News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by mahranch on Sunday January 31, 2016 @08:10PM (#11009005)
China's economic growth simply isn't sustainable, and that's even if it was true growth. There isn't a top economist alive who believes China's self-reported GDP numbers aren't fudged in one way or another (source: http://www.businessinsider.com/economist-reactions-to-chinas...). Either one of those situations (an economic slowdown, China fudging the numbers, or the more likely situation: a combination of both) makes hedging against the Yuan a pretty solid bet.

People and foolish investors think, "Well, China has more than a billion people so it will eventually have a robust and rich economy!" Only, it doesn't work like that (cue the "That's not how this works. That's not how any of this works" lady). Population size is only a tiny facet of a much larger picture. And it's not even a particularly important one, relatively speaking. There are some economists who are now starting to think that having a massive population size may have the opposite effect; it helps you reach a certain point but then your massive size begins to act as an anchor which keeps you from growing further.

Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by fspeech on Monday February 01, 2016 @01:17AM (#11010108)
It is not necessarily about the sustainability of the Chinese economy. No matter how much capital the hedge funds can muster it will be puny compared to PBoC resources. The real threat to the yuan is if regular Chinese become convinced of the trade.

Hedge funds bet against the yuan because right now it is one-sided: meaning they don't need to worry about short squeezes as typical shorters would have to. If yuan were to sharply rise it is pretty certain that PBoC would intervene. This makes the bet against the yuan relatively safe. The only way the PBoC can stop the shorts is to make borrowing cost high. But it is also trying to make the yuan more widely used so it is loathe to do that as well over any extended time.

Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by neximo4 on Monday February 01, 2016 @01:50AM (#11010215)
> No matter how much capital the hedge funds can muster it will be puny compared to PBoC resources

This is incorrect. Hedge funds borrow and create temporary money by writing derivative contracts such as options, futures & swaps. It is by this logic they can actually muster more funds than the PBOC in aggregate. Quite simply the market for currencies is bigger than the PBOC and the hedge funds, but there are more hedge funds that are richer than the 3T in reserves the PBOC has access to.

This is partly why the PBOC uses the overnight rate to limit resources (such as to affect the interest rate of the derivatives instead of the Yuan prices they bear). It would be possible to profit by arbitraging the interest rate so this would make using derivatives expensive too.

Of course affecting interest rates affects the entire economy as a whole and is unsustainable.

Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by fspeech on Monday February 01, 2016 @02:54AM (#11010420)
http://www.barclayhedge.com/research/indices/ghs/mum/HF_Mone...

Not all of them do macro bets, nor would they concentrate their position 100% against rmb.

Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by neximo4 on Monday February 01, 2016 @04:13AM (#11010658)
No they wouldn't, no one would put their eggs in one basket in terms of risk.

Nonetheless the size of markets in control of hedge funds is still larger than what the PBOC has access to.

It may be better to substitute 'hedge funds' with anyone out there wanting to make profit through a price anomaly. This amount of people and their money is larger than the PBOC's resources.

Also it doesn't always take a sell to lower a price, or a buy to increase a price. It just takes a price that has the largest amount of trades as it does on Monday morning auctions with every currency.

Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by fspeech on Monday February 01, 2016 @02:31AM (#11010360)
There is relative little rmb outside the country. Not everyone can just go inside China and borrow yuan and buy USD.

If you are talking about non deliverables, who will be your counter party if everyone wants to go short?

Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by neximo4 on Monday February 01, 2016 @02:56AM (#11010429)
> There is relative little rmb outside the country.

There doesn't need to be any, so long as the counter currency exists (the USD, EUR, JPY, etc) there can be a control against the onshore yuan, whether it trades or not.

There is always a counter party, It can be created using swaps to other currencies and to other companies actual cash flows.

I wouldn't want to argue against this topic excessively because its a fairly clear cut case of 'this time its different' with China, primarily through marketing.

I'd point out that on previous occasions in history, the gold & silver pegs, various cross currency pegs. It has always been the case the price setter has assumed they were bigger than the market and it has always turned out the opposite. It is also because the market can stand the test of time. This combined with today's use of leverage & derivatives is an even more dangerous combination.

Markets always assume the correct rate, because if not there is something that can be profited from.

None of what I say precipitates bias, I'm not against China's rise. I even believe the GDP numbers out of China, as I mention in another comment on this page. This is just the basis of how markets work. The predicate of your assumption is the PBOC is bigger than the market for Yuan trade and this is incorrect. In something as liquid as a currency a counter party will always be available.

Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by fspeech on Monday February 01, 2016 @03:35AM (#11010545)
If market is forced to trade at an artificial price often the result is illiquidity. Swap or not eventually someone has to be on the long side.

I didn't say PBoC is bigger than the market. I said it is bigger than the offshore market. I don't see how that is controversial. It can shut down the offshore market if it wants to.

Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by neximo4 on Monday February 01, 2016 @03:43AM (#11010569)
> If market is forced to trade at an artificial price often the result is illiquidity

There is, Offshore-Onshore spread & HKD interbank rate.

> It can shut down the offshore market if it wants to.

Not forever, markets can do what they are without any limit. The PBOC loses money or hurts China's economy doing this and it cannot be sustained.

> Swap or not eventually someone has to be on the long side.

There is always a counter party as someone will need to buy something in China. Not every flow is speculative. It is a very large exporter economy, if not the largest.

A swap allows finding a counter party in a currency that is not the Yuan at the cost of the interest rate differential.

Finding a counter party is actually very easy, especially with exchange rate swaps. It does not require a Yuan counter party with physical RMB.

Instruments such as swaps, options and futures were actually created to provide liquidity in cases when it is withheld such as what is being done. This is what makes today even less different than previous times when it comes to exchange rate pegs.

If not a swap, its an option. An option can have a counter party as someone will always be willing to underwrite an option as it pays off a premium that has _no bias_ to the expected price direction of the underlying instrument.

Hedge funds know this because they have it all at their disposal. It is simply the cost of time that has to be paid (in terms of options premiums or the swap rates), if they are correct.

The PBOC realises this and this is why their options are limited to making the trade expensive as opposed to being able to control it. This is why they jacked up the HKD interbank rate and increased reserve requirements on the RMB. Again, it ought to be mentioned this hurts all HK and China businesses and is unsustainable in the longer run.

Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by fspeech on Monday February 01, 2016 @11:03AM (#11012512)
Our positions are not substantially far apart except regarding hedge funds power. You first expanded "hedge funds" to include everyone looking to make a buck; then you said counterparties are easy to find for all these money looking to short. I don't see how that can be logically consistent. If everyone intending to short finds a long to match at the current price, why would that bother the PBoC?

As I said I believe the hedge funds bets against the yuan are relatively safe. I believe this is the case because they are working for the PBoC, not against it. The PBoC apparently would not mind the yuan to weaken over time. It just doesn't want it too quickly or disorderly. It wants to give time to companies that borrowed in USD to bet on yuan appreciation to unwind but it does not want to freak out retail savers to jump on the same trade so it is a delicate position. One can debate if such a policy is wise but I don't think it is at all like the all powerful hedgies put a gun to the PBoC's head. Having the offshore yuan trade lower actually provides political cover for the PBoC in Washington. It is just that herding cats can be challenging.

Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by aminorex on Monday February 01, 2016 @09:05AM (#11011772)
"Markets always assume the correct rate, because if not there is something that can be profited from."

There is always something that can be profited from. Therefore markets never assume the correct rates.

Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by tim333 on Sunday January 31, 2016 @09:58PM (#11009399)
>China's economic growth simply isn't sustainable, and that's even if it was true growth

People have been naysaying China for a while but it's kept merrily growing. Mostly it's because the Chinese tend culturally to be pro education and hard working but in China were reduced to very low incomes by Mao's communism and have since been recovering and getting back towards the kind of economy they have in Taiwan, Hong Kong, Singapore and the like.

GDP per capita in China is $6,800 (up from $951 in 2000) against $32k in Taiwan and $55k in Singapore so there's a way to go. A housing crash will probably just be a blip for a while. They'd have to turn back to Mao to really muck things up.

Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by sharetea on Monday February 01, 2016 @01:15AM (#11010104)
Yup China grew......by borrowing 32Trillion http://www.businessinsider.com/china-debt-to-gdp-statistics-... in order to support dead state companies http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/peoplesdaily/article-3422491... and build empty cities and buildings http://www.chinatopix.com/articles/75493/20160126/shanghais-... http://www.citymetric.com/skylines/enough-empty-floor-space-.... Now they have to layoff tons of steel/cement/coal workers, around 400,000 to start http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-01-26/china-stee..., and 300,000 soldiers.

Ironically, these unemployed million of disgruntled workers will not move into the empty buildings in the city; They'll most likely move back to the countryside. They will, however, be back in the city for protesting.

Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by adventured on Monday February 01, 2016 @07:49AM (#11011429)
It's bizarre that you're getting downvoted. The sole reason China's economy kept - supposedly - growing so quickly after the great recession was due to the extreme amount of debt they took on.

