Re:A number that fascinates physicists
by bobcostas55 on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @11:51AM
(#11160232)
Let's say the width of your desk is denoted by "w". The length is then 1.7w. The aspect ratio is dimensionless because it is = 1.7w/1w. w/w = dimensionless. But you still used a unit, w, to make the measurement in the first place.
Re:A number that fascinates physicists
by contravariant on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @12:22PM
(#11160498)
He could have measured the angle of the desk's diagonal makes with the longer side, that would give him tan(w/l), no inches or centimetres required.
You do need radians, but that's not a unit in the same way a 'meter' is, you don't need any kind of reference to know how much, say, 1 pi radians is. For most intents and purposes angles are unitless.
Re:A number that fascinates physicists
by kazinator on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @01:21PM
(#11161009)
That is inescapable for any quantity whatsoever that we extract from nature. In dimensionless quantities, the units just canceled out. Amperes divided by amperes, or whatever.
See root comment. I do not have to specify the units that I used when I quote the aspect ratio, or the method that I used.
Note that the aspect ratio lets us say things like: "these two desks have the same aspect ratio".
The "desk widths" interpretation of aspect ratio precludes this useful sentence from having semantics.
The aspect ratio 1.7 has a life of its own, independently of that desk.