News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Unethical Growth Hacking from YayView by trymas on Sunday January 10, 2016 @07:03AM (#10875040)
<rant>

It's not the first time I will rant about this, but why use the word 'hacking' here?

YayView sort of exploited the system by automatically creating users from freely available data on the social networks, but is it 'hacking' per se? I think that YayView is not a hacker company, and just a startup using very unethical business tactics.

IMHO, term `hacking` is used everywhere to raise `click-bait-itness`, no matter it fits there or not.

</rant>

Re:Unethical Growth Hacking from YayView by digbyloftus on Sunday January 10, 2016 @07:19AM (#10875077)
Hacker in this context means someone who quickly and cheaply creates new things, as in "it's hacked together". Like how we're on Hacker News, it's not a security website, it's a website for people interested in startup news. Growth hacking basically means any form of growth that doesn't come from a fat marketing budget or traditional brand growing methods. I definitely think their method counts.
Re:Unethical Growth Hacking from YayView by TeMPOraL on Sunday January 10, 2016 @08:10AM (#10875182)
I disagree. "Growth hacking" refers to "hacking" as in "the thing programmers do that make them oh so important in the XXI century". It's marketers doing collective "me too", they want to bask in the same glory, capture some of that positive halo that was created by IT companies that diluted the meaning of word "hacker". The word that itself doesn't mean much anymore within the commercial world.
Re:Unethical Growth Hacking from YayView by digbyloftus on Sunday January 10, 2016 @08:25AM (#10875214)
Plenty of what programmers are doing isn't hacking. A team of top cs men making some process in google 0.1% more efficient doesn't seem very hacky even if it results in oodles of profit. What's more is this type of marketing is very much the result of hacker programming. Scraping social media profiles and then automatically email spamming the recipients is a system that was programmed, they aren't manually doing it (I hope!).
Re:Unethical Growth Hacking from YayView by TeMPOraL on Sunday January 10, 2016 @08:31AM (#10875230)
Of course! Most programming, and especially most professional programming, has nothing to do with hacking. It's a different culture. But it's also totally different culture to what "growth hacking" is doing to marketing. Astroturfing the hell out of your service doesn't make you a hacker. It makes you an unsophisticated asshole.
Re:Unethical Growth Hacking from YayView by digbyloftus on Sunday January 10, 2016 @08:52AM (#10875290)
I mean, if all you do for a living is email spam then I wouldn't call that hacking, but seeing as this is a programming based startup and the marketing attempt required programming skill, I'm imagining this was put together by the same guy/guys that are on other days making new product features. If slapping together a marketing scheme that quickly lets you reach a lot of people without you needing to spend a lot of time optimising or upkeeping it isn't hacking then I just straight up don't understand how the day setting up a new feature and a day setting up the new spam bot are different conceptually.

I don't think being an unsophisticated asshole and a hacker are mutually exclusive. Plenty of hacking is unsophisticated and most people are assholes, hacker or otherwise.

Re:Unethical Growth Hacking from YayView by purpled_haze on Sunday January 10, 2016 @09:13AM (#10875343)
> Plenty of what programmers are doing isn't hacking.

and plenty of hackers aren't programmers. In Eric Raymond's definition of a hacker http://www.catb.org/esr/faqs/hacker-howto.html it states:

"There is a community, a shared culture, of expert programmers and networking wizards that traces its history back through decades to the first time-sharing minicomputers and the earliest ARPAnet experiments. The members of this culture originated the term ‘hacker’. Hackers built the Internet. Hackers made the Unix operating system what it is today. Hackers make the World Wide Web work. If you are part of this culture, if you have contributed to it and other people in it know who you are and call you a hacker, you're a hacker."

I mention this because Merriam-Webster's definition on the other hand is somewhat flawed:

1: one that hacks

2: a person who is inexperienced or unskilled at a particular activity <a tennis hacker>

3: an expert at programming and solving problems with a computer

4: a person who illegally gains access to and sometimes tampers with information in a computer system

In particular, #3 doesn't mention hackers that aren't experts in programming but might solve problems with hardware/networking. A better #3 definition would be: "A person that computer programming, computer networking, or other technology at an expert level to come up with an innovative solution."