China took on the greatest pile of debt in world history in the shortest amount of time. Nothing like it has ever been seen before. They're now arguably the most indebted nation when you combine public + private debt, and it continues to expand. They have no way to reduce that debt, as the moment they take their foot off the debt gas their economy will crash, and yet their new debt is generating almost no growth return. They're bleeding reserves, they're overflowing with zombie corporations, their asset classes keep trying to implode and require constant large bailouts, and they still have nearly a billion poor people to deal with and half a billion pretend farmers without jobs. How could they be more of a disaster?

Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by hackuser on Sunday January 31, 2016 @10:11PM (#11009441)
> People have been naysaying China for a while but it's kept merrily growing.

That's characteristic of both bubbles and genuine exceptional performance, and in many situations in addition to national economies. Look at rapidly growing startups, for example.

Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by tim333 on Sunday January 31, 2016 @10:35PM (#11009566)
I think China has both bubbles and genuine exceptional performance. The property market there is pretty bubbly. And I don't know if you'd even call the stock market thing a bubble when it was deliberate government hyping.
Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by mooreds on Sunday January 31, 2016 @10:18PM (#11009484)
China recently and Japan from 1960-1990 took very similar paths to prosperity:

Click on the max timeframe for the first charts below to see the similar growth curves:

http://www.tradingeconomics.com/japan/gdp

http://www.tradingeconomics.com/china/gdp

Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by tim333 on Sunday January 31, 2016 @10:50PM (#11009640)
I think Japan stopped growing rapidly partly because they'd caught up with the west and couldn't keep transforming by copying more developed countries. I don't think China's there yet. Maybe if their gdp/capita goes from $6.8k (China) to $39k (Japan) that will be the case but there's a way to go.
Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by yxhuvud on Monday February 01, 2016 @02:34AM (#11010366)
The problem is more that the rest of the world cannot absorb more chinese exports, which force the chinese to have to do consumption based growth. Changing direction of growth like that is not simple.
Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by adventured on Monday February 01, 2016 @08:07AM (#11011502)
Not only is changing direction extremely difficult, service based growth is far slower compared to manufacturing based export growth when you're coming up from nothing as China did, starting from $300 GDP per capita in 1990. They were able to tap into virgin (to them) export markets in the US and Europe. As you noted, there are no more well-off consumers to provide for their export growth, that party ended in 2009 or so.
Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by fweespeech on Monday February 01, 2016 @10:13AM (#11012127)
The problem here is China has seriously miscalculated and focused too heavily on exports. The rest of the world doesn't want more Chinese exports than they did in 2007. Export lead growth only gets you so far.

Japan [with a population of ~128 million] could run its economy into exports and scale to catching up with the West in that manner because of the smaller population.

China simply can't do that with 1 billion people.

http://www.cnbc.com/2015/10/12/china-exports-imports-continu...

China's exports have stopped growing and that is a very, very serious problem with debt fueled growth focused on exports. They'll have to print money [to bring export growth back and avoid a private debt bubble bursting] which is why everyone is betting against their currency. Or they'll go into a recession and they'll need to print money.

Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by nandemo on Monday February 01, 2016 @01:46AM (#11010200)
Indeed, China's GDP per capita in 2013 is comparable to Japan's in the late 1970s, well before the Japanese "bubble".

http://www.indexmundi.com/facts/indicators/NY.GDP.PCAP.CD/co...

Also, although China's been quickly urbanizing, China's % of urban population (about 51%) is still lower than Japan's in the 1960s (about 62%):

http://www.indexmundi.com/facts/indicators/SP.URB.TOTL.IN.ZS...

That said, plain old GDP also matters depending who you are. If your country's economy heavily relies on Chinese imports/exports (see my other comment), your government doesn't care much about the average Chinese citizen's living standards.

Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by 1stop on Monday February 01, 2016 @04:49AM (#11010775)
It wasn't Mao, it was a civil war coupled with a foreign occupation. Ever since then, their wealth has grown (including during Mao)
Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by memracom on Sunday January 31, 2016 @08:54PM (#11009158)
Last I looked, China was a big export economy. So the population size is irrelevant. Look elsewhere for indicators of China's future economic growth.

And never forget, that big revolutionary wave of iPhones and iPads? It came from China manufacturers.

In today's world, if you only look ahead, you will be blindsided from the rear. China is not China any more.

Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by toomuchtodo on Sunday January 31, 2016 @09:18PM (#11009256)
Which markets in the world, besides the US, have a stable enough economy for China to rely on their consumption?

Europe still has significant headwinds, Canada and the middle east...that's pretty obvious with $30/barrel oil prices, Russia of course not doing terribly great, capital flooding back to the US from Central and South America due to interest rates rising.

