News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by ergothus on Sunday February 21, 2016 @01:05PM (#11145602)
I vastly love being in a world where you can get answers. That said, I've noticed one trend in my younger co-workers and friends that is a little sad (to me).

I will often try to find concepts I don't know. Simple things like "Why do we say 'deceased'? Aren't they 'ceased'? If they are 'de-ceased', that leaves US as 'ceased'". I'm moderately curious, but mostly I enjoy finding the little perversities. Maintaining a sense of wonder, if you will.

Amongst my younger (I'm mid-to-late 30s, they are mid-to-late 20s) friends and co-workers, though, I typically get the response of "I don't know, what does google say?". Then they look it up, and stop wondering. (Sometimes the answer is pretty good, often it boils down to 'no one knows')

On the one hand, I'm glad to see people moving past the "I wonder..." stage towards GETTING answers. On the other, even when the answer is inadequate, they then stop wondering.

I'm curious if this anecdote is generally true, and if so, if it's a temporary fad in our relationship to information, or if this represents one step in a path of "permanent" change in our relationship to information.

I suppose I could google that...

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by mlangdon on Sunday February 21, 2016 @01:15PM (#11145654)
I jokingly enforce a no-googling-at-the-lunch-table rule on my millennial coworkers (I'm gen Oregon Trail).

This allows for the type of fatuous speculation that makes for decent conversation.

Occasionally I even give in to the need to know.

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by Ensorceled on Sunday February 21, 2016 @07:34PM (#11147499)
That's odd, what kind of decent conversations are based on fatuous speculation on facts that are a google search away?

I'd much rather have real conversation about politics, whether "The 100" is good TV, social issues, or just about anything really, than an argument about facts that could just be googled.

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by nommm-nommm on Sunday February 21, 2016 @10:43PM (#11148284)
It's called having fun!! lighthearted mindless conversation. Joking. Laughing! Using our imaginations.

No arguments.

I'd rather do almost anything else than "talk politics." Especially with people who like "talking politics." Playing in traffic seems much more appealing.

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by IanCal on Monday February 22, 2016 @02:22AM (#11149131)
I agree.

I think there's a big benefit in finding out that you're often wrong. It's easy to look something up and go "yeah I knew that" when really it was just one of the things you thought might be true. Regularly seeing that what you were really, really sure about is actually completely wrong after having to try and justify what you're saying is wrong (e.g. that X was in film Y, etc). Similarly, realising you don't understand something too well when trying to explain it to someone else.

Also, mistakes and weird misconceptions form bits of jokes that grow and change over time.

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by Ensorceled on Monday February 22, 2016 @06:59AM (#11150219)
Ah, I see. I have lots of discussions that are fun, light hearted and meaningless. They just are rarely based on speculation on fundamental facts that could be googled.

There seems to be a lot of reaction to "talking politics". Maybe my perspective is coloured by being Canadian and living where the politics aren't so polarized and gamed?

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by dragonwriter on Monday February 22, 2016 @01:33AM (#11148964)
The interesting part of the conversation are the arguments (not the debate, but the specific chains of reasoning people present to support their belief about the correct answer.)

Also, the tangents that are spawned based both on some.of the specific answers people propose and elements of the arguments for those answers.

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by mlangdon on Sunday February 21, 2016 @08:43PM (#11147804)
Yes, some people don't enjoy jokes.

This is well documented.

I'd rather talk about literally nothing than have another political conversation where I am either preaching to the converted or shouting at a stone wall.

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by Ensorceled on Monday February 22, 2016 @07:02AM (#11150233)
Where did you get that I don't enjoy jokes?

Yeah, I'm seeing that mentioning "talking politics" on a mostly American forum immediately labels you as a "debbie downer".

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by nommm-nommm on Monday February 22, 2016 @01:18PM (#11152966)
> Where did you get that I don't enjoy jokes?

You should read this - http://tirania.org/blog/archive/2011/Feb-17.html

excerpt:

"But our engineering strength is also our social weakness. Countless times as engineers you will find yourself interrupting someone telling a story, an anecdote or a joke to correct a false assumption, provide an extra fact that the narrator overlooked, give a bigger perspective on the problem or point out that the joke premise is actually flawed.

You can identify this behavior because the person interrupting usually starts with the phrase "Well, actually...".

As a kid, I thought this was my strength. I knew a little bit more than my sister. So whenever she would say something, I would quickly interject something like "Well, actually, the origin of the word Shih Tzu means Lion Dog and has nothing to do with the dog's digestive patterns".

Yes, I was really fun to hang out with.

Whoever pulls a "well, actually" almost always shifts the conversation to himself. And now we are no longer following along with your friend's joke, we get to learn how much more you know about the limitations of the Sun Protection Factor scale in sunblock products.

Even the most rudimentary of the well-actuallistas is able to spoil even the best Ricky Gervais material.

