On the one hand, there is such thing as supply destruction, oil producers that are marginally profitable and that go out of business if price collapses, taking tons of hard capital (not financial, but equipment, personnel know how, etc). The Saudis are pressumably aware of this and very much doing it on purpose.
The problem is that there also exist demand destruction. Companies that consume energy in large quantities to produce economically useful but expensive goods and services. This guys conversely go out of business when oil price spikes (there was some statistic going around in 2008 about how 5 out of the last 6 recesions in the US where correlated with high energy prices), which is the intended effect of Saudi strategy.
So, eventually, when the noise signal introduced in oil prices gets absorbed by the market negative feedback loops, the economy we go back to will likely be smaller than the economy we started with. We could debate wether this is a good thing or a bad thing, but many actors are nervous because this is a game of musical chairs, and very few can say they will have a guarrantied place at the table by the time the rubble stops bouncing.
http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2015/06/north-da...
Doesn't that equipment get sold? If not immediately, then eventually, modulo the odd pipe that gets bent or rusted in storage.
And those people are largely available for the jobs they're experienced at when jobs are available, so they aren't "destroyed" either, they're just idled. Some will move on, some won't.
A lot of it, no. A lot of equipment is built on site and would have to be destructively disassembled to be moved, but just leaving it there without using or maintaining it will cause it to rust or be damaged by the elements. And even the equipment that can be resold and still physically exists would have to be transported back to the site at significant expense. A lot of the sites are in remote locations.
> And those people are largely available for the jobs they're experienced at when jobs are available, so they aren't "destroyed" either, they're just idled. Some will move on, some won't.
The "some will move on" being the trouble. You have somebody who knows how to do a specific thing not many people know how to do, you lay them off and they go find some other job doing something else that pays about as well, move house, put their kids into new schools, now you want them back. Good luck with that.
Assests are not abstract. They are deployed to one particular site, and a big part of the cost goes to install them in that site. That's why all producers are basically operating at a cost right now.
You may reopen a closed oil ring (assuming you did nothing destructive to maximize your short term wins, which fraking companies are, AFAIK).
The personnel question is a tricky one. People need to eat, so if they face a downturn, many will be discouraged and move to different careers. Some will return, if the market picks up enough to pay way above average wages, but some just definitively won't. You will have to make up the difference by training a fresh crop of young crew members.
And I find it amusing to see that a subset of the HN audience can have such a hard time to grasp that other industries might have their own talent acquisition problems.
I mean, the markets are down, but that's just a "quickly grab a chair now that the music's stopped" situation isn't it? Or alternatively, regression to the mean?
Someone please correct me if I'm grossly misunderstanding here. As you may be able to tell I'm no expert, to put it mildly.
--
J.P. Morgan Builds Loss Reserves for the First Time in Six Years
http://www.wsj.com/articles/turning-point-j-p-morgan-adds-to...
More Banks Take Hits on Energy Loans
http://www.wsj.com/articles/more-banks-take-hits-on-energy-l...
RBS: Sell everything except high quality bonds.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/economics/12093807/RBS-cr...
J.P. Morgan: We believe the regime has transitioned to one of selling any rally.
http://www.marketwatch.com/story/bearish-jp-morgan-says-sell...
Citi: The cumulative probability of U.S. recession reaches 65 percent [this] year.
http://www.reuters.com/article/us-global-economy-idUSKBN0TL1...
George Soros Sees Crisis in Global Markets That Echoes 2008
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-01-07/global-mar...
OPEC seems to be dead - and that means we're getting real competition in the oil business.
The Saudis tried petro-power politics by driving prices up through cutting production, but other OPEC members immediately increased production for the additional lucrative revenue.
OPEC has been dead for a while -- why? It was a cartel that survived on the basis of raising and lowering production in unison, and now it is a race to the bottom. The Saudis were betrayed and this is their revenge.
The oil flood is as much about punishing other OPEC members as it is about killing potential Iranian oil revenue.
At 100$/barrel people would just switch to something else. At 100-40-120-60-200, people are going to keep buying low mileage gas powered cars in massive numbers, building car infrastructure, and living in the suburbs.