Re:Unethical Growth Hacking from YayView by digbyloftus on Sunday January 10, 2016 @09:48AM (#10875440)
None of his article seems to try to defend his assertions at all so it seems odd to link to it unless this is an appeal to authority. In which case, what makes Eric Raymond an authority on the English language?

"-er" is a suffix used to turn verbs in to nouns. A kicker is one who kicks, a stabber is one who stabs, a hacker is one who hacks. While you can certainly create a stereotype of the general "stabber", it shouldn't and doesn't really come in to whether or not a specific act was a stab. If most people who stab others are large, hooded men, but a petite, bow tie in hair girl thrusts a knife through someones torso, she stabbed them. Talking about the incident? She was the stabber. She does it regularly enough for it to be part of her general description as a person? She is a stabber.

Now, seeing as two very common definitions of the word hack are:

A: to cut or sever with repeated irregular or unskillful blows

B : to cut or shape by or as if by crude or ruthless strokes <hacking out new election districts>

it seems both odd to take people whose relationship with programming could be describe this way and not call them a hacker, and to call people who program out of a love of freedom and voluntary mutual help hackers. How the hell do freedom and voluntary mutual help relate to the word "hack" at all other than just by correlation?

People who made programs in a non-professional environment were and are more likely to hack together their programs. This group of people historically has had some values as mentioned in your article there. But to say those values are now the requirements or the defining characteristics of the term? Ridiculous.

Most people who bowl do it for the fun of it. If bowling suddenly becomes a lucrative sport and I take it up simply to chase the money and don't intrinsically care for rolling a ball at some pins, am I not a bowler? One who is partaking in bowling? Who goes to the bowling club to bowl?

Re:Unethical Growth Hacking from YayView by purpled_haze on Sunday January 10, 2016 @09:58AM (#10875479)
> In which case, what makes Eric Raymond an authority on the English language?

He is an authority on hacking and jargon: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eric_S._Raymond

In summary: every programmer/developer/software engineer is not a hacker and you don't have to be a software-hacker to be a hacker. If you want to learn the history of the term rather than try to define it, that would be great, rather than just debating it.

Re:Unethical Growth Hacking from YayView by digbyloftus on Sunday January 10, 2016 @10:09AM (#10875523)
I appealed to the history of it! If Eric and friends arrived at the term "hacker" through means other than the word "hack" i'd honestly love to know how, but like I said, his writing doesn't touch on it at all apart from to say that him and his friends started as a bunch of hobbiests. The best I can do is surmise that as hobbiests they believed they were crudely cutting and shaping software. What else would be it be? An Acronym? Happy Automation Creation Kids?

Discussion with someone who disagrees requires debate to settle the matter. We apparently disagree. Either debate or remain silent on it.

Re:Unethical Growth Hacking from YayView by purpled_haze on Sunday January 10, 2016 @10:29AM (#10875591)
> Discussion with someone who disagrees requires debate to settle the matter.

> Either debate or remain silent on it.

I disagree with you. I provided evidence showing that Eric wrote a dictionary of jargon including the term "hacker". I see no other reason to continue this debate because you obviously cannot click on the link to read what I provided, and I'm not going to take the time to copy and paste every detail here, which I won't force you to read anyway if you don't want to.

I do not have to remain silent, and you just contradicted yourself when you both said that someone had to debate if they disagreed but at the same time had the option to be silent. Did you ever take a class in logic? It would serve you well to study it.

Re:Unethical Growth Hacking from YayView by digbyloftus on Sunday January 10, 2016 @10:40AM (#10875623)
>I do not have to remain silent, and you just contradicted yourself when you both said that someone had to debate if they disagreed but at the same time had the option to be silent. Did you ever take a class in logic? It would serve you well to study it.

I said it was required to settle the matter. I didn't say the matter had to be settled. Have you studied reading comprehension? It's incredibly useful!

>I provided evidence showing that Eric wrote a dictionary of jargon including the term "hacker".

He wrote something and called it a dictionary. Great! I can do that. Anyone can do that. It's not a credential. It's enough to garner interest, and like I said, I read the entry, but writing something and slapping Dictionary as a heading is hardly evidence of that thing being true. That evidence is what he fails to even try to provide. I have provided a definition of both the word hack and how the suffix -er functions. Neither seem to be in dispute so the idea that there's disagreement over the combination is frankly nuts.