But instead of rolling with the punches and participating in a brainstorm of ideas and exploding humor, they contribute interruptions, facts and details that merely produce stop energy on an ongoing discussion. They turn the center of attention towards them."

-----

Similar with "talking politics."

When people want to "talk politics" they usually really mean "Let me show you how right I am and how wrong you are if you disagree. Let me show you how smart I am."

Nothing to do with being a "debbie downer."

Now, where is that traffic?

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by Ensorceled on Monday February 22, 2016 @01:52PM (#11153266)
That's a great article! Bookmarking.

But, what does ANY of this have to do with me? I learned to avoid (well, mostly avoid :-) the "well actually" trap almost two decades ago and have spent the intervening twenty years mentoring younger engineers out of that habit.

What I was actually responding to was the idea it was better to "speculate" about who played Snape, or why is the sky blue, or is vim BSD or GPL licensed rather than look it up.

I'd rather have conversations about Alan Rickman portrayal of Snape or what impact the sky being blue has on our emotional reactions to blue or why vim is clearly better than emacs.

Also, Canadians, in general, don't tend to discuss politics in that manner, at least not in mixed company. We have more political parties and our views are more fluid. I have, for example, voted for 4 different political parties in my life time at the federal level alone.

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by drjesusphd on Monday February 22, 2016 @07:16AM (#11150288)
As an American, I find this attitude disturbing as well. It's like there's a cultural repulsion to talking about anything of consequence. And we wonder why US politics is in the state that it's in...
Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by klenwell on Sunday February 21, 2016 @01:39PM (#11145786)
This allows for the type of fatuous speculation that makes for decent conversation.

Well put. Brings to mind "Modern Jackass" magazine from one of my favorite This American Life episodes:

http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/293/a...

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by nightpool on Sunday February 21, 2016 @02:41PM (#11146110)
I dunno, I find Googling-enabled conversation to be just different, not necessarily better or worse then pre-Google convos. This might have more to do with me growing up with them though

(also, I misclicked the upvote button and downvoted you instead, sorry!)

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by vacri on Sunday February 21, 2016 @03:25PM (#11146304)
I'm gen Oregon Trail as well, and I prefer fact-checking in conversation. It drives me nuts to see people run down a rabbit-hole for an hour over an obvious misconception. Online fact-checking doesn't really ruin conversations in my view, and it helps stop spread misinformation.
Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by k-mcgrady on Sunday February 21, 2016 @03:23PM (#11146295)
Googling'-enabled' conversation tends to end the conversation in my experience. Someone looks up the answer and we're done.
Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by azernik on Sunday February 21, 2016 @07:54PM (#11147569)
With people I know, that's usually the prompt to jump to a related topic. Long conversations tend to end up looking like collaborative Wikipedia link surfing.
Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by nightpool on Sunday February 21, 2016 @08:19PM (#11147676)
Generally, I just tend to end up talking about things that can't be trivially fact-checked. YMMV I guess
Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by acheron on Sunday February 21, 2016 @04:01PM (#11146494)
Heh, are we embracing the "Oregon Trail generation" name then? This may be the first time I've seen a reference to it outside of a discussion of the group itself.
Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by pmarreck on Sunday February 21, 2016 @06:35PM (#11147258)
I love that name but isn't it just another name for Gen X?
Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by sixo on Sunday February 21, 2016 @06:53PM (#11147336)
To my ear, it's a subset of Gen X, and definitely doesn't encompass all of Gen X culture.
Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by mlangdon on Sunday February 21, 2016 @08:41PM (#11147787)
It's approximately 1978 though '82. Basically the last generation that has a living memory of the before time, but grew up riding the crest of the wave of everything that happened over the past 30 years, technologically.

Or, people who played Oregon Trail on Macs and Commodore 64s in grade school.

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by dragonwriter on Monday February 22, 2016 @01:39AM (#11148980)
The dates don't match the description; from the (last, more specific) description, you'd need to drop back at least about 5, maybe closer to 10, years earlier on the start date for that "generation".

Really, just thinking of it as "members of Generation X with an early and lifelong interest in technology" would probably work better than trying to carve it out as a narrower subset of Gen X by age.

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by mlangdon on Monday February 22, 2016 @04:19AM (#11149564)
Here[1] is (I believe) the originating article.

Meanwhile, the first really popular version of Oregon Trail came out in 1985[2].

Ultimately I just meant it as a jaunty shorthand for the intergenerational window in which I was born. If you were also born then and this does not jive with your experience, it's going to be okay, eventually.

[1] http://socialmediaweek.org/blog/2015/04/oregon-trail-generat... [2] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Oregon_Trail_(video_game...

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by 6stringmerc on Monday February 22, 2016 @10:04AM (#11151209)
I think it's a very useful little note between Gen X and Gen Y, because that 78-82 group isn't quite either in my experience.
Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by riffic on Monday February 22, 2016 @12:03AM (#11148581)
Apple ][, bah
Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by pmarreck on Monday February 22, 2016 @01:50AM (#11149020)
So, me then. Got it. ;)
Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by lmm on Sunday February 21, 2016 @04:46PM (#11146734)
It says something bad about us as a species if we can only enjoy a conversation when most or all of the participants are making large numbers of errors.
Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by ergothus on Monday February 22, 2016 @01:27AM (#11148949)
We were talking about ignorance (not knowing, and speculating) vs being wrong (thinking you know, but being wrong).