Keep in mind, a lot of manufacturing is moving back to the US from China with automation being cheeper than (quickly rising) Chinese labor rates [1] [2] [3].

If China cannot stoke internal demand quickly enough (and I assure you, it cannot), it's going to slide into a deep recession. On the bright side, this is going to help cool off London, Toronto, Vancouver, SF/LA, Miami, and central Texas property markets (where a lot of Chinese money was flowing into).

[1] http://www.marketwatch.com/story/us-flips-the-script-on-jobs...

[2] http://news.yahoo.com/manufacturing-moving-china-us-survey-0...

[3] http://www.economist.com/news/special-report/21569570-growin...

Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by edwinnathaniel on Monday February 01, 2016 @12:20AM (#11009933)
> On the bright side, this is going to help cool off London, Toronto, Vancouver, SF/LA, Miami, and central Texas property markets (where a lot of Chinese money was flowing into).

I really really really really really hope so but man... I don't know... the Mainlanders have waayy too much money and the existing owners of multiple properties won't let the properties go anyway so we may have a stagnant period (good) for a while until either China gets better or... well, I hope the market goes down a bit :D.

Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by meric on Sunday January 31, 2016 @09:34PM (#11009314)
China has been conjuring demand for concrete buildings for 7 years. IMO "stoking internal demand" is harmful to the economy. There's always demand for what people really want. Clean air, comfortable, affordable, living spaces with readily access to transportation to quickly travel to where other people are, good food, etc.

But then again, China can't step back from the current structure of the economy without risking collapse, which would endanger the Party's power.

Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by khuey on Sunday January 31, 2016 @10:11PM (#11009442)
You do realize that Apple is one making the realy money from iPhones and iPads, not the contract manufacturers, right?
Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by gscott on Monday February 01, 2016 @12:23AM (#11009942)
This is not exactly true the contract manufacturers are being paid to learn to make their own phones and they are.

http://www.wsj.com/articles/foxconn-aims-to-fashion-its-own-...

Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by sharetea on Monday February 01, 2016 @01:22AM (#11010129)
Foxconn is a Taiwanese company
Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by 1stop on Monday February 01, 2016 @04:55AM (#11010798)
... The factories are still in China, meaning Chinese are gaining the skills and thus creating an industry for themselves
Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by khuey on Monday February 01, 2016 @07:27PM (#11016825)
"Making the physical iPhone" is not a very lucrative industry. "Designing and marketing the iPhone and its software ecosystem" is.
Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by rhizome on Monday February 01, 2016 @01:06AM (#11010078)
Now all they need is a billion dollar marketing department.
Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by 1stop on Monday February 01, 2016 @04:56AM (#11010801)
It's called Huawei, or Xiaomi.
Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by adventured on Monday February 01, 2016 @08:02AM (#11011480)
Xiaomi isn't doing very well these days. Their growth fell off a cliff last year, and is very unlikely to recover to the brief glory days. The smartphone market is going to grow extremely slow from here forward. Xiaomi will end up as just another irrelevant smartphone maker, in a heap of dozens of them like HTC or Motorola.

http://fortune.com/2016/01/15/xiaomi-smartphone-sales-fall-s...

Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by gscott on Monday February 01, 2016 @12:11PM (#11013134)
The Chinese are definitely focused on markets with new growing cellphone adoption rather then the US where it is hyper competitive. I don't believe their success here is an indicator of there overall wellbeing.
Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by maxthegeek1 on Monday February 01, 2016 @03:30AM (#11010527)
Any nation with a large rural population with access to easy credit has the potential for massive growth.

The majority of China's population still consists of subsistence farmers. China should be able to maintain rapid growth until those farmers are integrated into a modern industrialized economy at which point the returns on investment will start to diminish like it has for every other industrialized nation.

Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by adventured on Monday February 01, 2016 @07:55AM (#11011449)
China can't integrate those farmers, there are no jobs for them. And that's before China has to lay off tens of millions of industrial workers they no longer need, and that's before robotics completely decimates low-value manufacturing.

Those subsistence farmers are kept that way because there's nothing else for them to do and there never will be. China can't allow the productivity of their farming to rise - it's among the lowest on earth - because of the social chaos that would occur. Unless you can find another three to four billion global consumers equal to your typical US or European consumer, such that China can then employ 450 million more people in jobs.

Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by legulere on Monday February 01, 2016 @01:50AM (#11010213)
Printing tons of US Dollars to finance an enormous deficit in the balance of trade [1] seems way more unsustainable to me. The only reason it has been holding up until now is actually the US Dollar reserves of China [2].

