 @01:49PM (#11225939)
Wikiquote says this is an unsourced variant of "[I do not] carry such information in my mind since it is readily available in books" (referring to the speed of sound)

https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Albert_Einstein

Re:We Hire the Best, Just Like Everyone Else by andrewstuart on Friday March 04, 2016 @02:44PM (#11226376)
That's what I said to my heart surgeon as I was wheeled in to theatre and I saw he was holding a book.

And again on the plane on the way home I said it to the pilot who was carrying a book into the cockpit.

And when my 18 year child went out driving for the first time on his own I handed him a book titled "How to drive".

Re:We Hire the Best, Just Like Everyone Else by gknoy on Friday March 04, 2016 @04:41PM (#11227051)
There's some information that I need to memorize (how to use git, how to write code).

There are also and other things that are in the periphery of what I need to know, but can look up easily when necessary. These include things like my mother in law's mailing address, my coworkers' phone numbers, my wife's phone number, the population of the US, how to rewire a plug socket, and the recipe for Belgian waffles.

Each of those things would be good to know, but we can effectively offload it to external memory.

Re:We Hire the Best, Just Like Everyone Else by andrewstuart on Friday March 04, 2016 @05:16PM (#11227244)
There are many developers who think looked-up knowledge is the same as knowledge understood as part of a wider conceptual framework.

They become annoyed during interviews when they are asked some concept and suggest "I'd just look it up on Google", which is fine for matters of programming syntax, but not fine where it reveals that a developer does not understand an important concept.

Re:We Hire the Best, Just Like Everyone Else by PhantomGremlin on Saturday March 05, 2016 @09:00PM (#11232128)
the population of the US

Yeah, all that stuff is stupid. Who the fuck cares what the capital city is for each of the 50 states? That's what atlases used to be good for, now it's an almost instant search in Wikipedia.

Re:We Hire the Best, Just Like Everyone Else by mratzloff on Friday March 04, 2016 @11:01AM (#11224587)
Perfect. I wish I could single handedly up vote this comment straight to the top so everyone could see it.
Re:We Hire the Best, Just Like Everyone Else by hoorayimhelping on Friday March 04, 2016 @01:50PM (#11225948)
Has it become more costly to fire bad hires since then? In my mind, a lot of the idiotic behavior in hiring is driven by the fact that it seems to be way more expensive to hire the wrong person than to hire nobody. The risk of litigation from firing someone seems real to a lot of places I've worked.
Re:We Hire the Best, Just Like Everyone Else by Spooky23 on Saturday March 05, 2016 @12:00AM (#11228485)
Usually it's fear of confrontation and laziness. If you're not discriminating against people, it's fine.

I've had a few folks that I've had to let go folks, including folks in .gov with union contracts and motivated defenders. It is doable.

End of the day, don't be a wuss. Setting up some hunger games "audition" is passive aggressive bs. If you're nervous, hire a contractor and get them on the payroll later. Or just hire the person, and give them a months severance. Problem solved.

Re:We Hire the Best, Just Like Everyone Else by abustamam on Saturday March 05, 2016 @01:16PM (#11230282)
That's what my current company did with me. Works really well. Some people are not okay with becoming a contractor first but sometimes that's the way things go.
Re:We Hire the Best, Just Like Everyone Else by mratzloff on Friday March 04, 2016 @02:50PM (#11226424)
California has its own special brand of crazy laws, but in a lot of cases bad hires persist because poor managers (most) will do anything they can to avoid the confrontation.
Re:We Hire the Best, Just Like Everyone Else by JBlue42 on Saturday March 05, 2016 @06:46PM (#11231687)
Like what?

It's an at-will state so you can leave without notice and be laid off without notice. It seems that would cover the majority of circumstances and protect both employee and employer, for better or worse.

Re:We Hire the Best, Just Like Everyone Else by gozur88 on Friday March 04, 2016 @04:44PM (#11227075)
Yes, it has. There are more legally protected classes than there were, and the laws were changed to make managers liable personally for wrongful termination.

If you're a first level manager at BigCo, the risk of getting sued outweighs the benefit to your career of getting rid of someone who needs to go.

I suspect that's why you see healthy companies doing a lot of relatively small layoffs - when your manager tells you a person on your team needs to go, you'll lay off the one you might have already fired in 1980. The result is the same, but it's a lot harder to sue over staff reductions than a firing for cause.

Startups are different, of course, because a company with only a handful of employees might go out of business if it has to carry one as dead weight.

Re:We Hire the Best, Just Like Everyone Else by danieltillett on Friday March 04, 2016 @04:21PM (#11226952)
I think people (managers) have become scared of firing and so try to avoid all risk. Having had to do it is never fun, but it becomes easier the more you do. The first time I had to fire someone I tried everything I could to avoid it and made the situation worse by dragging out the whole process.

The other reason is the company is not really looking to hire, just placate their current employees - "yes we know you are over worked, just hang in there while we hire someone to take off the load".

Re:We Hire the Best, Just Like Everyone Else by JBlue42 on Saturday March 05, 2016 @06:43PM (#11231672)
>"yes we know you are over worked, just hang in there while we hire someone to take off the load"

Which may be why people that are below par haven't been let go? A need to throw bodies at a problem rather than step back and give it some thought / work it out.

Re:We Hire the Best, Just Like Everyone Else by danieltillett on Sunday March 06, 2016 @05:20AM (#11233177)
Yes it is certainly true that it hard to fire anyone when you are pretending to be looking to expand - nothing breaks the spell that all the hard work is just a consequence of not being able to hire like firing a member of the team.