I've seen people move from speculating to assuming too often, but I don't see speculation as inherently wrong.

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by lmm on Monday February 22, 2016 @04:50AM (#11149699)
I don't think there's anything wrong with speculation. But if speculation is more interesting than actual knowledge about the same subject then I think there's something wrong with that.
Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by ergothus on Monday February 22, 2016 @12:10PM (#11152364)
You make a lot of sense...but I'm afraid I must run into the "wrong" category.

The thing is, the topic under question is usually pretty pointless (see "deceased" example above, or my musing about how the first time bread "raised" must have been freaky, or any such thing).

While learning a piece of trivia is _nice_, it's rarely as interesting as the act of speculation. Because I'm not really (all that) interested in the question at hand, I'm teaching myself (and regularly exercising the ability) to NOT KNOW, to DESIRE KNOWLEDGE, and to ACCEPT THAT SOME THINGS ARE BEYOND MY GRASP. It's good to find that somethings ARE in my grasp (answer someone gave about about "deceased" was the first time I've had that question answered!), but I get that lesson a lot in life.

When I wrestle with the "big" questions (What should I do with my life? Am I happy right now? Why did this terrible thing happen to me? Does existence care about me? Why do I care if it does?) some comfort with the unknowable is good. When I'm dealing lesser "big" questions (Am I actually good at this, or am I just faking it and haven't be caught yet? Am I an insensitive ass to people around me? Can I really buckle down and get this project completed? Why the heck do people vote for <INSERT POLITICIAN HERE>?) I likewise want to have experience with both being able get answer as well as NOT being able to get answers.

Learning is awesome. I love it. But I also need to be good at dealing with wanting to know, or dealing with being unable to know. Around me I see too many people of many ages that aren't interested in things they can't easily learn.

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by herbetyukost on Sunday February 21, 2016 @04:31PM (#11146654)
> I jokingly enforce a no-googling-at-the-lunch-table rule on my millennial coworkers

Trying to control what other people can do... great joke!

> fatuous speculation that makes for decent conversation

Misinformed conversation... sounds awesome.

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by mlangdon on Sunday February 21, 2016 @04:36PM (#11146680)
You seem fun!

There's a deeply sarcastic culture of fake rules at my company, in which groove this fake rule fits precisely. Lunch time is generally understood as a time of bullshitting, conviviality and foosball. Every time we have to wait 30 seconds to find out, e.g., how many apple seeds you can eat without killing yourself, we are all richer for it.

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by OJFord on Sunday February 21, 2016 @04:54PM (#11146779)

    > e.g., how many apple seeds you can eat without killing
    > yourself, we are all richer for it.
I'm ashamed to say I had to know. I found two estimates: the seeds of 25, or of "over 2000" apples.

Either way, we should be safe, and it just goes to show how much more fun wondering is than an extremely inconclusive answer.

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by rangibaby on Monday February 22, 2016 @04:34AM (#11149632)
That's where I would think "there's only one way to find out..."
Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by anateus on Sunday February 21, 2016 @06:53PM (#11147335)
I think you've miscategorized a distinction. I'm in my late 20s, and I share both of the proclivities you describe: I'm both curious about things and prefer to find out if it's relatively easy to do so.

What you describe seems like a lack of curiosity, and I don't think easy access to information is a cause of incuriosity, though it could be a contributing factor.

Curiosity, and by extension a general sense of play about the world, are sucked out of most people by adulthood.

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by ergothus on Monday February 22, 2016 @12:14PM (#11152401)
That's the thing that I found dumbfounding: These aren't incurious people. These are clever, capable, curious people. (lack of curiosity occurs in far too many people of all ages around me)

It's just that they deal with their curiosity differently: They seek an answer, and are content with whatever level is currently available, and move on to other matters, while I revel in the uncertainty.

Can't say one is better, though I'm obviously more comfortable with my version. Will say they feel very different, and I end up feeling alone in the crowd.

Related: One coworker at my previous job noted that we enjoyed our high school interns more than than college interns because the high schoolers hadn't had their sense of wonder and curiosity beaten out of them. I'm still evaluating if I think that's true.

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by InclinedPlane on Sunday February 21, 2016 @01:54PM (#11145871)
Somewhat in the same vein, previously the way to learn about something you didn't know about before would sometimes have involved reading a whole book on the topic. Which would leave you much more informed than skimming some google result. I wonder if that sort of thing is more or less common today because people can sate their idle curiosity easier.
Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by ergothus on Sunday February 21, 2016 @03:35PM (#11146366)
In my pre-web days, I found that generally you never found what you were looking for.

