Now for a piece that's more interesting. The fine-structure constant (alpha) is the coupling constant that sets the strength of electromagnetism. This means that its value is the thing that matters in the equation: e^2/\hbar c. Each of the other values is a derived quantity. Further, to speak a bit loosely, only changes in alpha matter -- in the sense that if the speed of light (c) changes, but the other constants (e and \hbar) change in a way that keeps alpha the same, then you wouldn't be able to tell with an experiment that anything has changed.
Contrast this situation w/ a change in alpha -- a table-top experiment would be able to detect the change (given that it's large enough, and we have methods of measuring changes on year-time scales that are a few parts in ~10^-18 (Rosenband, 2008)), as it would mean that physics has changed in a fundamental way.
http://phys.columbia.edu/~millis/1900/readings/Science-2008-...
\alpha(\mu = M_Z) is about 128. But m_0(photon), h, and e are the same at both energy scales (we can determine the numerical values experimentally). To the best of our ability to measure, none of them (including, if we ignore the main posting, \alpha_em) varies anywhere in a background fixed by the isometry group of SR (where we find c as the sole free parameter, corresponding to the speed of a particle where m_0(particle) = 0).
So I'm having trouble understanding your assertion that "Alpha is the fundamental physical constant: c, e and \hbar are the derived quantities" (in your other comment, but also reflected in your second paragraph above).
I think we both totally agree that varying \alpha_em at different points in space or time leads to a mess.
But you are using units. Your unit is the width of your desk. If it were a different width but the same length, your measurement would be different.
Note that the aspect ratio lets us say things like: "these two desks have the same aspect ratio".
The "desk widths" interpretation of aspect ratio precludes this useful sentence from having semantics.
The aspect ratio 1.7 has a life of its own, independently of that desk.
You do need radians, but that's not a unit in the same way a 'meter' is, you don't need any kind of reference to know how much, say, 1 pi radians is. For most intents and purposes angles are unitless.
See root comment. I do not have to specify the units that I used when I quote the aspect ratio, or the method that I used.
I think the confusion is in actually measuring these things. Scientists use dimensionless numbers all the time, but you have to directly measure quantities with units to indirectly get the dimensionless quantity.
1. Standardised. 2. Defined by a numerical relationship to observable physical constants, like c, by definition.
Desk widths aren't a scientific unit. You can only measure the ratio of width to height by reference to a standard unit like the metre, which in turn is based on a constant observable quantity - the distance travelled by light in one second.
You can pick your derived units using any relationship to c - like the distance travelled in 3.2 seconds. But that's still a derived unit, not a fundamental observable unit.
And ratios are dimensionless because they stay the same whatever derived unit system you choose, as long as it's consistent.
/nitpick
Another point that throws me off is the Vulcan scientist part. They would need to be using the same numerical base in order to get that number. There might be some base-less representations of numbers, but they are usually restricted to representing integer numbers. The constant could still be represented by a fraction, but there would be no math-neutral way of saying "hey, this here is a fraction/division".
To give one example, my piece of US Letter paper is 93.5 in^2 in area. One side is 8.5 in long. If I divide these, I find that 93.5 in^2 / 8.5 in = 11 in. Is that eleven inches a ratio or a quantity?
How did you measure your desk in order to compute its length/width ratio?
I am not convinced they determined the ratio of his table's length and width without first measuring those quantities in some unit.
The units involved in the aspect ratio disappear because they are divided out. After that, we don't have to (in fact, must not) cite any units when giving the aspect ratio.
Of course, both the quantity and the associated error come from previous measurements.
If this sort of thing interests you, I'd encourage you to look at the quantum metrology triangle. Frequency, resistance, and current are all currently related to a josephson voltage standard, the quantum hall resistance, and the current generated by a single electron transistor. This allows us to standardize all these back to a frequency. Length can be related to frequency by wavelength of light. Everything has been related back to frequency. Basically the only thing not referred back to something absolute is mass, which I think is still referred back to a mass standard, which is a physical thing stored in a vault.
Okay well more than you ever wanted to know.
Consider two voltage sources that you want to measure the ratio of. Place one source on one arm of a resistor, and the other through a pulse width modulator, (ideal) low pass filter with a cutoff frequency much lower than the pulse width modulator frequency, and then attach this to the other lead of the resistor. Turn on the voltage sources and adjust the pulse width modulator until the resistor doesn't heat up. You could place it in a cup of water and monitor the temperature. Remember we're free to push up the current in this thought experiment
i would like an example of an experiment that directly measures a dimensionless quantity without inferring it from direct measurements of dimensional quantities. it's just a curiosity.
Suppose some rectangle is visible at a distance. We can use parallax angles from our vantage point to estimate its aspect ratio.
We have no idea how long or wide that rectangle is because we don't know how far away it is.
(Indeed, we don't even know whether it is a rectangle, or whether it is some quadrilateral that appears as a rectangle under perspective.)
Either that, or i'm misinterpreting your first sentence.
No they don't. For instance, a simple aspect ratio measures how something is wide relative to how it is long. It has no units.
This here desk I have here is about 1.7 times as long as it is wide. No inches or centimeters required.
There isn't anything amazing or mystical about a unitless quantity.