Re:Unethical Growth Hacking from YayView by purpled_haze on Sunday January 10, 2016 @11:24AM (#10875818)
Ok, write a dictionary where you've researched technical jargon and the history of the term hacker to a full extent and get back to us on that.
Re:Unethical Growth Hacking from YayView by Disruptive_Dave on Sunday January 10, 2016 @11:21AM (#10875798)
Not really. The programming part of "growth hacking" is, well, a part of it, but the general definition of the term is much closer to "using creativity and analytical thinking/practices to market a product/service." It's kind of glorified word of mouth marketing, but with landing pages and A/B tests. [All that said, as a startup growth guy, I pretty much detest the term.]
Re:Unethical Growth Hacking from YayView by the_watcher on Sunday January 10, 2016 @04:29PM (#10877290)
A question in the YC application asks about a time you hacked a system to your advantage, and is explicit that hacking does not solely refer to programming
Re:Unethical Growth Hacking from YayView by ekianjo on Sunday January 10, 2016 @09:19AM (#10875366)
> cheaply creates new things, as in "it's hacked together"

In other words it's marketing without much resources. Nothing much to do with hacking. When you repair your car with a used part or a part from a different model, are you "hacking your car" ? 

This word is getting way too much abuse, soon it won't mean anything anymore.

Re:Unethical Growth Hacking from YayView by digbyloftus on Sunday January 10, 2016 @12:20PM (#10876066)
If you fix your car by slapping together a bunch of junk then yes you most certainly have just "hacked it together". I don't see how you can call this abuse, crudely modifying and creating things is the original and primary use of the term. If anything it's the "high quality, open source programming in pursuit of interesting problems" crowd that's butchering it. "It's just something I hacked together" has never meant "I carefully crafted the shit out of it" except for maybe in a dishonest humblebrag sort of way.
Re:Unethical Growth Hacking from YayView by TeMPOraL on Sunday January 10, 2016 @09:57AM (#10875473)
> When you repair your car with a used part or a part from a different model, are you "hacking your car" ?

If you follow a popular on-line tutorial for that, then not really.

But if you find yourself with a broken car, and you figure out yourself that you can fix it by duct-taping some otherwise unrelated component into it, and the resulting solution somehow works better than original, then yes. Hacking is about playful cleverness.

Re:Unethical Growth Hacking from YayView by ThomPete on Sunday January 10, 2016 @09:06AM (#10875321)
Growth hacking as I understand it means doing non-obvious ways to grow your company. I.e. finding ways to spread that aren't following the normal user acquisition channels.
Re:Unethical Growth Hacking from YayView by TeMPOraL on Sunday January 10, 2016 @10:51AM (#10875672)
Sadly, the easiest way to do something non-obvious to grow your company is to do something unethical. Like using "user acquisition channels" that are not meant for user acquisition.
Re:Unethical Growth Hacking from YayView by forgotmypassw on Sunday January 10, 2016 @07:26AM (#10875095)
Re:Unethical Growth Hacking from YayView by zazpowered on Sunday January 10, 2016 @07:04AM (#10875043)
Growth hacker and hacker are very different things
Re:Unethical Growth Hacking from YayView by bottled_poe on Sunday January 10, 2016 @07:13AM (#10875064)
These roles look suspiciously like more traditional "business development manager" and "software developer" but I guess those titles weren't trendy enough so we hacked role titles and now everyone gets to be a "hacker".
Re:Unethical Growth Hacking from YayView by qubex on Sunday January 10, 2016 @07:39AM (#10875127)
”Growth hacker” is a term a marketer came up with to market marketers.
Re:Unethical Growth Hacking from YayView by trymas on Sunday January 10, 2016 @07:53AM (#10875149)
+1

exactly. There is business development, though if there is a article which title has 'developer' in it, it does mean `a software developer` mostly, unless you read a particular business development article.

Though `growth hacking`, personally, I think is made up buzzword, for some managers to feel good and cool, that they are like the hacker from 90s. Startup growth falls under `business development and management` in my head, not under `(growth) hacking`.

Re:Unethical Growth Hacking from YayView by rplnt on Sunday January 10, 2016 @08:12AM (#10875184)
Plus it's pretty common and has been over the years. Spamming student accounts, creating fake profiles from harvested data, etc... There is nothing newsworthy about this app. Just report them to appropriate places (school's tech whatever to block their spam, facebook for violating TOS, ... something else?) and move on.