First, someone would tell you "to look it up". So, travel to library, hit card catalog, find a few titles.

Go to shelves. Somehow, 50% of the books from the card catalog wouldn't be on the shelves, but there also tended to be other books here that you hadn't found in the card catalog.

Read books. While some topics were interesting, often you dealt with authors that did a terrible job of compensating for their biases, or did poor science. I have the same reaction to most news stories (which is why I hang out here :) ) It'd be like watching a 30 min youtube video while trying to find a single fact.

End result: Still don't know your answer, learned some trivia, and have more disdain for the state of knowledge.

I've found the accessibility of knowledge to be much improved these days, and have a better opinion of our collective knowledge as a result. I also still read a lot and gain a lot of trivia, but I'm generally reading material I'm more interested in. So I don't feel the internet-age has really hurt those areas.

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by ChuckMcM on Sunday February 21, 2016 @04:27PM (#11146634)
I think there is a more fundamental question, why are some people curious and others are not? As far as I can tell this has always been true.
Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by salmonet on Sunday February 21, 2016 @09:25PM (#11148003)
For anyone wondering, decease comes from the Latin word "decedere", which literally means "to go away."
Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by Theodores on Sunday February 21, 2016 @11:43PM (#11148494)
In the 'good old days' you could have a competition on the TV or radio that would require getting answers to questions correct. You would have to be very 'brainy' or well read, maybe even have educated friends to help you to get all the answers. You could also admire the 'genius' of those able to get the answers right.

To take a simple example, where was such-and-such an author born? If you had grown up in the same village as the author or read one of his/her books then you could answer the question. But, if you had no such head start, a trip to the library or asking a well educated friend would be the only way.

Nowadays, with Wikipedia, the answer is provided by 'OK Google' in the first paragraph of the first result. This effectively makes it impossible to run competitions on TV/Radio/print that require high levels of 'general knowledge'. In fact, even the phrase 'general knowledge' is not used as often as it used to be!!!

Although it is great to be able to look up everything and anything instantly, I liked it in the days when there was some rewards and respect for knowing stuff that nowadays is deemed to be 'trivia'.

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by k__ on Sunday February 21, 2016 @01:27PM (#11145718)
Reminds me of my stepdad who always had to show of with bis fact knowledge. He even would tell some BS just to be right.

Now we can simply look it up and be done with it.

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by ZeroGravitas on Monday February 22, 2016 @06:08AM (#11150003)
I don't understand this comment.

I have a similar mindset to you, and am of the same age as you, therefore I can clearly remember a time when I was interested in things like this and I needed to look it up in an actual book, or even in the early days of the web, use quite complex skills to find the answer.

To a rough approximation, no-one else in my cohort or older gave a damn about stuff like this. So are you remembering a different time when everyone was like this, maybe in a different country or area from me. Do your colleagues and friends of the same age or older all exhibit this thirst for (let's face it) mostly pointless knowledge? Or is this just a "young people today" cliche?

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by creshal on Sunday February 21, 2016 @02:30PM (#11146057)
Funny, I'm in my mid-20s and have the same complaints about my late-teen-early-20s coworkers.

The grass is always greener, etc.

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by jghn on Sunday February 21, 2016 @02:58PM (#11146172)
I'm 40 and would rather just look up the answer and be done with it. OTOH as a child I was the proverbial person who skipped ahead to the end of a murder mystery
Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by Joof on Sunday February 21, 2016 @07:55PM (#11147573)
This is why the fun questions are unanswered or ambiguous. You can learn the process, but not the answer.

Its a but more invested though.

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by rmc on Sunday February 21, 2016 @03:48PM (#11146438)
Kids today, eh?
Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by ergothus on Monday February 22, 2016 @01:25AM (#11148947)
I don't really view it as an age things - for one, I still consider myself a "kid", and second, past a certain minimum age we have a mix of experiences and any of us is "the noob" in a given situation.

It is, however, a bit of a generational experience. If you grew up using card catalogs and learning to spell from a dictionary (?!), your relationship with knowing/not knowing will be different than someone who grew up with the Web always around and accessible. I think it was Agatha Christie who said of her childhood "I couldn't imagine being so rich as to have a car nor so poor as to not have servants".

Irony: I just googled that to confirm, and was mostly right but not quite accurate, assuming the links are themselves accurate:

http://www.bradford-delong.com/2013/01/agatha-christie-i-nev...

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by hackuser on Sunday February 21, 2016 @02:07PM (#11145934)
I have a book called The Treasury of the Encyclopaedia Brittannica. It's probably the best demonstration of the difference between serious research and Wikipedia; here is a small sample of the articles (all excerpted from past editions of the Encyclopaedia):

* Space-Time by Albert Einstein

* Radium by Marie Curie

* Mass Production by Henry Ford

* Wireless Telephony by Guglielmo Marconi

* Wilbur Wright by Orville Wright

* Leon Trotsky by Vladimir Ilyich Lenin

* Guerrila Warfare by T.E. Lawrence ('Lawrence of Arabia')

* Yosemite Park by John Muir

* Life, Terrestrial and Otherwise by Carl Sagan

* The Philosophical Consequences of Relativity by Bertrand Russell

There are many, many more. Do I want to learn from those people or from the 'wisdom' of the crowds?