[1]: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/b/b5/Handelsb...

[2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_exchange_reserves_of_C...

Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by simonh on Monday February 01, 2016 @01:58AM (#11010250)
Reserves which fell by half a billion dollars last year, and still falling. This is why the funds are betting against the Yuan. How far is China willing to see it's reserves fall before it blinks?

http://www.wsj.com/articles/chinas-foreign-exchange-reserves...

Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by dingo_bat on Monday February 01, 2016 @02:23AM (#11010330)
Did you mean half a Trillion and not Billion? Because it seems to me that China has $1.5 trillion+ reserves, and half a billion drop would not be cause for surprise.
Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by dragandj on Monday February 01, 2016 @04:15AM (#11010662)
He probably means "european billion". In French and other European languages, milliard is a billion and bilion is a trillion.
Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by simonh on Monday February 01, 2016 @04:00AM (#11010627)
Oops yes Trillion, not Billion thanks. Too late to edit.
Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by vox_mollis on Monday February 01, 2016 @10:14AM (#11012132)
There isn't a top economist alive who believes China's self-reported GDP numbers aren't fudged in one way or another

Meta: Why is it SOP on HN to downvote/chastise those who claim US economic numbers are fabricated, or post zerohedge/shadowstats links, yet fully embrace the notion of the PRC is doing it? What makes the US so special in its sainthood?

Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by mahranch on Monday February 01, 2016 @08:36PM (#11017147)
> Why is it SOP on HN to downvote/chastise those who claim US economic numbers are fabricated, or post zerohedge/shadowstats links, yet fully embrace the notion of the PRC is doing it?

Because even if the U.S was doing it, it would be minor fudging. If China is doing it, it's almost wholly fabricated and un-reflective of reality. The U.S has plenty of independent verification of its numbers, and tons of channels for oversight. China literally has no oversight. Their government is the end-all, be-all. The alpha and omega. They don't have any oversight whatsoever. Their government runs the media (that's not an exaggeration, they literally own the news agencies) as well, so you don't get for-profit news organizations who would love nothing more than an economic controversy of that scale to come out so they could report on it and make loads of cash.

Basically, the entire premise is silly if you just use a little critical thinking.

Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by ken47 on Sunday January 31, 2016 @08:56PM (#11009168)
I would shy away from the word "fudged," but almost every country's gdp numbers are the result of subjective interpretation.
Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by aminorex on Sunday January 31, 2016 @09:56PM (#11009393)
China is an exceptional case. It has a long tradition that way.
Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by neximo4 on Monday February 01, 2016 @02:08AM (#11010283)
Recently someone at Davos asked a PRC rep about this and he mentioned the number is close but is often different due to smoothening.

He did mention it is close and showed that tax revenues grew quite close to the GDP rate. This is something that does not typically happen when GDP decreases or is far off from the actual numbers.

Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by simonh on Monday February 01, 2016 @04:28AM (#11010696)
There are many economic indicators that correlate to GDP growth, but are also influenced by other factors and so the strength of the correlation can be strong or weak at any given time. This means at any given moment you can probably pick or chose one or more other indicators to back up any particular contention about GDP, but that doesn't really prove anything. To get a good picture you need to look at a wide variety of indicators. If the vast majority of them indicate the GDP growth measure is wrong, then even if a few of them back it up it's still likely that the growth measure is being fiddled.
Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by neximo4 on Monday February 01, 2016 @04:38AM (#11010729)
There are many but wouldn't you agree tax revenues are a rather hard indicator to fudge if GDP decreases? Tax revenues are very well correlated to GDP, in downturns too.

6% is also a rather large increase YoY for the Chinese MoF's tax receipts. It is difficult to make hard cash of such a large number up.

I think what has happened is China actually grew faster than the claimed 7-9% in the past decade and now the amount is smoothened to reflect this

I've always noticed a sway on HN to downplay China's growth, given the large American audience this is quite expected. But it is good to be impartial to understand the changes a bit better.

Re:Currency War: U.S. Hedge Funds Mount New Attacks on China... by nandemo on Monday February 01, 2016 @02:10AM (#11010290)
There are many related indicators that you can't easily "fudge". Actors who have a stake in China's growth (or lack thereof) aren't simply looking at a PDF posted by the Chinese government.

For example, China is now Brazil's largest trading partner. In particular, it's the biggest importer of Brazilian goods (e.g. oil and iron). When China's manufacturing output grows or drops, its demand for Brazilian exports grows or drops too.

(One could probably make a stronger case by looking at e.g. Gulf countries instead of Brazil)