Re:Oil Crash is Kicking Off One of the Largest Wealth Transf...
by manyhats on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @12:08PM
(#11020704)
It can be spiral-like locally without it necessarily being so nationally or globally. Ask your average roughneck or metal bender in Texas or North Dakota about layoffs, salary cuts or personal spending trends and you'll find all of the spiral characteristics.
Re:Oil Crash is Kicking Off One of the Largest Wealth Transf...
by jameshart on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @11:11AM
(#11020298)
Yes, this is not obviously deflationary. Especially when it's a resource that contributes to market inefficiency, like transportation costs. If it becomes cheaper to move things from A to B, then price differentials between A and B become harder to sustain. (that can contribute both to price falls as well as price increases - if it costs less to export something to a foreign market, domestic consumers might have to pay suppliers MORE to persuade them to sell the item locally rather than ship it overseas).
The deflationary spiral bit I do not get. By itself, a cheaper resource should increase consumption because now everything is cheaper and you have as much money you can spend on stuff as you used to. Externalities aside, this kind of deflation is not what's called a "deflationary spiral", is it? A deflationary spiral is when consumption goes down because people don't have money to buy stuff, and then producers lower prices, profits fall, people are fired, consumption drops further, prices fall even lower, etc. But cheap resource availability is different, theoretically, because then consumption should rise instead of drop, not? (Also it'd be a bit strange if say finding large new deposits of some resource were a guaranteed economic disaster; one would think it should make things better.)