I think it's out of print, but I highly recommend it. (ISBN 0-670-83368-4)

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by dredmorbius on Sunday February 21, 2016 @03:07PM (#11146212)
I'm ... not so certain I'd expect to see a balanced or even accurate view (in cases), of Trotsky by Lenin, of Yosemite by Muir, of Wilbur Wright by his brother, etc.

I'm not saying that "balance" always achieves improved results -- see the Baathist Guard of Kochinistas standing jealous watch over any article concerning the Koch brothers, Koch Industries, or the various political influencing organisations. But what Wikipedia has that Brittanica did not is a "show history" page revealing who's made what changes to a page. That is often far more revealing than the page itself.

Now: if Wikipedia would grow a pair of balls/ovaries and actually do something about rampantly partisan editors, that'd be peachy.

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by hackuser on Sunday February 21, 2016 @06:02PM (#11147105)
> I'm ... not so certain I'd expect to see a balanced or even accurate view (in cases), of Trotsky by Lenin, of Yosemite by Muir, of Wilbur Wright by his brother

That's a good point about those examples; they are flawed in that respect. My point was that I'd rather read an article written by an expert and held to high editorial standards than one written by a crowd of people with various levels of knowledge.

I'd also expect to learn much more uniquely valuable insight about an issue from the authors listed above, but that's a different issue.

A philosphical question I heard on Car Talk: Do two people who don't know what they're talking about know more or less than one person who doesn't know what their talking about?

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by dredmorbius on Monday February 22, 2016 @12:12AM (#11148626)
I'm a strong believer in expertise, and there's an argument to both modes (Britannica and Wikipedia). The latter seems to have won the past decade.

Recruiting and vetting experts, and not falling into the trap of mindlessly accepting received wisdom, is tricky. So is false equivalence / false balance, and wisdom-of-crowds stuff.

Though ... some of the wisdom-of-crowds bits suggest that if you can harness the sensibilities of the many, you may end up with better results than of a single individual. I'm not entirely sold. Area of active investigation.

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by TheCoreh on Sunday February 21, 2016 @02:31PM (#11146063)
Isn't that essentially appeal to authority? As long as the information is factually correct it doesn't really matter where it came from.
Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by pjc50 on Sunday February 21, 2016 @03:05PM (#11146193)
"Factually correct" is never the whole story. You can produce many radically different articles with no incorrect factual statements that lead the reader to different conclusions. WP tries to correct this with "neutral point of view", but that too is a mirage. History and politics in particular require interpretation in order to make sense of the material at all.

Fundamentally compiling an encyclopedia is an act of summarising - declaring certain information to be more important, interesting or relevant - and it is impossible to eradicate subjectivity from that.

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by pixl97 on Sunday February 21, 2016 @03:32PM (#11146352)
Omission of information while still providing facts can lead the reader to incorrect outcomes also. Take this example.

Bob hit John in the face.

Based on that information alone it seems like an unprovoked attack in which Bob is an aggressive attacker. Yet the statement is still factual.

Bob hit John in the face because he was choking Mary to death.

In this statement we see Bob as the defender and not the aggressor. With more information we could see why the situation unfolded in the first place, but many times it won't be available and things get left to interpretation.

To agree with what you are saying above, large parts of human life are subjective, not because reality is subjective, but because information loss leaves us to interpret events via our biases.

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by vacri on Sunday February 21, 2016 @03:31PM (#11146341)
> it is impossible to eradicate subjectivity from that.

One of the strangest criticisms I see about WP is that it's subjective about things like politics or biographies. These are subjective topics, and as such it's impossible to be wholly objective about them, even from the most well-intentioned, educated, neutral point of view. It's a strange criticism, because usually the critic will have no problems in ignoring the subjectivity of their suggested alternative, or sometimes conveniently neglect to provide an alternative at all.

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by wildmusings on Sunday February 21, 2016 @02:35PM (#11146082)
Appeal to authority is totally valid when the authority is an expert in the subject matter.

>As long as the information is factually correct it doesn't really matter where it came from.

And who is the arbiter of factual correctness? Or conceptual correctness.

I've noticed that lots of Wikipedia articles are completely inaccessible to people without lots of domain knowledge. I find that math articles in particular tend to obfuscate rather than elucidate.

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by TheOtherHobbes on Sunday February 21, 2016 @03:19PM (#11146275)
I don't remember Britannica being any better.

Britannica was purely a social signalling tool. The content was secondary. People bought it as evidence of middle class disposable income, not because they seriously expected to learn anything from it.

My family couldn't afford Britannica, so I had to walk to a local library to read it. I remember it being fascinating from an "I didn't know that was even a thing" angle, but close to useless for learning about specific topics - mostly because the learning needed an entire book, not a short article.