PS: Don't forget you can manufacture oil for ~100$ per barrel, but if your factory folds when prices drop under 90$ it's a poor bet at those prices. It takes huge investments to create an alternative over decades, but you can kill them off with a few lean years.
The solar energy cat is out of the bag[1], it will forever loom over oil.
[1] http://www.treehugger.com/renewable-energy/striking-chart-sh...
Depends on why oil prices are low. If aggregate demand has dropped then it means another recession may be coming. If it is simply an over supply, then you're right. Everything I have read says over supply, but people are worried that China is really slowing down and the numbers are cooked to hide that fact.
So while high oil prices seem bad, they indicate huge demand and high economic activity.
It is the massive liquidation of sovereign wealth funds that is causing markets to move lower. When someone is forced to sell, what happens to the price? It tanks. There is no floor. Technicals take over. This coupled with expected negative earnings outlook creates a vicious cycle of downward trajectory.
That's kinda my point: what negative earnings outlook? Lower oil prices means lower costs for every industry but energy. "Developed" markets are mostly oil-importers, and are still (as far as I know) the source of most industries' profits.
2) It's difficult to quantify the impact the oil and gas boom had as a percentage of global GDP growth and therefore what the impact will be in its absence.
Those fracking/oil shale companies were leveraged up the wazoo. Remember 2008?
>But in the "developed" countries, this makes literally everything else cheaper.
Yup. This has the potential to turn into a deflationary spiral.
The deflationary spiral bit I do not get. By itself, a cheaper resource should increase consumption because now everything is cheaper and you have as much money you can spend on stuff as you used to. Externalities aside, this kind of deflation is not what's called a "deflationary spiral", is it? A deflationary spiral is when consumption goes down because people don't have money to buy stuff, and then producers lower prices, profits fall, people are fired, consumption drops further, prices fall even lower, etc. But cheap resource availability is different, theoretically, because then consumption should rise instead of drop, not? (Also it'd be a bit strange if say finding large new deposits of some resource were a guaranteed economic disaster; one would think it should make things better.)
Not necessarily. Take a look at Canada. With the Canadian dollar tanking, the price of everything imported is going up (because it's imported from the US and the USD-CAD exchange rate is lopsided).
Maybe what you really mean by "developed" countries is "just for people in the US."
> And when the Saudis have made their point, they'll drop production, prices will go back up, everything will return to normal, more or less.
Something will happen, but I think the cat's out of the bag: Even if prices rise significantly, the US has proven to itself that it is/came become very quickly self supplying in oil. This significantly decreases the Saudi's leverage in world politics which changes some balances in the middle east and beyond quite significantly.
Similar things are true for Europe (especially in the east) with regard to Russia. Russia's medium-sized stick has been the threat to cut off gas to its western neighbours, and it gets really cold there in the winter.
LOL. In Canada, the drop of oil prices dropped the loonie, and now grocery prices are through the freaking roof. It's harder to eat healthy when a cauliflower is $13.
Additionally, the lower oil prices wrecked the income of a number of state and national governments that just assumed the price would stay that way for the foreseeable future.
When Saudis drop production, they stop acting against fracking. In that case, normal means about $60-$70 per barrel. It's the point where fracking starts making financial sense.
Assuming this isn't a joke, why is that ?
The Nash equilibrium is everybody low or everybody high.
It is a Stag Hunt, and everyone is taking home Hares.
The Saudis are not so much chasing hares as cockroaches.
http://www.tradingeconomics.com/saudi-arabia/crude-oil-produ...
The Saudis will certainly "survive". They might put many other production areas out of business in the short term, and that is bad for current investors. It's good for alternate fuels, however, and it only keeps other areas out of production for as long as the price stays down. The internal contradictions of the Saudi state will eventually dictate a price rise...
I get that low oil prices mean bad days for energy companies, many "emerging" countries, and the financial markets, to whom any news is bad news.
But in the "developed" countries, this makes literally everything else cheaper. In the short and medium term, yay. And when the Saudis have made their point, they'll drop production, prices will go back up, everything will return to normal, more or less.
So why is everyone worried?