Wikipedia is great for factual gazeteer-type information about people and places, but it has the same problem with math and science - i.e. you literally can't teach the content in that format.

I've sometimes wondered about a WikiTextBook site which has definitive and progressive tutorials/lessons on topics that don't fit the 'pedia format, starting from pre-school all the way up to post-grad.

Online courses do this already, and some of them are very good at it. But it would be useful to have everything collected on a single site instead of scattered all over the web.

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by tzs on Monday February 22, 2016 @12:03AM (#11148583)
> I've sometimes wondered about a WikiTextBook site which has definitive and progressive tutorials/lessons on topics that don't fit the 'pedia format, starting from pre-school all the way up to post-grad.

I've wanted something similar, but going the other way. That is, you start at post-grad level and can expand things to lower level as needed.

For instance, an article in this format on the prime number theorem would start out stating the theorem and presenting a proof at a level that you'd see if this was a proof from a mathematics journal. At any step in the proof you could expand the article in two ways.

1. Horizontal expansion. This fills in omitted steps, but stays at the same level.

2. Vertical expansion. This explains the step in terms of less advanced material.

Expanded material could further be expanded, both horizontally and vertically. So for instance suppose that in the top level proof of the prime number theorem an integral appeared and was evaluated. Expanding horizontally would fill in the details of how you evaluate that integral.

But suppose you have not studied calculus. You could expand that integral vertically, and keep expanding, until you get down to an explanation of calculus. That would give you essentially a course in calculus--but just the calculus needed to support the prime number theorem proof.

This could be the basis of an alternative way to teach math and physics (and other sciences). Pick a set of interesting, advanced results, chosen so that when you expand all of them the bottom level will have covered the complete undergraduate math and physics curriculum. I think this could be a good approach because it provides more motivation. Everything you learn at the bottom level is motivated because it is needed for that specific advanced result you are trying to learn. Contrast that to the current approach where you have long stretches of material that might not seem interesting but that you are learning because you are told you'll need in 3 or 4 years when you are finally getting to look at interesting stuff.

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by wildmusings on Sunday February 21, 2016 @03:26PM (#11146311)
>I've sometimes wondered about a WikiTextBook site which has definitive and progressive tutorials/lessons on topics that don't fit the 'pedia format, starting from pre-school all the way up to post-grad.

There is a wikibooks, though I think it falls short of your ideal. https://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Main_Page

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by hackuser on Sunday February 21, 2016 @05:59PM (#11147094)
> Britannica was purely a social signalling tool. The content was secondary. People bought it as evidence of middle class disposable income, not because they seriously expected to learn anything from it.

I'm not sure what basis you could have to say that. Have you seen a survey?

Britannica was and I assume still is respected by academia as a serious, accurate reference tool.

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by adwf on Sunday February 21, 2016 @03:10PM (#11146226)
Yes, a lot of the math/science articles are terribly written. Somewhere in a drawer I have a dusty old Physics degree, but even on subjects I understand very well, the Wikipedia article is frequently badly written and hard to comprehend.
Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by vacri on Sunday February 21, 2016 @03:20PM (#11146284)
> Appeal to authority is totally valid when the authority is an expert in the subject matter.

John Muir lived in the 19th century. Yosemite Park has a bit more done to it and learned about it since then. Marconi straddled the 19th and 20th centuries, but claiming that his writings would inform you about wireless telephony as we currently know it is beyond foolish. They were experts in their time, but much has changed since then.

> I find that math articles in particular tend to obfuscate rather than elucidate.

Irony that you wouldn't use simpler English terms in this criticism :)

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by wildmusings on Sunday February 21, 2016 @03:34PM (#11146363)
>Irony that you wouldn't use simpler English terms in this criticism :)

Haha, you got me there.

I think you'd enjoy Orwell's essay, "Politics and the English Language". https://www.mtholyoke.edu/acad/intrel/orwell46.htm

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by vacri on Sunday February 21, 2016 @03:41PM (#11146400)
Thank you, I'll check it out.
Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by highwind on Sunday February 21, 2016 @03:00PM (#11146176)
Why not both? Learn from highly specialized experts. But since even the experts are not free from their personal biases, supplement the knowledge with 'wisdom' of the crowd.
Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by hackuser on Sunday February 21, 2016 @06:09PM (#11147138)
> Why not both?

Unless it's about something I already know, I can't always tell when a Wikipedia article is totally off base, either through omission or commission, about facts or context. I trust Britannica and experts more.

IMHO, often the difference between experts and amateurs is that the amateurs have huge blind spots, gaps in their knowledge that they are unaware of, and a lack of context. A doctor and a patient can read the same online research but there's a big difference in how they might interpret it.

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by vacri on Sunday February 21, 2016 @03:14PM (#11146252)
>Do I want to learn from those people or from the 'wisdom' of the crowds? ... I think it's out of print, but I highly recommend it

"snide comment that my thing is better than your thing, then comment that my thing is not achievable"

By the way, you're going to learn a shitload more about wireless telephony from modern sources than you are from Marconi. Likewise a few others in that list. And being a famous name doesn't mean that your writings are digestible to those not already in your industry.

My mother sold encyclopaedia door-to-door briefly when I was a kid, and I read our set voraciously, every volume cover-to-cover. I really don't understand this dick-swinging competition where one encyclopaedia is considered to be some sort of godhead, and the next is considered to be a cesspit.

I mean hell, Wikipedia has already won the 'source of truth' argument against Britannica, with independent studies showing that the former had a lower error rate than the latter. That doesn't mean that Britannica is useless, but it does point out that a lot of misconceptions about Wikipedia are unfounded.

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by DonHopkins on Sunday February 21, 2016 @07:50PM (#11147554)
Remember that annoying guy who thought Encyclopedia Britannica was his Key to the Information Age? [1]

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lMpgcz6s-eI

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by danielconde on Sunday February 21, 2016 @02:37PM (#11146094)
I didn't know about this book, and thank you. I think reading the style and opinion of key contributors to industry, science, nature preservation and other areas also helps me understand their motivations and world views. It's not just a listing of facts, but trying to get into their mind-set. I feel I do not get that from wikipedia.
Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by iso-8859-1 on Sunday February 21, 2016 @08:27PM (#11147725)
Your ISBN is wrong. It should be 0670835684. Available in Internet Archive: https://archive.org/details/treasuryofencyc00fadi_vmk
Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by hackuser on Monday February 22, 2016 @12:58AM (#11148846)
> Your ISBN is wrong. It should be 0670835684.

You are correct! And I even double-checked. I wish I could still edit my original comment.

> Available in Internet Archive: https://archive.org/details/treasuryofencyc00fadi_vmk

Wow, that's great! How does it work? Can I just get a logon and read any book there online? Download a PDF or ebook?

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by greglindahl on Monday February 22, 2016 @10:22AM (#11151356)
This book is part of the Internet Archive's "lending library" -- we own a physical copy, which sits in a shipping container, and we loan one electronic copy. We have an in-browser bookreader that you can use to read it. Sorry, no downloads of lending library books.
Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by icebraining on Sunday February 21, 2016 @03:35PM (#11146365)
If I want general knowledge, I prefer Wikipedia. If I need to delve into a specific topic, I'd rather read a book or three (by people like those, and others).

Having a collection of great articles on a dozen random topics is not really helpful, since the probability that I'll want to learn about those specific topics is low.

This is the Internet age. I'm not interested in having a poor man's library taking space on my shelf, when I can access the world's.

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by jgalt212 on Sunday February 21, 2016 @02:48PM (#11146134)
This is interesting. On a related note, how come I've never seen britannica.com in my Google search results?

Their robots.txt file doesn't scream crawlers go away.

http://www.britannica.com/robots.txt

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by dazc on Sunday February 21, 2016 @06:39PM (#11147274)
Interesting point.

Their first article is about 100th Anniversary of the Battle of Verdun so I search "Battle of Verdun" and their page, in the UK, is #15.

Looking at site overall I think this is a fair result?

Maybe demonstrates that results on page 2 are generally overlooked/rarely seen?

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by dpc59 on Sunday February 21, 2016 @10:40PM (#11148274)
I wonder what would happen if google added 50% more results per page.
Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by tim333 on Monday February 22, 2016 @12:29AM (#11148718)
>the difference between serious research and Wikipedia

I think for much serious research you could start with Wikipedia and then read the linked sources. Wikipedia itself is only an informal summary.

(I just read their summary of TE Lawrance's article https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strategy_and_tactics_of_guerri... . Shame the original is paywalled)

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by hackuser on Monday February 22, 2016 @12:49AM (#11148796)
> I just read their summary of TE Lawrance's article https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strategy_and_tactics_of_guerri.... . Shame the original is paywalled

Wow, I'm amazed to see it cited. I assumed it was a long-forgotten treasure (and it is a treasure; it revolutionized my understanding of irregular and asymmetric warfare, plus he writes exceptionally well).

To be clear, I don't know that the original is available anywhere online, paywalled or not. I think britannica.com (which has enough free articles that I rarely worry about the paywall) only has current articles, but I could be wrong.

EDIT: It is online, apparently: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11147725

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by tim333 on Monday February 22, 2016 @01:00AM (#11148856)
Googling takes me to

"Guerrilla warfare Written by: T.E. Lawrence"

on Britannica's site, followed by

"To continue reading activate your free trail"

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by tdaltonc on Sunday February 21, 2016 @02:10PM (#11145953)
This is what scholarpedia is for.
Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by leephillips on Sunday February 21, 2016 @03:07PM (#11146211)
I think there a a lot of insight into the Wikipedia phenomenon in this rant on Penny Arcade:

https://www.penny-arcade.com/news/post/2005/12/16

And in Jaron Lanier's article:

http://edge.org/conversation/digital-maoism-the-hazards-of-t...

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by frik on Sunday February 21, 2016 @01:05PM (#11145600)
The English language Wikipedia is great. Some other language have big problems with certain admins that prevent new articles or any additions at all (e.g. German language). WikiMedia should do something and "fix" those administrative issues.
Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by heinrich5991 on Sunday February 21, 2016 @01:14PM (#11145648)
This needs to be a bit more nuanced. I do see new articles popping up in the German Wikipedia.
Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by creshal on Sunday February 21, 2016 @02:28PM (#11146045)
It's a well-known problem in the German Wikipedia that has been regularly making it into the local newspapers for several years now:

http://www.taz.de/!5087443/

http://www.heise.de/newsticker/meldung/WikiCon-Konfliktfeld-...

I'm not sure whether there's English articles on the (apparently rather German-centric) problem. (For one, it's easy to find the German ones, because of course Germans have a distinct word for it: Löschnazi-Debatte.)

(Edit: Sorry, accidentally misclicked and downvoted you.)

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by frik on Sunday February 21, 2016 @03:18PM (#11146269)
> nuanced

Really? No. It's a well known wide spread systematic problem. The root cause should be fixed by the international Wikimedia Foundation.

Read about the issues on English Wikipedia:

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_Wikipedia#Characteristi...

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_Wikipedia#Deletions

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by kuschku on Monday February 22, 2016 @05:28AM (#11149836)
German Wikipedia is not associated with Wikimedia, and Wikimedia has no control over them.
Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by tokenadult on Sunday February 21, 2016 @02:53PM (#11146151)
I am a Wikipedian and have been since 2010. Because I read German, I occasionally refer to and edit German Wikipedia. I'm not so sure that German Wikipedia is really that much worse than English Wikipedia in the topics I follow most closely (psychology and linguistics), and I might rather say that English Wikipedia should be less hasty about adding new articles on every pop-culture topic for which few reliable sources exist.
Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by frik on Sunday February 21, 2016 @03:26PM (#11146314)
German Wikipedia looses a lot of valuable content, on some days more than new content is added: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_Wikipedia#Deletions

The notability guidelines are very off in the German Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_Wikipedia#Characteristi...

English Wikipedia is really good. Though sometimes even there I wished some articles were on Wikipedia rather than some obscure Wikia-subwiki with tons of advertisement. It's not like HDD space costs much money these days. And all these article have sources anyway. Wikipedia had this nice "triva" sections that I love on IMDB.com up to 2006 (or so), sad some decided to delete them as well. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Manual_of_Style/Triv...

  This guideline does not suggest removing trivia sections, 
  or moving them to the talk page. If information is 
  otherwise suitable, it is better that it be poorly 
  presented than not presented at all.
Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by sb057 on Sunday February 21, 2016 @03:13PM (#11146245)
It's not just non-English language Wikipedias that have have admin issues.
Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by greendestiny_re on Sunday February 21, 2016 @03:19PM (#11146274)
Hello world.

I have a different gripe with Wikipedia that has nothing to do with whether articles within it are factual or not: poor writing style.

Wikipedia editor guidelines encourage cooperation and consensus, but this regularly results in edit wars, where editors aggressively delete each other's edits. To resolve this, editors will usually resort to an unspoken system in which one editor will write one fragment of a sentence and cite sources for that fragment, the other editor writes the next fragment and cites it and so on. The result is a horrible mess that, although most likely entirely factual, is perfectly unreadable.

Worse yet, it is very difficult to simply copy such a paragraph from Wikipedia and paste it to your friend's chat box - the inline citation marks remain as full blown numbers and have to be removed by hand.

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by vilhelm_s on Sunday February 21, 2016 @03:21PM (#11146289)
I don't think the fact that citations occur inside sentences is necessarily because the articles are collaboratively edited. Scientific articles generally do the same thing, even if they are just written by one person, in order to make it clear which part of the sentence the citation refers to.
Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by kuschku on Monday February 22, 2016 @05:31AM (#11149851)
If you don't speak high-school level English (C1), then maybe just use simple.wikipedia.org?

That page focuses on articles with simpler grammar, easily understandable for children or people who learn English as second language.

Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by soared on Sunday February 21, 2016 @06:40PM (#11147278)
Can you point me to a good example of this? I've never noticed wikipedia to be unreadable.
Re:‘You Could Look It Up’: The World Before and Since Wikipedia by stirner on Monday February 22, 2016 @05:30AM (#11149846)
“The Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy”— in the words of Douglas Adams — “has already supplanted the great Encyclopedia Galactica as the standard repository of all knowledge and wisdom, for though it has many omissions and contains much that is apocryphal, or at least wildly inaccurate, it scores over the older, more pedestrian work in two important respects. First, it is slightly cheaper; and second, it has the words ‘Don’t Panic’ inscribed in large friendly letters on its cover.”

"Worse is better."